5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (25 May)

Wardlow lands MJF match, CM Punk crawls inside Page's head, Double Or Nothing build continues.

MJF AEW
AEW

All Elite Wrestling celebrated its third anniversary with an episode of Dynamite that fell right in with recent patterns, oscillating from "effective" to "unsatisfying" on a segment-to-segment basis, with big moments rushed through and not given time to resonate.

This is a very hyperactive television show at the moment. It's becoming a worn-out point, admittedly, but one worth repeating when the insistence on jumping around without ever settling continues to have a detrimental impact. Dynamite, for all its plus points, is stuttering, and it has resulted in the Double Or Nothing build becoming one of the most undercooked in AEW's three-year history.

Nonetheless, there were big questions to answer last night. Wardlow faced Shawn Spears inside a steel cage with a shot at former paymaster MJF on the line, while the two Owen Hart Cup Tournament finals were yet to be determined (though one has to wait until Rampage). Elsewhere, big names Jon Moxley, Eddie Kingston, FTR, Samoa Joe, and Jungle Boy were all on the lineup.

The pay-per-view will likely work out. AEW has earned that level of trust. Still, it's a shame that the go-home show couldn't elevate it beyond a cool-looking array of match graphics.

Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

5. Lukewarm 'Anarchy' Build Continues

Eddie Kingston
AEW

Bringing Eddie Kingston and Jon Moxley back together between the ropes for the first time since September was a nice idea to sell their cohesion heading into Double Or Nothing, where they'll join forces to face the Jericho Appreciation Society, but their win over Private Party did little to fire-up a match build that has cooled off since a couple of excellent first week.

Marq Quen and Isiah Kassidy aren't necessarily squashable, which made them suboptimal opponents here. The duo have too much cache to flatten - but Kingston and Moxley could have used somebody to flatten. A shorter, more impactful mauling in a more condensed runtime would have done more to make the babyfaces look good ahead of Anarchy in the Arena.

This, plus a same-same post-match angle that emphasised Bryan Danielson's bad leg coming out of Rampage, delivered nothing we haven't seen before from this group of wrestlers. The match's exceptional talent level must carry it now.


4. Hardys' Promo Doesn't Land

It's good that AEW opted for the most obvious and straightforward story for The Young Bucks vs. The Hardys, that being students vs. masters (the influenced vs. their influencers), but when faced with the most obnoxious tag team in the division, personality-wise, Matt and Jeff have done little to endear themselves.

Relying on the duo's perma-overness (The Hardys will get mega pops regardless of what comes out of their mouth) is disappointing. Matt and Jeff spitting out that the Bucks are cosplay Hardy Boyz comes off overbearing and obnoxious. Those are the words of somebody you want to root against, not for, and while this storyline should have tapped into the obvious impact that Hardys had on the Bucks in their chosen career path, Matt Hardy, angry veteran, doesn't present him and brother Jeff in the most effective light.


3. Thunder Rosa Gets Shorted For Time... Again

Tony Schiavone Thunder Rosa
AEW

Thunder Rosa, who has barely appeared on-camera throughout her Women's World Title reign, got another short, short, short segment on last night's episode of Dynamite.

The content was solid. Rosa came out without her signature makeup and ripped Serena Deeb, whom she claims isn't championship material because of her petty, complaining behaviour. She was frank and open without the paint. When she puts it on, however, a switch is going to flip - and they're going to go to war.

Rosa was good here. Unfortunately, the segment was so hurried that her entrance music hit before she was finished, meaning she had to awkwardly get her final few lines out while it played.

No sign of Deeb here, either, which is disappointing. A segment that perfectly encapsulates the problems with this under-served program that should have been one of the best in the division's history.


2. United Empire Stumble In Debut

United Empire Great-O-Khan Jeff Cobb
AEW

NJPW stars Jeff Cobb and Great-O-Khan attacked FTR during their match with Roppongi Vice, triggering a disqualification before continuing the beating after the bell. This looks like the first big step towards an inter-promotional match for Forbidden Door. Holding the ROH Tag Team Title belts aloft, the United Empire tandem certainly staked their claim.

But like much of this Dynamite, the angle fell flat.

Received with a murmur rather than a roar, suggesting unfamiliarity from the audience, O-Khan (one of the most improved wrestlers in Japan throughout the pandemic era) and Cobb stumbled through a couple of moves. Such botches aren't always the end of the world if they don't have a detrimental impact on the viewing experience. Here, they did, presenting O-Khan in particular as clumsy, not crushing.


1. Britt Baker vs. Toni Storm Falls Apart

Britt Baker
AEW

Britt Baker and Toni Storm's Owen Hart Cup semi-final went off the rails well before its contrived finish.

This, unfortunately, was a particularly cumbersome performance from Baker, who, for all the excellent work she has delivered over the years, is still a better character than a pure wrestler. She looked sluggish here, her work mere whispers of violence. So weak were her attempts at smashing Storm's head into the apron that Toni looked like she was throwing her own skull down. Prior to this, Baker shoving Storm into the post scarcely generated enough pace to shift a moth, let alone a human being.

The clumsy finish compounded a rough match that should have been considerably better. Jamie Hayter pulled two distractions, the second of which led to the end, with a sloppy roll-up assisted by Britt grabbing the ropes putting Toni away.

Storm had promised hell if Baker and her cronies screwed her out of victory. A good story beat for sure, though this first outing did little to build anticipation for a rematch.


Ups...

5. A Little Too Late, BUT...

Hangman Page CM Punk
AEW

CM Punk is becoming the AEW World Champion at Double Or Nothing 2022. 'Hangman' Adam Page will spiral in the aftermath.

This appears to be the story coming out of the go-home show. Page is now using his heart to a detrimental degree, taking on an angry, red-blooded persona that has gradually pulled himself away from the traits that helped him conquer Kenny Omega. Hangman is furious with a guy who hasn't spoken out of turn once. It's a continuation of his first promo on Punk, when he assertively promised to embarrass the Chicagoan at the pay-per-view, then flashed the camera a grim, conflicted glance, as if he was trying to convince himself of his words' validity as much as anyone else.

Punk is nestled deep inside his head. This was already the case before, but even moreso now that Hangman has knocked him to the floor. This came after Punk had gently shoved him away to escalate their in-ring confrontation.

The story works, though this segment could have benefitted from taking place earlier in the feud. A quicker escalation followed by weeks of upping the ante would have unquestionably led to this bout feeling bigger than it currently does. The slow road, in this case, was not the right road.

But the dynamic is established - and the match should resemble the inside of a volcano.


4. Samoa Joe Overcomes Arm Trouble

Kyle O'Reilly Samoa Joe
AEW

Samoa Joe vs. Kyle O'Reilly was a product of good storytelling.

Jay Lethal, Satnam Singh, and Sonjay Dutt targetted the ROH Television Champion's arm with a lead pipe-assisted assault last week, softening him up for Kyle, whose submission win over Rey Fenix reaffirmed his limb-destroying prowess. This gave the wrestlers a solid psychological foundation for their Owen Hart Cup semi-final, which delivered on its promise.

KOR started out by sticking and moving, trying to maintain a stiff distance while chipping away at the bigger, slower man, who eventually bulldozed his way inside. When given the opportunity, O'Reilly attacked the damaged limb as well as Joe sold it. This was done through multiple strikes, holds, and transitions, which Joe responded to by cracking Kyle's jaw at every opportunity, keeping the pressure on until he was finally able to put O'Reilly's lights out with the rear naked choke.

Good week-to-week professional wrestling from two experienced, clever pros who respect the craft.


3. FTR & Roppongi Vice Do What They Do Best

Rocky Romero Cash Wheeler
AEW

While the post-match angle wasn't optimal, FTR and Roppongi Vice worked what was fast becoming an excellent tag team match prior to the finish.

Rife with the kind of crisp, snappy offense we should expect from this combination of skilled tag team specialists, this was a lot of fun. Rocky Romero and Trent Beretta haven't missed a beat as a tandem. Their various combinations and interjections were as seamless as FTR's, which should be treated as a huge combination, given the level of esteem Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler are held in. Never once did these four feel like they were running routines. Their clash was organically dramatic and impactful, particularly with the late Strong Zero near-fall only broken by Wheeler shoving Romero into the fall attempt.

That AEW scarcely uses disqualifications keeps them effective, too. Indulging in them so infrequently means that those involved are genuinely protected from taking a defeat. Rather than inspiring eye-rolls, their sparse use works as a break from Tony Khan's typically strict clean finish policy.


2. A Fun, Creative Three-Way

Jungle Boy Ricky Starks
AEW

Swerve Strickland and Keith Lee won last night's Tag Team Title preview ahead of Double Or Nothing, with Strickland hitting his Swerve Stomp on Ricky Starks to defeat the Team Taz representative and Jurassic Express' Jungle Boy. This came after Jungle Boy had come within a hair of submitting Starks via Snare Trap - and was one of many creative spots in a fun, action-packed match.

The trio opted against settling into the usual three-way format of one wrestler chilling outside the ring for an unnaturally long time while the other two wrestle. There were moments of immobilisation, sure, but none felt contrived. Instead, this match was mostly about the trio interacting in unique, interesting ways, often all at the same time, with lightning-fast momentum changes appropriate to the format.

Starks was particularly great here, imparting effective heel work into a bout primarily based on action. He remains one of the most underrated wrestlers in North America and although he took the defeat, AEW may end up rewarding his efforts at the pay-per-view.


1. Wardlow Punches His Ticket

Shawn Spears MJF
AEW

Wardlow oozed pure animalistic energy as he stood atop the steel cage following Dynamite's opener, having finally punched his ticket for a Double Or Nothing 2022 match with MJF, ruining the latest of his former master's grand plans in dominant style.

One by one, Wardlow has knocked MJF's hurdles down, with the latest being a seemingly unwinnable cage match with Shawn Spears. That Max was a special guest referee (clad wonderfully in Burberry stripes) should have guaranteed Spears' victory. Indeed, MJF struck early, putting his hands on Wardlow when he knew the big man couldn't retaliate, stacking the deck against the babyface with every trick up his sleeve.

And yet, predictably, he fell.

The predictable outcome is often the right outcome in professional wrestling. Wardlow, when fighting Spears, was in complete control. Only skullduggery put him on the backfoot, so Spears and MJF's shenanigans backfiring to cost them the bout made all the sense in the world. A rogue chairshot to MJF's dome facilitated a powerbomb Symphony too potent for Spears to endure.

MJF scampered up the ramp afterwards, horrified. The stage is now perfectly set for Wardlow to tear him apart at Double Or Nothing

Or for MJF to screw him.

Again.

Either way, this remains the best-built match on the pay-per-view card - and it's no coincidence that it involves MJF.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.