5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (8 Mar - Review)
AEW TV stutters yet again as the true magic of Revolution feels like a false dawn on Dynamite.
The recent spate of bang average Dynamites were easy to forget while watching Revolution.
One of the best entries into AEW's pay-per-view archive, the Sunday supercard was stuffed to the gills with so much of what the company promised before it even existed. All In and the shows before Dynamite's existence lived and died on Being The Elite skits and/or the prestige and pre-existing legacies of the wrestlers themselves. To this end, "good" wasn't good enough. In this brave new world and with so little camera time to tell stories, match quality had to do a lot of the heavy lifting and the poorer efforts had damaging consequences.
As with 2022's Forbidden Door, the opposite was true here. Some stories had been haphazardly reheated from thier once-perfect temperature (Christian Vs Jungle Boy), some felt obligatory to the point of counter-productive (Chris Jericho Vs Ricky Starks) and some felt like they weren't really stories at all (The Elite Vs The House Of Black, the Tag Team Title four way dance).
And yet, the model of stacking and jacking a roster worked - the company could and should be too good to fail when it comes to producing a quality wrestling show, and Revolution was evidence of that. If you are a quarterly customer and no more, you let again left feeling like your financial, emotional and time investments were all satisfied.
For the rest of us, Dynamite needed a drastic upswing in quality to ensure the anticipation of the next PPV cycle could be as enjoyable as the show itself. Did this week's clear that bar?
Let's light the fuse...
Downs…
5. The Biggest Self-Own In AEW History?
AEW is proud to celebrate #InternationalWomensDay! pic.twitter.com/p7uG8lPsU0
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) March 8, 2023
"It's International Women's Day, you know what that means."
And with that, and Ruby Soho or Skye Blue or any woman's music not hitting, AEW invited yet more valid criticism and outright mockery for their inability to break away from the rigid format of one women's match per show on Dynamite.
The line was a cute take on the catchphrase and a worthwhile acknowledgement of an important celebration on the calendar, but was the disastrous dictionary definition of telling not showing. Like corporate charities or pro-cause branding from companies with rank HR records, this - like a tweet earlier in the day - brought yet more attention to the longest standing consistent problem in All Elite Wrestling's history.
The jokes - themselves gallows humour at this point - are being written on the reg without AEW supplying the feed lines.
4. Lacking Juice
Ricky Starks was a late but shrewd addition to the Dynamite line-up.
The supposed "benefit" of him beating Chris Jericho at Revolution might have been lost if 'The Ocho' was back on Wednesday no-selling the defeat and 'Absolute' himself was nowhere to be found. Starks taking television time to openly question what was next for him felt liked a lived in character choice for somebody desperate to pull away from the recent vortex he was trapped in.
The problem was with who extended their arm in rescue.
When the Bullet Club logo flashed up on screens and the iconic entrance theme played, the arena fizzed with excitement that known free agent Jay White might well have made his choice. This made the surprise appearance of Juice Robinsion doubly disappointing - not only did he feel like a step down the ladder for Starks, but Robinson not being 'Switchblade' (after an indifferent on-screen run in AEW thus far) was itself a letdown.
Everybody's mostly blameless for that, but does it even track narratively? Starks got ostensibly the biggest singles win of his career on Sunday, and now has a lower card filler match with Robinson as the provide. As for the man he defeated...
3. The Jericho Appreciation Society Vs Top Flight & AR Fox
In quite the twist, Chris Jericho is doing absolutely fine again after losing an eight-week pay-per-view programme that theoretically should have ended on the night it started.
The Jericho Appreciation Society were successful in a win over Top Flight and AR Fox in what was comfortably the drabbest match of the latter trios' run thus. Enjoying himself in a new division, Jericho called out the House Of Black and demanded a title shot for Dynamite's debut in his hometown of Winnipeg next week.
He got what he wanted in the end, but not before The Elite interjected to force a three-way. This wasn't without intrigue - Don Callis swiped the microphone away from Kenny Omega in another tease of their eventual split, and Omega reminding Jericho that they've all kept out of each others' way over the years was an impressive flex of what's not been wasted, but all of that was waved away to get to the cool match graphic after House Of Black teleported in and back out to give the challengers the nod.
It's going to be enormously heated stuff North of the border next week, but that'll make for an electrifying Up then. This middling match and nonsensically-arrived-upon ripper title match doesn't get that benefit.
2. Wardlow Vs Powerhouse Hobbs
The headline is that Powerhouse Hobbs defeated Wardlow in a Falls Count Anywhere after QT Marshall interfered with a steel chair, allowing Challenger to powerbomb Champion through the stage for decisive technical knockout finish and win his first singles gold in AEW.
And the company will presumably hope nobody remembers anything other than that, because it was hard not to feel like Hobbs' maiden championship victory wasn't mishandled while watching it play out.
The brawl was only ever decent at best, which was problematic considering what a wild contest featuring the youngest, hungriest monsters should have looked like. With his life hitting the skids, Wardlow didn't fight with desperation anymore than Hobbs did with opportunism. This was spots - some exciting, some less so - until the wrestlers got to the stage so everybody could move into place for the finish.
As Marshall struck, Excalibur rushed to remind viewers of a long-forgotten agreement between the two that QT one day "owed" Hobbs one, and that this plan apparently was acting as payment and the start of a union between the former Factory boss and the new Champion. Suddenly there wasn't any time left to contemplate that as Wardlow was being finished off with a deadly powerbomb...that then looked shoddy thanks to production revealing the cosy crash mats breaking Wardlow's fall.
It summed up a Dynamite where lots of things happened but so few registered the way they were supposed to. A blah win won't mark Hobbs' cards as Champion, but it remains perplexing how the booking fired wide whilst stood in front of an open and empty net.
1. But Seriously. What Is Going On With This Show?
This isn't the first time a post-Pay-Per-View edition of Dynamite hasn't managed to build on the tremendous momentum gained from yet another awesome Sunday show, but this might be the most egregious and poorly-timed misfire yet.
It wasn't as if there weren't developments. Jon Moxley's heel turn (more on that imminently), a light at the end of the tunnel for the tag division (more on that imminently) and yet another promo-of-the-year contender (absolutely positively loads more on that imminently) all served as examples of Tony Khan still knowing how to get all of this right and making Dynamite feel like the premiere destination for North American pro wrestling.
But that's a relatively low supply over two hours, and the Sacramento crowd never truly came unglued in the way several key matches and moments needed them to. Despite some exceptional in-ring in January, the consensus on AEW's flagship heading into Revolution was that it had nose-dived in spite of itself. The pay-per-view lifted spirits, but that already now scans as a false dawn rather than the start of a consistent upturn.
It's this prevailing feeling - one that as of this show extended beyond the online bubble and into the building itself - that will last longer than Sunday's euphoria if it's allowed to.
Ups…
5. Orange Cassidy Vs Jay Lethal
For a while, Orange Cassidy Vs Jay Lethal was merely good rather than great, and in the ultra-competitive landscape that makes up 2023 television wrestling, the vibe was less than ideal.
Thankfully, the experienced pair executed immense patience and skill to escalate this All-Atlantic Championship match into something that bordered on excellent. Lethal’s relentless targeting of Cassidy’s knee created tremendous dread around the potential of a centre-ring figure four leglock finish, or at very least the Champion finding himself prone to the Lethal Injection without the strength to move out of the way.
With all the casual nature of his typical offence though, Cassidy hid his own strategy in plain sight. Working the Challenger’s arm and shoulder, he played the waiting game then struck - when Lethal attempted to handspring into his deadly finisher, he forgot himself and crumpled under the pressure. Mindful of the trap he’d sprung, Cassidy was right there with the Orange Punch to take the win.
A Jeff Jarrett post-match attack folded into a corporate synergy development later in the show - Tony Khan announced the belt was to be renamed the “International Championship”, and it would “level up” with a maiden defence in Canada next week. Tantalisingly, Double J’s quest for gold can continue, even if Triple J’s seems to have definitively fallen short.
4. Destination Known
The best week yet for the Homegrowns/Outsiders angle (though that "Freelancers" name for the heels has to go) kicked off with a tremendous promo from Ruby Soho that initially threatened to go south before she threaded together the thought process she went through following her Revolution defeat to Jamie Hayter and new stablemate Saraya.
This was "each and every one of you" but she kept the receipts. Highlighting specific matches where fans booed her that were clearly drawn from painful memories, the rationale for her choice after suffering another loss audiences didn't really care about suddenly made great sense.
A decent match with Skye Blue followed, but it existed as an excuse for the promo before it and angle afterwards. Former Soho ally Willow Nightingale arrived to stop the heels beating Blue down after the bell, but Ruby made yet another big choice and decked her too. The heels stood tall, and the spray-paint gimmick was actually effective as an act of cruelty on somebody with Nightingale's obvious popularity.
3. FTR Are All The Way Back
On a show perilously short of excitement and the type of drama needed to generate big noise, FTR’s return interview was much-needed boost to the broadcast.
This was neither cheat code nor fluke of course. Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler earned all of the plaudits they’ve rightfully received for being THE team of 2022, but in speaking frankly about why the needed to recharge at the start of this year, a sense of excitement around 2023 grew.
The Gunns winning the AEW Tag Team Championships was an expect-the-unexpected gamble that already feels like it hasn’t paid off, but there was at long last a sense of satisfaction about the booking. Every living breathing human within earshot of this promo and Dax and Cash themselves knew one thing definitively after it concluded - those entitled nepo-baby paper champions are absolutely f*cked and there could be no two more fitting than the Top Guys to make right this very obvious wrong.
Maybe the ends will justify the means after all?
2. Blackpool Combat Club Vs The Dark Order
More of an extended angle than a match - and good job too, because the former was infinitely more interesting than the latter - The Blackpool Combat Club’s cruel dissection of The Dark Order formalised a heel turn that had brewing within the group for weeks.
The focus here was logically on Jon Moxley’s willingness to get down in the muck with partners Claudio Castignoli and Wheeler Yuta. While those two had developed a cynical streak in recent weeks, Mox’s actions felt a lot more like those of a man acting out as a way to combine the rage and embarrassment felt by his Revolution tap-out.This was doubly effective after Hangman Page had categorically confirmed that he was “done” with the former three-time AEW Champion after their most recent war. He clearly meant it too, but Moxley taking out his lingering frustrations on Page’s Dark Order pals brought the ‘Anxious Millennial Cowboy’ right back into the fold.
About as far away from a traditional this-feud-must-continue device as imaginable, this was intriguingly reframed one of the year’s hottest rivalries, perhaps leaving the door open for deciding fifth match, and some scary new directions for a heel BCC.
1. Iron Sharpens Iron Men
Dynamite’s had a mid quality for much of 2023, but a low-key success story on the show had been a notable shift in formatting and focus.
More than ever is being allowed to breathe. This obviously creates other concerns whenever it feels like valuable television time’s not apportioned out wisely, but the post-Revolution promos from MJF and Bryan Danielson made phenomenal use of the minutes.
Brasher than ever and understandably so, the Champion luxuriated in his win and promised a Re-Bar Mitzvah for next week’s show as the self-congratulatory sentiment flowed faster than the sweat and blood from his body.
In devastatingly stark contrast, Bryan Danielson was physically and mentally broken from the defeat. Noting that he previously believed going as hard as he could was the best message to send his kids, he was now left questioning if he’d been wrong the whole time. And was “home” a route one trip to the arms of his loved ones, or a return to the in-ring alma mater also owned by Tony Khan? This mesmerising speech had you rooting for both.
All of this put over so much - Bryan loves wrestling that much that it often feels like being out there is like staring into the face of god. Looking square in the eyes of the devil appears to have changed everything. Not only does that put MJF even more over as the company's most evil and prominent threat, it reminds viewers that the pay-per-views are where the biggest actions AND consequences reside.