5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE SmackDown (April 26 - Results & Review)

WWE's 2024 Draft already needs a rethink, but several trades did work in SmackDown's favour.

Cody Rhodes AJ Styles
WWE.com

This week's episode of SmackDown marked the opening night of WWE's 2024 Draft, and it's fair to say the promotion could use a rethink when it comes to the annual shakeup. Actually, the last word in that sentence there might not fit - only 6 of the 16 picks announced on TV actually jumped brands. That means no less than 10 announcements were pretty pointless.

Worse, one major name was allowed to dodge the entire process, and the explanation as to why was very weak. That did the Draft zero favours, but SmackDown did see a few positive new arrivals. One immediately targeted the top male champ, and another will give Bayley someone "new" to work with during her own title reign.

Friday's show wasn't a bad one by any means. However, it didn't do much to sell the Draft as must see, and that's something Triple H will need to think about going forwards. Beyond the Draft, he also booked a heel turn, a string of legendary cameos, and the official union of a brand new tag-team.

Here's all the good and bad from a night that definitely could've been better.


Downs...

5. That First Round Of Picks

WWE Draft 2024 Cody Rhodes Triple H
WWE.com

You'd think WWE might come bursting out of the starting blocks with something major to crow about during the Draft's first round, right? Nope. Triple H came out to announce picks, enlisted Cody Rhodes to help, then revealed that three of the opening four draftees were...staying put on brands they're already with.

How exciting.

Carmelo Hayes coming to SmackDown was the stand out here (more on that later), but why was Bianca Belair remaining blue the best choice to kick things off? Jimmy Uso and Seth Rollins still batting for team red was similarly puzzling. WWE didn't need to switch those guys, but at least omit them from the announcements if they're not actually going anywhere.

The opening round was WWE's chance to portray the 2024 Draft as something seismic. Instead, it came out looking bland, routine and all a little pointless. Even Cody was staring at the big screen behind him like, 'Well so much for that, eh?'.


4. R-KO Is Happening

Randy Orton Kevin Owens R-KO
WWE.com

Look, some fans will be into this and that's fine, but there's always been something off about the banter between Randy Orton and Kevin Owens. Their awkward union created a strange dynamic to the build for a three-way vs. Logan Paul heading into WrestleMania, and that's continuing on into the summer months post-Draft.

On Friday, Randy helped Kev fend off The Bloodline, then the announcers told everyone Orton will be on 'The KO Show' next week. Last year, creative moved Owens away from Sami Zayn so he could be a singles again. Then, they had him wrestle tag-teams like Pretty Deadly and A-Town Down Under solo (?!). Now, he's right back in another team.

Your point, caller?

R-KO is a clever name, but if that's the only reason these dudes are teaming then forget it. They don't actually even have that much chemistry. Meh, maybe that's harsh and the tag deserves some more time in the oven. Kev and Randy are top workers, so perhaps they'll work something out and gel eventually.


3. Roman Reigns Is In Charge?

WWE Draft 2024 Roman Reigns
WWE

The Draft is supposed to empower decision makers to do what needs done and ensure Raw, SmackDown and NXT are equipped for the next 12 months. A knock-on effect of this is that wrestlers are powerless to do anything about the winds of change. Unless you're Roman Reigns, apparently.

Paul Heyman casually dropped into conversation that Roman had decided to withdraw eligibility for the 2024 Draft. So, that isn't up to Triple H or even the top brand GMs? Wrestlers can just elect not to be involved at all if they don't want to be? That's clumsy; why wouldn't more push that through if it was an option and they didn't want to move?

For example, if Drew McIntyre gets drafted to Fridays on Raw next week, he can kick up a stink and say he isn't going anywhere. Do WWE even realise how big of a gaping hole this blows in the entire purpose of this thing?! They've crapped their own pants with this clanger of a call.

Why not announce that Roman is ineligible ahead of time?


2. So Much For His SmackDown Spot

Bron Breakker
WWE.com

Erm...Bron Breakker literally signed on the dotted line with SmackDown a super-short period of time ago. He was called up to the main roster pre-Draft, and blue GM Nick Aldis made a big song and dance about locking Bron down to a deal. That was one of the 'B' stories on SmackDown for a while - Aldis chased both Breakker and Jade Cargill.

Scrap that, 'cause Bron has jumped to Raw anyway.

OK then. Hopefully, creative can come up with something more substantial than the routine squashes Breakker has been working. Yeah, it's impressive to see Bron maul people, but he'll need more if he's going to survive on the flagship. Way more. WWE probs could've done without that unnecessary run of showings on Smackers heading into this week's show, to be honest.

Aldis looks foolish for pursuing Breakker like he did, seemingly securing him as a coup for SmackDown, then watching him dart out the door towards Adam Pearce. Nick wasn't even particularly p*ssed off about any of this. The only thing Bron's leap accomplished was making Aldis look like someone who takes his eye off the ball.


1. The Draft’s General Process

WWE Draft 2024 The Dudley Boyz
WWE.com

Time for Trips to get his thinking cap on.

'The Game' must try to scheme something more appealing than the dry announcements WWE goes for with the Draft every year. It's all so uninspired, and it'd be an outright lie to say Friday's opening night was a success. Far too many of the announcements were effectively, 'Hey! Wrestler A is staying put, folks!'.

That defeats the purpose of even holding a roster shakeup in the first place. On top of that, none of the legends brought in to feign excitement seemed all that interested in what was going on either. In fairness, what can The Dudley Boyz really say about a midcarder like Ricochet remaining on Raw?

Rico is great, but he's a high-flying midcarder who's barely even in key storylines at the moment. In short, him going Raw > Raw is boring as f*ck, and both Bubba Ray and D-Von had to sell it as an earth-shattering moment. Same with LA Knight staying on SmackDown and The Bloodline staying put.


Ups...

5. It Was Carlito All Along!

LWO Rey Mysterio Carlito Dragon Lee Zelina Vega
WWE.com

It was him, Rey. It was him all along, Rey.

Yours truly is willing to give Carlito's heel turn room to breathe, because it honestly could lead to some fun promos and matches over the next couple of months. No, the tag bout pitting Rey Mysterio and Dragon Lee vs. Angel and Humberto didn't get much time to speak of, but it was only there to set up Carlito's reveal anyway.

Again, happy to give all of this the benefit of the doubt and see what happens next. Carlito being the guy who ambushed Lee makes sense too, because he's been visibly upset that Rey overlooked him for several tag matches since joining the LWO. Nobody had Mysterio vs. Carlito on their predictions for 2024!

Carly becoming an enforcer for the poisonous influence of Santos Escobar sounds like a hoot, and so does Dragon Lee actually getting the chance to do some talking and develop a character in response. It's vital he gets to do that, otherwise he'll continue trundling along and Carlito's heel turn will be wasted.


4. Bayley Gets A Fresh Monster To Slay

Nia Jax Byron Saxton
WWE.com

Rather predictably, X has already decided that Nia Jax jumping to SmackDown and getting involved in the title picture opposite Bayley is the worst thing in pro wrestling history. Nah, not for this guy. If anything, Jax challenging the champion is way more fun than Naomi and Bayley being all buddy buddy during friendly bouts.

Nia might not be Bryan Danielson between the ropes, but her physically imposing style does have merit, and she's been largely fine since returning. Jax will be a nice 'B' level speed bump challenger for Bayley whilst creative builds Tiffany Stratton a little more and readies her to eventually supplant the babyface champ.

Tiff is the future - Jax is a temporary distraction.

Stratton and Naomi will work a three-way vs. Bayley at Backlash in France (unless Nia is added to that equation too, which could happen). After that, WWE can go all in on Jax vs. Bayley one-on-one, and have Stratton muscle her way past Naomi in singles on the side. Win-win.


3. Gets An Up, But…

Cody Rhodes AJ Styles
WWE.com

The contract signing between Cody Rhodes and AJ Styles was respectful and tense. It was defo good enough to score an 'Up', but it might be smart for WWE to start thinking about another wrinkle for Cody's opponents other than chatting about Dusty's legacy. That gets a pass here, chiefly 'cause it makes sense with AJ, but they can't keep pounding that same drum over and over.

It'll get boring.

Back to the plus points. Styles does have history with Dusty, and he's recently been angry at LA Knight for scooping title shots out from underneath his nose. Now, AJ has his own championship opportunity, and there's a desperate air to his voice when he talks about making Cody crumble under the weight of the belt at Backlash.

Creative doesn't have much time to work with, obviously, but they can always have Styles continue to question whether or not Rhodes can write a new story after finishing one back at 'Mania. AJ is ideal for this sort of post-'Mania positioning. The strength of his and Cody's mic work pushed this segment into good territory.


2. Carmelo Hayes Targets The Champ

Cody Rhodes Triple H Carmelo Hayes
WWE.com

It's refreshing to see an NXT call-up go straight after the biggest champion on the roster immediately. That booking made Carmelo Hayes look like someone fans should pay close attention to on his first official night as a SmackDown talent, which is awesome. He's also good enough to wear that sort of lofty spot well (even if some folks who only watch main roster action might not know much about him).

Melo interrupting Cody and Triple H was bold, and it was even bolder when he fired out a challenge to Rhodes for a match. As a babyface hero who never backs down from a fight should, Rhodes accepted. Suddenly, SmackDown had one of the freshest main events in recent memory to showcase.

It's one they'll come back to in 2025.

Hayes never looked out of his depth when holding the stick and eyeballing Cody. He can be proud of that, not least when it would've been easier to wilt under the scorching spotlight here. Credit must go to Rhodes and Trips for treating Carmelo like a serious threat and a major player too.


1. Hanging With The Main Man

Cody Rhodes Carmelo Hayes
WWE.com

The actual match itself proved to be a winner as well.

Cody vs. Carmelo was hardly PLE headlining fare, but it did a neat job of properly introducing Hayes to a wider audience and making Rhodes look every bit the workhorse babyface into the bargain. The way Cody gritted his teeth and fought through a possible injury only added to that killer presentation.

Oh yes, this is one Hayes will gaze back on with a smile. He's gone from putting Trick Williams over at NXT Stand & Deliver to rubbing shoulders with the biggest star in the company right now. Shawn Michaels knew he had something special on his hands with Carmelo, and it seems Hunter will treat him well on the main roster too.

Cody isn't the kind of babyface champ who's going to swallow opponents up and spit them out. He's rather giving, and he let Hayes take the lead several times throughout the main. That made the match better. What an excellent start to life on SmackDown this was for Melo.

Fingers crossed WWE follows up.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out WWE Draft 2024: 5 Things That Will Happen (And 5 That WON’T!) and 30 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Attitude Era PPV!


 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.