5 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 25

The Show(stopper) Of Shows.

WWE.com

It took until 2009 for anybody to notice that the modern-day 'Show Of Shows' had actually become everything the company had purported it to be, and that was only because WrestleMania 25 was a crushing disappointment.

A crushing disappointment that housed what many consider the greatest match in company history - and, in doing so, set the trend for the new modern-day 'Show Of Shows' going forward. The permanent move back to stadiums in 2007 wasn't just Vince McMahon's final necessary flex as his organisation comfortably dominated the North American wrestling landscape he reshaped, but an instant visual clue that his 'Grandest Stage' was for everybody.

Mammoth (yet still artificially inflated) crowds filled the venues. Folk bought in their hundreds of thousands on pay-per-view. Talk shows took wrestlers as safe bet guests instead of host-injuring wild cards. Celebrities made themselves available to a show that once carried stigmas worse than the fallen stars themselves.

Fitting it all in forced the figuring in of longer runtimes. More pre-show patter. More PPV performances. More monetised WWE Network minutes. For better, and worse...

(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, XIV, XV, 2000, X-Seven, X8, XIX, XX, 21, 22, 23, XXIV)


Downs...

5. Swing And A Miss

WWE.com

It was bad enough that the 24 actual females past and present entered without individual recognition thanks to a grim Kid Rock medley deemed more important. Yes, that was bad enough. Minutes later, WWE topped themselves - a match paying tribute to the previous generations of women won by Santino Marella in drag.

This was, perhaps, the lowest ebb.

Eliminations occurred before ring announcer Justin Roberts had finished explaining the rules. Divas Champion Maryse was dumped out without fanfare, but then Michael Cole was busy calling Gail Kim as ‘one of the Bella Twins’ during her departure.

Ill-conceived and executed, the match degenerated into a patronising mess of blown spots and mistimed tumbles. 'Santina's eventual celebration was grimly appropriate - he victory dance may as well have been on the grave of of the women's division.


4. The Wrestler

WWE.com

Mickey Rourke's eye-opening portrayal of fallen wrestling idol Randy 'The Ram' Robinson in 2008's The Wrestler drew new eyes and fresh acclaim for the former Hollywood heartthrob, but an inadvertent tease that he may work an angle with Chris Jericho at the next WrestleMania created a worst case scenario knock-on effect for everybody involved.

WWE's old stink with Academy fuddy-duddies allegedly ruled Rourke out of winning an Oscar, whilst the actor himself subsequently distanced himself from the entire project.

What remained was the multi-man tragedy that befell Chris Jericho. Though one of the legends shone under the WrestleMania spotlight (and more on him later), 'Y2J's flippant wins over decrepit Hall-Of-Famers Roddy Piper and jimmy Snuka was depressing in the extreme. A post-match shadow box with Rourke was presented as making the best of a sh*tty situation, but even an in-form Rourke didn't have the acting chops to pull that performance off.


3. Oh Brother

WWE.com

Matt and Jeff Hardy famously caught the wrestling bug watching Randy Savage go the distance at WrestleMania IV 21 years earlier, and spent the next several years wrestling each other every day in taped trampoline scraps that eventually helped get them signed.

This was, theoretically, their fantasy booking come to life. Tragically, the reality was altogether different.

Matt had been slotted into a heel position initially arranged for a returning Christian before Vince McMahon swerved his audience for daring to predict it - but neither brother could summon either the love or the hate from a crowd that had prepared themselves for something else.

As was often the case during the mid-2000s, Matt and Jeff really clicked away from the 'Grandest Stage' glare one month later. A "WrestleMania Moment" was reserved in fate for them, but they'd be made to wait.


2. All Filler No Killer

WWE.com

Underwhelming from the start of the story to this half-baked conclusion, the prestige of the World Heavyweight Championship (and the fraying need for two titles in 2009) wasn't recovered just because 'The Champ' was reunited with his precious.

The match had one big spot to pop the crowd, but even that underwhelmed - a double Attitude Adjustment from super-strong SuperCena underwhelmed when he pied them one-by-one.

Edge and Big Show's pithy feud over Vickie Guerrero's affections hadn't ever felt earned, and nor had Show's place in this very match. Iconic rivals earlier during their ascensions, even Cena and 'The Rated-R Superstar' were tired tributes to themselves during this turgid triple threat.


1. That Old Familiar Feeling

WWE.com

It shocked few discerning fans that Triple H and Randy Orton had failed yet again to get anybody to give a single sh*t about their rivalry. But knowing was only half the battle.

A pair with the antithesis of chemistry on their best day (smash-cut to "SCENE MISSING" slide...), the layout, placing and pacing really didn't help. 'The Game' went in as Champion, but looking for redemption after Orton had terrorised the McMahon family. He was, however, held back by rules that prohibited him going beyond ordinary in-ring violence. Only he wasn't, because he still won.

The stipulation served as a pair of handcuffs. The 25 minute run-time was indefensible in a court of their peers. Following Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker was the death sentence.


Ups...

5. Punked Out

WWE.com

CM Punk's second consecutive Money In The Bank victory would prove to be just another imaginary brass ring he spoke of with such disdain in 2011, but it did at least draw the required gentle disdain thanks to one breakout 'Grandest Stage' display and one returning WrestleMania icon.

Before he was rocking Royal Rumbles, Kofi Kingston boy-popped in pursuit of the briefcase, and his physical gifts were extremely well-received by the massive Houston crowd. But it was Christian that held their collective hearts.

'Captain Charisma' had left an indelible Ladder Match legacy on the 'Show Of Shows', and the long memories of the fans in attendance were serviced by his every near-miss. 'The Straight Edge Superstar' was not their guy on this night, but he'd make good on the boos by the time he actually used the golden ticket.


4. Unleash The Dragon

WWE.com

Breathing fire against Chris Jericho and breathing life into what had up to then been the deadest part of the show, 'The Dragon' rolled back the years with a rip-roaring display against 'Y2J' that betrayed the bullsh*t that had been presented up to that point.

Jericho in near-peak form didn't have it in him to get something good from Jimmy Snuka or Roddy Piper, but didn't need to carry Ricky Steamboat in their mini-match before breaking Houston hearts with his breathless win.

Steamboat shocked the world here - his movement and timing mastery earned him a singles slot against 'Y2J' the next month, but the true magic was bottled within this majestic maximising of his WrestleMania minutes.


3. Gone Bradshaw Layfield

WWE.com

There was absolutely nothing to complain about from John Bradshaw Layfield's WrestleMania retirement, as the big Texan got some cheap shots in before the bell ahead of Rey Mysterio taking his Intercontinental Championship.

Going out the right way, JBL was comprehensively beaten by the 'Biggest Little Man' and made to look a bully and a fraud one last time on his way out.

His 2008 comeback had rapidly undone the goodwill built up amongst fans following a stellar year on commentary with Michael Cole, but he did at least keep his own involvement short when it was apparent just how little he could physically achieve. At 21 seconds immediately following the aforementioned over-wrought Hardyz hardcore bout, it was exactly what the crowd needed too.


2. Cenation

At time of writing, the above video of yet another spectacular John Cena entrance has been viewed over 55 and half million times, and it's probably safe to assume that the only a small percentage of those clicks came from the friends and families of the extras the decked themselves out like 'The Champ' on the 'Grandest Stage'.

It was beautiful in it's sheer absurdity.

WWE had made themselves an avatar so user-friendly that they decided to show and tell their biggest audience of the year all about it. The men that lined the ramp for the real Cena to run through sported his exact look just like millions of fans worldwide and the man himself. For all the match couldn't remotely deliver anything on par with what the crowd had already seen, the entrance remains one of the most brilliantly-curated flexes in company history.


1. The Greatest?

WWE

Something of a late bloomer as an in-ring performer after over a decade of duds, The Undertaker tightened his grip on superstardom with a superlative Shawn Michaels series, but WrestleMania 25's show-stealing masterpiece wasn't the start.

This Undertaker thrilled audiences at the end of the 2007 Royal Rumble. And at start of the 2008 one. And in two era-defining WrestleMania classics.

Once a frightened rabbit in the fearsome face of 'The Deadman' during their sensational 1997 rivalry, The 'Heartbreak Kid' was all man against him in their advancing years. Chasing a count-out win just for the win, Michaels exhibited spectacular desperation when Undertaker whiffed on a dive. Later, Undertaker lost all hope when Shawn somehow lifted a shoulder from the Tombstone.

'HBK's guts garnered no glory in the end as a Undertaker caught him off a moonsault with a second for the climactic conclusion, but this was a new beginning, rather than an end. The pair closed the book on moribund main events by cribbing pages from the New Japan Pro Wrestling playbook, but this script remained incomplete...


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.