5 Ups & 7 Downs For AEW In 2023 (So Far)

An erratic feel has blighted AEW's 2023 thus far, but the highs have been HUGE.

Some will glance at the 'Ups' and 'Downs' counts, scoff and then instantly figure there's an epic AEW slagging coming. Not quite. In fact, there's a lot to be cheerful about from the first six months of All Elite programming in 2023. Sadly, it's just that...well, the negatives have been a bit more abundant.

There's time for that to change, obviously. Tony Khan has some seriously-satisfying moments to look forward to between June-December. Specifically, he can point to a historic date in the UK and the magic of that coming Wembley Stadium show. Then, there will be other twists and turns along the way.

That's the beauty of pro wrestling - it's ever-changing.

CM Punk will be back soon, and his return handily lines up with the debut of Collision. AEW's brand new Saturday night show will supplant Rampage as the company's 'B' show. Depending on viewership and overall fan interest, it could even equal 'A' show Dynamite long-term.

So, what's been good and bad about the first part of AEW's year? Let the differing opinions commence, because you will not agree with everything here. That's fine, but here goes...


Downs...

7. The TNT Title Mess

Wardlow AEW TNT Title
AEW

Wardlow-related grumbles technically started in 2022 when he lost the TNT Title without being pinned/submitted at Full Gear. Samoa Joe choked out Powerhouse Hobbs to grab the gold, then AEW began passing TNT around like it was the old WWF Hardcore belt.

Darby Allin won it, Joe regained the thing, Wardlow had his second go-around, Powerhouse Hobbs "enjoyed" a short reign, then Wardlow won it again in mid-April. Some consistency would be nice, because all these start-stop pushes are doing nothing for the title or the wrestlers chasing it.

WWE would be (rightly) blasted for this sort of sh*t.

Of the five title changes thus far in 2023, only one has felt like it actually mattered; Wardlow's win over Joe at Revolution should've settled things down, but it didn't. In fact, the company just went wild by booking Hobbs' rubbish stint before putting it back on Wardlow anyway.


6. Missed Opportunities In The Tag Ranks

The Acclaimed AEW Tag-Team Titles
AEW

The Acclaimed deserved way more than they got from AEW after becoming Tag-Team Champions last September. Despite clearly becoming one of the most popular acts in wrestling, the duo lost those belts to The Gunns on Dynamite in February. Then, to top things off, Billy's sons lost to FTR in early-April.

It's hard to hate on FTR bagging belts, but stability is needed. The AEW tag-team scene is pretty much in the same state as the TNT Title division. Things have been rather erratic, and Tony Khan has to yet to prove that he can settle down a little here. Hopefully, FTR will calm his booking style.

It's anyone's guess what the future holds for Anthony Bowens and Max Caster though. They've moved sideways to the Trios Title scene alongside Billy Gunn, but were unable to take the belts from House Of Black at Double Or Nothing.

Has AEW poured cold water on The Acclaimed just as they caught fire?


5. Rampage’s Decline

AEW Rampage logo
AEW

Sure, the 'B' show dropped in quality significantly throughout 2022, but 2023 has been really poor. Rampage has fallen off a cliff in terms of overall importance to AEW. Worse, it's about to become the default 'C' show once Collision launches, and the duff ratings reflect this slide.

Tony Khan's apathy towards Rampage has transferred over onto his audience, and no amount of last-minute tweets hyping the card will change that. People know they'll rarely (if ever) see anything that actually matters on the Friday show. It's a collection of decent-good matches with barely any consequence.

This could be the beginning of the end.

It's not beyond the realms of possibility that Rampage will slip even further before the end of the year. Christ, it already feels like Khan is writing the show's format on the back of a napkin in catering, and it's hard to envision him putting more emphasis on it now he has Collision to think about.


4. Dynamite Is No Longer Appointment TV?

Tony Khan
AEW

This point is definitely arguable.

Go back and watch the earlier episodes of Dynamite post-launch in 2019. Then, fire up one from 2023 and see if you can spot one of the biggest differences. High-quality wrestling is still there, and some of the storytelling is perfectly fine. There isn't the same pull generally though.

Dynamite once felt like can't miss telly for wrestling fans. It was vibrant, different and a clear alternative to plodding programming over on the WWE side. AEW's flagship doesn't have that same appeal these days, sadly. The ratings curve has flattened, and it's hard to see how TK grows his audience exponentially.

Hell, maybe he doesn't need to. Maybe execs at TNT/TBS are happy with the numbers, and it's fair to say wrestling has other measurable metrics that count too (check out the 'Ups' for that!). AEW is hardly in trouble, but Dynamite no longer comes across as the most must-see wrestling broadcast of the week.


3. A PPV Stinker

AEW Double Or Nothing 2023 Adam Cole Chris Jericho
AEW

Time to zoom in on one specific pay-per-view clanger.

Chris Jericho vs. Adam Cole has been called the worst AEW pay-per-view match ever by many this week. That's likely a case of recency bias, but the bout wasn't very good. All Elite didn't help matters by sticking it on the same card as a riotous 'Anarchy In The Arena' scrap at Double Or Nothing, to be fair.

Regardless, Cole vs. Jericho was 17 minutes of painfully-slow brawling that felt like it lasted 17 hours. There was a total lack of intensity despite the fiery build, which included Britt Baker getting a black eye, and nothing seemed to come off for these guys. Also, Sabu might've made one of the worst PPV cameo appearances in company history.

He disappeared mere minutes in, then Jericho and Cole proceeded to crawl their way through an uninspired set of spots that the live crowd badly struggled to care about. Some are even calling this a sure sign that Jericho is finished. That's harsh, but the "Unsanctioned" match did suck.


2. The Spectre Of CM Punk Drama

CM Punk AEW Return Update
AEW

CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk, CM Punk.

Punk's dramatic exit from AEW in late-2022 and his increasingly-likely comeback has dominated promotional chatter for the first six months of 2023, and rarely in a positive way. In fact, people seemed to be sick of CM by the time Tony Khan gleefully announced he'd be back for Collision's debut on 17 June.

This better end well. If Punk brings even more drama to All Elite's door during the second half of the year, then Khan will look foolish for bringing him back into the mix. It's also vitally important for the wrestler's own relationship with pro wrestling fans that he has critically-acclaimed matches/feuds that help AEW grow.

One thing's for sure: Punk has been more akin to a negative than a positive this year. Time for that to change? Absolutely. Will it? Watch this space.


1. Hyped Signings Without Substance

Jay White
AEW

Jay White was touted as a major coup for AEW when he officially became #AllElite in early-April. This was particularly pleasing for company hardcores, because WWE had reportedly fancied inking a deal with White too. Tony Khan got his man...then proceeded to do absolutely nothing of note with him.

'Switchblade' is teaming with Juice Robinson as Bullet Club Gold, and was just another face in the 'Blackjack Battle Royal' at Double Or Nothing. Yes, this marquee free agent signing was there to make up in the numbers in a 21-man International Title bout. Wow.

That's indicative of a wider bitch about AEW. They've got far too many wrestlers under contract, and don't know what to do with half of them. Collision might remedy that, but White's plight is a dizzying reminder of how easy it is for even top workers to get lost in the shuffle.

Man, hope White and Juice vs. FTR cures all ills.


Ups...

5. AEW Starting House Shows

AEW House Rules
AEW

Previously, working limited dates compared to WWE's more rigorous schedule was a dangling carrot for wrestlers signing with AEW. One match per week (at most) became the norm for many, but the company began promoting non-televised live events this past March.

They've been testing the waters ever since.

Fingers crossed this expands into a fuller touring schedule, because there are tons of workers on the roster who'd benefit from more in-ring reps. House shows should also, in theory, let AEW dip a toe into fresh markets to gauge interest - if successful, those places would then get Dynamite, Collision and/or pay-per-views.

The biggest benefit of house show touring is that wrestling fans get more top-notch fare in local markets. AEW's roster produces the goods in-ring, so you're practically guaranteed a night of great wrestling if you buy a ticket.

This is a big positive for the promotion.


4. Hangman Page Rejoins The Elite

The Elite
AEW

Boy-oh-boy, this was tremendously executed.

Hangman Page roared out to reunite with old pals Kenny Omega and The Young Bucks on the 18 May edition of Dynamite. He was the final piece of the jigsaw for The Elite vs. Blackpool Combat Club, and AEW's fanbase was absolutely here for it. They were loud.

A resultant 'Anarchy In The Arena' scrap between both squads at Double Or Nothing then earned rave reviews from most. Best of all, reuniting with The Elite was a change Hangman's career solely needed. He had to stop p*ssing around with The Dark Order etc, and get right back to basics.

Page seemed more important to AEW TV again immediately. There's just something right about seeing him line up next to Omega and The Bucks. This alliance is one Khan and pals can reap rewards from for a solid 12-18 months before moving on.


3. Collision Is Coming

AEW Collision
AEW

Yes, yes it does resemble classic WCW Monday Nitro.

That's not a diss, it's simply the truth. AEW's new Collision show already conjures up images of Nitro's glory days, but it'll feel fresh to younger viewers who didn't live through WCW's peak. Really, the aesthetic is an overall win for Tony Khan, but it'll be interesting to see what the numbers are like for All Elite's new Saturday night show.

It'd be stupid to give Collision a 'Down' without at least seeing what it's like. This show deserves a fair shake, and everyone's hopeful that it'll sit snugly alongside Dynamite as 'A' tier AEW programming every single week. There has also been talk of a soft brand split to help differentiate it too.

The hubbub generated by a new weekend wrestling show earned Collision 'Up' status here. Khan's announcement, and the fact it gives people more rasslin' to watch, should be viewed as a good thing. Go forth and smash it, AEW!


2. An ‘Iron Man’ Classic

AEW Revolution 2023 MJF Bryan Danielson
AEW

60-minute matches are a risk in the age of endless scrolling and lower-than-ever attention spans. Remarkably, unlike the aforementioned Chris Jericho vs. Adam Cole snore, MJF vs. Bryan Danielson at Revolution raced by whilst somehow still feeling epic.

That speaks to the talent of both men.

Their 'Iron Man' match at Revolution was a pure joy. It was excellently-worked from start to finish, had the right winner, and was all-round wrestling goodness without interruption. If anything, it's the kind of bout purists wanted from AEW when the promotion launched in 2019.

A LeBell Lock finish in overtime made MJF the captain of sh*thousery too. That was a neat touch, one that sold him as AEW's premier heel. Danielson, to his credit, did everything in his power to cement Friedman's World Title reign. Mission accomplished, gentleman.

What a classic.


1. The Wembley Stadium Ticket Rush

AEW All In UK 2023
AEW

AEW only announced that they'd be invading London's Wembley Stadium this summer on 5 April. Some critics scoffed, but Tony Khan had the last laugh when tickets went on sale. AEW shifted around 36,000 briefs during the first day of pre-sales, then announced they'd hit 43,000 the next day.

General sales started on 5 May, and the number soared to approx 60,000. That's a magnificent achievement, and shows there's a hunger for non-WWE stadium shows in the UK. Make no mistake, this was a massive success for AEW, and one they're rightly bragging about.

Now, there's a very-real chance the company could fill Wembley in late-August. Imagine that?! Sure, there will likely be some comps and discounted tiks along the way, but this is still set to be a money-spinner for Khan and AEW. It's colossal, and probs ruffled a few feathers at WWE HQ too.

Where's that 'angrytremblingTriple H.GIF' file when one needs it?

What do you think of AEW's 2023 thus far? For more like this, check out 10 Ups & 6 Downs For WWE In 2023 (So Far) and 10 WWE Nightmares Vince McMahon MUST Regret Booking!


Watch Next


In this post: 
CM Punk
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.