5 Ups And 2 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Mar 14)
Bray Wyatt is reborn, but Shane McMahon & AJ Styles steal the show.
With just two weeks of television left before WrestleMania 33, all of SmackDown's major matches are finally in place. Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt was put together last week, but last night saw The Miz & Maryse vs. John Cena & Nikki Bella and Shane McMahon vs. AJ Styles finally coming together, rubber-stamping the blue brand's top three bouts for Orlando.
All three rivalries enjoyed a healthy presence on last night's show, but it was Shane vs. AJ that took centre stage. The duo were all over the show, book-ending with AJ's opening promo and Shane's closing diatribe, with a brutal parking lot assault sandwiched in-between. It was a mixed bag of content, however, as while most of the storyline's contributions were strong, it wound-up derailing SmackDown in a major way.
The other two rivalries escalated through words, not physicality, while SmackDown's women played a prominent role as the build to their multi-person WrestleMania match continues. American Alpha returned to television after several weeks in the abyss, meanwhile, but the likes of Dean Ambrose and Luke Harper were nowhere to be found.
The good outweighed the bad on this week's SmackDown, but the show still hit a couple of major snags. How do they all stack up? Let's take a look...
Downs...
2. How To Lose Your Audience
Last night's SmackDown Live was a fine show until little over halfway through, when Dolph Ziggler and Mojo Rawley showed-up to do their best to put the audience to sleep. Their match was a follow-up from a confrontation last week, when Mojo burned Ziggler for his career's lack of WrestleMania moments, and while brief, it succeeded only in derailing SmackDown.
Mojo still isn't over with the crowd, and if Ziggler has even a small amount of cache left with his once loyal fanbase, it wasn't on display last night. The match completely sucked the life out of the arena, and furthered a rivalry that should have never been built in the first place. Mojo scored a count-out victory when Ziggler walked-out on the match after less than three minutes, and though the goal was likely to build hype for the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, WWE accomplished the opposite here.
Matches like this really expose SmackDown's paper-thin midcard. The writers are continually forced to feature wrestlers with little to no crowd investment, and while that's partly their fault for not building them up over the past few months, the blue brand are in dire need of a refresh at this level. For SmackDown, those rumoured post-WrestleMania roster trades can't come soon enough.
1. Never Mind The Tag Division, Here's Shane McMahon
SmackDown finally remembered that it has a tag division this week. The Usos and American Alpha have been off television for close to a month, and for the second time in their SmackDown careers, it looked like their feud had been completely forgotten about. The crowd had almost forgotten either team existed, but despite this, WWE decided to pair them up for the main event.
The Usos won, but the company didn't even pretend to care about the match. Instead of focusing on the action, WWE indulged in one of their favourite tropes by having an authority figure completely steal the spotlight from active roster members. The match was first disrupted by footage of Shane McMahon in the backstage area, and from that point on, JBL and Tom Phillips weren't focused on the match at all. All they cared about was Shane's medical condition, and the action completely passed them by.
Shane was shown backstage again just before the match reached its conclusion, then arrived on the stage in the immediate aftermath. The show closed with him booking his match with AJ Styles at WrestleMania, which was inevitable sooner or later, but it's a shame SmackDown couldn't find a way to do it without trampling on their tag division.
There was no need to completely disrespect American Alpha and The Usos in such a manner, but at this point, it looks like WWE have zero interest in putting the spotlight on tag team wrestling in the near future.
Ups...
5. AJ's Rage
The AJ Styles/Shane McMahon story went off a cliff later in the show, but their first few contributions were excellent. SmackDown opened with Styles demanding Shane's presence following last week's argument on Talking Smack, then cutting an intense, venomous promo on the brand's commissioner. Chastising management for essentially taking his WrestleMania match away after carrying SmackDown since the brand split, Styles came-off very strongly throughout.
The duo finally got violent later in the show. Shane arrived at the building halfway through the night, but AJ was in no mood for talking. Styles beat McMahon down in the parking lot, smashed his head through a car window, and walked away. Daniel Bryan was naturally furious, and after claiming he'd lost all respect for the former WWE Champion, he "fired" him, and banished him from the building.
These first two AJ/Shane segments were great, and escalated their rivalry in a quick, effective manner. While many fans would rather see Styles face a more credible opponent, few could complain about these segments, and the car window spot suggests that the match should be a great deal more heated than Shane's last WrestleMania bout. Here's hoping the feud continues down this route, rather than following the main event's example.
4. Carmella Joins The Hunt
There wasn't much creativity in the way SmackDown's women were booked this week, but they had a solid show regardless. It started with the first match of the night, Becky Lynch vs. Natalya, which held the crowd's attention throughout, and accomplished its goal of giving Becky a credible victory over one of her WrestleMania opponents.
Carmella jumped both women after the bell, and later confirmed that she intends to enter the SmackDown Women's Title match at WrestleMania. This brings the match's list of participants up to five, and while there was nothing original about the way WWE inserted Carmella into the fray, it got the job done. She won't exactly be a favourite, but if SmackDown are going to utilise every available woman in Orlando, Carmella can't not be involved.
Becky will walk into the match with a great chance of winning, so it was important to give her a strong victory. Natalya, meanwhile, has settled into a midcard gatekeeper role since joining the blue brand, and that doesn't look like changing anytime soon. She's a strong competitor who's capable of having a good match with almost anybody, but lacks the star-power to lead the division like a Becky Lynch or Alexa Bliss, and it'd be a big surprise if she won on April 2nd. Still, the build to the match has been well done thus far, and it should be a fun, chaotic affair.
3. This Week On Miz TV...
We should know what we're getting from The Miz, Maryse, John Cena, and Nikki Bella at this point. The feud has largely revolved around both couples throwing deeply personal verbal barbs at each other, and that's probably how it's going to continue for the next couple of weeks. If the segments are as strong as they have been thus far, however, nobody will be complaining, and last night's Miz TV was typically excellent.
Miz once again felt like he was shooting from the hip as he continued his theme of drawing upon real-life criticisms to run Cena into the ground. Maryse wasn't shy of getting involved either, and while not as refined as her husband, her promo was equally vociferous. The duo have done a great job of exposing their twisted visions of Bella and Cena to to the world, and they have successfully built one of WrestleMania's most heated rivalries as a result.
Their words eventually drew Cena & Bella out from backstage, but Daniel Bryan interjected before things could get too out of hand. The match is finally in the books, and while Bryan is in real danger of becoming a full-on Cena apologist character, he clearly has a dog in this fight. He's right when he says that Miz is taking advantage of the fact that he can't fight him, and an embarrassing Miz loss will be high on Bryan's WrestleMania wishlist.
2. A Big Win For Mickie James
The build towards WrestleMania's SmackDown Women's Title match continued with Mickie James vs. Alexa Bliss, which didn't have the same level of crowd investment as Natalya vs. Becky Lynch, but was the better match all-round. Bliss has been hit and miss in the ring, as has James in her recent matches with Lynch, but both performed well last night. They have strong chemistry together, and their work was sharp throughout.
It ended in a loss for the champion, and Mickie's biggest victory since returning to the main roster. Though the crowd were unfortunately quiet throughout, it wasn't through a lack of effort from the women, who both went all-out to try and capture the audience's waning attention. It resulted in the strongest match of the night, and after capitalising on a mistake from the champion, James emerged with a much-needed win.
SmackDown's women continue to enjoy a prominent position on the show. They haven't been pushed as far into the spotlight as Charlotte Flair and Sasha Banks on Raw, but they don't really need to be. They're regularly enjoying their fair share of weekly television time, and you can bet your house on the blue brand allotting at least 20-30 minutes of segment time to their women every week. The WrestleMania match reeks of getting as many people onto the show as possible, but should be a lot of fun.
1. Forged In Hell
Things have quietened down for Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt since the shack-burning incident. The Viper's betrayal sent Wyatt into hiding last week, but Orton stayed active by defeating AJ Styles to finally cement his number one contendership. Last night saw Orton hit the ring to address the crowd, and while the ensuing segment didn't represent either man's best work, it was an effective follow-up.
Orton explained that his relationship with Wyatt was just a ploy to get close to him before hitting the Eater of Worlds where it hurt. He successfully did that by destroying Sister Abigail's burial ground, but after promising to take everything that Wyatt had left, Orton was interrupted.
The WWE Champion appeared on the screen, and indulged in some of his hokier tendencies. Claiming that Abigail was "forged in hell, and her heart still beats," Wyatt stated that the betrayal had only made him stronger, then baptised himself in Abigail's ashes, adding at least one more level of creepiness to WWE's creepiest character.
If you're not excited about this feud, this segment probably won't do much to change your perception, but the performances were relatively strong. The initial Orton vs. Wyatt feud wasn't particularly compelling, but they have turned things around through their brief allegiance, and created a match worth of taking a prominent card position at WrestleMania. The one remaining question surrounds Luke Harper's involvement, though this will surely be addressed in time.