5 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Madison Square Garden 2015

The Beast annihilates in a largely forgettable show.

For all the hype leading up to Saturday€™s WWE live event at Madison Square Garden, the main attraction was more of a massacre than a Clash of the Titans. The company tried to portray Big Show versus Brock Lesnar as some huge, storied rivalry, despite Lesnar obliterating Show when they last faced at Royal Rumble 2014. They tried to make Show look like he was unstoppable by having him beat up lower-card wrestlers in the lead-up to Saturday. None of that mattered, as Lesnar did what many expected: shrug off the attack and destroy the giant in mere minutes. That doesn€™t mean it wasn€™t entertaining, but it does mean that the big selling point for the show was not nearly as epic as the billing suggested. With three title matches and no new champions crowned, and relatively short matches (by PPV standards), this was a largely forgettable show. Sure, it was Madison Square Garden, but if you don€™t care about that sort of thing, then it was just a televised house show. Still, there were some entertaining moments throughout, and if you were bored Saturday night, it wasn€™t a bad way to spend the evening. So what shined in the Big Apple and what got taken away with the trash? Let€™s find out€


Downs€

6. Fun And Forgettable

Anyone who has been to a WWE house show knows what they€™re in for: a fun night that has no lasting effects on the overall product or storylines. Saturday€™s Madison Square Garden show was in that same vein, with very few developments and little resolved. An episode of Raw moves storylines more. While that isn€™t a bad thing, it wouldn€™t have killed WWE to have a couple significant developments. Look at Beast in the East, where we crowned a new NXT Champion and Neville had a standout match with Chris Jericho. At MSG, there were three title matches, with three successful defenses, a mix-and-match tag team match and a repeat Divas match from Raw. The unique match was Brock Lesnar versus Big Show, which might have some fallout if Show addresses it on Raw, but otherwise, it was just a fun, extended squash for the Beast. Again, it€™s not a terrible thing, but it€™s a shame considering that WWE bragged about all the huge things that have occurred in MSG that something big didn€™t happen Saturday.

5. Return Of The Pink Ropes

It€™s October, which once again means a month of WWE turning everything pink in an overt attempt to show how much the company cares about battling breast cancer. That means pre-taped segments with superstars talking about breast cancer, John Cena and others hawking merchandise washed in pink. To be fair, other professional sports also are doing the same thing this month €“ in the NFL, even the referees are sporting pink whistles €“ but that doesn€™t make it any less annoying. It doesn€™t help that WWE partners with Susan G. Komen, which has had its share of issues through the years. Look for WWE to toot its own horn a lot on the next several episodes of Raw about how much it cares about breast cancer, which will likely grate on everyone by the end of the month.

4. Tugging On Superman€™s Cape

The ongoing Neville/Stardust rivalry is just perplexing on many levels. Both men are extremely talented and capable of having good matches, and Cody Rhodes€™ commitment to his gimmick is admirable. But this feud just doesn€™t click. The two got some time for their one-on-one match Saturday night (as opposed to the rushed bouts on Raw), and it boiled down to Stardust being obsessed with Neville€™s cape. Yes, his cape. At one point, Stardust put the cape on and flew off the top rope, only to get superkicked and then defeated moments later. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=50j4GRzIak4 Neither man has anything else going on, which is a shame, but this rivalry doesn€™t look like ti€™s going to lead to bigger and better things for either man.

3. Directionless Heels

Saturday€™s event was simply a televised house show, so it€™s understandable that you would see the good guys with their hands raised more often than not. But that still is no excuse for how Sheamus and Rusev were left flailing in their tag match against Randy Orton and Dolph Ziggler. Sheamus, who should be a world champion at some point in the next eight months due to his Money in the Bank briefcase, ate the loss again. Then Rusev grabbed the mic and started berating him for losing, and the Celtic Warrior hit him with a Brogue Kick, making the Bulgarian Brute look more than like a goof. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apa1SBvy88w The bigger problem here is that there are no real monster heels right now in WWE, so having two guys who could be serious villains get neutered repeatedly like Sheamus and Rusev have been just highlights the problem. Saturday€™s tag match wasn€™t offensive on its own, but it just furthered the issue.

2. Night Of Champions Redux

WWE did a nice job playing up the Dudley Boyz€™ Tag Team Championship match against New Day, making it look like winning the titles was a strong possibility, even the duo€™s destiny. Instead, the match ended the same way that it did two weeks earlier at Night of Champions, with Xavier Woods causing a disqualification by breaking up a Dudleys€™ pinfall attempt. If WWE was going to pull the trigger on a record 10th tag title reign for the Dudleys, Saturday at MSG was the time and place to do it. But if they aren€™t going to give Bubba Ray and D-Von the belts, then New Day should have actually gotten a pinfall victory (whether it€™s through cheating or clean is immaterial) rather than just prolonging the feud. The Dudleys reunion tour in WWE was a nice idea, but having them win matches by DQ and then €œgetting their heat back€ by beating up the guy who more or less is the manager isn€™t a memorable way to go out.

1. Raising Kane

Glad to see WWE making new main event stars, pushing that up-and-coming talent, Kane, to the main event. Let€™s make sure we€™re clear about this: This is the same guy who has won 18 televised matches since 2014 while losing 69 bouts. And now that Kane has re-donned his mask, he€™s now being pushed as an unstoppable monster. Witness WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins, the supposed best in the business, cowering in fear and then getting annihilated by the Big Red Monster on Saturday. Kane is supposedly dominant once again and presumably will headline the Hell in a Cell PPV at age 48. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tBInfTz-Rjc Don€™t get it wrong, this dual personality deal with Corporate Kane seemingly unaware of (or willfully ignoring) Demon Kane is fun and has made the character more interesting than he€™s been in more than a year. But pushing him as a top guy suddenly after jobbing him out for two years is just ridiculous.

UPS€

5. Heyman Stays Connected

In case you missed it (and shame on you if you did), Paul Heyman updated his old Paul E. Dangerously character a little Saturday night. Dangerously was known for carrying that old (well, new at the time) brick cell phone to ringside, which often would be used on opponents during matches. In a backstage interview with Renee Young before his client€™s match, Heyman repeated waved around not one, but two cell phones in his right hand. Interestingly enough, one was an iPhone and the other was an Android. Heyman€™s been seen with a cell phone in hand in recent years, but there was something about being in his hometown that made it a little more pointed. And as usual, Heyman€™s promo was absolutely outstanding, firing up the crowd and hyping the imminent match.

4. Paige Left High And Dry

One of the few big developments during Saturday€™s show was the continued implosion of PCB. Five days after Paige walked out on Charlotte and Becky Lynch, the girls gave Paige a taste of her own medicine. After Paige inexplicably tagged herself in, Charlotte and Becky short-armed her and walked out on the match, leaving her to take the loss. In this case, turnabout was fair play, and it likely signals the end of any semblance of a partnership between the three. Of course, there€™s always the chance that they will try to reconcile on Raw and things will string out for another week, but at least Charlotte and Becky stuck up for themselves Saturday instead of getting ditched again and looking like fools.

3. Trip Down Memory Lane

Say what you will about Chris Jericho returning to WWE seemingly just to lose matches, but his pre-match promo at Madison Square Garden was actually a pretty cool deal that made his appearance feel a little more special. Y2J took the mic and noted that October 3rd was his 25th anniversary as a professional wrestler. He told the story of his first match in 1990 in Alberta, Canada against Lance Storm, who was front row in attendance. Jericho then reminisced about his own history in MSG, how his father played hockey in the Garden with the New York Rangers, and other memories. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7o2MKKyLCg Sure, Jericho lost his Intercontinental Championship match against Kevin Owens, but his promo was a cool moment. The only thing that would€™ve topped it would have been Owens coming out and cutting into Jericho with his own promo.

2. Calling It Like They See It

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94S8nuW8ooE If you saw the WWE Network program €œTable for 3€ that featured the New Day, you learned that the WWE Tag Team Champions improvise a lot of the stuff they say during their promos, which begs the question: Why do they pay writers in the first place? New Day€™s antics are always one of the best parts of any WWE program, and the Madison Square Garden show was no exception. They jumped on the Dudley Boyz, mocking their €œ90s television€ references, specifically the €œWazzup?!€ drop, and how they wear glasses without lenses. It€™s stuff like that that makes them a highly entertaining act, and it makes one wonder if there are others on the roster who could blossom like this if they were unchained from the anchor that the writing staff can be.

1. Beast Mode On

Despite the buildup and multiple squash victories, no one seriously thought Big Show was going to present much of a challenge for Brock Lesnar. In fact, the only questions were how long would the match last and how dominant would Brock be. The answers to those questions were simple: €œNot long€ and €œvery.€ Lesnar shrugged off three successive chokeslams to quickly deliver four German suplexes and an F5 for the convincing victory. To add insult to injury, Brock returned to confront a dazed Big Show, who flipped off Lesnar. Brock would deliver an overhead belly-to-belly suplex and another massive F5 to the hapless giant. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AQ6t_rxj778 It will be interesting to see if this is played up at all on Raw, whether Show comes out and laments losing so convincingly. Fans have been chanting for Show to retire, so maybe it€™s time to incorporate that into a storyline.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.