5 Ups And Downs From Last Night's WWE Raw (Dec 15)

Here comes the pain.

The advertisements might have said that Raw is Jericho, but Monday night belonged to one man, a long-absent conqueror who was mowing down anyone in his path before he disappeared this fall. No not Roman Reigns. Welcome to Raw is Lesnar. As much as it has been a well-deserved criticism that WWE World Heavyweight Champion Brock Lesnar€™s absence has drastically hurt the WWE product, his return from a three-month hiatus automatically strengthens the programming. Reigns€™ return to in-ring action €“ even if limited right now €“ also has a similar effect of bolstering WWE. And their returns could not come at a better time. WWE continues to falter in the wake of injuries, part-time wrestlers, poor writing, pacing problems and an overall lackluster product. Monday night€™s Raw wasn€™t bad, but aside from a tremendous main event and a couple other bright spots, there wasn€™t much to this. There just are too many confusing decisions being made right now that run counter to what you would expect. Case in point: Why is Dolph Ziggler, who won the Survivor Series main event and then recaptured the Intercontinental Championship the night before jerking the curtain and then losing (although he thankfully wasn€™t pinned)? If the announcers are going to build him up on commentary, then the booking has to match that. If not, what€™s the point? That€™s just one quick example. Let€™s get to the ups and downs of Monday Night Raw.

DOWNS...

5. Where Was This Match Sunday Night?

Don€™t take this the wrong way. The main event steel cage match between John Cena and Seth Rollins was tremendous. Both men hit each other with their proverbial haymakers and kept coming back for more. Sure, Rollins€™ security team got involved (as expected), but even their interference didn€™t detract from a solid match. The problem is, this was a free match on Raw with no stipulations, not the PPV match that had Cena€™s number one contender€™s spot on the line. The Tables, Ladders & Chairs match between Cena and Rollins was an overbooked mess that was hampered by constant interference, run-ins and false finishes. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3NKy6SCJvPE Had this cage match taken place Sunday night, TLC would have been a lot more tolerable. Sure, the ending wouldn€™t quite fit, but the effort and performance were so much better last night.

4. Gotta Keep Show Strong€ Why?

Without rehashing everything that was said in the rundown of TLC, there€™s no good reason for Big Show to keep beating younger talent to build him up€ just so he can put over another young talent down the road. In this case, Show knocked out and pinned Erick Rowan for the second consecutive night. Also for the second consecutive night, Show had a confrontation with Roman Reigns. And Reigns once again got the better of the exchange. It€™s obvious here that the writers are trying to make Big Show look like an unstoppable monster so that it€™s a perceived bigger deal when Reigns eventually takes him out. Unfortunately, Show is quickly reaching Kane levels of irrelevance. While Kane is generally respected as an all-time great big man, no one takes him seriously as a threat when a hero is booked against him. Kane is the former monster resting on his laurels and reputation, when he hasn€™t been that person for quite some time. Show is about the same thing right now, so having him beat Rowan isn€™t building Show up, it€™s stunting Rowan€™s growth. Just let Reigns decimate Show and move on.

3. Miz Messes With A Married Woman

On the one hand, it€™s good to see some actual backstage character development involving tag teams and a woman that doesn€™t revolve around a Total Divas crossover. But making sense of this is a head-scratcher. If the Usos were tag team champs, then this would at least be plausible: Miz is trying to get in Jimmy Uso€™s head by targeting his wife Naomi. But Miz (and Damien Mizdow) already has the titles. Then after the two have a one-on-one match and Jimmy gets his retribution, Miz continues the mindgames with Naomi. Why? We know Miz is married to former Diva Maryse, so it€™s probably not going down an infidelity route. This is a tough one to predict the payoff. Call this a cautious €œdown€ for now with some upside that there€™s more to the storyline than the highly entertaining Mizdow flopping around at ringside.

2. Treading Water Has Begun

The gap between Survivor Series and TLC was a scant three weeks, leaving barely enough time to digest the departure of the Authority and set up an eight-match pay-per-view. But the gap between TLC and Royal Rumble? That would be six weeks, with the usually slow, no-angle advancing weeks around the Christmas and New Year€™s holidays in the middle. This means that storylines most likely will move slowly, almost repeating themselves over the next couple weeks. There were a couple major developments Monday night (more on them in a bit), but given that two of the six bouts were rematches from TLC, another was a tag team match combining two other TLC contests and a fourth was a singles match derived from a TLC tag team match, it seems like the slow doggie-paddle toward Royal Rumble is underway.

1. The New Day Is A Ploy, Right?

We€™ve now seen the trio New Day in action a few times, and it really is just Kofi Kingston, Big E and Xavier Woods in matching tights with a positivity-preaching gimmick. Maybe it€™s just slow to catch on, but they just aren€™t getting a good reaction from fans. Even when he was jobbing left and right, Kofi still got a good response from the crowd for his offense. That seems to have ebbed as part of this stable. Monday night, the crowd seemed more interested in chanting for CM Punk and even NXT than New Day. When Xavier Woods got the €œhot tag,€ the fans actually turned on him, booing his offense. The conspiracy theorist would suggest that the New Day is a ploy to get fans to turn against three longtime faces, leading them to turn their backs on the fans and thus let them re-launch themselves as a more serious, edgier group closer to what they originally seemed to be back in the summer. Think of shoving an overly happy and positive Rocky Maivia down the fans€™ throats. New Day€™s positivity, clapping and smiling is almost too saccharine to be genuine. Or maybe Vince McMahon really thinks this is how you push three young black wrestlers in 2014.

UPS...

5. Reigns O€™er WWE

There are plenty of people who don€™t think Roman Reigns€™ anointing as the heir apparent is €œbest for business,€ that either of his two former Shield stablemates would be better standard-bearers. And his return has felt forced in some ways €“ the Superstar of the Year Slammy despite missing three months of action, and the constant updates on his health whereas other injured wrestlers disappear for months. But it stands to reason that Reigns€™ injury has put his ascension up the card behind schedule and WWE is compressing everything to make it still work for WrestleMania XXXI. The concern from some fans is that WWE is shoving Reigns down our throats, which is similar to what happened with Batista around this time last year (ironically enough, Reigns was the last man Batista eliminated from the Rumble). But Roman got a pretty solid reaction at Raw, drawing chants and a big cheer for taking out Fandango, then socking Big Show with a Superman punch. That€™s an easy way to increase someone€™s popularity immediately: Have them take out an annoying character that everyone just wants to see defeated or off their screen altogether.

4. Thank You Kane!

Case in point, Kane became the most popular wrestler in Detroit Monday night when he hit a tombstone piledriver on the Bunny. After demolishing Adam Rose and hitting a double chokeslam on Rose and the Bunny, Kane accommodated the fans who chanted, €œOne more time!€ and sent the man in a bunny costume straight to hell. Even €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin got in on the action, tweeting a Jim Ross-esque, €œBah Gawd that bunny had a family, dammit!!!€ Hopefully, this means that WWE finally recognized that the Bunny is a god-awful character that has no business being on television, especially the same program as a former UFC champion in Brock Lesnar. With a little luck, the Bunny has indeed been euthanized, as JBL said. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GjajtVTZKLI And really, it€™s for the best. Any reveal of a wrestler under that head would be a massive disappointment and hurt that person€™s career. Poor Hector Guerrero is still known to more casual fans as the Gobbledy Gooker than anything else.

3. The Irresistible Force Meets The Immovable Object

Smart, bold booking reared its head during Raw when Ryback took up the challenge laid down by U.S. Champion Rusev. The Bulgarian Brute has been on a tear since debuting in WWE, mowing down everyone in his path. He seemed to be stalling a little recently due to Survivor Series, but he still is one of the more protected heels in the company. At this point though, Rusev needs a serious challenge. Enter Ryback, who since returning from an injury has largely been booked similarly to how he debuted back in 2012, bulldozing opponents as a fan favorite. Even with some questionable booking here and there, the fans still exploded and loudly chanted, €œFeed me more!€ when the Big Guy answered the call to stand up to Rusev. This really is smart booking. It€™s not often that the company has two dominant forces cross paths. Usually, the company tries to keep them separate to keep them both strong. By pitting them against each other though, WWE is potentially sacrificing one monster to build up another even more. Rusev defeating Ryback would be seen as a pretty big victory, which is more than can be said about his repeated wins against poor Jack Swagger. Ryback will take a hit in losing such a feud, but he probably has a shorter shelf life given his past mishandlings. It€™ll be interesting to see how this unfolds.

2. Here Comes The Pain

For three straight pay-per-views and 12 episodes of Raw, the WWE World Heavyweight Championship was nowhere to be seen. The champ had taken his ball and gone home, leaving only an advocate behind to occasionally remind fans that he still existed. Brock Lesnar€™s absence hurt the overall product as main eventers fought over the number one contender€™s spot at two of the three PPVs and people rarely got bent out of shape at not having the richest prize in the business around to chase. All of that changed Monday with Lesnar€™s return to Raw. Thankfully, Brock was not limited to just his segment with Chris Jericho, a somewhat uncomfortable scene with Lesnar demolishing a former six-time world champion in Y2J. While that confrontation helped re-establish Brock as a dominant force, it was his presence in the main event that signaled that he was back. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=clpPaJL2d8o Say what you will about John Cena, but he takes a pretty convincing beating. Lesnar threw him around the steel cage like a ragdoll. Granted, Cena was already down from a grueling cage match, but Lesnar€™s dominance still was impressive. It set the stage for what will probably be another solid Cena-Lesnar match at Royal Rumble. Sure, we could have a different opponent and Lesnar was gone for far too long, but this should only help WWE going forward.

1. The Newest Paul Heyman Guy

Somehow, it€™s a pretty safe bet that the newest Paul Heyman Guy is going to work out a lot better than Curtis Axel or Ryback. It might seem odd for Seth Rollins to side with Heyman and Brock Lesnar €“ and it€™s probably stranger for the WWE World Heavyweight Champion to align himself with a guy who has a Money in the Bank briefcase he can cash in for a title match. But this works for a couple different reasons. First, Rollins is a man without a country. When he sold out his Shield brethren several months back, he sided with the Authority as a way to advance his career. Now that they are no longer in power, Rollins finds himself with his stooge security team and an occasional partner in Kane and possibly Big Show. Backed into a corner after crossing Lesnar once, it made sense to once again €œbuy in€ with another force to maintain his standing in WWE. For Heyman and Lesnar, the old adage to keep your friends close and your enemies closer could easily apply here. Lesnar surely hasn€™t forgotten Rollins curbstomping him and trying to cash in his briefcase at Night of Champions, but it€™s easier to keep an eye on him when he€™s standing next to you. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q6GlgVn7xhk Lesnar and Rollins aligned puts Heyman in the driver€™s seat in WWE, which could mean for some seriously entertaining programs on the horizon. Time will tell as this develops, but let€™s hold out hope that Rollins ends up far better than Curtis Axel did.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.