5 WWE NXT Rookies Who Needed The Modern Format
NXT was originally a game show, and these five performers deserved much better than assault courses.
NXT is WWE’s best televisual output at the moment. With stories that make sense, performers at the top of their game with something to prove, characters who have developed personalities in front of a receptive crowd and cohesive announcing, it is an hour of wrestling that is a joy to watch.
Which makes it all the easier to forget that NXT started life as something closer to a game show than a wrestling program. Wrestlers from the WWE developmental system were assigned pros to tutor them, and week after week they would take part in increasingly asinine challenges in order to avoid elimination. Matt Striker would bring down anyone garnering support, Michael Cole would deride the product from the booth and the whole thing was a shambles.
Over its five seasons a total of 28 superstars competed on the show. Some of these have lasted the distance in WWE, with Daniel Bryan now one of the biggest stars in the company, Bray Wyatt (who was on the show as Husky Harris) entrenched in the main event and Titus O’Neill and Darren Young sitting pretty as the tag team champions. 11 NXT alumni went on to hold main roster gold.
But what of those forgotten? If these 28 superstars had entered an NXT closer to the one we know today, would their careers have gone differently?
Here are five NXT alumni who could have benefited from being introduced to the WWE Universe in today’s NXT, as opposed to the NXT they found themselves on.
5. Derrick Bateman
774859Derrick Bateman may well go down as one of WWE’s biggest misses of the modern era. He has the look, the size, the charisma, the ability and everything else that is seemingly desired for someone to be a WWE superstar, yet creative seemingly never had anything for him. He even did the hard work for them and came up with his USA Guy character (complete with hilarious vignette). Impact Wrestling has been something of a dud for a while now, but Bateman’s performances (or EC3 as he is known in TNA) have been a revelation. In WWE he mostly played the comedic yet serious babyface, but as the entitled, smarmy rich heel he has been the highlight of that show for some time now.
Bateman first appeared on NXT Season Four with Daniel Bryan as his pro. Their partnership was one of the only highlights of the season, and it was something of a surprise when Bateman didn’t finish the season on top. This was even more surprising considering the prize was a tag team title shot with their pro, and Bateman and Bryan were the only combination with anything approaching chemistry.
How would Bateman’s WWE career have panned out if he had been introduced into today’s NXT, possibly even with his USA Guy gimmick? A performer of such talent and ability almost seems tailor made for the show, and he would surely have been taken in close to the hearts of the Full Sail University crowd.
4. Kaval
774860After mostly avoiding such signings for a long time, WWE has finally given in to logic and started to snap up the top talents on the independent scene. Five years ago the signing of an independent star was a rare occurrence, with Daniel Bryan and CM Punk being exceptions rather than the rule. They weren’t the only ones however, as Low Ki was also snapped up. Re-christened Kaval, Ki was one of the stars of NXT Season Two, with Michelle McCool and Layla as his pros. This partnership was seen as a joke at the time, almost a punishment for Kaval daring to make a name for himself rather than come up through the WWE system.
Kaval went on to win the second season of NXT despite losing a lot of his matches and having his serious, hard-hitting persona blunted by the wacky game show format. He then did a whole lot of nothing on the main roster, failing to defeat Dolph Ziggler for the Intercontinental belt and losing his spot on Team Smackdown to Tyler Reks of all people. He was released soon after.
In the modern waters of NXT, it is easy to believe that Kaval’s WWE career may have taken a different direction. In front of a partisan crowd, his stiff in-ring style would have been allowed to develop, with more of the focus being allowed to move on his wrestling capabilities as opposed to whether he can finish an assault course in an allotted time. Kaval is an example of someone who may have been brought in before his time.
3. Maxine
The third season of NXT is only really remembered because of CM Punk’s commentary, which says a lot about the quality of the show itself. The first all-Diva season, from start to finish it was an absolute shambles. Sure, two Divas champions (AJ Lee & Kaitlyn) came out of the show, but without doing the research for this column I pretty much forgot who took part and how. One of the divas who did take part however was Maxine, and she had the peculiar spot of being a heel on what was essentially a popularity contest.
This obviously didn’t go so well for Maxine, and she was voted off fairly quickly. She would return in NXT Season Five, the seemingly neverending season which wasn’t sure if it was a game show or a TV show, and she was without doubt one of the highlights in her love rectangle with Kaitlyn, Derrick Bateman and Johnny Curtis. Maxine now performs in Lucha Underground as Catrina, who may or may not be a teleporting ghost that happens to lick the victims of her client, Mil Muertes. That show is awesome.
WWE’s only real main roster diva characteristic seems to be ‘crazy’, but on season five Maxine showed that she had the character chops to shine regardless of the material she was given with. There is something about her that makes her stand out from the other women on wrestling television, a presence and poise that the Divas division sorely lacks. The success of Lana as Rusev’s manager showed that there still exists a place for female seconds, and being introduced via a wrestling show might have seen Maxine held in the same sort of regard. Contrary to Lana, Maxine also made a love rectangle storyline work, which is an achievement in itself.
2. Justin Gabriel
The first season of NXT was unequivocally the best, and the results are in the longevity of the rookies who took part. It started with eight, and to this day only two are no longer with the WWE. One of these isn’t too surprising, as Michael Tarver didn’t seem to offer more than a genuinely intimidating presence. The second is definitely a surprise. Outside of Daniel Bryan, Justin Gabriel seemed the most likely to find himself positioned well on WWE programming in years to come. It never really came together for the South African, and he subsequently asked for his release earlier this year.
Gabriel is different to the other names on this list. All eight season one rookies came up to the main roster almost immediately as The Nexus, which started out immensely strong but was buried under chairs and John Cena. The group were a heel gang of sorts, who would attack anyone and everyone that stood in their way. Justin Gabriel just never seemed to fit into this though, with his high flying offence and clear babyface demeanour.
One problem with Gabriel was that his character never expanded beyond ‘he’s from South Africa and he likes adrenaline sports and something about a werewolf’. As with Kaval, a more traditional wrestling show format would have benefited Gabriel and his relationship with the WWE Universe.
1. Johnny Curtis
The success of the first format of NXT can be seen in the careers of its four winners. Wade Barrett won season one, and can now be found either winning the intercontinental title or losing to a guy who carries a plunger to the ring. Kaval won season two, and was released not long after. Kaitlyn won season three and forged herself a pretty decent career, but she has since taken her delightful thighs and moved on. Johnny Curtis won season four, and now he’s a dancing jobber.
Yeah, I forgot too. Johnny Curtis won season four of NXT!
Johnny Curtis is one of the most surprising talents in the WWE. When he was introduced to us as the aforementioned plunger-carrier’s rookie in season four, he was a vanilla as all hell babyface, entirely forgettable. Imagine my surprise then, when he developed one of my all time favourite wrestling characters in season five. In season five Johnny Curtis became weirder than weird, turning up in all manner of situations with his jacket and no shirt, making strange comments and generally being incredibly sinister and well, weird.
If there’s one thing that season five of NXT showed, it was that all the performers benefited from the game show elements of the show being toned down. It was here where the Prime Time Players came together after all. Johnny Curtis, Derrick Bateman, Maxine and Kaitlyn held the show together, and only now do I realise that this article might just be a love letter to that lost group. Either way, if Johnny Curtis was introduced into the NXT of today, who knows where he would be. Fandango might never have beaten Chris Jericho at WrestleMania, sure, but maybe I would have gotten a little more ‘Dirty Curty’.