50 Things You Learn Binge-Watching Every WWE WrestleMania
20. “Once In A Lifetime” Was Always A Lie
People called this at the time.
There was no way WWE could book one solitary match between The Rock and John Cena then move on. The promotion knew they had a box office smash hit on their hands, so a rematch was always going to occur. Being blunt, WWE blatantly lied to our faces and smiled as they did it. "Once In A Lifetime'. This is your only chance to see the Hollywood star square off with our poster boy. No, really. Ahem.
WrestleMania XXVIII's first match was decent but didn't blow anyone away. To be honest, neither did the rematch, although no-one knew for sure initially if they'd plough ahead with plans to run that at 'Mania 29 (on/off roman numerals be damned) or not. Everybody could see it coming eventually. Going back to back on the match after branding XXVIII “Once In A Lifetime” was almost laughable. Understandable for business reasons, but laughable given how hard WWE’s announcers pounded that drum.
It's hard to ignore the "Once In A Lifetime" stuff when watching this era back, 'cause it was everywhere you looked. Thank God the writers didn't try this with Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes at 'Mania 39 then instantly regret it before booking the same bout at 40. Hype is important, but that Rock vs. Cena business is a cruel reminder that it can also be detrimental if you're full of it and going to load a second round anyway.
This was WWE's very own version of, 'Just one more game and then I'll go to bed'.
19. How Silent A Post-Streak Match Was At XXX
Ringsiders were shocked out of their WrestleMania t-shirts by Brock Lesnar ending The Undertaker's long running win streak at the 30th event. One guy's eye popping reaction became a meme overnight, for example. That was just the start of it. The air had been sucked right out of the place, because nobody in attendance could quite believe that a run lasting since 'Mania VII was now officially over.
There was a funeral-esque atmosphere in the Mercedes Benz Superdome straight after Brock pinned 'Taker's shoulders to the mat. A "Vickie Guerrero Invitational" bout for AJ Lee's Divas Title simply had no chance of succeeding in the death spot sandwiched between that streak ender and the main event three-way starring Daniel Bryan's quest to beat Randy Orton and Batista.
AJ retained her belt in front of a quiet live crowd stunned into silence by what they’d just witnessed. It’s almost eerie when watching this all over again. People did not know what to do with themselves. Some tried to get back onboard with the card by giving Lee, Alicia Fox, The Bella Twins, Tamina Snuka, Cameron, Emma, Eva Marie, Naomi, Layla, Natalya, Aksana, Rosa Mendes and Summer Rae some respect, but most in the 60,000+ strong mass of reeling humanity either stared at their feet or talked amongst themselves.
What's the sound of thousands simultaneously posting outraged feedback on Twitter? This, apparently. 'Mania XXX's penultimate showcase was the most deathly quiet a death spot had ever been. Someone had to go next, and the era dictated that it was the less important women's match. WWE would probs be smarter about things today.
18. Fan Power Remains Impressive A Decade On
A decade plus on, it's true that one name still rings around rooms whenever fans get together and ponder 'Mania XXX: Daniel Bryan. Or, Bryan Danielson if you're that way inclined. WWE's renaming job was one of the least bothersome of the era anyway. Daniel Bryan was sure better than Joe Hennig becoming Michael McGillicutty, let's get that straight right away! Being fair, Bry could've been called Dippy Daniel and still captured the hearts of wrestling fans.
He was never supposed to enjoy moments like this. Vince McMahon didn’t see Dan as a bankable top star capable of beating Triple H, Batista and Randy Orton all on the same night, but fans pushed hard for it and point blank refused to take no for an answer. Clearly, WWE’s approach softened enough for them to book it, because Vince could’ve stubbornly refused regardless of peer pressure, but it’s still impressive that people pushed for a deserving pro wrestler even when the machine fancied someone else (Batista). That still makes it almost surreal to see Bryan hoisting the belts above his head right at the end of the show.
His victory was a victory for pure technical expertise. This was wrestling winning on a show bearing its name.
Fans affecting change the way they did shows something else: WWE like to do things their way (every promotion does), but people power counts for a hell of a lot if it's overwhelming and genuine. Affection for Bryan was. Preventing him from fulfilling his potential and living the dream just to spite themselves would've been a crime from higher ups.
Wrestling wins! Wrestling wins! Wrestling wins!
17. Sting Didn’t NEED To Win, But…
‘Mania 31’s match between Sting and Triple H is often called one of the worst flubs in the event’s rich history. Fans were irate that WWE brought the WCW legend in from TNA towards the end of 2014 then mishandled him so terribly. Stinger in WWE was hardly worth the wait for anybody when it should've been a licence for the McMahons to print money by the truckload.
Keep in mind the next part is coming from a WCW fanboy. That's what this writer is, and he makes no apologies for being Nitro and Thunder daft. OK, here goes: Sting...didn't actually need to beat Triple H during his first WWE match. Cue the head shaking from those who will never agree with that, but hear it out. If the icon was going to lose, then there was a way to do that which would protect him and lead to more down the road.
The post match 'attaboy' from Trips was stupid and made Sting seem less-than. That's undoubtedly the most stunningly bad thing about the match when revisiting now. Sting losing? Meh, everyone can lose if things are done the right way. Sting losing then Hunter acting like this was some midcarder who'd tried to crack into the top leagues but just couldn't? No, get that right in the nearest bin.
WWE are currently in the process of building some new main event megastars. If this sort of moment happens with many of them, cool, but Sting was an established headliner who had been one of wrestling's best since the late-80s. Acting like WWE was a step too far for him was counter-productive and ruined the point of portraying him as a threat to The Authority at all.
As Randy Orton might spit, that was "stupid"!
16. Brock Lesnar’s Ambrose Disinterest Is Clear
Whilst WrestleMania 32 had highs (Zack Ryder's Intercontinental Title win, the women's three-way for a brand new belt, 'Taker vs. Shane McMahon inside Hell In A Cell etc), it was without doubt one of the most long winded events during this here binge session. WWE didn't do restraint in 2016. They wanted 'Mania to be a marathon that numbed fans to the point of exhaustion. That's fine if everything lands, but some major matches fell flat.
Roman Reigns vs. Triple H was a boring main event, and Dean Ambrose vs. Brock Lesnar was one of the most phoned-in 'No Holds Barred Street Fights' you'll ever see. Charlotte Flair, Becky Lynch and Sasha Banks must’ve been rubbing their hands backstage with glee knowing they were following a garbage brawl between two guys at odds. Revisiting the thing makes it obvious just how disinterested Brock was in the whole affair.
He and Ambrose just didn't see eye to eye on the way the match should go. Deano wanted a CZW style hardcore pain train, whereas Lesnar fancied getting in and out without the threat of barbed wire gouging out one of his eyeballs. Paul Heyman later revealed that they were an oil and water blend behind the curtain. This was always going to be a disaster.
Disaster is perhaps too strong, but Brock vs. Ambrose wasn't very good. At all. Speaking as a viewer, it's clearly Lesnar who was holding things back a little with his apathy. What a pity that WWE programmed these dudes together on the biggest show of the year. They barely had a match worthy of main eventing Raw.
15. Rock & Rowan Is So Odd
Recently, some accounts on social media shared around a graphic boasting that The Rock hadn’t lost a match at WrestleMania since 2013. Yes, but he’s wrestled twice since then; once at ‘Mania 40 in a tag bout with Roman Reigns vs. Cody Rhodes and Seth Rollins, and vs. Erick Rowan in a six second squash at ‘Mania 32 before that. It’s still so weird so many years on to see him in that setting, but hey - Rowan can always point to the fact he had a match with Rocky at WrestleMania.
File it under most random.
An awful lot of folks seem to have forgotten that The Rock warned Cody Rhodes he was coming back for him and his title on the post-WrestleMania 40 episode of Raw earlier in 2024. That left everything up in the air for WWE, and presumably means they'll book a belt-based showdown between the pair in the future, so expect Rocky's record to change soon enough. As always, it might even have happened by the time you check this lengthy piece out.
WWE felt they needed something to buffer between a 20-man Andre The Giant Memorial match (won by Baron Corbin) and the Roman vs. Triple H main event back in 2016. That's why Bray Wyatt's clan went nose to nose with The Rock, and it's why Rowan was selected ahead of Bray himself. Not many had this on their predictions lists before the pay-per-view aired, right enough.
What an oddity it is. Unlike Rock's antics in 2024, it honestly told us nothing about his immediate plans for the future. He was exclusively there to add star power and bag a nice payday for very little.
14. Shane McMahon Had 33’s Best Singles Match?!
If Rock vs. Rowan can be filed under most random 'Mania matches, then this one should go under the most unexpected tab. Build for AJ Styles vs. Shane McMahon at 33 predictably painted the latter as a hard man nobody should mess with. That's a tedious presentation of Shane we've all had to suffer for too long, but he did reach into his bag of tricks and pull out a gift when it mattered most of all.
Get this: Shane vs. AJ opened the main card at 'Mania 33, and it's actually one of the best singles bouts on the entire card. Shockingly, it was a better watch than a so-so protege breakout between Seth Rollins and Triple H. Other singles like Kevin Owens vs. Chris Jericho struggled to get going, Randy Orton vs. Bray Wyatt proved to be a boring WWE Title effort, and The Undertaker vs. Roman Reigns was plain sad at times.
Only one other singles match came close to Shane vs. AJ. More on that shortly.
This was a surprising find. Yours truly was in attendance live for WrestleMania in 2017, and he doesn't remember being blown away by the main card's opener in person. WWE's cameras and the commentary helped turn this into a much better watch overall. Credit has to go to Styles for bringing his A-game, and to McMahon for doing his bit too.
No-one would've had this above Trips vs. Seth, KO vs. Jericho, Randy vs. Bray or even 'Taker vs. Roman before a ball was kicked. Who knew 'Mania 33's singles output peaked with the first match on the pay-per-view?!
13. WWE Finally Got Goldberg At ‘Mania Right!
Almost unbelievably, WrestleMania 33 was only Bill Goldberg's second whirl on WWE's top pay-per-view. He'd worked an infamously unwanted scrap vs. Brock Lesnar at XX in 2004. That was dumped on by a trolling Madison Square Garden crowd who realised both men were leaving the company right afterwards. Smiling guest ref Steve Austin was the only one who got a favourable reaction from New York.
Orlando in 2017 was somewhat different. 'Mania 33's re-rematch (they'd clashed again at Survivor Series 2016) between Goldberg and Brock Lesnar is the only time Bill lived up to the hype on the biggest show. Other matches like that bizarre one vs. Brock in 2004 and Braun Strowman in 2020 tanked for various reasons. He and Lesnar more than made up for XX’s car crash with a thumping five minute power move explosion in Florida.
It's still one of the most fun matches this writer has ever seen live. Brock and Bill should've slipped Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt a wee thank you note for stinking up the joint with their WWE Title bout before the Universal Title took centre stage. Fans in the Camping World Stadium were delighted when Lesnar and Goldberg hurled one another about the ring then went to the finish pronto like they'd set the momentum bars to fast in WWE 2K24.
This was the only time WWE got Goldberg right at 'Mania. Expect that to remain the case, 'cause it doesn't look likely the ex-WCW squash match machine will ever lace up a pair of boots on the show again. If he does, then it'll be a Rock vs. Rowan style sprint, surely.
12. Roman’s First 4 Main Events Struggled
Roman Reigns has headlined WrestleMania as a singles star eight times. He’s actually main-evented nine times if you include a tag-team bout with The Rock during 40’s opening night, but eight different 'Mania weekends have witnessed Roman play a starring role in WWE's plans. In-ring, the first four really struggled to get going, which becomes clear when watching them in short order.
Bouts vs. Brock Lesnar at 31, Triple H at 32, The Undertaker at 33 and Brock again at 34 were all hard to watch again. It’s a good thing that WWE chiefs showed patience with Reigns, because his 'Tribal Chief' run since 2020 has been sweet, but these weren’t enjoyable to sit through again. All four shows featured superior matches on the card that would’ve been better show-closers than anything Reigns-related.
Of course, the fact Seth Rollins was cashing in Money In The Bank at 31 meant Roman vs. Brock had to close.
There's a lot WWE wants you to forget about the clumsy way they booked Reigns as a top guy between 2014-2020. His 'Big Dog' run had some mortifying moments, and some of the main events he worked on pay-per-view were rather forced. Being brutally honest, Roman didn't have a truly great WrestleMania main event until 37's triple threat with Edge and Daniel Bryan. That was in 2021!
In-ring quality hadn't always been the most important thing for 'Mania headliners traditionally, but even other pet projects like Hulk Hogan produced the goods more often than not. Or, at least, he gave the core audience what they wanted to see. It'd be a while before Reigns was able to do that.
11. Ronda Rousey’s Debut Was Her WWE Peak
Ultimately, MMA trailblazer Ronda Rousey proved to be a poor fit for pro wrestling. She never got to grips with the idea that characters shift alignment like some sort of adapt or die dialogue choice in a video game. Not thriving as a babyface? Well, you can always turn heel to restore freshness on the baby side later on. Ronda didn't want to be booed - she took it as a personal insult and described the whole WWE experience as "needlessly stressful" after the fact.
Nobody on the planet can take WrestleMania 34 away from Rousey though. She teamed with Kurt Angle on the show, and they worked one of the greatest mixed tags ever vs. Triple H and Stephanie McMahon. This was Ronda's proper in-ring debut. Think of the pressure attached to that. This could've blown up in everyone's faces, but 'Rowdy' Ronda was prepared, and three class acts helped guide her through.
The poise and aura Rousey displayed that night may never be matched by anyone working their first ever feature length match at 'Mania. She was Logan Paul before Logan Paul! On that, far more was expected from a combat sports specialist like Ronda than a YouTuber like LP. Her Terminator like armour would've been shredded had she sucked.
Some may point to Rousey headlining the following year as bigger. It was, but it wasn’t better than 34's dazzler, at least not in terms of her overall performance personally. Too much of Ronda's WWE output dropped below this standard. In fairness, she'd set the bar bloody high in 2018.
Going from this to the woeful MMA infused battle vs. Shayna Baszler at SummerSlam 2023 was quite the drop off.