50 Ups & 50 Downs For WWE's Decade: The 2010s

31. The Undertaker Vs Roman Reigns, WrestleMania 33

WrestleMania ROman Reigns Undertaker
WWE.com

Anybody with their keys not stuck down with salty bodily fluids following his stumbling Orlando loss to Reigns could have predicted he'd probably return yet again at WrestleMania 34, but it didn't stop the relentless "Thank You Taker" messages that followed this depressingly dismal effort.

The battle of the big men in black, Reigns' similar physical appearance did at least portray him as 'The Deadman's younger hungrier replacement. It was just a shame a company icon was inadvertently made to look so inferior in the process.


30. Bobby's Sisters

Go easy on this one as light and utterly f*cking stupid WWE comedy, or kick them a YouTube view on their official account and let the horrendously misused performers do the talking?

Enjoy this, Part Two of a three-part series.


29. The Wild Card Rule

Vince McMahon
WWE

What a f*cking load of sh*t.

Pardon the vulgarity, but it only matches the hideousness of this wretched ratings quick-fix that didn't even work. P*ssed off with all the decline happening around him, Vince McMahon appeared on a May 2019 edition of to confirm that superstars could take advantage of a "Wild Card" rule every week, allowing them to flit between brands if the mood struck them.

It muddied the waters of a roster split that was already struggling - so much so that an October draft lacked the usual punch due to ardent viewers genuinely being unclear where a Superstar even resided. The rules and ramifications (and even the amount of people permitted each week) were never fleshed out as the company tried and failed to spread the likes of Roman Reigns and AJ Styles thinner than usual for the good of the cause.

A hated concept thankfully binned after just a few months, McMahon had the temerity to call himself a "genius" the very night he launched it. In contrast, the @WWEonFox Twitter account immediately mocked it upon the network taking control of the blue brand's future.


28. The End Of Asuka's Undefeated Streak

Asuka SmackDown
WWE.com

Asuka losing to Charlotte at WrestleMania 34 in 2018 came with all the usual bleating calls from WWE fans to "let it play out" and "follow the story", but the 'Empress Of Tomorrow' never again reached the heights a lengthy stint in NXT helped create.

Falling to 'The Queen' at the 'Show Of Shows' was one (extremely concerning) thing, but treading water on SmackDown Live's midcard was another too far. She succumbed to the sterile stupidity of James Ellsworth en route to a loss to Carmella, before losses became the norm within months of having never suffered one before. Title wins in the single and tag divisions were meaningless in the aftermath.

Perception and aura have never been more important than in modern day WWE. In spite of a Royal Rumble win, it was sadly the year Asuka had both ripped from her grasp.


27. Bray Wyatt Vs Kane, SummerSlam 2013

SummerSlam, Ring of Fire
WWE.com

Hot garbage.

Bray Wyatt and his 'Family' had arrived on Raw weeks before the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer' in grand fashion, kicking the sh*t out of Kane despite looking remarkably like pro wrestlers rather than dangerous woodsmen, all to set up a "Ring Of Fire" encounter. The rebadged Inferno Match was a total disaster.

The match sucked, but the finish was somehow even worse. With result determined by pinfall or submission, the threat of somebody getting set on fire was removed, and good job too. There was no intent of performing the stunt, or any stunt, despite the flames still being gimmicked to shoot towards the sky with every big bump. Bray's goon squad botched their way through a beatdown. A kendo stick was sort-of-almost on fire and immediately put out.

Wyatt won with ease after the fact, but couldn't have looked more like a loser. Not least while sporting his own WWEShop.com clobber.


26. Bayley: This Is Your Life

Alexa Bliss This Is Your Life Bayley
WWE.com

Go easy on this one as light and utterly f*cking stupid WWE comedy, or kick them a YouTube view on their official account and let the horrendously misused performers do the talking?

Enjoy this, Part Three of a three-part series...or don't, because even WWE don't want this out there anymore.

Indeed, this was the worst of a terrible trifecta of Raw impersonator skits from the last few years that featured Alexa Bliss going through the motions with a host of bad actors reciting bad lines all to lead to then-Champion Bliss battering 'The Hugger' with a Kendo Stick.

After repeatedly highlighting an unnaturally close relationship with her Father in a running gag that only felt half-written, Bayley's teacher, former best friend and ex-boyfriend all droned on until Bayley ran in to take a thrashing too. The entire farce was designed to build heat for a 'Kendo Stick on a Pole' match that was completely centred around Bayley's inability to use the weapon in anger - this total diversion from a relatively simple plot completely sunk the entire angle.


25. The 2014 Royal Rumble

Batista Royal Rumble 2014
WWE.com

The Royal Rumble remains a beloved WWE institution, yet there were two iterations in the 2010s so poorly received that they nearly killed the gimmick for good.

Cinematically playing out like a poor original and an even worse sequel, the back-to-back battle royals told the stories of two men, and one increasingly agitated audience.

In 2014, Daniel Bryan was knee-deep in the run of his life, but as noted, WWE weren't really booking it. Bryan was irrefutably the top star in the entire company, with an ethos and chant that had galvanised the "WWE Universe" and confidently commanded a position in the WrestleMania XXX main event.

Many logically felt the Rumble would be the place do it, but when he wasn't even afforded a place in the contest, the disdain landed on the broad shoulders of eventual winner Dave Batista. Big Dave (along with Rey Mysterio, of all heroes) was booed out of the building despite his recent return as a conquering hero. Shield member Roman Reigns was runner up that year, and received a positive response if only as an alternative to 'The Animal'. How quickly times would change....


24. The 2015 Royal Rumble

Roman Reigns Royal Rumble 2015
WWE

One year on, and Daniel Bryan was still the man fans insisted remained at the top of the card. However, 12 months was long enough for the audience to find a new hate figure in the departing Batista's place. Enter Roman Reigns. 'The Big Dog' become the new muscular golden child and now faced even greater vitriol than 'The Animal' had a year earlier.

WWE attempted to get around the problem by having Bryan eliminated early, but it only fuelled hatred that lasted even longer. By the time Roman despatched Rusev to win the bout, the hostility had peaked, and even a transparent rub from The Rock couldn't curb the ill will.

As an out-and-out babyface beloved by 100% of the audience, Reigns never truly recovered.


23. Brock Crushes Kofi

Brock Lesnar Kofi Kingston
WWE

As of writing, Kofi Kingston hasn't gone absolutely f*cking spare and battered Brock Lesnar in a revenge attack for the humiliation he suffered on the first edition of SmackDown on Fox.

The New Day man had audiences weeping for his win at WrestleMania earlier that year, and whilst some of his decidedly midcard title matches left fans bored to tears in the months that followed, he deserved far better than the nine second squash he was made to endure when he lost it.

WWE appears to revel in the disappointment of its audience sometimes - this was one of the most recent completely criminal examples.


22. The Undertaker Vs Goldberg, Super ShowDown 2019

Undertaker Goldberg
WWE Network

The Undertaker looked legitimately furious following his clandestine victory over Bill Goldberg at May 2019's Super ShowDown, almost as if he'd had an awakening half way through the dull-yet-dangerous snoozer. Adding anchors to his legacy rather cementing it, 'The Deadman' entered another rotten display against the former WCW icon, but Big Bill nearly killing him shortly before the finish somewhat vindicated his concern.

Suffering a concussion and working under the intense Saudi Arabian heat, Goldberg looked in no fit state to be out there and in control of another man's frame as a crowd supposedly thirsty for megastars looked on in bored bewilderment. An ugly offering on an ugly show paid for with ugly money from ugly causes, this was too fitting for the show and for its own good.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.