50 Ups & 50 Downs For WWE's Decade: The 2010s

21. Linda McMahon Joins The Trump Administration

McMahons White House
Twitter/@WONF4W

All bias and leanings cast to one side for a second - this is still an odd photograph capturing a very odd moment in political history.

Whenever he'd utilise the obnoxious billionaire on television, Vince McMahon always presented Donald Trump as a babyface, perhaps in his mind because 'The Donald' was the perfectly nice face of wealth in natural opposition to the malevolent 'Mr McMahon' character.

As anyone without billions in the bank can attest to though, there's really no such thing. Real life buddies due to obvious similarities, Vince and Trump had strong relations for years, and the family's significant financial investment in the 2016 presidential campaign came as a surprise to few. Slightly more shocking was the appointment of Linda McMahon as Small Business Administrator on Trump's first cabinet.

Dispiriting for Democrats and the global left at large, the reality was further cemented by a photograph that did the rounds showing Vince, Linda, Triple H, Stephanie McMahon, Shane McMahon, Marissa Mazzola, and their respective offsprings posing with the President.


20. Raw 25

Raw 25
WWE

The supposedly celebratory Raw 25 was so violently bereft of joy that it took virtually every major name in the show's history and wasted them all whilst simultaneously locking the most hardcore sect of fans in a building and forcing them to watch it on happen mostly on a screen.

DX and The Bálor Club's tepid union inside the historic Manhattan Center came at the expense of The Revival. Stone Cold Steve Austin wasn't permitted to say a word ahead of hitting Vince and Shane McMahon with Stone Cold Stunners and showing what bullets he still had in the chamber just minutes later. Legends were sent out in lines to smile and wave instead of engage in something meaningful. The rest were thrown into an increasingly silly poker vignette. A heavily teased show-closing Brock Lesnar/Braun Strowman showdown lasted less than five minutes.

An ungainly mess, the whole event it brought into focus one of the decade's bigger losses...


19. The Death Of Nostalgia

Nobody wanted to really admit this one and WWE simply couldn't afford to, but the 2010s gave audiences so many opportunities to say hello the past that they were only too willing to say goodbye by its end.

A lack of stars created the thirst (and need) for older stars on WrestleMania cards, but the philosophy gradually extended to feature on other pay-per-views and eventually special editions of Monday Night Raw. By 2019, frontloading the red brand with old names was the only way to pop a rating but the company simply gave up trying to book them.

Smile and wave, Trish Stratus! Bury all our current stars, The APA! Do an entire opening Raw segment without saying a f*cking word, Stone Cold Steve Austin!


18. The Original NXT

Ryback, Skip Sheffield
WWE.com

Oooft.

Ignoring the accidentally brilliant NXT Redemption that somehow found a way to parody the parody, this absolute f*cking parody of pro wrestling talent development was effectively the show that permanently gave Triple H the keys to the kingdom. You can practically hear the Titan Tower pitch; "Have you even watched this sh*t nnnnDadddddd, we need a Performance Center!"

Throwing out a bunch of FCW trainees onto national television and proving that most weren't actually ready for it, NXT barely even let them wrestle half the time, instead creating a hybrid wrestling/talent show that worked to exploit the weaknesses rather than the strengths as if to completely subvert Paul Heyman's entire ECW booking philosophy.

Wrestlers stumbled over their words, stumbled over obstacles and stumbled getting over until the sheer farce of it all became the only reason to tune in. Season One itself was so calamitous that it spawned a stable furious with their treatment on the show...but more on those shortly.


17. The Undertaker Vs Triple H, Super ShowDown 2018

Undertaker Triple H Super Show-Down
WWE.com

A knackered tribute album of all the hits they used to be able to play, Triple H and The Undertaker's Super Show-Down headliner might have provided a brand new decades-old spectacle for a star-starved Australian audience, but the central theme of paying homage to prior classics was just one of several fatal flaws.

Undertaker decked referees as he was prone to doing when he feuded with the original version of DX decades earlier. 'The Deadman' had the same slackened jaw from his WrestleMania 25 epic with Shawn Michaels when Hunter kicked out of the Tombstone, but he was grasping at straws rather gasping for breath. The pair fought through the crowd as they did at WrestleMania X7 - though this match was as inferior a comparison to that spirited brawl as the Melbourne Cricket Ground lawn furniture was to the priceless padded chairs from the Houston Astrodome.

Whilst invoking echoes of their most profitable period, WWE shamelessly delivered something as ponderous as the weathered WCW main events they once derided.


16. The Authority Vs Dani...The Big Show

Big Show Daniel Bryan Randy Orton Battleground 2013
WWE

Assuming positions as despicable malevolent owners in the clichéd vein of just about every boss the company ever booked, Stephanie McMahon and Triple H's modus operandi after SummerSlam 2013 was oppressing the former champion so aggressively that he'd never get near the title again. A great thread, considering how the story would climax at WrestleMania 30, but not really, considering that was never the planned route.

In an attempt to turn their targets against one another, they attempted to manipulate The Big Show into using his almighty right fist to cave the 'Yes Man's beard in. Reducing him to tears almost weekly in sh*t-itchingly uncomfortable scenes after exposing to the world his apparent financial ruin (and thus his need to keep his job), Stephanie McMahon went one further in an insane ramble one week, referring to show as 'My Giant' thanks to the years he apparently mentored her backstage at live events when she was 12 years old.

The Big Show is five years older than Stephanie McMahon, and at 17, he was not following WWE around the country doling out worldly wisdom to the bosses daughter. This, along with Show stealing the "YES!" taunt for himself, reflected lowest point of an abysmal angle.


15. The Dean Ambrose Heel Run

dean ambrose seth rollins tlc 2018
WWE.com

The 2018 WWE Network 'Chronicle' feature on Dean Ambrose's return from injury was another absorbing production that meshed kayfabe and reality for the good of his comeback and eventual switch to the dark side. It tragically proved to be the last thing the company ever did right by him.

It's possible that this story started life as one about 'The Lunatic Fringe's unravelling psyche, particularly after his "brother" Roman Reigns' awful leukaemia revelation shortly following his return. A sickness was engulfing everything that propped Ambrose up - his own body had even failed him after years as an indestructible force. This travelled through a Vince McMahon filter and Ambrose became a prop comic. Gas masks, big needles and banter promos at the expense of a rivalry that some even suggested could one day headline WrestleMania. Per the rechristened Jon Moxley's appearance on Chris Jericho's podcast post-release, he'd have used a pooper scooper too. The one (horrendous) pay-per-view singles match between the former Shield men permanently derailed it, and Ambrose's idea of a future within WWE.

NJPW and AEW's gain was McMahon's loss, but it's likely he still doesn't realise just how stupid his requests were.


14. Shawn Michaels Returns

Shawn Michaels Triple H
WWE.com

There were those that didn't want Shawn Michaels to come out of retirement because they - like him - believed in the commitment he'd made after a career and life well lived and a spectacular main event against The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXVI (and more on that later). There were those that were happy to just see 'The Showstopper' do what he did better than most one more time. Then there was 'HBK' himself, a man presumably chuffed to be trousering a f*cking fortune considering the alleged offers he's turned down in the past.

Somehow, everybody above were deeply unsatisfied with the eventual outcome.

Part of a match regrettable as it was happening, Crown Jewel's wretched main event saw Michaels try and fail to carry a contest over the line he shouldn't have agreed to in the first place. He knew it too - sadder than the effort between the ropes was the wistful post-match promo.

And about that match...


13. D-Generation X Vs The Brothers Of Destruction

Triple H Crown Jewel
WWE

Just months before this piece of pro wrestling garbage, Triple H helped Ronda Rousey assemble a bonafide masterpiece in her very first match. He'd proven himself, in the right environment, still to be a master of the craft. Here, he was literally too injured to even ensure the basics went to plan.

The one who used to get by on aura alone continued to strip himself of it. The one who'd perhaps been retired too long to just snap back into it had been retired too long to just snap back into it. The one who only needed to keep his f*cking mask and wig in place failed to tighten the f*cking straps.

These were not the quartet that left a blood-soaked Cell in 1997 having crafted one of the greatest moments in the history of the industry, nor even the three than ended an era in a WrestleMania this decade. These were tired and tragic versions, doing something resembling their best to try and recapture what made them such a draw to the Saudi Arabia Sports Authority in the first place.


12. The Nexus Collapse

John Cena Nexus
WWE.com

Crushed first by a humiliating defeat to John Cena at SummerSlam 2010, their crumpled remains were set ablaze by the months that followed.

As you'll read a few slides from now, the arrival of The Nexus felt exactly like the change WWE were trying to project as they decimated 'The Champ' and the literal fabric of the canvas upon which they'd been prohibited from working on over the past several weeks.

Within seven months they were a busted flush. Within 12 they ceased to even exist. The original defeat against Team WWE at the 'Biggest Party Of The Summer' was damaging in the extreme, but the repeated beatings they took from cartoon hero Cena in the months that followed were just as awful. They were goons from inception - the trick the company never bothered to play was masking that fact.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.