50 Ups & 50 Downs For WWE's Decade: The 2010s
11. Jinder Mahal: WWE Champion
The sight of Jinder Mahal clasping the once-richest prize in the game remains troubling for those that lived through a truly wretched summer with him on top.
Reducing it in stature just by existing in its orbit, Mahal was almost an innocent victim of the crime being committed in his image. WWE were supposedly keen to milk a market that didn't pay for their product on television (and wouldn't at arenas in a flop of a tour later that year), whilst the 'Modern Day Maharaja's rapidfire physical growth seemed to aid the decision-making process.
Cynical, cynical, cynical, and totally sh*t too - Mahal couldn't remotely work up to the spot in matches or on promos, inspiring less than nothing at best and broad racist anti-comedy at worst. It was, by some margin, the saddest and dullest timeline.
10. The NXT Call-Up Conundrum
It doesn't f*cking work, lads.
For all NXT has been the jewel in the WWE crown for over half of the decade, the speed at which the black-and-gold stars go from kings to paupers on the main roster undermines the entire operation.
It's genuinely easier to name those that have made a success of things than not at this point, and even those have typically had to see their initial incarnations torn up ahead of a Vince McMahon rebuild. It echoes the what occured for most of the WCW arrivals post-2001, only these were WWE's to begin with.
NXT's move to Wednesday has hopefully put paid to the entire concept - it's just a shame it came too late for The War Raiders not to be memes before they were monsters.
9. The Divas Division
The Women's Revolution was brilliant on its own terms, but it was a miracle considering just how much work needed to be done to chase away the ghosts of divisions past.
When matches and angles weren't designed as p*ss breaks or box-ticking filler, they were toxic in the extreme. Women fought over the title one at time, or men, or how Jerry Lawler's belief that "all women secretly hate each other", or Playboy magazine covers, or whatever a bunch of old white men thought young women cared about.
Natalya got the farts, Nikki Bella wished Brie had died in the womb and Alicia Fox was perpetually cast as crazy because all women were. Decent matches were forgotten whilst well-trained wrestlers and hard-working ex-models alike were all undermined.
Bullsh*t, and eventually (tacitly) called as much.
8. Brock Lesnar Vs Roman Reigns, WrestleMania 34
After a year of beating everybody with a single F5, Lesnar delivered so many to 'The Big Dog' at 2018's 'Show Of Shows' that finishing moves as we once knew them were lost to grainy Network archive footage. Designed around triggering the biggest reactions from crowds and teasing conclusions, the F5s failed at both. And they failed over, and over and over again.
In olden times when wrestling stakes meant more, this would have been catastrophic. As a modern era spectacle, it merely became part of the p*ss-poor patchwork.
The two weren't doing anything outwardly bad, but the New Orleans faithful let their emotions flow like Roman's claret. His blood only only boiled theirs, resulting in the audience missing Lesnar's win assuming it wasn't likely to come. They weren't prepared to go looking for it.
7. The Summer Of Punk
The follow-up to an awe-inspiring promo and electric Money In The Bank battle with John Cena has been long-lamented as one of the company's most catastrophic creative cul-de-sacs, but the month or so in which Punk was cast a revolutionary source of rage remains a reflection of a perplexed performer at his dynamic best.
It's all the more reason to bury everything that came after it.
More on Punk's irripresable rise in the Ups, but his fall was exactly as devastating as his "Pipe Bomb" predicted. He called out a system for failing over and over again, and it responded by...failing him over and over again. A pathetic whotextit storyline with Triple H and Kevin Nash was as pathetic as a pay-per-view loss to Triple H covering for Kevin Nash and only slightly more pathetic than a tag team match alongside Triple H that saw Kevin Nash on run-in duty.
One guess which wrestlers contested what proved to be the grand payoff to CM Punk's big moment.
6. The Death Of The Top Babyface Role
"Or how I stopped worrying and learned to love watching them bomb".
The "mixed reactions" John Cena received for all of his time on top of WWE broke down the last key tenet of the top babyface's relationship with the audience long after the anti-hero reframed the narrative during the Attitude Era.
Cena represented a noble attempt by the company to try and bring the old-fashioned hero back, but his very existence pulled back the curtain completely. He was a product rather than a persona, and a sizeable portion of the crowd weren't ever going to get behind that. Roman Reigns suffered the same but worse, whilst Seth Rollins struggled so much with the same treatment that he was turned heel months after being given the heroic WrestleMania babyface win.
It used to be the top job in the entire industry - it's now a plain-sight poisoned chalice.
5. Bray Wyatt
Just look at two separate feuds during the death knell of Bray's original singles run that sum up why he's always failed on the main roster as well as how.
A giant bug was an appropriate takeaway visual for his WrestleMania 33 feud with Randy Orton, considering how Wyatt was squashed like one just minutes later. An offensively pedestrian WWE Title win for 'The Apex Predator' should have a nadir for a character such as Bray, but the defeat instead kicked open unseen trapdoors he subsequently went sailing through.
Their useless 'House Of Horrors' rematch was an insulting mess. Shoddy horror flick action in the pre-tape begat an uninteresting conclusion designed to move Orton onto his WWE Title feud with Jinder Mahal. Bray couldn't even get near the belt in a contractually obligated rematch he actually won.
For a man capable of changing house lights and human arms merely with the raising of his own, Finn Bálor as both 'The Demon' and 'The Man' didn't have it in him to carry Wyatt to something good. Bray caught a serious viral infection right before he was to debut his literal manifestation of Sister Abigail to conclude their feud. Sh*tting the bed in private was presumably infinitely preferable to doing it on pay-per-view.
Your writer once dedicated an entire article to Bray Wyatt's disastrous WWE run, but - like everybody else - spent months drunk on optimism for his bright future after a bizarre 2019 reinvention actually worked. The Fiend seemed like a rehabilitation for the ages...until the company squandered everything they'd built by his second match. And as for that...
4. Seth Rollins Vs The Fiend
Hyperbole to put this as one of the worst 50 moments of the decade? Possibly? Worth arguing for it's place? Absolutely.
F*ck WWE for the state of this match, f*ck them if they had reasons beyond their control for having it go to a non-finish, f*ck Road Dogg for having post-show fights with fans years ago about seeing where the story goes as if everything was still joined up, and most of all f*ck all of us for always accepting the corporate reasons for something sh*t rather despite a willingness to betray the creative. Because this was a betrayal for the ages.
WWE sold tickets to a show based on the premise of their most over character doing battle with a Universal Champion he'd taken complete control of on television. For an eighth of the match, they allowed the match to tell the story - The Fiend no-selling just about everything finally, finally brought Bray Wyatt as close to The Undertaker as his fans have been fantasy booking for years, but the moment the match careers off a cliff can be viewed with eyes sealed shut.
The browbeaten Sacramento crowd began sounding their displeasure as Seth hit stomp after stomp after stomp after stomp as bullsh*t on top of b*llocks killed both characters rather just the one. An abysmal non-finish was an entirely unacceptable ending to a contest where men (two in particular) risked their lives for the cause. It's not the worst because it just happened, or because of the rushed and panicked booking that brought it to life in the first place.
It's the worst because it's the f*cking worst.
3. Mauro Ranallo's Not So Excellent Adventure
"Mauro Ranallo the WWE main roster commentator" felt destined to fail if only for the memories of others entirely unable to cope with Vince McMahon screaming in their ears, but the combat sports commentator instead had to deal with his colleague b*llocking him the flesh too.
Amidst the awkwardness of Tom Phillips being added as a "host" to help shunt him out of his SmackDown Live lead commentator role in late-2016, Ranallo's mix of style and substance was relentlessly shouted down by JBL doing his best impression of himself as a total a*sehole.
Bradshaw was subsequently booted from the both whilst Mauro found a finer fit with a role as NXT's play-by-play man where he thrived happily for two more years before a needless Corey Graves Twitter attack brought much of it back to the surface. Until a company that's proven itself somewhat toxic earnestly tries to make changes, it'll be hard to imagine it not happening again.
2. The Saudi Arabia Deal
Much has been written about WWE's hideously problematic agreement with Saudi Arabia over the last two years - probably enough to not spend any longer on it here than is absolutely necessary. But what, then, is necessary at this point?
The deal was a dirty one, WWE's decision to stick with it in spite of the Jamal Khashoggi murder ahead of Crown Jewel 2018 was even filthier, and the shows that followed as a result have been amongst the silliest in company history. Reductively so, in fact. Greatest Royal Rumble, the first Crown Jewel and Super ShowDown were so absurd that the insanity created a thin enough smokescreen to get through them in the first place.
The deal has eight years left to run, but do WWE's suits even have enough sleeves, let alone tricks still to pull from them?