6 Major Booking Mistakes WWE Made At No Mercy
Mistakes which made No Mercy just another ‘B' show.
Expectations have rarely been so high for one of WWE's second-tier pay-per-views as they were last night for No Mercy. But expectation is a dangerous thing.
WWE built the show at the Staples Centre, Los Angeles, around two WrestleMania worthy main events between first-time opponents John Cena and Roman Reigns, and reigning Universal Champion Brock Lesnar and challenger Braun Strowman.
These high-profile matches merely satisfied, without excelling, and the undercard was just as much of a mixed bag. The RAW Tag Team Championship match was an outstanding spectacle, and RAW’s women more than held their own under the spotlight.
However, those positives were countered by an ill-judged match-up for the Intercontinental Championship and a cruiserweight catastrophe in California. All in all, No Mercy 2017 will struggle to be remembered as much more than just another 'B' show.
Yet it could have been so much better had WWE avoided these glaring mistakes...
6. Enzo Dethroning Neville
Neville as champion was the one thing holding the cruiserweight division together.
Among all of the unimaginative six-man tag team matches and the poor WWE Network ratings, the title still felt important because it was Neville who was the one holding it.
The Briton made people take interest in the stars of 205 Live with his defined character, and the viciousness with which he combined it with his acrobatics. And WWE fed him to Enzo Amore.
They made Neville look like a fool by falling for Enzo’s tricks, and this type of victory will not curry him any favour with the wiser fans who are beginning to see past his promo charm.
Enzo was moved to the cruiserweight division with the hope that he would enhance it, but putting the title on him this early is more likely to kill it. Since he was split from Big Cass, his in-ring limitations have become so obviously exposed that one-time fans have turned against him, and even more will do so now following this undeserved coronation.
Unless this title change is quickly reversed, already low interest levels in the cruiserweight division, and 205 Live, will drop even further. WWE needs someone to help Neville share the burden, but Enzo is not the man. The Cruiserweight Classic was about celebrating the best cruiserweight wrestlers in the world. That audience isn’t going to tune in for Amore.
5. Misjudging The Audience
The Miz and Jason Jordan put on a solid opening match at No Mercy, with the babyface showing his athletic prowess and the heel using the numbers game to his advantage.
But the Californians in attendance ignored the clear face-heel dynamic in front of them. The majority of the 16,000 crowd were firmly behind The Miz and booed Jordan’s every move.
Sometimes the audience unfairly sabotages a match to protest against the product, but this rebellion was easier for WWE to foresee as the event was in Miz’s adopted home state.
The Intercontinental Champion was always going to have the backing of the Los Angeles people and WWE’s failure to recognise this made it a lose-lose situation for Jordan, who had an impossible job winning the fans over. There was a time when Jordan pulled off back-to-back rolling northern lights suplexes, and the crowd still booed his attempted pinfall.
Throwing one half of American Alpha into this hostile situation, in his first pay-per-view singles match, when he is already battling the stupidity of the Kurt Angle’s son storyline, was an ill-advised move on behalf of WWE creative. Jordan handled himself well, showing that this match-up could have been far more effective on another night, at another venue.
4. Bray Losing... Again
From page one of WWE’s booking manual, Bray Wyatt and Finn Bálor fought in a rubber match after picking up wins over one other on RAW and at SummerSlam respectively.
The match told a good narrative. Wyatt assaulted Bálor from behind early on, throwing him onto the announce table to send the Irishman retreating towards the locker room, only for Bálor to take Wyatt’s bait and return to the ring to collect the brave comeback victory.
On its own, that makes sense. But previous booking meant that Wyatt needed this victory far more than Bálor did. He was made to look strong in defeat, but only wins can repair the damage already done by WWE in constantly booking the 'Eater of Worlds' to lose.
Bálor has the fan support to recover from losses much bigger than this (Daniel Bryan lost clean to Wyatt at the 2014 Royal Rumble and was famously crowned WWE Champion by WrestleMania), but Wyatt is now directionless and his momentum is at an all-time low.
This win could have changed his fortunes. It would have shown him to be cunning; goading Bálor into dropping his demon gimmick and then attacking him as the match started, and also ruthless, to prey on his injured victim. Instead, it showed him up as a fraud, again.
3. Bayley Eating The Pin
Although this felt like another false dawn for Nia Jax, who is in danger of becoming the Bray Wyatt of the RAW women’s roster, WWE got the winner of this match absolutely right.
With Asuka debuting at TLC on 22 October - as confirmed at No Mercy - another title change before the 'Empress of Tomorrow' takes her place atop the division would have created unnecessary chaos. The focus ahead should be on Asuka versus Alexa Bliss.
What WWE did get wrong was having Bayley eat the pin at the hands of the champion, less than a week after her return from a shoulder injury which sidelined her for two months.
This was a chance for Bayley to start afresh, having been badly mismanaged by WWE since her promotion to the main roster from NXT, where she was beloved by the entire fanbase. But WWE have picked up where they left off, having her pinned in her first match back.
It would have been better for Emma or Sasha Banks to have had their shoulders to the mat. Any damage done to Banks would be outweighed by her hotly-anticipated heel turn when she eventually backstabs Bayley, who is badly in need of momentum before that feud.
2. Braun Going Down Easily
WWE stuck with its recent formula of short, hard-hitting slugfests for Brock Lesnar’s latest one-on-one title match - an approach which worked at WrestleMania and Great Balls of Fire.
His encounter with the 'Monster Among Men' went less than 10 minutes, time in which Strowman had a chance to get in plenty of offence, including a pair of running powerslams. But it took only one F5 from the Universal Champion to put him away at the Staples Centre.
It was not an effort in defeat befitting of the behemoth that WWE have built Strowman to be. This is the same Braun Strowman who walked away on his own two feet when Roman Reigns trapped him inside an ambulance and crashed him into a production truck in July.
This lacklustre finish made Strowman look weaker than Lesnar’s previous opponents - Goldberg, Samoa Joe, and Reigns, who took more punishment before going down for three. It also gave Strowman little scope for a rematch, despite Lesnar’s next foe being unclear.
What is more certain is that Lesnar is heading towards Reigns at WrestleMania 34, and that the results of the two main events at No Mercy were designed to strengthen both men.
1. Cena Passing The Torch
Which brings us nicely onto WWE’s biggest mistake of the night: not learning their lesson with Roman Reigns.
Of course it was the right decision for Reigns to go over Cena, who is leaving for Hollywood before WrestleMania season, while Roman is on course for that showdown with Lesnar.
But the cheesy post-match arm raise from Cena, an unofficial passing of the torch designed to try to gain support for The Big Dawg, is not going to work. Fans are not that easily led and can see through that most basic of manipulation tactics.
The same trick failed with The Rock at Royal Rumble 2015. It will only increase the hate on Reigns. Most of the viewership have already made their mind up that they aren’t going to cheer for him, so WWE has to come up with different ways of booking him.
It would have been better to see Reigns reject Cena’s congratulations and spear him to the canvas. That would have been more fitting of the cool badass persona which Reigns has developed to blur the lines between face and heel. It would also have left this story open for another chapter. Instead, the book on Reigns versus Cena seems closed before it really had a chance to start.