6 Match Star Ratings For WWE WrestleMania Backlash 2022

WWE does non-WWE things to great effect - with one notable exception...

Edge AJ Styles
WWE

WWE is an exponentially better promotion when it gets out of its own way.

Of course, WWE often gets in its own way because they won, they continue to win in the face of moneyed, rave-received opposition, and what they do now, despite not being rave-received, earns them more money than they've ever generated.

WWE gets in its own way in several different dire ways - a plague of televised non-finishes, wacky, convenient and or repetitive storytelling, a terrible and insulting approach to continuity - but principally, the company invites the most criticism through its weirdly fake promos and homogenised in-house style.

The talent roster, even the depleted 2022 vintage, is so strong that the LOLWCW comparisons can't possibly exist on Premium Live Event weekends. The homogenised in-house style is such that the stronger WWE 'PLEs' often only reach a 7/10, but at WrestleMania Backlash, two stirring developments unfolded. One match worked within these parameters to incredible effect, and the main event, after some customary dawdling, just got on with the task of making fans go apesh*t at an accelerated pace.

When WWE feels like the very best version of itself, or something different entirely, it's still a very fun time...

6. Cody Rhodes Vs. Seth Rollins

Cody Rhodes Seth Rollins
WWE.com

This was tremendous: just a great, very accomplished and deeply impressive professional wrestling match on multiple levels.

Stripped of the dual luxury that was the surreal, game-changing circumstances and big-time stadium atmosphere of WrestleMania, Cody and Seth had to work within a more normalised context. This was the real test of Cody's ability to get and stay over within a WWE system that makes getting over far more difficult than it needs to be - and he passed it in what was a rip-roaring, unqualified success. This thing just clicked so much that they feel like they were born to rival one another.

The word rival is used deliberately.

This was up there with Cody's most admirable career accomplishments; the man unfairly criticised throughout his AEW run as heavily reliant on the blade, fire and various other shortcuts showed that he can tell a pure wrestling story as well as anybody. The story of the match saw Seth, having time to prepare, counter almost everything Cody attempted in the opening phase. Without bleeding or rushing through anything, Cody and Seth told a focused story worked at an engaging pace. The tone was especially impressive; this felt like an ultra-competitive battle between two very prideful performers desperate to win and showing that intent to win throughout. It was built quite brilliantly - they never once lost a super-heated crowd - and it was a distinctly WWE match.

It was almost more impressive for how resourceful it was; head drops rule, but you don't get them in WWE. Cody and Seth didn't need them.

They succeeded in working a terrific match that felt as important to them as anything they'd fought for in their careers.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


5. Omos Vs. Bobby Lashley

WWE WrestleMania Backlash Omos Lashley
WWE.com

There are two ways of describing the second match between Omos and Bobby Lashley.

1) It was superior to their outing at WrestleMania.

2) It was a mild improvement on everything that Omos has achieved in the singles context so far.

This doesn't mean the match was even good, or that Omos has hitherto unseen potential. It just means the layout was as flattering as possible in how basic it was, and he no longer gets so lost that it breaks any semblance of immersion. The issue - and this will remain an issue for forever, because, unlike a deeply simplistic match structure, it cannot be learned - is that Omos entirely lacks a threatening aura.

Simplicity can be beautiful, if the hoss monster is capable of projecting menace. The most rudimentary offence imaginable can feel just as dramatic as stiff, intricate work, if the worker has an intangible, scary quality. This simply isn't true of Omos, though he deserves praise for his ability to land a halfway impressive big boot. He's better athletically than the Great Khali ever was, but Khali's look carried him over a line that Omos might only approach with time, patience and practise - by which time the window will have closed.

This was the wrong result, looking at a bleak long-term picture.

On a night on which WWE didn't even have it in them to beat a stablemate of Roman's in a non-title match, the promotion now has two fewer viable big match opponents than it did before the show started.

Star Rating: ★¾


4. Edge Vs. AJ Styles

Edge AJ Styles
WWE.com

This match really wasn't helped by the opener because it strove for a similar sense of gravitas - and failed.

Where Cody and Rollins effectively conveyed a sense of importance with the sheer spirit behind everything they did, Edge and AJ for the second consecutive "Premium Live Event" thought their match was important because they took an eternity to do anything in the spaces between moves. They very much abused the making-everything-matter principle, yet again, wrestling under the belief that the fans were deeply invested in their storyline. They aren't. The piped-in crowd effects on TV can't obscure this.

The slow, drab pace only masqueraded as weighty, important storytelling, and it was almost annoying when Edge and AJ showed off their advanced grasp of the working art deep into the match as a result. AJ rolled back the years with a stunning aerial, which Edge caught as safely as you'll see in the North American scene without detracting from impactful it looked. When they're great, they're great, but so much of this just existed.

Generally, it was a match in which every move happened in a sensible order and was sold very well, but it was just...boring, lacking in as much dynamism as soul.

WrestleMania Backlash drew very little interest for its rematch-heavy premise. Between the scaled-back action and second consecutive interference finish, in which it was clear that this was always trending towards the trilogy, this was the most WrestleMania Backlash match to ever WrestleMania Backlash.

Star Rating: ★★¾


3. Charlotte Flair Vs. Ronda Rousey - SmackDown Women's Title I Quit Match

RondA rousey Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Pitched somewhere between their Survivor Series minor classic and the drawn-out WrestleMania 38 sequel, this, thankfully, was closer in quality to the former.

Ronda Rousey is back; she worked with an intensity, speed and viciousness that appeared to have deserted her throughout this subpar return. She impressed and generated an elusive, hot crowd reaction with her unique and thrillingly convincing judoka skill-set before a plunder brawl so intense unfolded that the boring and redundant kendo stick actually felt like a dangerous weapon again. In a great mini-sequence pitched as a martial arts movie fight, the weapon fight sprawled to the stage upon which Flair took a gnarly flat-back to sell Rousey's legitimacy. This was blocked very well - an inspired layout that allowed the match not to descend into WWE's redundant plunder match trope-fest.

Charlotte caught a wicked German straight on the head, and even if that probably wasn't executed as intended, it elevated what was already a furious tone.

The ac-ting at the end of the match was a bit on the nose, and this use of a risible modern trend was particularly jarring since the fight felt very unlike a performance elsewhere, but at least it was the finish.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


2. Madcap Moss Vs. Happy Corbin

Madcap Moss Happy Corbin
WWE.com

The exact sort of WWE match so formulaic that it's almost impossible to analyse.

Positioned in the death slot, it was never going to receive a hot reaction, but on a night on which the usual terrible mechanisms of WWE television were easy to put aside, this match only brought into focus just how much time the promotion wastes with witless bullsh*t that is all but impossible to invest in. It was a match premised on a heel falling out with his heater because his jokes were bad, and the heater, your new upstart babyface, still tells them and wears suspenders as ring attire. The content is low-stakes, Vince McMahon-friendly stuff, and the blow-off to a development that began just less than a year ago played out to bored silence.

The actual work was decent. Corbin can go when the stage demands it, and Moss is as athletic as his secret Performance Center history suggests when he bursts into vulnerable positions to feed Corbin's underrated power game.

But structurally, this was every WWE television match you've ever seen, so much so that you could almost picture Michael Hayes with his headset on telling them not to go too hard or too long.

Remember your spot on the card.

Star Rating: ★★¾


1. The Bloodline Vs. Drew McIntyre & RK-Bro

Rk-Bro Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

A match of two halves, the first was very inert.

It's hard to gauge. Was it prolonged house show-level stalling, or did the main crux of the story - Roman's fear of sharing the ring with Drew McIntyre - not feel like a highly-anticipated show-down because the televised build felt so sudden?

It's not as if Drew has spent the last however many months as some super-over fan favourite on some epic quest heading towards the title picture. His last two programmes were comedy-centric.

The second half was thrilling: an honest-to-goodness spot-fest loaded with high spots and saves worked at a breakneck pace removed from the WWE norm. To much controversial discourse, Dave Meltzer compared the main event to a PWG match, and there's something to the take. The spots weren't quite as audacious nor state-of-the-art, nor was the feeling elicited quite that of unbridled, dumb pro wrestling ecstasy, the sort that truly makes you lose your mind. The breakneck turn-taking action however did very much warrant chants of "This is awesome!", which is rare for a modern pro wrestling crowd.

Randy Orton's hot tag is an absolute revelation, and placed in the context of a relentless trios banger, it genuinely felt like the man has never been better nor more over than he is. If you were to build a spot monkey from the ground up, at WrestleMania Backlash at least, he'd look like Randy Orton.

For all the talk of Roman having next to no credible challengers, on this evidence, it's really not an over-exaggeration to state that this version of Orton could very well headline opposite him at next year's 'Mania if the Rock can't make it.

A quite inexplicable, but very welcome over-delivery of a match with a questionable, practically cowardly finish.

Pulsating, twist-heavy action >>>>>>>> chinlocks and monologues.

Star Rating: ★★★¾


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!