6 Reasons The 'American Bad Ass' Undertaker Would Rock WWE

The Undertaker is ripe for a shake-up...

The Undertaker is the single most enduring character in WWE history. Perhaps the biggest success Mark Calaway can point to since debuting in 1990 has been his ability to keep things fresh. Initially, the character was an undead zombie, but the man has also played a Satanic 'Lord Of Darkness' and supernatural phenomenon, amongst others. One of the most startling shifts was when 'Taker returned at Judgment Day 2000 as something completely fresh. Going by the nickname, 'American Bad Ass', The Undertaker was suddenly more realistic than ever before. Looking to throw their weight behind this drastic new direction, the creative team handed 'Taker more mic time and morphed him into an uncompromising brawler. Calaway's real-life wife at the time, Sara was even eventually added into storylines. By the time WrestleMania XX in 2004 rolled around, WWE had decided to return 'Taker to his roots. Ever since then, the character has been pretty content as 'The Deadman'. However, after Undertaker shockingly returned to confront Brock Lesnar at Battleground, there's been talk of the 'American Bad Ass' biker persona returning. This article explores the viability of such a theory, and looks at the plus points of The Undertaker becoming more 'human' once more. Would it work in today's WWE? Also, just what would it mean for the future of the infamous character?


6. It 'Humanises' Character Again Before Retirement

It's been quite the journey for Mark Calaway in pro wrestling. The Undertaker initially seemed like a short-term deal in the then-World Wrestling Federation of 1990, but the character has dominated Calaway's adult life. Over the years, it certainly hasn't been uncommon for Undertaker to appear under the guise of the persona, rather than as himself. Even when WWE has been festooned with more realistic people like John Cena, The Undertaker has remained one constant. There's only one time in his career that 'Taker was more 'human'. As the 'American Bad Ass' biker character, the man was definitely more identifiable for wrestling fans. All of a sudden, people could relate to the legendary figure, but a lot of the same mythical appeal was somehow kept alive. The big question is whether or not a return to a much more earthly persona is wise? The Undertaker doesn't have an awful lot of time left in the industry, that much is clear. Calaway's body is starting to break down physically, and he has noticeably aged over the past 5 years or so. Before the guy waves goodbye to one of the most famous characters in WWE history, perhaps humanising it again would make for a memorable ending. If nothing else, this might make for an easier transition into post-career interviews and documentaries.

5. 'Taker Would Be Able To Cut Proper Promos Again

For years now, The Undertaker hasn't been a big talker on WWE television. During the 'American Bad Ass' era, that wasn't the case at all. On the contrary, 'Taker was highly vocal, promos were a big part of that particular persona. At first, the biker character was a babyface, but that eventually gave way to an arrogant heel schtick. This was arguably the best portion of Undertaker's career on the mic. Claiming that the ring was his "yard", and that he called the shots added legitimacy to proceedings. Wrestling fans had been aware for years that Mark Calaway was an authority in the WWF/WWE locker room, so it made sense to parlay this into storyline. Imagine an Undertaker who was entirely vocal about the current state of affairs in the company, standing up to The Authority? That's something that could work, and fans would no doubt enjoy hearing more from one of the most respected men on the roster. For many years, 'Taker's character has forced him to keep quiet, so promos would feel fresh and new. This could make for some very entertaining segments on Monday Night Raw, just as one example.

4. Gives 'Mania XXX Defeat More Meaning

It really felt like a watershed moment when Brock Lesnar pinned The Undertaker at WrestleMania XXX. The latter had amassed an incredible 21 victories at the grand event in succession, so fans had been conditioned to believe it incomprehensible that he'd lose at 'Mania. The reaction of fans around ringside said it all on the night, few thought the 'Streak' would ever end. If The Undertaker changes up his character to become the more realistic 'American Bad Ass' again, it could help that 'Mania XXX match mean more. In promos, 'Taker could explain at length just what losing the winning streak did to him mentally. That could be the catalyst for a major shift in persona, because there would need to be some sort of justification. Brock Lesnar could be painted by WWE as the man who changed The Undertaker forever. 'Taker himself could state that he felt human for the first time in a long time, all because of Lesnar's power. Not only does that justify the character change, it also makes Lesnar look insanely strong in the process. Sure, Undertaker did face Bray Wyatt the following year at WrestleMania, but that could be palmed off as the man trying to hang on to his past.

3. Would Be Tailor Made For One Last Heel Run

It's been over a decade since The Undertaker was a villain. In fairness, the character is so strong - and has been running so long - that a heel turn has been unnecessary. It's unclear without trying exactly how many people in the audience would be willing to actually boo Undertaker, but it's an interesting premise. WWE have long said that 'Taker feeds off the energy of his 'Creatures Of The Night', so maybe that could be played into things. If Undertaker were to cut a promo saying he no longer needs that energy, it could be powerful stuff. In a sense, there will always be a large portion of the fan base who will cheer the man regardless of what he does or says, but being a heel could open up some interesting possibilities. As a bad guy, Undertaker was excellent in previous feuds and matches against the likes of Jeff Hardy and Rob Van Dam. There's room for a heel 'Taker in WWE currently. Brock Lesnar has transitioned into being a more fan-friendly character, without sacrificing his own hard-man persona. That means the top heel spot is there for the taking, and The Undertaker would be perfect. There are few better ways to reinvigorate the legendary gimmick.

2. Could Finally Pave Way For Match With Sting

There's still at least some degree of hope that a match between The Undertaker and Sting will happen. Neither man is getting any younger, and with each passing month, the chance becomes slimmer. Nonetheless, age would be forgotten the first time both guys went face-to-face. There's just one problem, the bout would need some sort of reason to take place. An aforementioned heel turn by 'Taker could be the ideal fodder for such a collision. Admittedly, the man's track record against former WCW stars isn't too great (DDP anyone?), but that could be set right with Sting. If either wrestler retires without this match taking place, it'll top any list looking at 'ones that got away'. In short, WWE must book it at some point. Casual fans who haven't been interested for years would surely be intrigued to see what might happen. The Undertaker vs. Sting is maybe even the ultimate WWE vs. WCW match. The bout has eluded fans so long that it'd actually feel strange if it was confirmed to happen, but a villainous Undertaker would add an interesting dynamic to the match. Facing Sting as the 'American Bad Ass' is not something anybody would see coming from Undertaker.

1. Would Totally Freshen Up The Undertaker

Overall, reverting to the 'American Bad Ass' persona would give The Undertaker a much-needed overhaul. Just as it did for the character in 2000, getting on the motorcycle and becoming a more realistic figure could help stir interest in him again. It's unfair to say that Undertaker will be overlooked if he doesn't become the kick-ass biker again, but it wouldn't hurt. Mark Calaway is entering the final stretch of his active in-ring career, that much seems obvious. Right before he rides off into the sunset for good, there's no reason not to try and shake things up again. The near 4-year stint as the 'American Bad Ass' is fondly remembered by most fans who lived through it, because it represented something radical for The Undertaker. In 2015, WWE could do with a injection such as this. The Undertaker will always be considered a legend, regardless of what path the character takes, but there's another chance to surprise fans. Post-'Streak', there's a general feeling that Undertaker isn't as important as he once was. Showing a different side of his skill set to a new generation could help change that.

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.