6 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (28 February - Results & Review)
Sting channels classic WCW Nitro on very, very good AEW Dynamite.
It was all going so well.
Revolution 2024, on Tuesday February 27, was the most well-built AEW pay-per-view in two years. The card looked stacked, but not too stacked. If you're of an anxious disposition, the only worry was the threat (for which there is precedent) of Khan adding too many unnecessary matches to it. Weirdly, it was almost nice to fret over AEW's direction, as opposed to grimly accepting that the action on the night would be great without feeling a great deal of emotional investment ahead of it.
Enter Chris Jericho.
The man who most needs to go away threatened to make his presence felt at a pay-per-view that needs absolutely nothing else added to it. The man who most needs to go away and cruelly did for a brief time was set to wrestle the rave-reviewed Atlantis Jr. on Dynamite last night under the Lionheart guise. There is cute, inspired lore behind the pairing, but even beyond the threat of a post-match angle with Revolution implications, this felt like the sort of random, nerdy, ultimately trivial affair that AEW promotes between pay-per-view cycles.
Last night was the last chance for AEW to drive all the way home that it was back; the unwanted return of Chris Jericho underscored that some of its problems will literally never go away.
Beyond the bleak and more important idea that Jericho may well be at best a creep, he's been as piss-poor as he's been over-exposed this year. For his own good, he needs to take one of his trademark hiatuses.
Was that too harsh? Did he do what Chris Jericho used to do, time and time again, and tell the doubters to "go f*ck their ass"?
Downs...
X. Another Off-Night For Jericho
Every Chris Jericho match in 2024 has a sort of teetering quality to it. It's never perfect. The struggle is all too real.
The 2024 Jericho match always feels like it's bound to collapse under the weight of its over-ambition. Lionheart Chris Jericho Vs. Atlantis Jr. was choppy in that now trademark Jericho way. Jericho first took a few monkey flips as Atlantis initially struggled to win the crowd over with some desperate appeals. It didn't help that Jericho, to be blunt, landed like a sack of sh*t. The monkey flip only works if the recipient gets blown the f*ck away across the breadth of the ring. He landed instead with an anticlimactic thud after clearing very little distance. Groan-inducing, deflating stuff.
Also, on the outside, he struggled badly to get up for a powerbomb. He was always meant to reverse it when he could get into position and send Atlantis Jr. into the ring steps, but that initial sandbag made that brief moment before the counter absolutely terrifying. The mishaps happen every single time he steps in the ring now. You can't wear what you wore in the '90s and become that person all over again. The first half of the match made that agonisingly clear.
In fairness to Jericho, the second half of the match was much tighter, better and more dramatic than the first. The counters were far more crisp, and Jericho's top-rope hurricanrana looked spectacular. Fans were initially bemused by Atlantis Jr.'s approach - he does a lot of vintage lucha and wears almost old-timey gear in reference to his lineage - but his awesome strength and crowd control ability got him over in the end.
After nailing Atlantis Jr. with a top-rope bulldog from his old CMLL catalogue - a neat touch - Jericho won after a neat Liontamer reversal when Atlantis threw in the towel on his son's behalf.
Jericho celebrated after the match before it was announced that...
X. What Is THIS Match?
With multiple wrestlers slated for #AEWRevolution's Meat Madness match out injured + shelved by AEW docs, I'm temporarily freezing the bout until they're clear
Meat Madness is on ice;
— Tony Khan (@TonyKhan) February 28, 2024
instead Sunday's ppv will feature an
All-Star Scramble Match!
See you tonight on #AEWDynamite!
The news could have been worse. Chris Jericho, it turns out, will not be eating into the Revolution run-time; he will be taking part in a match that will replace an already announced postponed attraction.
'Meat Madness' is now off - Tony Khan stated on Twitter that some of the names scheduled to be added are not medically cleared - and will be replaced by an eight-man 'All-Star Scramble', the winner of which will earn a World title shot against whomever emerges with the hardware at Revolution.
The match should be fun enough - it is incredibly difficult to f*ck up an urgent, action-heavy one-fall-to-a-finish stip like this - but also, Jesus Christ.
It feels like an excuse to get Jericho's mandatory PPV match on there, and the desperation, the tumble down the card, is almost undignified. Could his appearance be any more unnecessary?
Surely, the precious spotlight can wait a few months. This cannot be good for his brand. He literally exists in AEW for the purpose of existing now.
He's turning himself into the opposite of a star.
Ups...
6. Ultimately Passable, BUT...
There was some good, some bad in the opening segment.
Hangman Page can affect a hell of a limp. Were it not for the clarification from Fightful's Sean Ross Sapp last week, you'd think Page was out for several months or up to a year with a serious ankle injury. Page also successfully verbally manipulated the crowd into thinking he was too hurt to work Revolution. The very real wrinkle of the personal issue affecting Page obviously helped, but his cracked-voice delivery was understated enough to achieve that "this one's real, guys..." effect.
To the bad: it was a bit convenient that Swerve Strickland walked out there and then, and that Page would anticipate that. You could ask what Page would have done, had Swerve not emerged to gloat in Hangman's face, and it would be a fair question - but the story AEW has told is one of pure, dangerous obsession. Page and Swerve cannot stay away from one another even to the detriment of their stated ambitions. Of course Swerve was going to gloat over Page's "injury". That part of Hangman's plan made sense.
What didn't make sense is that, with Swerve's back turned to take in the words of an interrupting Samoa Joe, Page "took out" Swerve with his crutch. Swerve sold this for ages as if he'd been cracked in the skull with a brick. You can't really do a Texas Death match and an angle like that in the same storyline. The former made the latter difficult to take seriously.
These TV angles are often left to linger past the point of credibility, but this was especially unconvincing.
Joe coming out made this feel like a wrestling angle too. Joe basically spoke as if there was never a chance that Page wasn't wrestling. They're having a three-way match at the PPV AEW wants you to buy, you see.
God forbid you aren't allowed to forget that three men are wrestling in the same match even during an angle when you're meant to believe that there's only two men in it!
AEW has this annoying tendency to insult the intelligence of the fans, and that tendency undermined a segment that was performed just well enough to earn a passing grade.
Just: can wrestlers please stop talking about being hungry and starving and the like? It's fast becoming one of the more irritating clichés.
5. Decent Match Dovetails
Orange Cassidy Vs. Nick Wayne was a decent, compact TV effort.
Nick Wayne's aerials were both beautiful and impactful as he blew Orange away early as the customary star is given a tough test Dynamite match. There wasn't a great deal to it - there was never going to be much in the way of true drama so close to a PPV title defence - but the work while it lasted was well above solid, and the Beach Break counter from a German suplex attempt was breathtaking.
In a weird moment, Matt Taven and Mike Bennett encroached on ringside. This was an International title defence. Could they have been so sure that Strong would go on to wrestle Wayne in the event that he actually won the title?
Daniel Garcia neutralised the interference and his distraction of Wayne allowed Cassidy to retain the title via Orange punch.
The finish wasn't fantastic, but this was a fun enough match. Tony Khan resourcefully built two PPV matches in one segment here, albeit in the most basic way imaginable.
4. Kris Statlander RULES
With ideal timing, Skye Blue defeated Kris Statlander following her tightest and most accomplished in-ring outing yet. Until the finishing stretch, this was a straight shoot-out. It was lean, focused and explosive. Stat is just an awesome wrestler who can take anybody out from any angle without revving up, as she demonstrated by smashing Blue with a propulsive leaping back elbow after barely moving a step toward the corner.
Stat's physical timing is just something else. She has the ability to almost warp wherever she needs to be. It never feels like she's dumbly walking into anything or waiting to take a move. That said, Blue needed to be on-point to make this as tight as it was. Her strikes were snug and beautifully timed, and she used that dialled-in sense of timing to maker her counters - a gorgeous drop-toe hold especially - look last-gasp.
This was a familiar modern match in a lot of ways - Canadian destroyers, German suplexes on the apron etc. - but the execution elevated it.
At the finish, Stokely Hathaway urged Statlander to use a chain, and in another really well-timed moment, Julie Hart punished her with a belt shot to allow Skye the win.
3. Will Ospreay Stakes His Claim
Will Ospreay made his debut as a full-time member of the roster in a promo segment. Now, Will Ospreay is not a particularly cool guy. Nor is he especially funny.
When he compared himself in his green tracksuit to "Kermit the frog on leg day", he might as well have welcomed you all to Monday Night Raw. In 2019.
But!
AEW was mired in a lot of bullsh*t in 2023. The vibe was gone. More than one wrestler indicated, on socials, that they'd rather be elsewhere. More than one wrestler felt like they'd been dragged into work to cover a shift on their day off. More than one wrestler looked checked-out altogether.
Will Ospreay wants this more than anyone, whether you think he's the very best wrestler in the world or whether you think he cynically works 40 minute plus matches purely for the asterisks. You can see the enthusiasm beaming from him, and the audience can feel it.
AEW needs a top guy to love it, to lead it, to set a standard. AEW in 2024 needs a mascot like Ospreay.
He was interrupted by the Don Callis Family. Callis arrived at the best analogy yet for a match, at Revolution, that only really exists for its potential quality and as a means of driving Ospreay away from the heel side. Callis said it was like when Jordan and Pippen would maul each other in practise to sharpen their claws. That will probably do.
Ospreay can't not be a babyface. This is a vehicle to achieve that, as indicated by the not exactly friendly handshake between Ospreay and Konosuke Takeshita.
It was hard for Ospreay to feel like a superstar in front of another piss-weak gate, but everybody who wants that top spot should take notice.
Ospreay is an animal who treats every day on the job like it's his first.
2. Excellent Trios Match Deepens The "Feeling"
FTR and Eddie Kingston Vs. Blackpool Combat Club was a killer trios war that effectively built the respective matches at Revolution. It was brimming with several ideas and overlapping plots that never detracted from the urgent tone, one moment aside.
FTR are rather too fond of the stagy sequence in which they reach out with one another's hands to escape a submission predicament they are trapped in together. They did a three-way version of this trademark here, and it felt even more glaring in the context of such a pissy, frenetic brawl. The crowd seemed removed from this brief threat of jarring melodrama. Elsewhere, though, this kicked ass. It broke down early in such an awesome, organic way that early with a fight on the outside that felt genuinely out of control.
On Collision, Bryan Danielson sought to peck at Eddie's psyche, knowing that his rival is prone to impulsive fits of temper and a lack of composure. This story was told throughout and informed the finish of the match. Eddie faded into unconsciousness trapped in a triangle choke. Bryan is in Eddie's head.
He has said that Eddie beating him was a one-off, that class is permanent and form is temporary. That finish juiced up Revolution nicely, and in a cracking subplot that underscored how believable Eddie is as a character, he spent the opening phase distracted by his other condescending nemesis in Claudio Castagnoli.
It's a shame that Cash Wheeler happens to be a member of an all-time great tag team (and that Dax likes to volunteer himself for singles matches) because, as displayed again last night, he'd be absolutely incredible in a one-on-one grudge programme. He chopped Jon Moxley like Mox had killed a close family member of his in cold blood. He is incredible.
The structure did threaten to loop with the placement of a second commercial break. The match sagged as it meandered through this obligation, but the crowd sparked back into life after a three-way machine chop spot.
A blistering series of near-falls and saves preceded the finish, during which Eddie came agonisingly close to pinning Danielson. This was inspired - the layout made you want to preview the feel-good result on Sunday before casting doubt over the outcome.
It's also really quite sweet that every single time Mox and Eddie find themselves in the same ring, they share a very brief glance of "How did we end up here again?" before kicking each other's face in. Their reunion will rule even more than this did.
This was (mostly) a tremendous TV match.
1. Classic Dynamite Moment Pays Tribute To Vintage Nitro
AEW delivered a suitably iconic moment to drive pay-per-view buys.
Before this was arrived at, AEW told a show-long storyline in which the Young Bucks stalked the backstage area looking for Sting. They wanted to thank him for his services and conduct an "exit interview". Bats in hand, they were trailed throughout the night by a camera crew. The eventually located Sting's dressing room, and crept in tentatively, selling fear of the scary, dead-eyed promo he cut on them last week. Inside, they found an assortment of bats, in a really neat bit of foreshadowing, hanging from the ceiling. The hunt made it ringside by the main event segment. Nicholas Jackson removed the masks from the "Sting fans" at ringside.
In a cool tribute to a timeless bit, one of those fans was Darby, who went after the Bucks before the one man advantage caught up with him. The Bucks then retreated up the ramp in anticipation of Sting's entrance when the music hit. The wonderful aspect of that foreshadowing is that nobody clocked it until the perfect time. It seemed impossible that Sting would ever repeat the old trick, but for the last time - and you just had to mark out for this if there's any wrestling fan DNA inside of you - he repelled from the rafters. God, that was just such an awesome thing to have happened. Sting then took out the Bucks with bat shots before drilling Nicholas with the Scorpion Death Drop.
The Ric Flair element was bleak.
He had walked to the ring, teased turning heel on Darby, and executed an absolutely awful-looking beat-down before Nicholas hit him in the nuts.
He shouldn't be on television, but that Sting entrance was so magical that the vibe was rescued at the last minute.
This programme, the odd ill-advised moment aside, has absolutely ruled.
Everything is in place for Showtime on Sunday.