6 Ups & 3 Downs For AEW Collision (Dec 9 - Results & Review)
Fantastic Continental Classic action and plenty of love from the Montreal crowd.
Another week, another AEW Collision in the books.
As the Blue League of the Continental Classic rumbles on, this week's edition of AEW's Saturday staple brought a couple of cracking tournament matches in the shape of Eddie Kingston vs. Claudio Castagnoli and Andrade El Idolo vs. Bryan Danielson. Elsewhere, Willow Nightingale and Mercedes Martinez faced off as their burgeoning issues continue on, Wardlow got to test his mettle against Willie Mack, and there was plenty of love from the Montreal, Quebec crowd as Ethan Page challenged Kenny Omega, and Daddy Magic and Cool Hand Ang squared off with Penta El Zero Miedo and Komander.
While the focus was largely on in-ring action this week, there was still a few promo segments thrown in for good measure, with Jon Moxley and Swerve Strickland hyping their upcoming Continental Classic meeting, a smidge of Keith Lee and Shane Taylor ahead of their ROH Final Battle bout on Friday, and a little more in the brewing romance between Ruby Soho and the aforementioned Angelo Parker.
With all of that in mind, then, Saturday night's alright for fighting...
Downs...
3. A Solid Effort Hindered By Familiar Problems
Willow Nightingale vs. Mercedes Martinez was such a mixed bag of a match. On the plus side, both women brought some brilliant physicality to the action, told a solid story, and nicely progressed things in the rivalry pitting Willow and Kris Statlander up against Mercedes and Diamante.
However, there were just sadly a few too many issues at play that means this bout lands on the Downs side of this week's Collision review - and, as is often the case with the AEW women's division, those issues were largely out of the hands of any of the talent involved.
In the stale, stagnant formula of AEW Collision and wider AEW programming, this was the sole women's match on the show, went nine minutes, three of which were part of a picture-in-picture commercial. On top of that, as someone watching Collision through FITE, that P-in-P break cut to the standard Collision logo and music halfway through.
Elsewhere, Nightingale and Martinez fought on the outside for nearly two minutes shortly after the bell had sounded, all while referee Mike Posey didn't even bother to start a standard ten-count until Mercedes eventually made her way back in the ring; making the standard countout rule totally redundant.
As alluded to, it wasn't all bad here, as the actual action itself was good, with the heel Martinez brutalising Willow's back and dropping her with a gnarly draping DDT on the outside. That restricted Nightingale in what she could do, selling the back and struggling to lift her opponent.
Still, Willow Nightingale would pick up the win here, managing to surprise Mercedes after being hit with what was essentially an impressive Razor's Edge turned into a Dominator. While Willow scoring the victory made sense for the wider story, it did feel as if maybe she'd been beaten down a little too much to realistically be able to still get the 1-2-3.
Either way, the inevitable plunder war of Willow & Stat vs. Mercedes & Diamante should be fun. Now, let those ladies get 15 or 20 minutes as and when that contest arrives.
2. More Ridiculous Tony Schiavone Hyperbole
Pro wrestling is a business built often built on exaggeration and hyperbole, but Tony Schiavone has a habit of taking this to ridiculous levels.
Last week, Schiavone described Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal as "one of the great tag teams". That'd be the same Daniels and Sydal who have only operated as a tag team on 25 occasions across 17 years, have never won a match on AEW television, and have spent the bulk of 2023 losing in ROH to the likes of the Righteous, the Gunns, and the Gates of Agony. Two extremely talented guys with great careers to their name, but not exactly an all-timer of a tag team.
This week, Tony labelled Ethan Page as one of the greatest Canadian wrestlers of the modern era. Full disclosure, your writer is a huge Ethan Page fan dating back to Page rocking up in IMPACT Wrestling - often paired up with Matt Sydal, as it happens - back in 2018. All Ego is an incredibly talented worker, both in the ring and on the mic, and he has an immense upside of which we've only just scratched the surface.
However, describing Ethan Page as one of Canada's modern-day greats is ludicrous and is the sort of comment that puts a dent in Tony Schiavone's credibility. By throwing such terms around with such loose regard, it makes Schiavone seem either totally clueless or blindly biased - two traits that you don't particularly want associated with your lead announcer.
Describing Kenny Omega as one of Canada's greatest wrestlers of modern times? That's absolutely fair; the same can be said about Chris Jericho, about Adam Copeland, about Christian Cage. Right now, Ethan Page is simply not at that level. Here's hoping the former North man eventually does get to that level, but for now such comments just chip away at what credibility Tony Schiavone still has.
Another mild grumble, too, is that, while Ethan Page was never going to beat Kenny Omega, why book Page in a loss when he's got a big PPV match - an I Quit offering against Tony Nese at ROH Final Battle - coming up on Friday? Was the lure of doing Canadian vs. Canadian in Montreal really worth handing someone a momentum-draining loss ahead of what should be viewed as a major PPV bout?
1. Misogynistic Miro
Miro guarantees he won’t attack his Hot & Flexible Wife’s client, Andrade El Idolo, until the #AEWContinentalClassic has concluded.
But does CJ Perry believe him?Watch #AEWCollision on TNT!@ToBeMiro | @TheCJPerry | @AndradeElIdolo pic.twitter.com/PW0bMgQcTu
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) December 10, 2023
While CJ Perry managing talents who aren't Miro is an intriguing proposition, added to nicely by the smart pairing of Perry and Andrade El Idolo, could Tony Khan have used something other than misogyny as the base for the issues between this real-life married couple? Opting to take things in that direction is certainly a choice.
As seen on AEW Collision, the beef between CJ and Miro stems from how the Redeemer expects her to stay at home to cook and clean. How dare she want to have her own career and be anything more than a doting housewife pulled straight out of the 1950s? CJ should simply be happy to stay home and clean the fish that Miro catches...
Could we not do any better than this? Having CJ Perry and Miro on opposing sides has so much potential, and the inevitable Miro meeting with Andrade should be fantastic, but did we really need to drop in how the Bulgarian Brute is pissed off that CJ isn't a good little wifey who stays home and does the ironing? That story wrinkle just seems so unnecessary when looking at ways to cause friction between this husband and wife duo.
Ups...
6. Pre-Titles Promos
As is ever the case, AEW Collision's use of pre-titles promos will always garner an episode an Up.
This time out, it was Ethan Page, Kenny Omega, Bryan Danielson, Andrade El Idolo and CJ Perry, Claudio Castagnoli, and Eddie Kingston who all got to throw out some short, sharp barbs to hype the impending action.
So simple, so effective.
5. The Pig-Headed Iron Will Of Eddie Kingston
From the moment Eddie Kingston stomped to the ring like an agitated, angry toddler - in the best possible way - you knew the Mad King was in no mood to put up with Claudio Castagnoli's BS.
As soon as the bell rang, Castagnoli dominated Kingston, using his superior strength and technique to easily take control of the bout. From a narrative standpoint, Eddie was on his ass and on the cusp of being effectively eliminated from the Continental Classic. A loss here would've made it impossible for Kingston to progress in the tournament, and making it an even more bitter pill to swallow would be the fact that this L came against long-time rival Claudio Castagnoli.
The body language of Eddie Kingston was utterly exceptional here, whether that was outwardly showing his frustration at being dominated by Claudio, whether that was in how he at times mocked the Swiss Superman in an attempt to knock him off his game, or whether that was as part of Kingston's spirited attempts to get back in the game; spirited attempts that were constantly shot down by the one-time Cesaro.
No matter what Eddie threw at Castagnoli, the Blackpool Combat Club man forever had an answer. The only reason why Claudio couldn't score the win, was down to the sheer pig-headed stubbornness of his opponent. Kingston would be damned if he'd lose this match, and he'd be damned if his Continental Classic adventure - which of course has his ROH World Title and NJPW Strong Openweight Title on the line - was brought to a halt by, of all people, Claudio Castagnoli.
Even when Eddie did get the victory, it wasn't particularly definitive. Instead, it was a case of Kingston somehow surviving Claudio's plentiful onslaughts for long enough that he was able to take advantage of a minor opening to reverse Castagnoli into a pinning predicament and score the underdog 1-2-3.
The Continental Classic rumbles on, and Eddie Kingston is still just about alive and kicking in the Blue League.
4. Continuing In The Right Direction
Few talents have been as bungled in AEW as Wardlow, with how expertly he was used in his formative days making it all the more baffling to see how badly the ball was dropped once the War Dog decimated MJF at Double or Nothing 2022.
Still, since Mr. Mayhem returned to action in October, slowly but surely we're getting back to what established Wardlow as one of hottest acts in the company. Namely, he's brutalising fools in comprehensive, impactful fashion.
For the most part, said fools have been enhancement talents or low-totem names. That's not to say Willie Mack - an incredibly talented fella in his own right - is particularly viewed as a big deal in AEW or ROH, but he did at least feel like a smidge more of a challenge for Wardlow than, say, Griff Garrison or Ryan Nemeth.
For those who've seen Mack compete for the likes of IMPACT, GCW, Lucha Underground, or AAA, you'll be well aware what this athletic powerhouse can bring to the table. However, that wasn't what Willie was here for on AEW Collision. Instead, he was here as a slightly bigger threat to Wardlow than the names the three-time TNT Champion has faced in recent weeks; a slightly bigger threat who'd put up a valiant effort but ultimately be left laying and looking at the lights.
It would take just over three minutes, but Wardlow got the ref stoppage win after hitting his Last Ride-infused powerbomb on Mack. Again, this continues to keep the former Pinnacle man moving in the right direction, all as his issues with MJF linger on in the background.
3. A Nice Showcase For All Ego
Despite the Tony Schiavone hyperbole, Ethan Page vs. Kenny Omega was still a bunch of fun.
Was it a little too competitive? Possibly, but the action here was great as All Ego got an opportunity to showcase his abilities on the Collision stage; a stage he's not been on since challenging MJF for the AEW World Title in June when AEW Collision was in Hamilton, Ontario.
Having Page 'hang' with the Best Bout Machine for 12 minutes can certainly be a nice rub for the former North man if it's followed-up on in the future, and Ethan, as per, clearly made the most of his minutes in front of the Montreal crowd. A cutter from Page was particularly impressive, whereas a suplex to the outside from Omega onto Page was particularly wince-inducing.
To the surprise of nobody, it was Kenny who walked away with the win, doing so with his patented One-Winged Angel. Post-match, Omega was taken out by Big Bill, which nicely keeps things ticking along for Kenny Omega and Chris Jericho's upcoming shot at Bill and Ricky Starks' AEW Tag Team Titles.
Now, let's hope it doesn't take for AEW to return to Canada for Ethan Page to be featured in a televised one-on-one match again. While Page has been having a fun run in ROH across these past few months, he's a talent who really should be given more opportunities as an AEW singles act in 2024 and beyond.
2. Montreal Shows Plenty Of Love For Daddy Magic And Cool Hand Ang
Would it have hurt to give Daddy Magic and Cool Hand Ang the win here in front of a passionate Montreal crowd? Given how he's been used in AEW and ROH so far, Komander could've easily eaten the pin and let these Canadians bask in victory in their home province of Quebec.
Still, it was at least great to see Matt Menard and Angelo Parker get to have what was clearly an emotional moment for them in front of their friends and family.
Menard and Parker are good dudes who've long busted their backsides in this industry, criminally cast aside by WWE despite making the most of every scrap they were given by the market leader. Despite not being used as featured players, per se, in AEW, the duo have still made for a ridiculously entertaining presence whenever they're on screen. So, getting to see good guys reap the rewards of this Quebec reaction was brilliant to watch.
A shooting star press and piledriver was enough to get the win for Penta El Zero Miedo and Komander, and the match itself was fine for what it was; several high-energy crowd-popping spots for a rampant crowd.
1. Excellent Wrestling, Excellent Larger Story
Andrade El Idolo is one of the very best wrestlers on the planet, an elite in-ring worker who effortlessly blends Rolls-Royce sheen with brutal crispness. Bryan Danielson is arguably the best wrestler on the planet, a timeless, special talent who's wrapping up another banner year of a truly legendary career.
This week's AEW Collision main event had all the ingredients to be special, and boy, did we get something special.
As one would expect, the in-ring work between Andrade and Danielson - bar one scary Bryan dive - was exceptional, but making all of this even more compelling is the various spinning plates of story development we got during and after this bout.
Of course, one key component to this contest was El Idolo tearing off the eye patch that's protecting the American Dragon's orbital injury and helping with his vision. From there, the former La Sombra upped his viciousness, targeting the bullseye that was Bryan's left eye and unleashing a relentless assault on that area before putting the wounded, weakened Danielson down with the hammerlock DDT. Fantastically adding to the drama and brutality of this situation, you had the commentary team calling for the match to be stepped, with even Nigel McGuinness joining in with those calls.
This match and all that surrounded it achieved so, so much.
- Andrade looks like a killer who'll do anything to win and now looks like a genuine threat to win the entire Continental Classic
- While not ringside, CJ Perry seems to have been a great influence on her new charge
- Bryan Danielson immediately becomes the compromised underdog in his remaining Continental Classic bouts, fighting against the odds to try and be the inaugural winner of this tournament
- How will this broken-down Bryan possibly fare against the monstrous Brody King when they face off in this tourney?
- Will fellow Blackpool Combat Club man Claudio Castagnoli take advantage of this obvious bullseye when he faces off against Danielson?
- And the impending Continental Classic meeting of Andrade and Claudio now has a whole added level of spice and personal issues to it
This was a magnificent main event to close out a Collision episode that was particularly strong when it comes to in-ring action, and Andrade vs. Danielson serves as yet another stellar outing for what is proving to be a very impressive tournament - with so many mouth-watering match-ups still to come for the Continental Classic.