6 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (16 Nov)

AEW blurs the lines before Full Gear on a go-home show that sold EVERYTHING, if not all of it well.

MJF William Regal Jon Moxley
AEW

All Elite Wrestling understandably doesn't want all of its existence to still be determined and defined by if something happened before or after CM Punk - not least because of more christ-like connotations the former AEW Champion certainly doesn't need - but until at least after this Saturday's Full Gear, that's what will happen.

He's an emblem of the type of chaos that has defined AEW's 2022, and Dynamite has been almost as illustrative of it on a weekly basis. The new signings don't stop, the Ring Of Honor overlap continues to jar, and the nagging sense a lot of your favourites are being underserved by booking failures lingers unglamorously underneath the hundred mile-an-hour wrestling show never taking its foot off the gas.

Yet, since All Out, the top programmes have been tight enough that we find ourselves approaching the weekend pay-per-view staring down some of the biggest and most intriguing matches of the year. Full Gear looks every bit the quarterly supercard it absolutely needed to be. But did another busy Dynamite fulfil its role as vital go-home show with similar aplomb?

Let's light the fuse...


Downs…

3. Bandido Normalised For The Ethan Page Project

Bandido being given a banana skin victory on Rampage only to predictably lose days later anyway is all the more reason why the flashy new signing and former Ring Of Honor Champion probably shouldn't have been in the tournament in the first place.

That's two matches in a row where the flyer felt as though his wings had been clipped by the end, and because Ethan Page has been signposted as a tournament finalist since before the brackets even existed, somebody else probably should have stepped in to take this inevitable loss.

Page has cruised through to the Full Gear final, which is at very least the point of all this. He'll be fresh as a daisy for a Ricky Starks that now has to get past Lance Archer and Brian Cage ("you big dumb b*tch" Lore incoming) before he can even take a swing at The Firm's main man. This thread is the best story beat of a tournament that's otherwise felt a little undercooked and unimportant.


2. Mox & Max In The Mix

MJF Jon Moxley
AEW

Even when Jon Moxley is bad, he's good.

His words in the evening's show-closing angle seemed knowingly glib, and if that scans as generous then you try and not be won over by the glint permanently placed in the man's eye. A charmer and a perfectionist in equal measure, he doubled down a mistake he'd made earlier in his promo about the date of Full Gear to make a mini-moment with MJF just before Dynamite went off the air.

Before that though, the fans didn't seem to know what to make of the Champion refusing to take the Challenger seriously, which is probably excellent foreshadowing about 'The Salt Of The Earth' doing something f*cking awful to all of us the second he's got the belt. Unfortunately, words that might age like fine wine in the future stunk like off milk today.

MJF beating up The Firm felt pointed in doing away with any doubts of that split being an Aces & Eights-style misdirect, and the 'Generational Talent' more than held up his end of things on the microphone as usual, but possibly because of the faux all-babyface vibe, this was the coldest this otherwise-red hot match has thus far felt. After Hangman Page Vs CM Punk and Jon Moxley Vs CM Punk, did we even need another build insistent on blurring the lines?


1. A Double Turn Or A Total Turn-Off?

Britt Baker
AEW

A great promo is a great promo is a great promo, but was there any worse a time for Britt Baker to go up the gears as an AEW banner-waving babyface?

Last week's face-off between the former Women's Champion and returning former WWE star Saraya undermined the emotion felt by the latter when she taunted the former about supposedly stolen opportunities and accusations of minor league achievements. Baker's right to reply this week felt like a necessity for the character, but not once did her tone or cadence veer in a way that gave audiences an excuse to boo her. She even expressed respect for Saraya before pledging to beat her. Britt Baker just cut the best babyface title challenger go-home promo of her life, and she's heading into a contest without a title where she's supposed to be the heel.

Or is she? Saraya's response added nothing new to the story, but confirmed she was chomping at the bit to get back between the ropes. While not overtly heelish, it didn't do anything to dampen the audience's obvious enthusiasm for her opponent. Saturday's bout is the type of All-Star stuff the division's been missing since it launched, but it remains to be seen if gambling on people's in-built affections for both was really the wise route to take in the build.


Ups…

6. Signs Of Things Not To Come

Chris Jericho Sammy Guevara
AEW

Long gone are the days where The Young Bucks or a similarly supreme double act would kick off the first commercial-free fifteen minutes of Dynamite that put fans in high spirits for the rest of the night, but this expert effort between three veterans and a "pillar" attempted to establish all those same vibes even with an ad break.

Designed around showcasing what probably won't happen at Full Gear, Claudio Castagnoli and Sammy Guevara in particular were in scintillating form as Chris Jericho and Bryan Danielson slid into the background of the action as their respective foils. Guevara's amazing flights of fancy and spring-loaded assaults were peppered in magnificently here, serving as yet another reminder of Jericho's inherent genius as a tag layout specialist in his later days.

A lack of cohesion in the Blackpool Combat Club wasn't remotely teased, and the former Cesaro's multi-tooled approach literally de-weaponised the bat-swinging ROH Champion and his JAS pal. Making it look easy on television will be what motivates something from the mastermind on Saturday, because that's how this works. Action of such a high quality on the run-up isn't so much as icing on the cake as a second slice altogether.


5. Don't Call It A Swerve Turn On Saturday...

Swerve Strickland Anthony Bowens
AEW

...because The Acclaimed will have had this one coming.

A pre-match music video from the Tag Team Champions served multiple purposes ahead of Swerve Strickland's choice win over Anthony Bowens. It was a popper in places, and the crowd on this specific Dynamite came up for Captain Insano even if they didn't for much else. It framed the challengers as mentally over a hurdle they are still yet to physically scale. And it was very, very cruel at the expense of Keith Lee - a man that has tried throughout all of this to keep the fights fair and his wayward partner in check.

Hard not to justify him ripping Bowens' head clean off and pouncing Max Caster into Row Z after this.

And he may get the chance if the arm, shoulder and scissoring fingers of Bowens sit along side his bum knee as target practice for Swerve In Our Glory. Strickland confidently and ruthlessly flexed his range, experience and technical expertise over a Bowens booked to feel a little outmatched without The Acclaimed/Daddy Ass unit present as a whole. Saturday's Tag Title Match got even harder to call as a result of this committed booking - almost as if AEW never should have veered from the philosophy in the first place.


4. Explain. Rebuke. Kick Ass.

Powerhouse Hobbs Samoa Joe
AEW

Like the TNT Champion himself, there wasn't an ounce of fat on the segment that set up Wardlow's killer three-way at Full Gear.

Samoa Joe arrived first to explain that his turn was to remind the young star that he should keep his eyes open to threats like him rather that disrespectfully looking right past him as he'd done more than once. Out came a fearless Powerhouse Hobbs to pie any post-WarJoe tension if it got in the way of his aspirations to deck 'The War Dog' until Wardlow himself arrived and the brawl was on.

A locker room clearance to try and keep them apart was more pleasing than the usual security scrubs, particularly as they fed into a nice bit with Wardlow. The Champion battered them with ease before asking The Dark Order if they really wanted any of that. When they politely declined and stepped aside, he hit the ringside throng with one of his awesome dives. This was full-bodied big boy bullsh*t to set up a match that should be more of the same.


3. Elite Trios Performance Foreshadows The Big Return

Rey Fenix PAC Penta

AEW

Death Triangle were in need of a win, some cohesion and frankly a little bit of pride in themselves if The Elite's Full Gear return was to be even a slither more than a forgone conclusion. The booking here ensured that, and gave A.R Fox the type of showcase that might get him another appearance at a minimum and an #AllElite graphic at best.

A match made entirely of empty calorie high spots, said moves were performed so gracefully that they were impossible to resent. This was a welcome return for Top Flight as a duo and Darius Martin in particular too - with Dante's singles aspirations stalled, they made a case for taking a run at the tag belts unless Fox was indeed good enough to keep the three as a trio a little longer. Only solid for this genre, the performers made it memorably so, and more power to them for it.

PAC's post-match promo crucially framed the Champions as fully aware of their fate. They'd seen the tapes, and 'The BASTARD' was in no mood for games. He seemed to frighten the tech team into revealing the match graphic, which could have felt like a damp squib of a real had it not been signposted clearly enough for the wrestlers themselves to acknowledge. The match was always better advertised than kept as a surprise, and the home team are coming back to try and reclaim their belts.


2. Anna Jay A.S Steps In & AEW's Women Step Up

Jamie Hayter Toni Storm
AEW

The Dynamite main event on a technicality, Toni Storm's latest singles win over late replacement Anna Jay A.S (The Bunny was off sick) might be her last as Interim AEW Women's Champion but what a fabulous run it has been.

The booking hasn't improved anywhere near as much as it should have, but the strides taken since she claimed the vacant strap at All Out (and in the run-up to that, in fact) have highlighted that she might have been the babyface Tony Khan needed to help drive change all along.

Near-weekly offerings from Storm have established her as the cornerstone of the league, even if it still occupies the death spot and - evidently - not enough of the AEW boss' attention. That these matches are almost always over-achievements explains why she's a fixture as champion, and her omni-presence has subtly helped the elevation of Jamie Hayter as challenger too.

Jay and Storm worked a snug and tidy match (Jay doesn't get enough credit as a prodigy for how small her Cagematch profile actually is) before an NXT-style stare-down between the Full Gear tied a bow on a good build for Hayter's title shot. Everybody involved - even Britt Baker noticeably hanging back when it mattered - was on good form, even if the road to parity on the show remains a little too long and winding.


1. Are The Clouds Parting?

Sting Darby Allin
AEW

And we end where we began, not strictly with CM Punk, but more with a pay-per-view build so polished and tidy that last night's Dynamite could dedicate short last-minute builds to everything without feeling as though anything was particularly neglected.

Full Gear has to deliver as an event to prove this to be true, but AEW can claim to have weathered its worst storm yet if it does. Across two economical hours, just-enough-but-never-too-much time was given to feuds featuring Jungle Boy and Luchasaurus/Christian Cage, Jade Cargill and Nyla Rose and Sting/Darby Allin and Jeff Jarrett/Jay Lethal. That's everything currently booked for an 11-match supershow attended to, and a bonus Jun Akiyama dream tag match on Rampage that will feed people into the Road To countdown special too.

The pay-per-view cycle Vince McMahon declared dead at the start of the 2010s is one WWE still books around, but AEW has disproved the former and mastered the latter. Regardless of subjective views on what worked on the night, this was as go-home as a go-home show gets, leaving nobody in any doubt of the biggest destination for the company right now. If this episode didn't guide you cautiously into the waiting arms of Full Gear, nothing will.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.