6 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (19 Apr - Review)
Double Or Nothing main event thrown into disarray and Britt Baker gets destroyed in Pittsburgh.

What to make of All Elite Wrestling just over a month out from Double Or Nothing 2023?
The top two programmes are objectively in reasonable health, regardless of where your subjective tastes in pro wrestling lie. The Elite and The Blackpool Combat Club are now on opposite sides of a blood-soaked divide, with Hangman Page and Kenny Omega yet to make amends as babyfaces, while the heels are as united and violent as they’ve ever been. The potential match quality of all the potential singles and tags are so high that it’s giving long-standing fans rosy reminders of the company’s stable-heavy early days, not least with the melodrama and tension hanging thick in the air between the heroes.
Speaking of heroes, Darby Allin and Jack Perry had been welcoming the opportunity to be big ones opposing MJF. Sammy Guevara is more about the belt than himself, but all Four Pillars want to be champion and are willing to fight for it. This is fundamentally enough, even if a little bit of spice between the champion and his contenders wouldn’t go amiss.
Pittsburgh promised to be another big night for both of these stories, but what else stood to get the locals spinning those Terrible Towels?
Let’s light the fuse…
Downs…
3. Crumbling Pillars
It’s both a compliment to the regular quality of AEW Dynamite and criticism of a rank Four Pillars promo train that this overlong mini-tournament announcement instantly became one of the worst opening segments in the show’s history.
If one can put aside the reliance on interruptions, race-to-the-bottom negging remarks and the impromptu main event established in contrived circumstances, the content and performance was unforgivably lame until MJF showed up to try and salvage it.Sammy Guevara, Darby Allin and Jack Perry came across as petty and unlikable tossers, which is less than ideal considering the babyface status of the latter two and the ‘Devil’ they wish to oppose.
This was shockingly poor in a very literal sense - everybody involved from the creative forces behind it to the performers themselves have proven themselves above this sort of thing countless times. How it conspired to reduce the status of every challenger made the segment a failure on an almost remarkable scale.
2. The Acclaimed & Billy Gunn Vs The Jericho Appreciation Society
The Acclaimed potentially joining The Jericho Appreciation Society was never much more than filler fluff on the undercard, but as this listless payoff match against 2.0 and Jake Hager dragged on, it became all too apparent that one of the company’s hottest act was winning stupid prizes for playing stupid games.
This felt every bit like the typical obvious winner/obvious loser match, but was the payoff to a storyline that has eaten up weeks of television time and yet more of Max Caster and Anthony Bowens’ momentum. They felt no further forward whatsoever for this victory, and Billy Gunn felt the stalest yet alongside the pair too. It had to end, and it had to end this way, but the inconsequential nature of the entire thing being so brutally laid bare was dispiriting.
The tag division is a long, long way from stacked, but without the belts for now, are Bowens and Caster stuck with this low stakes fare for good?
1. Sammy Guevara Vs Jungle Boy Jack Perry

There was no shortage of exciting spots in the impromptu main event between Sammy Guevara and Jungle Boy, but should this really be the main takeaway from these two at this point?
This had the air of an early-AEW classic. You know the sort because both these men featured in them. The halcyon 2019/2020 days where relatively unknown talents were suddenly tearing it up on television and highlighting the amazing depth and potential for evolution.
To be four years forward and still working with that air rather than feeling like completed projects is problematic, particularly when both are being positioned for a title shot.
Or are they?
Guevara defeated Perry by count-out thanks to help from an MJF shamelessly trying to gimmick the Pillars Tournament in order to get the contest he wants, even though we can all see that neither heel is to be trusted. This hampered the idea here too - with no honour among thieves and no satisfying finish either, will the whole thing be scrapped to re-set up the four-way that looked likely all along?
Ups…
6. The Elite & The BCC Cause Anarchy
The Elite were all business in their “We’ll hear from…” spot, with Kenny Omega asking for little more than the Blackpool Combat Club’s presence in order to restart hostilities that have raged over the last month.
Bryan Danielson’s distraction from the big screen gave The BCC the advantage but when a babyface fightback brought the ‘American Dragon’ out to tip the scales, a major plot development came with him.
Don Callis thought better of getting involved physically, but waved out his new protege Konosuke Takeshita to even the sides, kick ass and save the day. He did just that, positioning himself as a potential fourth man should Hangman Page not make it back or Omega simply not sanction that specific reunion for the eventual showdown.
He didn’t seem hugely keen on THIS one - there was more than a little side-eye from Omega even as The Elite toasted their small slice of retribution.
5. Powerhouse Hobbs Vs Wardlow
In an unexpected but extremely welcome development, Wardlow revealed in a pre-match promo that he’d turned to Arn Anderson for guidance and support going into what felt like his last chance to reclaim the TNT Championship.It had a magic wand effect.
Wardlow looked equal parts smart, humble and confident with ‘Double A’ by his side, and when the legendary Horseman joined Penta El Zero M in taking out QT Marshall at the climax of his brawl with Powerhouse Hobbs, fans were rabid for a powerbomb symphony that put the secondary strap on ‘The War Dog’ for the third time.
There didn’t appear to be a fully functional finish on paper, but this went down well on the night. The post-mortem on Hobbs’ maiden reign won’t make for great reading, but he’ll recover form this loss and it peaked at its conclusion at the very least.
4. Jay White Vs Kommander
AEW set out to achieve a lot - arguably too much - with Jay White’s formal debut for the organisation, but the match was a strong showing for ‘Switchblade’ and teased the possibility of something quite special down the road for the former IWGP Champion and the floundering Ricky Starks.
White’s experience saw him score the win, with Kommander’s hesitation and posturing undermining the stunning aerial artistry elsewhere in the bout. Alongside that, Shawn Spears was ranking the moves to play off his old gimmick and fold himself into Bullet Club Gold’s path for a post match that drew out Starks and drew battle lines for the inevitable tag.
All a little formulaic after the fact, but white was in devilishly great form bell-to-bell. What could have been fluff felt bigger in his hands, and for the first time since he made his big North American decision, ‘The Catalyst’ felt worthy of all the speculation that predicated it.
3. Battle For Mark Briscoe

Friday’s edition of AEW Rampage peaked with the formal introduction of an idea that could have been too dark for its own good had the key players not pitched their performances so spectacularly. Days later on Dynamite and it became clear why.Triple J’s manipulation of Mark Briscoe is the sort of inspired wrestling silliness that works because of dramatic irony. Using and abusing Jay Lethal’s bond with Briscoe, the group have glommed on to him in a tactical attempt to monetise his talent and potential vulnerability. We as fans know deep down that Briscoe will outsmart these clowns, but the former ROH Tag Team Champion being centre to a tug of love as a result has cast doubt upon that and potentially set up a tremendous Double Or Nothing tag team affair in the process.
When FTR were alerted to Briscoe being attacked by The Varsity Athletes backstage, they raced to the medical office only to find Jarrett et al already there. Briscoe forced a truce between the warring sides, but - and take a seat if you need to - they can’t really co-exist.
Fun for now with rich emotions and high stakes lurking dangerously in the background, this was truly inspired.
2. Adam Cole & Chris Jericho Turn Up The Heat
Spying the opportunity to make the most of the location while simultaneously heating up two pay-per-view stories, the face-to-face between Chris Jericho and Adam Cole was a tremendous slice of TV angle advancement even if your mileage may vary on the acting by the end.
Cole showed just the right amount of reverence towards Jericho to kick it off, almost as if knowing his work so well came with a consequence of knowing the JAS leader might be a total jerk in response. And when he was, Cole wasn’t shaken - he was ready to do away with the pleasantries and get to hostilities, but after Daniel Garcia running down to help his boss drew Britt Baker into the fray, the fix was in.
Appearing from under the ring (and in lockstep with Jericho from the off), The Outcast re-emerged and beat down ‘D.M.D’ with a kendo stick as Cole was chained to the ropes and forced to watch. Cole and Baker were a touch schlocky selling it all, but not to the extent that the heat was ruined in the slightest. A raging Pittsburgh crowd rained rage upon the heels, and a Double Or Nothing singles match that already had intrigue is now loaded with emotional heft too.
1. Jamie Hayter & Britt Baker Vs The Outcasts
For a change, the women’s division was given a plum spot on Dynamite, and were even better-placed to lift the crowd’s spirits thanks to local hero Britt Baker leaning into her hometown support.Toni Storm, Ruby Soho and Jamie Hayter typically work hard-hitting matches in an effort to elevate over-familiar and under-cooked booking, but the Outcasts/Homegrown feud felt anything but that with a crowd sizzling for ‘D.M.D’ and some actual action as a contrast to the show-opening gabfest.
The heels got what they deserved from the cauldron of heat after some quality cheating and triple-teaming too - an awesome nearfall on Baker only earned them two before the former Women’s Champion made her own save and tapped out Soho with the Lockjaw.
The Terrible Towels were spun proudly, but Baker wasn’t in celebratory mood. Hayter was launched into the steel stairs before the finish, and required medical attention immediately after the bell. Baker earnestly followed up on that rather than basking in the glory, ostensibly highlighting a fiercely tight bond between the babyfaces ahead of a bigger payoff down the line.