6 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (7 June - Review)
Orange Cassidy is the highlight of Dynamite yet again. Perhaps he should be loaned to Collision...
Last year's Forbidden Door build was struck by piss-poor luck, but the actual plans weren't great - or at least didn't make the show feel like a unique collaboration between All Elite Wrestling and New Japan Pro Wrestling.
Before the match was abandoned through injury, Bryan Danielson revealed that Zack Sabre, Jr had accepted the offer of a bounty made by Chris Jericho. The idea was to use the ultimate technical dream match as a means of building the Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Blackpool Combat Club Blood & Guts match with a trademark AEW device. Firstly, that was unnecessary; the match should have sold itself.
The person whom the Best Technical Wrestler Award was named after versus the man who nearly equalled him in his own category?
That in itself is a great story, but the pitched build was lopsided in the favour of an ongoing AEW storyline. The same issue affected the build for Jon Moxley Vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi.
"Story", "storyline".
You'll read and resent those two words a lot over the next couple of weeks, but if there's ever a time to book the most simple story there is - who is the superior pro wrestler? - it's at a time when some of the best wrestlers of all time, intersecting their physical and psychological prime, are set to do battle.
Did AEW muddy this simple, glorious premise on the first step towards the PPV...?
They didn't do too much with the build at all; the show felt like business as usual, for better and worse...
Downs...
3. The Collision Main Event Announcement
Measured against the curve that is the First Dance, the Second Coming is nowhere near as fascinating or exciting.
Tony Khan announced that CM Punk and FTR will take on Jay White, Juice Robinson and Samoa Joe in the main event of the inaugural Collision. On the night, the match could be awesome. Punk/Joe nostalgia will be fun, and they'll doubtlessly do a great job of milking the "Holy sh*t!" chant before they even touch. A Punk/White interaction feels like an unfathomable dream pairing in spite of Jay's stuttering launch in AEW.
It isn't tremendously exciting. It isn't absolutely must-see. It doesn't feel like it was worth waiting 10 months for, nor does it feel like a grand apologetic gesture for the cloud that has lingered over the promotion since Brawl Out.
Punk and Joe will make you want to see the inevitable singles match. There's still time for Joe to cut a promo and heat it up.
But right now, it manifests everything that was feared ahead of the show: it's Punk teaming with his mates against a handful of people willing to wrestle him.
Collision is a bittersweet compromise of a show, and this match proves it: it simply isn't as electrifying or as believable as the prospect of Punk working any of the countless people he doesn't get along with. Who's to blame for the fact that this isn't happening?
That is still up for debate, and the prospect of that debate raging on is tedious.
2. Poorly-Judged Backstage Segment
In the back deep in the show, it was revealed that Christian Cage and Luchasaurus had attacked Brock Anderson in retaliation for Arn Anderson equalising the odds at Double Or Nothing. This was a funny, twisted heel motive - Luchasaurus had attempted to cheat first - but the execution of the angle was poor.
It didn't help that Preston Vance had only just stopped pissing blood out of his temple, but when the camera cut to Brock lying in agony, it looked like he'd gigged himself with a ketchup packet. Nobody should blade for an unseen backstage attack, but this looked so fake. Suspension of disbelief was impossible.
Couldn't they have wrapped a chair around his neck to make it look like Christian had laid him out with a Con-chair-to?
1. Abrupt Main Event Under-Delivers
The main event was good, not great. Good isn't good enough.
AEW has failed to optimise the impact of Jay White, and this chapter of a sludgy, non-committal storyline did not help. Is Jay White considered a star or not? How much should we care about and expect from him? This confusion hung over the atmosphere of a lukewarm main event. White, who has a disgusting amount of potential, isn't a game-changer in the narrative. Tony Khan understands his potential, but doesn't want to beat Ricky Starks cleanly. The stakes felt low, the atmosphere almost cynical, as a result. The work while not enormously effective was very good. In patches.
Ricky Stark emotes like few others. White is great, Christian Cage-like, at setting traps and playing bastard's tricks. This should have created an absorbing dynamic, of the impulsive babyface trying to overcome the composed heel, but it just hasn't clicked. Is it a chemistry issue? Did the fans suspect the carny finish? The Gunns joined Bullet Club in a telegraphed angle - not everybody was banned from ringside - following the sort of ref bump spot that feels ancient. Is this good/effective because they're brats who have undermined the sanctity of the sport?
No.
The original Bullet Club worked in the context of early 2010s New Japan because interference was an actual transgression. The fans were legitimately disgusted. In AEW in 2023, it's the norm, and it's impossible for most heels to get heat for it. Jay White feels like a cliché, and it's all a bit bleak. He is far too good.
Needs a major rethink, all of this.
Ups...
6. Orange Cassidy Doesn't Miss AGAIN In Electrifying Opener
Orange Cassidy at this point wrestles classic matches as easily as he puts his hands in his pockets. He is the greatest Television champion ever, but he's something more than that, too.
The hit rate, the effective long-term story of his accumulated injuries, the fact that in every match he engineers at least one incredible near-fall: he is the best babyface champion in wrestling by a country f*cking mile, and the best since Jon Moxley in 2020. His match against Swerve Strickland was superb, the second half particularly, and it was elevated by the hand injury that Cassidy has sold for months. Great wrestling, great anything, is all about build.
And because Cassidy has effectively told the audience that his hand is f*cked, he can use that foundation to get his sh*t in. Swerve took some awesome, gnarly bumps near the finish of a maelstrom of a chess match. He kicked out in the sort of near-falls that might have stretched suspension of disbelief even in the modern context - had Cassidy not built the logic and credibility of the hand injury.
OC couldn't hook the leg nor apply all of his weight to the lateral press. This allowed Swerve to justifiably kick out of several gruesome-looking kill-shots. The result was a special-feeling, exhilarating white-hot opener that didn't take the piss. The Orange Punch/Beach Break combo was as great as false finishes get, and the finish was unreal. It protected Swerve without relying on a carny device - turnabout was fair play when Orange grabbed the tights after Swerve tried it first - and it was easy to forget, lost in the story, that Orange still has one good hand.
OC won, again, but this isn't a case of OCWinsLOL. The man is simply too great at playing babyface. Who will eventually dethrone him?
Whoever it is will feel closer to a World champion than a TV champion: the idea to stealthily elevate the International title as a Trojan horse for the Collision main event scene feels like one of Tony Khan's most inspired ideas ever.
5. Yet Another ACE Trios Match
Trios matches are just the best. AEW didn't pioneer the genre, but the decision to promote it as a key selling point of the promotion was ingenious. These matches rule almost every single time. Somehow, you never see the save coming. The formula is a conveyor belt of false finish drama.
CHAOS jumped the Blackpool Combat Club early. This was a great choice: it instantly ushered in the excitement and put over the BCC as an unbeatable gang of hard f*ckers. While the babyfaces shouldn't do this sort of thing in general, there's no hard and fast rule, and this worked in context - particularly since the BCC Vs. Best Friends subplot has never been abandoned. It's a neat bit of AEW continuity. The Best Friends still to this day feel insulted that Wheeler YUTA abandoned them for the BCC and wrestled, again, with a determination to prove them wrong.
This wasn't a standout Trios match - it was a blizzard of action without quite being a PPV quality TV affair - but one spot in particular was. Claudio Castagnoli countering a Trent moonsault with an uppercut was awesome enough for Bryan Danielson to howl with sadistic glee on commentary.
Next week, the BCC take on the Hung Bucks. That should be a PPV quality TV match, but the genre is so great that it can't be less than very good.
4. MJF Vs. Adam Cole Heats Up Instantly
Exposition is the signature move in a pro wrestling promo. It is stuck in a form that has always played to the back row, but MJF did exposition very, very well last night.
Aware that he had just one week to build a shocker of an Eliminator match on Dynamite next Wednesday, he told the Adam Cole story through his fandom of it. MJF was an Adam Cole "mark" glued once upon a time to ROH on HDNet. In a deft speech, he put over Cole in a personal, meaningful way - he didn't just read out his opponent's Wikipedia page - and buried him for not living up to the grand expectations set from his time in ROH and NXT. A well thought-out spiel built to a great subversion of a line, in which MJF hit Cole with the Karrion Kross. Cole's response bordered on the underwhelming until he conjured the amusing image of himself and MJF pissing in cups at the same time to see whose is hot.
This worked; luring MJF into a fury, their first match is set for next week. This was long, but very effective. The building loved it. The verbal sparring was world class.
The choice to have MJF cut off Cole's "Boom!" entrance appeal was ingenious, too. MJF had drawn positive reactions as the most entertaining Pillar during Double Or Nothing: this was an inspired means of conducting the heat where it belonged.
3. Texas Tornado Match Eventually Whips Up A Storm
The Texas Tornado match was trundling along, assembling the furniture for the set pieces, before the magic of pro wrestling struck.
There was a distinct lack of chaos and energy early, which wasn't helped when HOOK and Preston Vance walked up a bleacher and brawled by a balcony. This is AEW; it wasn't unreasonable to expect a deranged stunt. They simply walked back down after creating that expectation (fairly or otherwise). Then, HOOK grabbed a chain and walloped Vance in the brow with it. One hardway cut or over-enthusiastic blade job later, and the man was gushing plasma.
Instantly, the match took on a more dangerous, hateful tenor, and whether by accident or design, Vance smelled his own blood, got hot, and threw HOOK into the barricade several times with a force that suggests he wasn't working. He was. He just did it very well, making it feel like an improvised, expressive flurry of proper wrestling energy. His violent spree put HOOK over all the more when he popped his hips and smashed Vance though a table from the apron.
Jack Perry was a passenger in the background, missing out on the glory - but if he is to turn on HOOK, that's actually a neat bit of storytelling.
2. The Don Callis Effect
While not as loud as last week, the Don Callis and Konosuke Takeshita segment was fine.
That it even happened was a step in the right direction. AEW has a rotating cast policy. Konosuke Takeshita himself was cycled in and out of storylines for a year or so as his very slow-burn story was told. His second consecutive Dynamite appearance wasn't necessarily about the content: it was an overt message that the time to truly invest in the character is now. This in effect was a ceremonial event: Takeshita is no longer a recurring character. He's in the credits.
He defeated some Damon Ace in a squash, and not that it matters - Takeshita is already one of the best wrestlers in the world - it wasn't great. His opponent was taller than he is and the match didn't feel like a massacre. The segment was worth watching for Don Callis conducting it like an old master. He sensed that it wasn't going to be as loud as last week's cauldron.
Self-assured, he took his sweet time, and used his tricks to dial up the volume before he began his promo.
1. TBS Title Match Is Fine
Kris Statlander Vs. Anna Jay AS was fine. Respectable. There is very little else to say about it.
The story of the match was deeply basic: Anna's stablemate Daddy Magic distracted Statlander throughout, handing Jay the advantage, before Stat's intelligence, power and superiority won the day. It was boilerplate U.S. television wrestling. Without being tremendously exciting in and of itself, though, it was a promising glimpse into the long-term reign. Jay is very good, given her level of experience, but sometimes gets lost. This didn't happen here; this was a lean, focused match that while not heated coasted on the enthusiasm fans hold for Statlander. Statlander looked sharp, much of her power-based arsenal popped the crowd, and she marshalled a less experienced wrestler into an effective TV match. Nobody should do cartwheels over "solid" TV wrestling. The standard is too high.
If nothing else, this proved that, when given something of real substance, Statlander can be reasonably expected to deliver big.