6 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE Payback 2023 (Results & Review)
Trish/Becky end feud on high note, Nakamura earns main event, tag match goes pure chaos.
Payback probably was the definition of a WWE B-show, a PLE with no Roman Reigns, no Cody Rhodes match, no Bloodline drama, no Brock Lesnar, no Charlotte Flair and no celebrities.
But that didn’t stop WWE from delivering a pretty good show Saturday night, anchored by a better-than-advertised steel cage match, a chaotic tag title battle, and a solid world title main event. Throw in John Cena and a legit surprise appearance/announcement and you have the makings of an enjoyable evening.
Trish Stratus and Becky Lynch deserve probably the most credit on the night, as their feud could be deemed a dismal failure heading into the PLE. They were bumped from SummerSlam and forced to carry on a good month past the point anyone wanted to see this rivalry, which was sputtering by mid-summer already. They turned around and produced a cage match filled with anger, using the cage repeatedly as a weapon and battering each other until they were visibly beaten down.
Probably the biggest strike against this show was the fact it was only six matches deep, which meant a few of them went longer than they should have, missing their peaks by several minutes. This has been a common problem with Triple H at the helm, and it’s something that could be addressed pretty constructively.
Otherwise, a low-expectations show produced, making for a positive experience.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
3. A Mild Disappointment
Watching the WWE Women’s World Championship match, it was clear what angle they were playing: Rhea Ripley and Raquel Rodriguez were very evenly matched.
But after the 63rd example of the two of them establishing parity, it got to become near-parody. How many times can you have two people no-sell clotheslines, shoulder tackles and strikes to get across the point that they’re evenly matched? WWE might as well have just had them carry signs that read, “We’re both equally strong.”
And as we saw with the LA Knight/Miz match, this one had some extra time tacked on that pushed it past its sweet spot. Rodriguez looked lost for a moment, which Corey Graves covered by saying she had never been this deep into a match before. A good point, but also an indication it had gone on for too long.
Both women are powerhouses and have bright futures, and it’s clear they have chemistry in the ring. Perhaps a different tactic of showing they’re evenly matched and trimming about five minutes off the bout would have helped.
2. ‘Taking The Crowd Out Of The Match’
That’s the kind of statement that you really don’t want to hear during a featured PLE match, and it’s doubly troubling when it’s one of WWE’s announcers admitting it.
LA Knight has been getting some of the loudest reactions from fans at WWE events for the past few months, and Saturday’s match against the Miz was no different, with the crowd rallying behind him throughout the contest.
But as with many matches in the Triple H era (and on a three-hour PLE with only six matches), the runtime was clearly padded out by several minutes, resulting in this bout missing its peak. The crowd grew silent during one of Miz’s several “heat” segments, which is not exactly what you’re shooting for when you’re supposed to be building support for the babyface.
Fans came back to life when Knight made his comeback and erupted for his win, but WWE’s penchant for making every match last 10+ minutes could have crippled this contest. All that was really needed here was a brief period of Miz in control, a false finish and then LA stomping Miz and putting him away. It’s not like this was some epic feud that required multiple back-and-forth segments.
Right result, good overall reaction, but man it got dull in some parts, and that’s not what you’re going for in this situation.
1. In Need Of A Reboot
There are wrestlers you see on your TV screen who just scream, “Go away for a few months and come back with a fresh start.” Austin Theory has to be one of those superstars.
Theory has been a fixture on WWE programming for a couple years now, but he has yet to really connect. Sure, his in-ring work is technically fine, and he had a decent United States Championship match with Rey Mysterio Saturday night, but he elicited almost no reaction despite battling one of the most popular superstars in WWE history.
This is a guy who beat John Cena at WrestleMania just five months ago and has gained literally nothing from it other than a useless talking point he repeats ad nauseum with no impact.
On a six-match card for Payback, the US title match was easily the most forgettable of the bunch, with Theory being only a couple upgrades above a Create-A-Wrestler character. He desperately needs to take some time away, find himself and come back.
UPS…
6. Stark Gets A Bit Of Shine
If this is the end of Trish Stratus’ mini-run with WWE, you’ve got to give her credit for going all-out in her steel cage match against Becky Lynch.
But it didn’t stop there with the WWE Hall-of-Famer.
After losing to The Man, Stratus got testy with her protégé Zoey Stark, who unsuccessfully tried to aide her during the match. Trish shoved her away and then slapped her, which turned out to be a big mistake. Stark slammed the cage door shut, got in Stratus’ face, and delivered a Z-360 to put Trish down. Zoey removed her “Thank you Trish” T-shirt and walked out, getting a measure of revenge on a mentor who only used her.
While this was a great little scene to give Stark a clean break from Trish, it would be fantastic if Stratus hung around for one more match to put the NXT callup over on her way out the door. If not, at least they didn’t leave Zoey standing around in that T-shirt after Status had left.
5. Cena Endorses Knight
LA Knight has been in this strange zone of being insanely over with fans but not getting a signature win or the true recognition from the company that they see something in him.
His feud with Miz has overall been a move in the right direction, letting him cut loose on the mic and spar with someone regarded as a WWE staple. Picking up the win itself at Payback was another positive (match quality being a separate issue).
But afterward, Knight picked up an endorsement that could also carry some serious weight: a handshake from John Cena.
Cena served as the special guest referee during the match and raised his hand in victory. Later, on the ramp, Big Match John offered up a handshake as a show of respect, which was a nice display of support from one of the biggest stars in company history.
Given that Cena is hanging around for a bit on SmackDown, there’s always a chance their paths will cross again, maybe even in the ring together. Getting that endorsement isn’t necessarily a golden ticket, but it doesn’t mean nothing either.
4. Subverting Expectations For A Legit Surprise
Cody Rhodes appearing on the Grayson Waller Effect did not scan as setting the table for a major announcement involving another superstar.
But that’s exactly what unfolded during Payback, when the American Nightmare quickly turned his guest spot on the Aussie’s talk show into an opportunity to declare that he saw a wrong that needed to be righted from SmackDown and unveiled the newest member of the Raw roster, Jey Uso.
While Main Event Jey had only been gone for a few weeks after quitting, it’s a legit surprise to see him pulled completely away from the blue brand and all the Bloodline drama. He’s the first member of the faction to really make a break like this, and it should give him the chance to stand on his own two feet. It means fresh matchups for Uso and a fresh start as well.
Rhodes cashing in his favors to bring Jey to Raw is an intriguing thread if WWE want to pick it up, particularly as WrestleMania season draws near and they presumably start trying to bring Cody and Roman Reigns back together and possibly pit Jey against twin brother Jimmy Uso.
For now though, this was a pleasant surprise that could provide some interesting outcomes.
3. Looking Like A Real Threat
For a good chunk of the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, Shinsuke Nakamura looked like he was going to walk out of Pittsburgh with the title.
That’s how good of a job the build did to convince that Seth Rollins could lose his title Saturday due to his injured back. Nakamura targeted it repeatedly throughout the bout, looking more motivated than he had in a long time. (Main-eventing your first WWE PLE will do that to you.)
Rollins played the champ-in-peril well, relying on grit, guile and fighting spirit to overcome Shinsuke, finally taking advantage of his opponent’s positioning to deliver an opportunistic stomp for the win.
But give a lot of credit to the story they told in the lead-up to Payback, and to Nakamura, who finally looked like the world title-caliber wrestler everyone said he was when he signed with WWE all those years ago.
They probably could have belted him Saturday and it might have actually worked. The question now is whether Shinsuke will get another shot at the title or if this was a one-and-done.
2. Exceeding All Expectations
The feud between Trish Stratus and Becky Lynch went well beyond its sell-by date, dragging on to diminishing returns and limping into Payback for its long-overdue final chapter, nearly five months after the rivalry began.
But if the wrestlers knew that the angle was a colossal disappointment on Raw and fans had lost interest, Lynch and Stratus seemed to use that for fuel Saturday night in their steel cage match, Trish’s first time being locked inside the structure.
Both women used the cage as a weapon, battering each other into the cage repeatedly and even working in a cheese-grater spot. Both used moves that were callbacks to past opponents and allies, with Trish hitting a Widow’s Peak and Becky utilizing a Twist of Fate. They fought up top and drove each other off the top with signature moves.
Stratus looked worse for wear, sporting a huge welt on the middle of her forehead, but she and Lynch both had a physical war. It would’ve been nice if this feud was about two months shorter, but at least it closed on a really strong note.
1. A Glorious Car Crash
What can you say about the Undisputed Tag Team Championship match between Judgment Day and Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn?
As a match, it’s not going to be regarded as a five-star technical classic. But as a pure chaotic, frenzied brawl, this was a fantastic piece of business. The defending tag champs have been portrayed as dominant and able to overcome almost every bit of adversity, so naturally, it took Finn Balor, Damian Priest, Dominik Mysterio, JD McDonagh and Rhea Ripley to finally topple Zayn & Owens.
Along the way, tables got broken, chairs swung, trash cans dented and bodies flying everywhere. It was an orgy of activity. KO and Sami almost overcame the numbers Saturday, with Owens putting Dominik through a table with a senton from the crowd at one point. But it was Mysterio who proved the difference-maker, dropping Sami with the Money in the Bank briefcase.
The end of the Canadians’ five-month title reign was disappointing from a fan’s perspective, but Judgment Day is on top of its game and kind of needed some validation. There’s no shame in losing what essentially was a 5-on-2 handicap match.