6 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (May 29 - Results & Review)
All the fallout from Double Or Nothing, and Forbidden Door build begins with a MAJOR main event
Double Or Nothing was the usual pay-per-view for All Elite Wrestling in that seemingly just as many thought it was the best show of the year as found it drab to the point of lethargy.
The debate occurs with increasingly regularity now because the pay-per-views themselves do, which is really part of the wider problem beyond if you found the event too long or not. Ultimately the best chance AEW stood of actually ever being Elite was in the original version of the model - a two-hour television show broken up by the company's tentpole events that were a privilege and reward to appear on. Regardless of if you enjoy AEW in 2024, the opposite is now true.
Across multiple hours of first-run weekly television and a pay-per-view nearly every month, the company literally cannot do the above. Either television in-ring quality dips in order to preserve the big matches on the cards you pay for, or those monthly supershows aren't worth the money because Dynamite remains home to the most thrilling wrestling around. Growing pains perhaps, but more growth is incoming.
And as for this month? Time to reset the cycle for Forbidden Door and light the fuse...
Downs...
4. Trent Joins The Don Callis Family
Predictability in wrestling is often a good thing, but there's not a lot worse than the obvious twist when it comes at the expense of a cool babyface.
AEW had attempted - with partial success perhaps - to lead viewers away from thinking that Callis had in fact been setting up an alliance with Trent Beretta all along after he lost to Orange Cassidy yet again at Double Or Nothing. Trent said he was leaving, Callis looked elated at a result gone his way, and though it was still clear Cassidy wasn't going to sign on the dotted line, new questions were raised about just who it would be.
Instead, the payoff reverted the obvious twist, and was all the weaker for it. Cassidy should have clocked this possible threat weeks ago as everybody else did, and in kayfabe, why exactly would 'The Invisible Hand' spend weeks of his life on a flimsy misdirect just to bring a multi-time loser and choke artist into his ranks?
Folding in Kris Statlander for the reveal was at least economic use of television time, but more on her good night elsewhere.
3. Jon Moxley Vs Rocky Romero
In a pre-match promo presumably designed to add a bit of fire to another heatless Dynamite 50/50 filler match, Jon Moxley reeled off his schedule as a way to put himself over as the hardest guy in the world as if that was brand new information. He noted with disdain that he wasn't "pissing away at Disneyworld", but honestly a segment featuring Mox in mouse ears chowing down on a turkey leg at the Magic Kingdom would have been more interesting than the periods he had to sell peril opposite Rocky Romero.
This cannot stop and it realistically never will because on the weeks where a random and ostensibly uninteresting television match delivers a banger and/or a new sensation, AEW is rightfully lauded for platforming it. When it doesn't, the malaise brought about by Just Good Wrestling in an era where greatness is the new normal becomes a grind.
Speaking of a grind, Jon Moxley won again. He had to here of course, but then - as with Double Or Nothing - matches often exist where he has to. Was this one particularly necessary anyway? The IWGP Champion does "show up", as he puts it, but his personal pride isn't quite the evocative draw it was in 2020. The Romero singles "run" continues to confuse.
2. The Elite & The TNT Title
It'd be grossly unfair to not put over the killer lines in this before assessing the major issues at play in the latest chapter of The Elite's hostile takeover of AEW. Matt Jackson explaining that he'd told Adam Copeland to "break a leg" and Kazuchika Okada instructing the crowd to "shut up, bitches" was laugh out loud stuff from men that often measure humour in wrestling well.
Elsewhere, this was a brutally deflating comedown from Anarchy In The Arena.
The group intended to crown Perry as Champion, and probably just should have. Instead, the segment went on to reveal Christopher Daniels as the Assistant To The Regional Manager to Tony Khan. The "Interim Executive Vice President" explained that he was making calls on behalf of the president, even though Tony Schiavone relayed a Khan edict elsewhere on the show and the man himself was there in person for Double Or Nothing. Then, before The Elite could outnumber and destroy 'The Fallen Angel" once again, The Acclaimed and Daddy Ass arrived to make the save.
The last thing a (still mostly unwelcome) corporate power struggle needed was more tiers in the hierarchy, and bang average filler combinations before the inevitable Blood & Guts pay off with bigger stars wasn't the most captivating Forbidden Door teaser.
1. TV Time With Chris Jericho
Because people get angry when he takes up TV Time you see.
Lampshading is still lampshading. Intentionally bad is still bad. "Meta" "troll" Chris Jericho is still Chris Jericho. This entire run remains for an audience of one and that one isn't even Tony Khan. Usual cadence and delivery from Jericho, a set with a tree in it, Bryan Keith officially enters the vortex, you've seen it all before even if you haven't seen it.
He wasted your precious time having to watch it so this article won't take up anymore talking about it.
Ups...
6. Swerve Strickland Vs Killswitch
A cute fusion of corporate synergy and tying up a last remaining storyline loose end, the AEW World Champion's latest television match was better-than-solid stuff, even if it was designed to pass without conversation following the reveal of his impending Forbidden Door challenger.
Swerve gave the former Luchasaurus a frankly incredible near fall, when The Patriarchy's monster kicked out of a House Call and Swerve Stomp. A second go-around of the latter finished the job, and then Strickland finished his feud with the whole group by chopping off a braid of Killswitch's hair in a last act of revenge.
Unspectacular at points, this was another foundation laid for Swerve as the company's top dog. He'll only become even more captivating as he moves into his next major programme too.
5. Kris Statlander Has A Great Night
Though Double Or Nothing didn't afford anywhere near the time for Kris Statlander's heel turn on Willow Nightingale to resonate, Dynamite was an extremely welcome opposite.
Alongside Stokely Hathaway (but in a promo very much not carried by him), Statlander's villain origin story came to the fore, and as it had been teased effectively on television too, none of it felt like forced mining of old dates for continuity.
The pair referred to the Dynamite four-way won by Willow to get her the TBS Championship match in the first place, suggesting that she was a bad friend to Stat for not stepping aside. Statlander specifically spewed her resentment for being taken advantage of by too many people in the past, saying that she was "done being the protector".
All of this followed Statlander's part in the attack on Orange Cassidy, severing what remained of her link with that side of the divide. Focus on a character in more than one segment is the low bar set for North American television, but still an important one to clear nonetheless.
It wasn't the only case on this show either...
4. Mercedes Moné Has A Great Night
TWO women positioned as stars on the same show? Well no, actually, more than that, thanks in-part to the increased presence of the new TBS Champion and 'CEO' Mercedes Moné.
Moné opened Dynamite with her advertised Championship celebration, but the party was halted by a Skye Blue who revealed that she had been responsible for the lights out attack weeks earlier. That felt as rushed as the match between the two booked for the later in the show, but better a mystery get a payoff rather than simply being dropped completely. This was a problem-solving exercise too - a match between Mariah May and Saraya was postponed until next week, leaving Moné and Blue to step in and fill the hole.
Before that, a video package for NJPW Strong Women's Champion Stephanie Vaquer aired ahead of her working against somebody at Forbidden Door. That somebody turned out to be Moné, with the two facing off in person following the Champion's victory over Blue.
Vaquer appearing live after the video was a nice touch, as was the package itself if only to stave off the bad faith goons that surface in number around this specific pay-per-view.
3. Forbidden Door Casino Gauntlet
Perhaps AEW just really have something with Will Ospreay, but it genuinely feels as though AEW really have something with the Casino Gauntlet gimmick.
The International Champion has won two in two months now and kicked *ss in both, and while this can't just become the next thing the company books too many of, the format and consequences felt exhilarating once again.
Just about everybody that entered got to shine before Ospreay wrapped it up following a breathless exchange with Orange Cassidy, and though there's a bizarre lack of explanation about exactly who gets to work these things and doesn't dating back to Hangman Page randomly wrestling Silas Young in a singles match instead of entering a Dynamite one in 2022, the sheer quality of the contest powers through the plotholes.
Forbidden Door being the winner's destination massively sold the stakes too - the reemergence of Mistico, Hechicero, Lio Rush, Shota Umino and others was a reminder of just how wide the net had been cast for the show at this point.
2. MJF
From day one!Here's a look at the journey of MJF in #AEW!
Watch #AEWDynamite LIVE on TBS!@The_MJF pic.twitter.com/ue44AKSRe3
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) May 30, 2024
It was a shame for the live crowd that the Double Or Nothing follow-up of MJF's return was "just" a video package, but watching at home, AEW really did the work here.
Recounting the former World Champion's career thus far as an epic saga peaking with his enthusiastic pay-per-view returned, this continued to seemingly quash any further afters with the Undisputed Kingdom in an effort to reestablish the significance and importance of the 'Salt Of The Earth'.
A voiceover recapping the various records and achievements he'd garnered over his five years with the organisation made it clear that a tippy top guy was back in the fold, even if the company reverted to type by randomly rolling the recently-returned RUSH out there to take the job as his designated first win back. Otherwise, this was tremendously well-made and presented stuff, right up to The Young Bucks killing the pop by entering the arena as fans buzzed for the Burberry.
1. Swerve Vs Ospreay...NOW?!
The sort of bold booking both men - and the company - needed, Swerve Strickland defending his AEW World Heavyweight Championship against Will Ospreay made everything that matters about All Elite Wrestling feel alive in one fell swoop.
Strickland's been dogged with accusations that he's on borrowed time as Champion and simply keeping it warm for 'The Aerial Assassin', and Forbidden Door's main event can utilise the conversation happening in reality to enhance what should be some gripping fiction. The polar opposite of 75% (more?) or AEW's matches, it is unpredictable with two awesome outcomes.
The Champion retains and he sits firmly atop the mountain having pushed back his most obvious and dangerous challenger. Ospreay lifts the gold, and the consensus best wrestler on the planet is holding the top title in the company "where the best wrestle" and knocking together a belt collector run in the process. That it will be the main event and should be the match of the night doubles down on the benefits for both men.
This was a pleasing masterstroke, and sets up a potentially spectacular summer.