6 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (Sept 19)
Damage CTRL, Judgment Day have good nights, just keep mic away from Dominik.
If you like wrestling with your wrestling program, Monday Night Raw was for you.
The latest edition of the red brand brought us a title match, a bout featuring #1 contenders, and three contests that continued ongoing sagas. As is par for the course in this new era, silliness was minimized from historic proportions, though Raw was not without its challenges.
Dominik Mysterio continues to be a bewildering figure. He is horrid on the mic, average (at best) in the ring, has no presence or charisma to speak of, and yet he drew tremendous heel heat Monday night. In theory, he should be greeted with crickets, not nearly booed out of the building.
Dexter Lumis’ appeal is strange and confusing, and if anyone can explain how this story is going to work, we’d be open to hearing it. Right now, we have a stalker who has kidnapped a man, invaded his home and tried to abduct him a second time on national TV, all while not blinking. That’s the story. We’re being patient, but it would be nice to see some progression.
On the flip side, Kevin Owens is mint. Damage CTRL and Judgment Day had solid nights. And Seth Rollins and Matt Riddle tormented each other throughout the evening.
Overall, a good night for Raw, so let’s give it up for that.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
4. Why Is Lilly Still Here?
Unless Alexa Bliss is making money hand over fist with sales of Lilly dolls, there really is no reason for her to continue carrying hers to the ring.
It’s a reminder of a former character that was the butt of many jokes and really can’t exist in today’s era of live fans, and it also feels like a bit of an anchor, preventing Bliss from moving on entirely from that spooky persona.
Monday, Bayley referenced the doll a couple times during an in-ring confrontation, forcing Alexa to also talk about Lilly and how she bites, but the wrestler bites too. (What?) Keep in mind that Lilly was conceived of as Bliss’ only friend with mystical powers. Without that silliness, she’s only a doll carried to the ring by an adult wrestler.
It’s time for Lilly to be retired so Bliss can move on and evolve to the next phase of her career.
3. More Lumis Creepiness
At what point do the Dexter Lumis shenanigans run their course?
The unblinking psycho has been tormenting the Miz for a month now, kidnapping him, then invading his home last week. Monday, he cut his way up from under the ring and tried to pull Miz, then Tommaso Ciampa, under with him.
Still, there’s been no storyline development whatsoever. No indication of why Lumis is doing this, or why Miz refuses to talk about it and acts like a battered spouse. This might work for a couple weeks, but by now, we should be getting breadcrumbs of a story, some kind of advancement.
As it stands, Lumis isn’t creepy enough – like a Kane for example – to warrant weeks upon weeks of weirdness without purpose. We need to get to the fireworks factory and find out what Dexter wants with Miz relatively soon, or this little program could lose all steam.
2. Interference, Distraction Finishes Aplenty
A distraction finish on its own is not necessarily a bad thing. When done right, it can provide a simple out for a wrestler who needs to lose a match but also needs to maintain their credibility.
But when nearly every match on the Raw card includes outside interference or a distraction finish, that’s a big problem and a sign of lazy booking. Raw Monday night featured five matches, four of which had distraction finishes or interference that directly led to the outcome of the match. Only Brawling Brutes versus Street Profits had a clean finish.
It’s a bit surprising that WWE allowed this many rubbish finishes on an otherwise good episode. It wasn’t noticeable at first, but after Rhea Ripley, Dominik Mysterio and Seth Rollins all got involved in Judgment Day’s match with Rey Mysterio and Matt Riddle, it had become a bit cliché. The main event saw even more of these outside hijinks, making Raw a very distraction/interference heavy show.
Yes, the matches all had finishes, but you run the risk of alienating fans who want to see some kind of definitive endings, and nearly all could be run back because of outside influence.
1. Dominik On The Mic
If you were being prepped for the biggest push of your career, don’t you think you’d really try to up your game, especially if you knew you had a wooden delivery on the mic?
While you can’t expect someone to improve overnight, Dominik Mysterio needs help desperately and immediately. His showing on Raw Monday night was horrid. And yet, the crowd heat for him was off the charts.
Mysterio tried to cut a promo after his fellow Judgment Day cohorts warmed up the crowd, but the jeering audience drowned him out several times. When he finally got his lines out, it sounded like he was reading them off a cue card under the hard camera. It was painfully bad, especially after Rhea Ripley did a nice job setting him up.
Dominik needs help, because standing next to his Judgement Day family, he looks uncomfortable and unconvincing. The fans saved the day by booing him out of the building, but he can’t count on crowd reaction to save him from having to deliver a credible performance on the mic.
Ups…
6. More Rollins Versus Lashley Please
It’s rare this day to see a marquee matchup among WWE veterans that hasn’t been done to death, but Seth Rollins versus Bobby Lashley somehow has managed to feel like a fresh pairing.
The two tangled for the United States Championship on Raw in only their fifth singles match in four years, two of which took place in 2018. Rollins had slick counters to Lashley’s insane power game, and Bobby just wasn’t having Seth’s antics, overcoming some of his trademark offense with sheer athleticism.
Yes, this match had a bit of hijinks at the end, with Rollins breaking the Hurt Lock with a low blow, and Matt Riddle providing a distraction to help Lashley out. But still, it was a star-powered opener with high stakes, big moves and fairly good finish.
This doesn’t mean we want to see this matchup every week for the next two months, but build a program around it and run it back and we’ve got something here.
5. Brutes Brawl Way To Victory
If you’re going to promote a tag title match as a big deal, you might want your challengers to look like a legit threat who stand a chance of toppling dominant champs.
So, booking the Brawling Brutes on Raw to face the Street Profits is a pretty nice move. (Although, the match was seemingly an impromptu clash rather than a scheduled one, so we’ll dock a couple points there.)
Butch and Ridge Holland face an uphill battle to defeat the Usos on SmackDown on Friday, but it didn’t hurt that they had a fun, super-competitive match with the Profits, drawing fans in and getting them behind the action.
Whether that carries over to SmackDown remains to be seen, but this was a nice effort from everyone and gives the Brutes a bit of shine before their big title match.
4. Well-Timed Payback
When Seth Rollins was announced as Bobby Lashley’s latest challenger for the United States Championship, you immediately have to wonder how they get to a conclusion that doesn’t detail either man’s momentum.
Enter Matt Riddle.
In this case, the Original Bro’s interference was well-timed. Rollins was locked in a vicious battle, but he also was caught in the Hurt Lock seemingly with no escape. Seth managed to land a low blow and looked poised to stomp Lashley into oblivion, but Riddle ran down to ringside, distracting Rollins long enough for Lashley to recover and spear him for the win.
While the basis for the Rollins/Riddle feud continuing might be suspect – Rollins won cleanly after frustrating Riddle and taking him off his game – on a grander scale, Seth had attacked Riddle mercilessly for weeks before their Clash at the Castle match.
And all of this has now set up a match at Extreme Rules, so there’s that.
3. Judgment Day Continues To Thwart Rey
If we have to keep pitting Rey Mysterio against Judgment Day, at least the stable keeps winning and keeps pressure on the legendary luchador.
The dark group has expanded their reach to include Matt Riddle, who lost to Finn Balor last week after rejecting an offer to join them, and so it was Riddle who teamed with Rey to take on Judgment Day Monday night. The duo flashed some signs of brilliance, but Rhea Ripley, Dominik Mysterio and an attacking Seth Rollins proved too much for them.
Judgment Day racking up wins only helps the group, though we’ll repeat: the group needs to branch out from Rey and now Riddle. It’s getting repetitive and makes it look like the roster is nonexistent.
2. Owens Continues To Torment Theory
The goal here has to be to frustrate Austin Theory to the point where he makes a mistake and puts his Money in the Bank briefcase on the line, right?
Kevin Owens toppled Theory once again in singles action, overcoming a pre-match assault and bettering the briefcase-holder. He got a bit of help from Johnny Gargano, who prevented Austin from using the briefcase, which provided a distraction that gave KO an opportunity to flatten him with a superkick, cannonball and pop-up powerbomb to win.
It’s pretty clear by now that Owens is a featured player on Raw and not just having lip service paid to him. This is great news for his fans, and it will be fun to see if he somehow ends up with the MITB briefcase.
Meanwhile, Theory’s descent could be seen as a burial, but there’s still enough there that makes you believe it’s a realignment more than anything, so we’ll have to see there.
1. Bayley Defies Hometown Jinx
You know how you know that we’re no longer in the Vince McMahon era of WWE? A wrestler won a match in their hometown Monday night.
Bayley acknowledged her homecoming to San Jose, California on Raw, and then went on to wrestle Alexa Bliss in the main event, where she eventually dropped the Goddess with a Rose Plant to continue her winning ways. The victory wasn’t without a bit of assistance from the rest of Damage CTRL, but she still managed to get the pin, which is far better than many superstars have fared in their hometowns.
For years, WWE has seemingly reveled in beating superstars when they’re in their hometown, embarrassing them in front of fans who want to get amped and celebrate a local hero or heroine. It happened so often that it became a running gag for years, and when a wrestler won in their place of birth/residence, it was almost a shock.
The match itself was fine, and Damage CTRL laying out Bliss, Asuka and Bianca Belair was a nice coda to the show, with Bayley finally declaring that she wants the Raw Women’s Championship at Extreme Rules. This sets the table nicely for that show, as that title match should be a good one.