6 Ups & 6 Downs From AEW Dynamite (September 13 - Results & Review)
A dry Dynamite sets the stage for Grand Slam but falls surprisingly short elsewhere.
There was a time when the "table-setting" editions of AEW Dynamite were the ones you forgot about because - like the pay-per-views they followed - they only came around four times a year.
Revolution, Double Or Nothing, All Out and Full Gear had winners, losers, outcomes and consequences. A vacuum effect was created by the sheer drama on a Saturday and Sunday that tempered the action the following Wednesday, but this was a good thing for the patient, discerning viewer. It was a reminder that the specials were worth paying for, and that new seeds could soon sprout underneath the scorched earth.
There are more of these episodes now because, regrettably, there are more pay-per-views and less focussed longterm storylines. Such is life in the content super-service era, but the September 4th post-All Out edition of the flagship was the first time in forever that a series of new and fresh directions were cleanly laid out for the (admittedly shorter) next cycle ahead. Hangman Page Vs Brian Cage is seeped in AEW legacy lore from a beloved pair of matches in 2021, but also feeds the former AEW Champion's new rivalry with Swerve Strickland. Don Callis wanted to move on from Kenny Omega, but saved his new target for this week. The hottest story in the company promised to feature heavily in a Tournament Final for a title shot that itself just feels like one more big chapter.
Could this week's show build on that momentum just seven days out from an under-performing Grand Slam card?
Let’s light the fuse…
Downs…
6. Darby Allin & Nick Wayne Vs Daddy Magic & Cool Hand Ang
Darby Allin doesn’t have bad matches and Nick Wayne’s still too flashy to be boring, but this routine squash felt like an inadequate use of valuable television time more than an important battle for the reunited babyfaces. Particularly when Christian Cage’s post-match promo - the only real highlight of this segment of the show - could have still been cut as part of a far shorter backstage bit.
Cage is always a riot, but this wasn’t a night for both sides to get their jabs in. He was horny on main for Wayne’s Mother and laid out the challenge for a tag match to get revenge for the Wembley Coffin Match loss.
Not to labour over a well-worn point yet again, but couldn’t this time specifically have been used to push another women’s division story instead? Not least considering the breaking news before showtime that Becky Lynch and Tiffany Stratton pulled a monster number for NXT and the post-show bombshell about a potentially seismic roster change heading AEW’s way…
5. Rushing It On To Rampage
Since the departure of CM Punk following All In, AEW have rapidly opened the floodgates for who works Collision and Dynamite, and though this will cause new issues along the way, the ability to take stories from Wednesdays to Saturdays and back again looked evident when a video package featuring Jade Cargill's surprising return was given pride of place on the flagship. Things got a lot more confusing when the grand payoff was announced not for Grand Slam, but for this Friday's Rampage taping.
This made more sense after a major news story broke hours later, but the lack of a major stage for Kris Statlander’s TBS Championship rematch with Jade Cargill was jarring following the graphic drop.
Ultimately, it was wise to tie this loose end up should Cargill sensationally show up in WWE in the weeks and months ahead, but the disjointed feeling was a difficult one to shift on a less-than-stellar night for the women's division at large.
4. Women's Number One Contender's 4-Way Dance
Toni Storm is going to be one of the most over babyfaces inside Arthur Ashe Stadium next week, and looking at the ticket advances, the show’s gonna need the noise she brings.
Her victory and performance wasn’t enough to drag a mostly-heatless and sloppy Number One Contenders match over the line, but it must always be said that the wrestlers involved in matches for this division are only ever half to blame at a maximum. Here, they can shoulder some for a couple of timing issues during the multi-woman spots and Baker not really connecting at the all-important conclusion.
Beyond that, the booking can yet again be held to account. The Hikaru Shida/Britt Baker tension feels manufactured and has twice now been deployed illogically. When they were tag partners, Shida raged at Britt not tagging her in. As opponents, she raged despite Britt not tagging her in the face with a kick. The latter made ‘D.M.D’ look gullible too, especially when she took the brunt of something resembling a beatdown from her former friend afterwards.
That whole scene was all a bit of a mess too, and wasn’t the only thing that wasn’t helped by…
2. Failing To Fake It
With the exception of roaring their approval for Jon Moxley in the opening match, the 2,521(ish) in attendance at the Heritage Bank Center in Cincinnati, Ohio didn't really have too much to raise their voices for elsewhere on the show.
AEW playing to emptier buildings has been a 2023 trend, but the lack of producing around the smaller crowds continues to be a problem as far as the television viewing experience goes. When matches sagged and fans sat on their hands, visuals revealed empty parts of the building while the silence was filled by the commentary veering off into random asides, leaning too hard into their favourite running jokes, and at one point, another dreaded "bizarro world" reference.
The vibe was off for most of the night, furthering the frustration when certain matches or segments didn't really sizzle in the way they had the potential to. Speaking of which...
1. Le Sex Gods Talk...
...and talk, and talk, and talk, and talk.
An interminably and inexcusably boring 11 minute conversation between Chris Jericho and Sammy Guevara was the last sales pitch for their singles match at next week's Grand Slam edition of Dynamite, but was perhaps the most uninspired chapter of a four-year story.
Uncharacteristically rambling his way through large swatches of the dry dialogue, Chris Jericho's delivery was rough around the edges and failed to tee up his longstanding friend and protege up for any particularly biting replies. The video package should have been the best bit - the story is real! - but repeating the beats of it in a lifeless conversation without a climax made for one of the more bizarre scenes in recent memory. Everything was so half-sold - is the hatred underneath the surface or are they just expressing how they actually feel? Are they just going for the strain of drama already boxed off by MJF and Adam Cole, and if so, how stupid is that? A mooted tag title match when all was said and done next week only muddied the waters further.
Never was it clearer how far this had missed the mark than by the very end. Jericho threatening to punch his friend hard in the face was a closer designed for gasps, let alone cheers and boos. It generated nothing of anything.
Ups…
6. Jon Moxley Vs Big Bill
Passable thanks to the crowd intermittently getting up for seeing their hometown hero rallying in the face of a bigger threat, Jon Moxley Vs Big Bill nonetheless finds itself in this half of the article because we don’t have a down-the-middle section.
There was nothing egregiously wrong with the action, but as has been the case with a number of Moxley’s singles matches of late, it never truly sparkled despite the undying glint in the International Champion’s eye.
Rote even when it was good, Moxley bled, chopped down the tree and found a way to win in spite of Ricky Starks’ interference. Broadly entertaining by default, r here was too little nonsense from Big Bill to elevate it above the norm. A post-match angle that built a Blackpool Combat Club/Starks & Bill tag match for Collision wasn’t that thrilling either, beyond again seeing how the BCC could juggle the uneasily-defined tweeter roles they’ve been forced into lately. It wasn’t up to much either. It never magically gets hotter again after the peak - the them or split them whenever the opportunity presents itself.
5. Hangman Page Vs Brian Cage
It took a while for Hangman Page and Brian Cage to rediscover the meaty chemistry that aided their terrific rankings-smashing 2021 programme, but in the short few minutes where the magic was present, this was great. By the time the former AEW Champion was reversing his way into cradles and abandoning the Buckshot for an almighty Deadeye, fans were bang game.
A victim of some slightly pedestrian booking after a red hot kickoff to the feud last week, Swerve Strickland's musical distraction and long stare was almost too drab a follow-up. As was Hangman winning despite Strickland's presence. Defeat again to 'The Machine' felt like the bolder move, but it was clear that Cage was only there to be a hurdle this time, at most picking himself back up for a trios match between Mogul Embassy and The Elite before the WrestleDream singles match.
From opening bell to closing shot, this was all good without ever being great. Dedicate former forum poster and hardest of hardcore wrestling fan Tony Khan himself has said that all this weekly analysis is more granular than he likes nowadays, and perhaps this why. This wasn't bad, but never took last week's lit touch-paper and set anything new ablaze.
4. MJF Does Steiner Math
It takes quite a bit of generosity to give this an Up without a significant qualifier, but MJF's performance of the much-loved meme was so impressive that it only seems fair to meet in the middle.
Filmed seven days ago in the trainers room, MJF managed to recite-and-upgrade the legendary "Steiner Math" promo from 'Big Poppa Pump's TNA feud with Samoa Joe. This was better than cute and you know it - the Champion's line recital was flawless, contextual changes flowed with all the insanity of the original, and Adam Cole and Renee Paquette's reacting was almost as fun to watch as the main promo itself. There are funny bits and big laughs, and this was much more of the latter than just the former.
It is awfully fortuitous that Joe and Roderick Strong made the final as MJF predicted, otherwise none of this would have been relevant and 'The Salt Of The Earth's efforts would have been for nought. That's very 2023 AEW, but there's an awful lot to be said about wrestlers than can take those plotholes and/or critiques and deliver top drawer material in spite of them. Not for the first time, the AEW World Champion did it with ease.
3. Samoa Joe Vs Roderick Strong
Samoa Joe and Roderick Strong's Grand Slam Tournament final was the last in a series of matches on the show to not really locate their potential peak. But if nothing else, it was a rich reward for the excellent storytelling the company has done with both finalists as pertains to MJF and Adam Cole.
Fans came up for a Muscle Buster attempt before The Kingdom saved Strong's neck, and the pair earned at least one hot nearfall when a flying kick appeared to put Joe down and out. Those fortunes were quickly reversed, and the unfashionable manner 'The Samoan Submission Machine' locked on the Coquina Clutch felt like just the right amount of realism for the finish.
A post-match angle threaded everything together without the need for the AEW World Heavyweight Champion to appear in person too. This was all good build for both the short and longterm - Strong appeared to outrageously fake a new flare-up for his bad neck when Adam Cole arrived on the scene, but Cole had no choice but to sow concern as Roddy was stretchered out of the building. This opened the door for Joe to strike him, choking him out from behind to send a further message to the 'Salt Of The Earth'.
2. Don Callis' Next Target Revealed
It's Kota Ibushi, and this is great if Konosuke Takeshita follows up on Don Callis' violent promises and beats him with ease when they finally meet.
Those that have only seen the 'Golden Star' in AEW have openly wondered what the fuss was ever all about. His contributions have been kept short or scaled back following lengthy injury and illness layoffs, and it remains to be seen if he can ever perform again at the level he once consistently set. As an important project at present, the newly-christened 'Alpha' should thus decimate Ibushi in a manner not witnessed since Brodie Lee brutalised Cody Rhodes for the TNT Championship in 2020.
Ibushi (with or without Kenny Omega) could get revenge for that down the road, revealing himself to be more recovered that his early appearances have let on. That's for then, but Takeshita is for right now - let the "dream" match become a nightmare.
1. Orange Cassidy - Locker Room Leader
Merely light refreshment on a fairly stodgy edition of Dynamite, a brief exchange between Orange Cassidy, Renee Paquette and Hook was nonetheless the highlight of the night.
'The Cold-Hearted Handsome Devil' hadn't yet got a word out following his regaining of the FTW Championship at All In before Cassidy limped into shot to remind him of how good his life was. Hook called Cassidy a "great champion", Cassidy responded in kind, and Hook slinked off to allow Paquette to charmingly check in with the former International Champion. "I'm still so tired" drew laughter in the building, and the humour was the perfect payoff to this much needed bit of levity from the company that used to be the masters of it.
'Freshly Squeezed' played with every emotion here. He was the veteran putting the young guy over, he was the battle-worn warrior trying to pick himself up again, he was the sympathetic figure everybody wanted to help get back on his feet. The response to "I used to have a Championship" drew the sort of noises a Saturday morning studio show would bottle for scenes where characters were in need of consolation or comfort.
Something very special appears to be brewing here, and if anybody can pull off an extremely slow stroll to the main event picture, it's Orange Cassidy.