6 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 36 (Part 2)

Second night has its moments, but doesn't keep pace with first night.

And just like that, WrestleMania 36 is in the books.

Night two of WWE’s signature event followed what was widely considered a modest success with Saturday night’s event. However, Sunday’s effort fell short of matching the first half of the PPV.

Sunday’s program featured time-filler matches that would have been better served on Raw or SmackDown, while one of its signature matches – the Last Man Standing contest between Edge and Randy Orton – was a long, dull, plodding affair that was nowhere near as vicious and aggressive as it should have been.

New champions were crowned Sunday night, and we’re leaving WrestleMania with two new world champions, saying farewell to our part-time standard-bearers. It’s understandable that we weren’t going to get classics out of either of them given the circumstances, but both matches underwhelmed.

A huge highlight Sunday night was the NXT Women’s Championship match, which opened the show and set the bar really high – and was never eclipsed. And of course, we got our second cinematic “match” of the PPV Sunday night, with John Cena facing the Fiend in a Firefly Funhouse match. Expect opinions on that one to be divided.

With that said, let’s break down the second part of WrestleMania 36. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

6. Inoffensive, Middling Tag Title Match

Street Profits WrestleMania
WWE.com

It’s tough to categorize the Raw Tag Team Championship match. It wasn’t bad, and it wasn’t boring. But it also didn’t do anything.

The Street Profits and Angel Garza & Austin Theory were on the offensive the whole match, but it wasn’t much more than a decent Raw tag match. Montez Ford and Garza dove around the place, with Theory getting a TKO on Angelo Dawkins before Ford broke up the pinfall with the Cash Out, securing a win for the Profits.

The match wasn’t good enough to merit an “up,” so we’ll give it a very tacit “down” because it could have just waited until Monday on Raw rather than here on WrestleMania.


5. Just A Match

aliester black bobby lashley
WWE.com

Not every match at WrestleMania can be a barnburner, four-star classic, but if you have a match at the biggest show of the year, you should be doing something to try to make it memorable in some fashion.

Bobby Lashley and Aleister Black had a first-ever match Sunday night, ending with Aleister countering a spear with a Black Mass. The match itself could have been a contest at the top of the second hour of some random Raw, flown in here, and we never would have been able to tell the difference. It was just a normal, run-of-the-mill, subpar match.

Maybe part of that feeling is because there was zero buildup for a match announced more than a week before Mania, but it was impossible to get invested in the match. Even Lana’s involvement at the end – stopping Lashley from hitting the Dominator and insisting he spear Black – was forgettable.

This was a total palate cleanser of a match, one that will be forgotten before Raw airs. At least the right guy won.


4. Building Up To Nothing

Sasha Banks Bayley
WWE.com

For the longest time, we’ve been waiting for Sasha Banks to finally show her true colors and turn on her friend Bayley over the SmackDown Women’s Championship. Sunday provided the perfect opportunity, as they were part of a five-woman elimination match for the title.

The two worked together initially to eliminate Tamina and Naomi, but things then fell apart, and heel miscommunication led to Banks getting eliminated.

Um, what?

Then, Sasha came back to bail out Bayley and helped her beat Lacey Evans to retain her title.

Um, what?

So we sat through a 20-minute match that literally left us where we started with no advancement at the biggest show of the year. If ever there was a time for Sasha to turn on Bayley, this was it. Instead, we got a mediocre time-filler of a match.


3. Bigger Isn’t Necessarily Better

Edge Randy orton
WWE.com

So overall, how does WrestleMania 36 fare?

You obviously have to get past the “should they or shouldn’t they” debate, and then give a bit of a pass for the lack of reaction because of the absence of a live crowd.

But once you get past that, it’s safe to say that WM 36 was long. It was 18 matches over two nights (thank God for that), with nearly half of them being nothing more than TV matches filling time at the biggest PPV of the year. We haven’t seen that kind of proliferation at Mania in years.

The second night definitely felt longer and with more filler than Saturday, as the Last Man Standing Match and SmackDown Women’s Championship match were long and underperformed, and the Raw tag title bout was something we could see on any Monday night.

So while Mania 36 was “too big for just one night,” it wasn’t big enough – and good enough – to fill both nights with quality wrestling. Saturday gets passing marks, but Sunday gets a middling grade, with advice to use fast-forward.


2. Video Game Main Event

Brock Lesnar Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

WrestleMania 36 was an experiment in trying to make an event that relies on crowd reaction a success with no audience. At times, it worked fine, but at others, it was a disappointment.

Sunday’s main event of Brock Lesnar versus Drew McIntyre for the WWE Championship was Exhibit A of what didn’t work.

The match itself was nothing more than a series of finishers, consisting of three German suplexes, three F-5s and four Claymore kicks. That was it during a sub-5 minute match. There was no drama, no tension, no feeling of anything being at risk. It was just move, move, cover, move, cover, move, cover, move, move, move, move, pinfall, new champ.

And what should have been McIntyre’s crowning achievement in WWE played out to silence.

There’s been an argument among fans about whether WWE should have just shelved WrestleMania in light of the situation and waited until they could put it on in some fashion in front of fans, or whether the show should go on. While that’s an open question, this was a perfect example of how having some fan reaction would have helped immensely.


1. Last Man Standing Just Kept Going

Edge Randy Orton
WWE.com

Leading up to Sunday, the match this writer was most looking forward to was the Edge/Randy Orton Last Man Standing match. It wasn’t just because it was Edge’s first singles match in nine years. Quite simply, it had one of the most compelling stories behind it too.

And then the bell rang.

More than a half-hour later, some fans had to be yelling at the TV, “Just end it already!” The match dragged on and on and on, with Edge and Randy roaming the entire backstage area – the gym, a conference room and the storage area. They wandered around, punching each other and bouncing their heads off various surfaces. Edge dropped an elbow off a storage cage through Orton, who was lying on a table, but the match then kept going for another 10+ minutes.

The ending came on top of a production truck, with Edge countering a punt with a spear, Orton countering a spear with an RKO, and finally Edge hitting a conchairto to get the 10 count.

What makes this unreal is that this match was taped days and days ago. It should have been scripted out much better, booking better, more innovative spots. They had the ability to shoot these spots from numerous angles, do multiple takes and set stuff up creatively. They did none of that.

They were going for “epic,” but all we got was “long.” It’s really a shame, because Edge’s big return after a well-done storyline deserved to be so much better.


Ups...

6. Gronk A Champion Again

Gronk Hardcore
WWE.com

You had to figure that WrestleMania 36 host Rob Gronkowski wouldn’t just show up at Mania and be a spectator.

The three-time NFL Super Bowl champion watched his buddy Mojo Rawley steal the 24/7 Championship out from under him on the first night of WM, and he vowed to leave Mania Sunday night with the title.

Sure enough, Mojo was pursued by a mob of jobbers into the arena, and they settled under the podium perch where Gronk was holding court. So Gronk proceeded to dive onto the group, wiping them out and pinning Rawley for the 24/7 title. And then he fled the arena with the championship.

Cute little bit, and it’ll probably get a ton of coverage on ESPN, considering how desperate they are for sports-related news these days.


5. RKO Outta Nowhere

Edge Randy Orton
WWE.com

While the match itself was a long, plodding affair, we’ve got to pay tribute to one aspect of the Last Man Standing match… Randy Orton’s RKO to open things.

Edge entered the ring first and was awaiting Orton, when a shadowy figure sprung into the camera’s view and hit an RKO on the Rated-R Superstar. Replays then showed Orton disguised as a ringside cameraman who put his camera down, slid into the ring and nailed Edge.

It was a clever piece of booking and should have set the tone for a creative match to settle the blood feud, but alas. Still, this was a pretty cool moment.


4. The EST Makes Her Mark

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

In the aftermath of the middling Raw tag title match, the defeated challengers put the boots to the Street Profits, with Zelina Vega getting involved.

That was all a prelude to Bianca Belair making her main roster debut (presumably), running down to confront Vega and save her husband (Montez Ford) and his tag partner (Angelo Dawkins). With Belair, the Profits were able to clear the ring and stand tall after successfully defending their tag titles.

This worked decently, especially when you consider there isn’t much for Bianca to do in NXT at this point, and Raw could use another strong presence in the women’s division.

The question is, will WWE acknowledge her marriage to Ford on Raw? It’s been referenced on NXT before (and in this video), but as we’ve seen, the “main roster” doesn’t always utilize every fact or facet of an NXT superstar’s makeup when they’re called up.


3. Otis Gets The Girl

Mandy Rose Otis
WWE.com

As a match, Otis versus Dolph Ziggler was never going to be Kurt Angle/Shawn Michaels, but as a storyline, this might have been one of the better ones on the WrestleMania 36 card.

Otis learned Friday that it was Sonya Deville who had sent a false text to him, ruining his date with Mandy Rose, then deleted the evidence. This capped off a months-long storyline and set the table for Sunday’s grudge match. The bout itself could have used a little more aggression from Otis, who whipped Ziggler in the turnbuckles a bunch of times when he should have been going berserk on him.

But the climax came when Sonya distracted the ref and Dolph hit Otis with a low blow, so Mandy came out and repaid the favor to Ziggler, allowing Otis to hit the Caterpillar for the win.

And then Otis swooped Mandy off her feet… and they shared a kiss. You can “aww” or gag, whatever your pleasure. But this was the right call for the angle and worked well. It obviously would’ve worked better with an audience to react.


2. Fiend ‘Ends’ ‘Overhyped’ Cena

John Cena Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

While Saturday’s Boneyard Match was widely praised, it’s likely that Sunday’s Firefly Funhouse match will be much more divisive.

Bray Wyatt challenged John Cena to this “match,” which was more of a series of vignettes tracing the two wrestlers’ careers rather than a contest. The puppet Vince McMahon, Mercy the Buzzard and Huskus all made appearances as they recreated Cena’s WWE debut against Kurt Angle (with Bray playing the role of Kurt), a Saturday Night’s Main Event promo, Cena as the Doctor of Thugonomics (in a Yankees jersey as a smart wink), a classic nWo promo, Wyatt as a cult leader, and Cena and Bray’s WrestleMania 30 match.

There was really no “wrestling” here, just a series of promos and Cena being unable to get his hands on Wyatt. Finally, the Fiend appeared, locked in the Mandible Claw, hit Sister Abigail and reapplied the Claw, finally downing Cena. And then John disappeared.

Look, if you just wanted something different and wanted to see the Fiend topple Cena, then you were satisfied. But if you had higher expectations after the Boneyard Match, then you likely were disappointed. We’ll give this positive marks, but it’s completely understandable if you hated it.


1. Flair, Ripley Tear It Down

Rhea Ripley Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

You had to think that Charlotte Flair wasn’t going to let an empty Performance Center stop her from trying to tear down the house Sunday night with Rhea Ripley.

The two battled for Ripley’s NXT Women’s Championship, with Rhea getting an early Riptide but quickly falling victim to Flair’s precision attack on the knee. Sometimes a wrestler targeting a body part can be boring or repetitive, but this was really well done, with Ripley getting in some offense and continuously swinging back at Charlotte whenever possible.

In the end, Flair fought for and locked in the Figure Four, which she bridged into the Figure Eight for the tap-out win.

You could make the argument that this cuts Ripley’s legs out from under her – and that’s a perfectly plausible case to make – but it’s also a 10-time champion defeating a relatively young wrestler. Now, Rhea has a goal: work at her game and get a rematch to win back her title. If WWE can successfully tell that story, then we’ve got something here.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.