6 Ups And 7 Downs From WWE Clash Of Champions 2016

For fans of: screwy finishes, authority figures, and solid in-ring action.

seth rollins ref kevin owens
WWE.com

Raw's first brand-specific pay-per-view of the new Brand Split era is finally in the books. Matches like Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins and the Women's Title Triple Threat made for a strong card, and while SmackDown's Backlash was one of the year's better shows, the red brand looked well-equipped to at least match their Tuesday night rivals.

As is often the case with WWE, however, things didn't quite turn-out as well as hoped. Clash of Champions 2016 was marred by a stretch of regrettable and confusing booking decisions that took the steam out of almost every major match. Even the clean finishes left a sense of dissatisfaction, and when Clash went off the air, it was hard to shake the feeling that this show was a huge missed opportunity.

Still, the night produced a number of big talking points. There was no Triple H appearance, nor was there a Goldberg sighting (as far-fetched as it seemed), but 4 of Raw's 5 title holders successfully retained their belts, with only the US Champion breaking rank. Roman Reigns' win over Rusev provided Clash's only title change, though not for want of trying from a game set of challengers.

As has become customary in all post-Draft Raw productions, Clash of Champions was a minefield of ups and downs. Let's get into it...


Downs...

7. The Chirping Of Crickets

141 CHAMP 09252016hm 0676 5e0fcf4f157469fa928b08fcce7f0df8
WWE.com

A hot crowd can be the difference between a good show and a great show. Look at ECW One Night Stand 2005: the matches were serviceable, but there wasn't much that'd blow you out of the water. It was the hot-blooded crowd and the raucous atmosphere they created that made ONS such a special show, and one of the most exciting WWE-produced PPVs in recent memory.

When the audience is excited, so are the viewers at home, but when the crowd is dead? Eugh...

You could hear a pin drop on carpet for most of last night's show. For whatever reason, Indianapolis just wasn't into Clash of Champions from the very first match. Big moves brought the occasional energy spike, but that was it: the night's early matches were met mostly with silence, and it was to everyone's detriment.

It's hard not to feel for the performers in these situations, but what can you do? The fans paid their money, and they have the right to respond to the action however they see fit. They slowly came alive later on, but it's a shame they couldn't have created more of a buzz earlier, because there was a lot of great action on display at Clash.


6. Kicking Off With A Clunker

Alicia Fox Nia Jax
WWE.com

There might be a strange parallel universe in which Nia Jax is the second coming of Bull Nakano, but this isn't it.

Clash of Champions' first official match was as clunky as expected. A few weeks removed from being speared through the barricade, Alicia Fox was out for revenge against the all-conquering Jax, but fell predictably short. Fox had her moments, but nobody in the building believed she stood a chance against Nia, whose offense consisted of a few throws, a sloppy chokehold, and her new fireman's carry powerslam finisher.

The match does Jax no favours. Still growing into her skin as a performer, she remains a largely unconvincing monster, and being made to sell for a lowly wrestler like Fox only harms her mystique. Moreover, the lengthy resthold portion murdered the match's already-slim chances of capturing the fans' attention when Jax could've been tossing Fox around like the dominant savage she's supposed to be.

WWE are in a tricky situation with Jax. The endless squash matches are starting to wear thin, but tonight proves she's still too green and unseasoned to wrestle for any longer than a couple of minutes. Jax may eventually grow into the convincing monster heel WWE hope she becomes, but it's going to take a considerable amount of time to get there: time that would undoubtedly be better served in NXT.


5. What A Waste

Sheamus Cesaro
WWE.com

Only WWE would end a Best of Seven series on a draw.

While the first six matches of Cesaro and Sheamus' series typically varied from "good" to "very good," and now that we've seen the last of them, they'll be missed. While the "comeback story" booking was predictable, Cesaro and Sheamus could always be relied on to deliver a quality wrestling match every week, as expected from two workers of their calibre.

Clash of Champions looked set to provide the best match of the series, and the European bruisers unleashed tremendous amounts of punishment on each other. Both shone, and while Sheamus brought his A-game, Cesaro was the star of the show, pulling-off a 619 of all things, and almost killing himself on a dive through the ropes.

The match spilled through the barricade, and that's when the referee decided he'd seen enough. With both wrestlers down, it was decreed that neither was fit to continue, and thus the series ends. WWE were en route to rounding-off one of their best matches of 2016, but they took a wrong turn at the final junction. We're likely heading towards a flat, lifeless resolution on this week's Raw, and it'll take something spectacular to wash this disappointment away.


4. Overstretched Authority

WWE.com

One show without significant authority figure involvement, WWE. That's all we ask. Stephanie McMahon's complete elimination from all programming would be nice, but hey, who are we kidding? This is 2016, and as sure as Braun Strowman is gonna murder local talents, Raw's authority figures are going to hog airtime.

Mick Foley and Stephanie's involvement wasn't as irritatingly drawn-out as usual, but it was completely unnecessary. They approached Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins in-turn to gauge their respective mindsets ahead of the Universal Title match, and it accomplished precisely nothing outside of granting Steph and Mick their oh-so-precious airtime.

There was nothing here that couldn't have been accomplished with a quick interview with both men. Though short, the two segments reeked of WWE's writers getting the Commissioner and General Manager on-screen at all costs. Then, of course, Stephanie showed-up during the main event, because in WWE, everyone plays a supporting role to the McMahons.

All these moments did was re-affirm pre-existing plot points. WWE could've used this time to give Cesaro vs. Sheamus a proper conclusion, or allow the tag teams a little more time, but alas.


3. The Roman Reigns Charade

Roman Reigns WWE United States Title
WWE.com

Almost none of this is Roman Reigns' fault. He is but a solid wrestler who happens to have a look that Vince McMahon loves, and has thus been made subject to one of the most misguided babyface pushes in WWE history. His Clash of Champions match was a basic but enjoyable showdown that, like everything else Reigns does, was rendered a farce by his miscast role.

Reigns was jeered, and Rusev, the anti-American monster heel, was cheered and chanted for. It's the same story every time the Samoan steps into the ring, but if WWE haven't acted by this point, they're likely never going to. They've handed Roman so poorly that crowds are actively rooting for the company's most obvious boogeyman to succeed against him, and that's a huge problem.

A section of the crowd had started cheering for him by the match's conclusion, but the guy exudes obnoxiousness, and it's tough to tell what a United States title reign does for him. The whole situation reeks of Rusev's US Title run-ins with John Cena throughout 2015, and when Reigns celebrated with his new belt, it was hard not to hark back to the disastrous three-month period that the Bulgarian Brute has never truly recovered from.


2. Dead End Booking

Luke Gallows Karl Anderson
WWE.com

WWE sprung a number of booking surprises on their fanbase last night, and not in a good way.

While it's too easy to complain when your favourites lose, it's safe to say that few people had Chris Jericho down to pin Sami Zayn last night, nor did anyone think Cesaro vs. Sheamus would finish as a draw. Such results didn't just suck the life out of Clash of Champions, but they provided no clear indication of losers' future direction, and left several key roster members stuck in dead ends.

Where do Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows go from here, for example? Sure, they lost through weapon use, but they've now failed to beat The New Day on two consecutive pay-per-views. Can they ever be built-up as credible challengers again?

Cesaro and Sheamus are stuck in the mud, Rusev lost his championship in decisive fashion, and Sami Zayn must head back to the drawing board. Surprises are the lifeblood of professional wrestling, but these moves left fans scratching their heads rather than begging for more.


1. A Limp Universal Champion

Chris Jericho Seth Rollins Kevin Owens
WWE.com

On its own, Kevin Owens becoming WWE Universal Champion was a hugely cathartic moment. His coronation felt like a long-overdue reward for all the years he'd spent grinding through the independent circuit to get to where he is today. From ROH and PWG to NXT and now the main roster, Owens has proven himself as one of the world's very best, and the title win was his recognition.

Sadly, Owens' reign has been tainted from day one. It doesn't help that the Universal Title is a brand new belt completely devoid of legacy and lineage, but KO wouldn't have captured it without Triple H's involvement, and was presented as a lucky champion from the moment the belt was placed on his shoulder.

The Prizefighter lost a cage match to Rusev on last week's Raw, further compounding his lowly status as Universal Champion. Then, at Clash of Champions, he was only able to put Seth Rollins away after a lengthy (and unnecessary) Chris Jericho interference, though the rumoured Triple H appearance failed to materialise.

Kevin Owens' booking as Universal Champion has been nothing short of terrible. At a time when WWE desperately need to build the belt's credibility, their writers are running both it and their champion into the ground. As it stands, Owens comes off weak at best, and completely pathetic at worst. Though many expected him to retain last night, the manner of Owens' victory dealt significant damage to him, the belt, and the product as a whole.

Click "next" below for the Ups...


Ups...

6. Tremendous Tag Team Action

Luke Gallows Karl Anderson Kofi Kingston
WWE.com

The New Day's WWE Tag Team Championship defence against Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows was everything it needed to be. A long run-time would've been nice, but all four participants brought their working boots, and with Xavier Woods and Francesca 2 providing the decisive factor, there's plenty of scope for a rematch.

This was the best match of Anderson & Gallows' WWE careers thus far. Anderson in-particular has struggled to adapt to the company's style after leaving NJPW earlier this year, but they started strongly and rarely let-off. While Gallows destroyed Woods and Big E at ringside, Anderson dismantled Kofi between the ropes. The duo's mean streak shone through from bell-to-bell, momentarily banishing all memories of those terrible doctor segments, and proving they'll be a long-term asset in Raw's tag division.

Meanwhile, The New Day continue to impress. They're now 78 days short of matching Demolition's record-breaking 478-day title reign, and all three were on top form last night. From Kofi's selling to Big E's mid-match dominance, the trio's cohesion brought The Club's downfall in a breathless tag match. They're still on top, and it'll take a mighty effort to dislodge them.

It's hard to tell where Gallows & Anderson go from here, but both teams put forth an effort to be proud of.


5. The Cruiserweights Take Flight

WWE.com

If the Tag Title match got Clash of Champions off to a hot start, the Cruiserweights turned things up a notch. TJ Perkins and Brian Kendrick wrestled an excellent Cruiserweight Title match that firmly established each man's role in the division, and reintroduced the lighter weight classes in perfect fashion.

Kendrick is the crafty veteran with loose morals who has worked long and hard to regain his WWE spot, and will use every shortcut in the book to keep hold of it. Kendrick refused Perkins' handshake, tied him up in the apron curtain, and wrestled a slower, methodical heel style that didn't always please the crowd, but put him over as the division's ultimate opportunist.

Perkins, meanwhile, made his way-out to some new 8-bit video game-style music that's either the best or worst entrance theme in WWE today. He was as smooth, fluid, and eye-catching as ever, and his high-flying antics late in the match helped recapture the crowd when it sounded like they'd gone to sleep.

TJP walked away with his first successful defence after weathering numerous Captain's Hook attempts and even a Sliced Bread. WWE are going to have to work hard to get the Cruiserweight division over, but it's impossible to fault the competitors' efforts, Kendrick's post-match headbutt gives the Cruiserweights their first real story thread.


4. Hey, These Guys Can Actually Talk...

It's incredibly difficult for a wrestler to get over without considerable microphone time. Dazzling in-ring skills can carry a performer so far, but if the crowd aren't given a chance to get to know these men and women's personalities, it's almost impossible to build long-term investment.

This lack of mic time is a big part of WWE's inability to create new stars in the modern era, with Raw lagging particularly far behind in this department. If you're not an authority figure, main eventer, or Enzo Amore, you're rarely given a chance to talk on WWE's flagship show, and that's a problem.

Tonight saw a switch in the formula, however. TJ Perkins cut a confident promo prior to his Cruiserweight Title defence against Brian Kendrick, while Cesaro - the most underused of underused wrestlers - was allowed a rare opportunity to share his thoughts prior to wrestling Sheamus.

The real acid test will be seeing whether or not such interviews carry over into weekly television, but it was refreshing to hear from some of Raw's quieter voices. Here's hoping such opportunities continue.


3. Zayn & Jericho Get Clash Back On Track

Sami Zayn Chris Jericho
WWE.com

Clash of Champions needed a pick-me-up after the Cesaro/Sheamus non-finish. Chris Jericho and Sami Zayn were tasked with recovering the show's lost momentum, and not the night's most exciting match, they largely succeeded.

Jericho has lost a few steps between the ropes, but he's one of Raw's most consistent and entertaining personalities. Half bitter veteran, half obnoxious douchebag, Jericho continues proving his status as one of the most charismatic performers in wrestling history. It's the little things like his outrage at Indianapolis' early-match "olé" chants that make him so fun to watch, and in Zayn, he had the perfect opponent.

The former NXT champion has struggled since defeating Kevin Owens at Battleground, and while the result leaves him languishing, this was a typically exuberant display from Sami. He is Raw's most affable and easy-to-support performer, and it's thanks to gritty, determined performances like this.

It's easy to call foul on the result, particularly given where each man is in their respective careers, but Zayn will have plenty of opportunities to push towards the main event. For now, he remains Raw's biggest underdog.


2. Hail To The Queen(s)

Bayley Sasha Banks Charlotte
WWE.com

Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Bayley have put on better matches between them, but last night's Women's Title match was a solid outing. Triple Threat matches often suffer through lengthy spells when two participants are wrestling and the other is lying around like a third wheel. Last night was no different, but the trio's chemistry along with the continually vicious offence between Sasha and Charlotte shone through, and they produced Clash's finest match.

There were a number of notable spots throughout. From Charlotte's double Moonsault to Sasha and Bayley inadvertently teaming-up against the queen, it was a well-paced affair between Raw's three female standouts, and while the finish was awkward, Charlotte walked-out a rightful winner.

Bayley is better suited to the underdog role, and will benefit from a long-term build before winning her first belt. Sasha, meanwhile, will enjoy many lengthy title reigns before her career ends, but for now, Charlotte is the perfect figurehead. She's one of the company's most effective heels, and she improves in all aspects of her performance every time we see her. While still a little rough round the edges, Raw's Women's Champion is rapidly growing in stature.


1. Before It Got Messy

Kevin Owens Seth Rollins
WWE.com

On a card full of potentially great matches, Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins always stood-out. A legitimate dream match between Raw's two most complete performers, it felt like Clash of Champions' most obvious "sure" thing, and a potential WWE Match of the Year candidate.

Did it deliver? If you compartmentalise the action, absolutely.

Owens, the defending champion, was on top form throughout. KO built-on his always-sharp in-ring trash talk with feigned concern for Rollins' well-being, and threw-in a little easter egg for those who've followed Rollins since his ROH days ("when I'm finished with you, you're gonna fade to Black."). Listening to him verbally run his opponents down is almost as much fun as watching him beat them up at this point.

Owens gradually wore his challenger down with typically brutish offence, but Seth fought his way back. After taking significant damage to his knee and back, The Architect worked through the pain, producing the kind of gutsy display that will be vital in cementing him as a face. Even when Owens blasted Rollins with a top-rope gutbuster and the Frog Splash, Seth kept coming back, and he only fell through interference.

The finish may leave a sour taste, but let's not forget the tremendous match Owens and Rollins were having until Chris Jericho and Stephanie McMahon showed-up.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.