6 WWE Stars Who Could Join The Club

The best candidates to join (or rejoin) AJ Styles, Luke Gallows, and Karl Anderson in The Club!

The Club Nia Jax
WWE

With Ricochet getting over and The Good Brothers seemingly staying put, the recent revival of The Club must go down as a huge win for WWE. AJ Styes has come out of this looking better than ever, reinventing and positioning himself for another run at the top and feels like he's caught a second wind.

Now the question becomes where do The Club go from here? If they stay a trio it will start to feel a lot more like they just did the whole revival to keep Gallows and Anderson out of the competition's hands and the good programming was a short-lived happy accident. Therefore it stands to reason that the brilliant minds in WWE creative are hard at work crafting a plan to who should be the next in line to throw up the too sweet and get that sweet heel momentum!

Which is why this article is here; to beat them to it so they will hopefully just steal these ideas instead. Here's six potential candidates who could become The Club's newest member...

6. Finn Bálor

Bullet Club
NJPW World

This really is the obvious choice, isn’t it?

The original founder of the Bullet Club back in 2013, Finn Bálor just makes the most sense to join up with WWE’s version. Adding fuel to the fire is his recent request to take some time off from WWE television and dropping the Intercontinental Title at Extreme Rules on the “kickoff show”. This all seems to point towards some sort of drastic change in direction for Finn in the near future.

This could very easily mean a massive push and heel turn, allowing Finn to perhaps slide back into the main event picture as AJ’s right hand man. You could even keep him right on SmackDown, having Balor be the other brand’s leader of The Club as if it was a separate chapter of a biker gang. This of course allows more people to benefit from the success of this stable, and everybody gets to be on television in the process.

And plus Finn is just so damn good at being a heel that this just has to happen at some point, why not give him credit for something he pretty much inspired already?


5. Adam Cole (and The Undisputed Era)

Adam Cole Bullet Club
NJPW/ROH

Another alumni of the Bullet Club, Adam Cole seems a perfect candidate to join The Club but how do you then handle The Undisputed Era? Well, the obvious way would be to have Adam leave them behind, realizing the wealth of opportunity that stands before him by joining with the major brand's dominant stable.

They’ve even teased this on Twitter somewhat. Verbal jabs were thrown after AJ Styles laughed at comparisons between them. Cole said “Careful what you wish for AJ…” and seemed to tease a feud between the groups.

Undisputed Era versus The Club? That sounds good on paper but it could destroy the momentum of both groups. WWE needs to be more creative here than just a faction war. Rather than have Cole dismantle the group and leave them to pick up the pieces, why can’t a massive coexistance of two stables be on the cards as one cohesive unit? Undisputed Era JOINS The Club.

Let The Undisputed Era be their very own “chapter” of The Club gang with Adam Cole remaining the leader on NXT. Finn Balor heads SmackDown. AJ remains the mastermind of it all and runs the Raw "branch". This allows you to keep letting The Undisputed Era work their magic while giving them an endorsement (and perhaps television time) with some major established talent.

Cole gets put on equal footing with Balor and AJ in the power structure and everybody looks stronger. Then we can maybe let them break off later.


4. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre absolute piece
WWE.com

The other day Drew actually said the words “I am going to disembowel you” on television to Cedric Alexander. To say that his promos are a bit underwhelming lately is an understatement. The guy is talented and even the ageing eyes of The Undertaker can see with perfect vision that he has the makings of a potential star.

So why hasn’t he been pushed properly? Well, partly McIntyrehas been stuck in this Shane McMahon shtick that has dragged on for too long now. He feels an accessory in the murdering of the air time of WWE's roster.

So how do you remedy this and get him to say the mega heel he always should’ve been?

Have him abandon Shane in the midst of this Quebec Rattlesnake storyline with Owens but not for a face turn. Drew just goes where Drew can be in the best position of power to suit his own needs. And once he sees Shane being taken out and The Club slowly taking control of the roster, he will turn to them and become their new enforcer finally becoming the bad ass he was always meant to be.


3. Nia Jax

Nia Jax
WWE

This one is a smart play on two fronts. You can ease Nia back into television as she recovers from injury and still heavily involve her in storylines leading up to a big feud with Becky Lynch. This allows The Club to threaten even the women’s division titles, further proving just how dominant a force they can be. And then of course for some added heel heat you have her telling Becky about how she is going to break her face again like she did before Survivor Series 2018.

This will just further intensify an already deep amount of real heat Nia has from this incident and further play into how low The Club is willing to go to gain the advantage.

You also have the added benefit of the fact that Nia has been proven as a threat to even men, having enjoyed the rub from that brief Dean Ambrose program on his way out. You could even throw a cheeky shot AEW’s way here and say Nia’s elbow sent Dean straight into the “minor leagues” or something along those lines. This all helps build back Nia and hopefully gives her some time to work on her in ring skills as well.

Nobody wants anymore ACTUAL broken faces to happen again.


2. Seth Rollins

AJ Styles Seth Rollins
WWE

The Man’s man has himself turned into a bit of a broken face in his own right. After his reign as . Universal Champion lost all of the momentum it had left with yet ANOTHER round of Baron Corbin, we are set for another Rollins versus Lesnar at SummerSlam. But at this point if he does win it back as a triumphant babyface and lays Lesnar out clean, what is there really going to be for Rollins to do? His promos as of late have been lackluster ("crack you like the liberty bell", really?) and he seems almost bored on screen, especially when being forced on screen with Becky.

So go a different direction entirely. Have Seth realize the insurmountable odds that stand before him and seek the help of The Club.

Last time it took a low blow to help seal the deal so it isn’t like Rollins hasn’t needed a boost to beat Brock before. You could even take this a step further and have The Club interfere and force a purposeful DQ, laying a beat down on Brock and stealing the belt in the process. This could then lead to AJ deciding he wants it instead, or Rollins going after it again with evened out odds.

The possibilities here are wide open. And if you do bring in Nia Jax, maybe you even have Rollins turn on Becky at some point. The experiment of them on screen together has failed anyway, so why not make a spectacle of abandoning it?


1. Roman Reigns

Roman Reigns AJ Styles
WWE.com

Everybody wants to see a Roman heel turn. Yet somehow there has never quite been the right program with enough magnitude to make it the right time to pull the trigger. That all could be changing as we reintroduce The Club.

With Reigns fighting Shane McMahon and Elias on the past two events there is reason to understand why he would be growing frustrated and desperate to reclaim his former glory. This is the guy who was borderline unbeatable not long ago and now hasn’t had a title shot since winning the Universal Championship at Summerslam in 2018.

So have Roman take back the gold with a little help from his friends, and shock the world by putting your biggest superstar on the roster of The Club. This cements their stance as the scariest presence in the WWE and allows you to start looking at scenarios where you can try what NJPW did with Bullet Club but across all brands.

Every title in the hands of The Club simultaneously, truly selling the fact that this is their dynasty.

With Dean Ambrose officially dead (and his spirit living on as Jon Moxley in NJPW and AEW), this is the closest thing we could get to The Shield coming together again.

And imagine the powerhouse squad, headed by a mega heel version of one of the biggest drawing stars in recent memory?


Contributor
Contributor

Future 24/7 Champion. Self crowned king of sarcasm. Defeated WWE's plane in Saudi Arabia by TKO. Lister of nonsense achievements. Mostly just an aspiring writer and podcaster looking to mark out over wrestling.