7 Match Star Ratings For WWE Clash At The Castle

Drew McIntyre's dreams get broken in a white-hot main event.

Gunther Sheamus
WWE

The build to Clash at the Castle, the first real test of 'Papa H's' credentials as a booker, was better than Vince McMahon mustered for several years. That's not saying much, because Vince McMahon's booking philosophy was screaming "Go f*ck youself you little mark c*nt!" for about two decades, but looking at the Nielsens, it's enough.

WWE has told the same story with Drew McInryre for two years now. "I was sh*te, a proper disappointment, and then I came back much better - which is probably an indictment of the developmental system, but don't think too much aboot that bit hen."

WWE has never told it in quite such an effective way, however, and the video packages that captured the sheer amount of work Drew has put in were so good that he'd have to turn heel if he didn't get it done. His match with Roman Reigns was framed, brilliantly, as nothing less than the culmination of his life's work.

Elsewhere, Matt Riddle and Seth Rollins worked people into thinking they actually hurt one another, which is half the battle. Gunther and Sheamus just stared at each other as their underlings brawled around them. Why rip off the angle that everybody buried before Forbidden Door?

,,,twice?

The Bayley faction versus babyfaces bit was only good, being honest, because people were happy to see Dakota Kai and Iyo Sky on the main roster. Three performers in a six-person programme are miscast. So, an uneven build.

How was the show itself...?

7. Pre-Show: Madcap Moss & Street Profits Vs. Austin Theory & Alpha Academy

Chad Gable Austin Theory
WWE.com

There wasn't a great deal to this unannounced pre-show match: short, simple, the babyfaces and the heels did things in the correct order to get the crowd up. Madcap Mass got them going with his explosive rope runs and unreal power game, Chad Gable was a phenomenally entertaining d*ckhead, and the Street Profits continued, albeit quietly, their tremendous 2022 run.

This was a house show match with an amazing PPV-level finish: the Profits levelled Gable with a Blockbuster to the outside in a demented spot that was perfectly executed.

Star Rating: ★★¾


6. Bianca Belair, Asuka & Alexa Bliss Vs. Bayley, Dakota Kai & Iyo Sky

Asuka Bayley
WWE.com

The UK fans aren't ironic or contrarian.

The reaction to the opener proper was nothing personal against Bianca Belair. They are simply besotted with Bayley and hold treasured memories of the NXT live event tour of 2015: the best house show series the UK has ever seen. She was incredible at doing everything she could think of to dispel the reaction, but an older, rabid fanbase recognised how clever the improvisation was and fell for her even harder. This opening six-woman tag was very good and super loud.

A story of a collective versus three individuals, the teamwork informed Damage Control's win following a stunning last three minutes. The idea to hold Bianca in place by the ropes by her braid, allowing Kai to kick her flush in the face, was a super creative means of telling that story.

Throughout, the action was exciting without ever hitting true, mind-blowing exhilaration, but the reception was so warm that it was a glorious spectacle nonetheless.

Asuka and Iyo Sky continued to tease an exceptional singles match, Alexa levelled up to more skilled opponents and rivals in what was her best performance in years, and in a bold finish, Bayley pinned Bianca Belair to emerge as a badly needed main event heel player.

Star Rating: ★★★½


5. Gunther Vs. Sheamus - Intercontinental Title Match

Gunther Sheamus
WWE.com

This was incredible.

It was the best WWE match of the year, but that sells it short almost. There's no need for the qualifier; this was so physical, dramatic and deafeningly loud that it barely felt like a WWE match. Since WWE almost perfected the quintessential WWE match in the main event, this was a fantastic night for a promotion that has both rediscovered itself and marched forward.

Part of rediscovering itself means letting down tens and thousands of fans, but still.

This was crafted in such a patient, extraordinary way. It was the fight everybody expected. They beat the absolute f*ck out of each other. Watching live in the stadium, from the upper decks, some of Gunther's chops were somehow audible. The match was built around Sheamus attempting to trap Gunther with the beats of the bodrhan. Encapsulating the great struggle at the core of the match, even at the third, successful attempt, Gunther tried to battle free as the crowd counted. He didn't just stand there frozen. This match was the perfect intersection of crowd interaction and a super competitive, intimate war.

This was Sheamus' career-best performance. His selling was incredible. His body looked like battered sh*t by the finish, his eyes were dead. The way in which he evoked sympathy and drew the crowd back, to the point of several standing ovations, was incredible.

Run it back.

Run it back forever.

A true classic.

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


4. Liv Morgan Vs. Shayna Baszler - SmackDown Women's Title Match

Shayna Baszler Liv Morgan
WWE.com

The crowd was exhausted after watching an emotional Sheamus soak up the adulation that a superb body of work has always deserved.

This, combined with Liv Morgan's dud of a SmackDown Women's title reign, created an apathetic atmosphere in the building. She did well to get the crowd somewhat into it as she fought through a painful onslaught of submission offence by the finish. Liv countered with some MMA stylings of her own, and while the technical application of the work wasn't terribly convincing, the comeback almost worked because of it. She was out-skilled, but fought with enough guts and spirit to convince the crowd to get behind her. A bit.

When she broke free of Shayna's grasp and created enough space to fly into strikes, her kicks didn't look particularly credible either, which is always going to look more glaring against an opponent of Baszler's calibre. In the end, though, she did just about enough to get the desired reaction.

Is that impressive, given the match that preceded it, or should she have done more to get something out of a crowd so hot on the night elsewhere?

That's up for debate, but Liv needed an unqualified great night after this bad spell - and this wasn't it.

Star Rating: ★★¾


3. Edge & Rey Mysterio Vs. Finn Bálor & Damian Priest

Edge 619
WWE.com

As somebody who attended WrestleMania XXX live in person, Edge's pop rivalled Daniel Bryan's. The man was incredibly over.

This match was so much fun in the building. Unfussy, light, and nostalgic, its crowd-pleasing vibe didn't detract from the drama. The babyface win and glorious 2002 callbacks did however obscure the post-match angle in plain sight. The use of contrasts here really was expert shock tactic storytelling. Watching Edge and Rey Mysterio work like it was 2002 with their old double team signatures was so great - astonishing, really, given their respective ages and injury records. Without being a classic, this was masterful stuff across the board. The build to Edge's hot tag was loaded with hope.

In a scene that shocked the stadium, Dominick blasted Edge in the balls and mirrored exactly the Eddie Guerrero heel turn which, combined with his mullet, was superb, detailed booking.

The heel run might very well fail, because Dom is hardly a great TV performer, but the turn itself, complete with Finn Bálor pissing himself laughing, was inch-perfect.

Star Rating: ★★★½


2. Matt Riddle Vs. Seth 'Freakin' Rollins

Matt Riddle Seth Rollins
WWE.com

This was a very good to at times excellent version of a match that Seth Rollins and Matt Riddle shouldn't have had.

Yes, Riddle was furious in the opening exchange, kicking several shades of sh*t out of Seth's thigh to convey how pissed he was after Monday's shoot-style promo exchange. Beyond that however, structurally, this felt indistinguishable from most modern main event style matches: methodical start, finisher theft sequences, big kick-outs down the stretch.

Again: it was an excellent version of that genre of match, and the tone was nasty when the action was laboured, at least. They lost the crowd for five early minutes of a match that was very Triple H, but the second they got out of 2003, this was great. Rollins, the obnoxious heel ar*ehole, taunted Riddle by mimicking "Wandy's" signature offence. He was so charismatic and witty that he split the live crowd right down the middle in a sequence that informed the finish.

After a blistering series of counters executed beautifully, Riddle grabbed a chair. Rollins evaded the assault, and when Riddle slid back into the ring, he was met with a curb stomp. A top-rope variation ended it.

Another heat-heavy finish, Rollins is such a beloved fixture of WWE at this point that half of the stadium was happy, at least.

Star Rating: ★★★★¼


1. Roman Reigns Vs. Drew McIntyre - Undisputed WWE Universal Title Match

Roman Reigns Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

For so long, this was timeless pro wrestling magic.

Without doing much, Reigns and McIntyre had a white-hot crowd on strings. That's not to say they added 10 minutes of a chinlock to a match to waste time. The cagey start, in which both men recognised the danger that the other possessed, was superb in generating thick tension. Reigns in particular was on superb form, telling the story of his being more scared than he was prepared to acknowledge with his face. The pacing was exquisite.

The match felt enormous by the time they exchanged, with perfect dramatic timing, the big bombs, and the traditional epic big match feel was so well established that, when Austin Theory threatened to cash in, it felt like a transgression. The crowd bought two near-falls late to create a cauldron of an atmosphere. In the building, the fans weren't performative when counting 1, 2, 3 before the Spear and Claymore kick-outs. They lost their minds when they hadn't actually seen the finish yet. The finish itself was a superb delivery of an ill-advised idea. That crowd was convinced Drew was winning, were deflated when he didn't as a result of Solo Sikoa's shock debut. If not Drew, then who?

If WWE gets another babyface this hot, it will take some bloody doing.

Drama out the ass, but a familiar, alienating feeling.

Star Rating: ★★★★½


In this post: 
Sheamus
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!