7 Secret Versions Of Classic WWE Matches
Featuring the *****1/4 version of a rare-in-itself main roster classic.
The non-existent chapter select function and inexplicable search algorithm aside - if you type in ROCK AUSTIN, you aren't directed to the WrestleMania X-Seven main event but rather ROCK star Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. AUSTIN Aries, for f*ck's sake, f*ck your marketing - WWE's Network is wonderful.
It doesn't merely track history, it actively curates it; the recent discovery of the Bret Hart Vs. Tom Magee Holy Grail presented to subscribers the secret history of WWE in addition to its on-demand library of endlessly consumable content. The WWE Network is a manifest, affordable, black market wish list that enriches our understanding of a past once thought impossible to recover.
That aforementioned match was once considered the collector's item among the most ardent of hardcores. Bret Hart is just tremendous in his performance; mastering the space between moves in such a way that it framed his soft, goosesh*t-green opponent as a force of nature without barely executing any, this discovery didn't just satisfy an itch on an unreachable area of the back; it afforded Bret, grimly downtrodden in later life, a euphoric last-minute karmic pinfall.
Cameras were not present at several of the following tentative experiments, sadly - but the beauty of the Network is such that we don't have to stop believing.
7. The 1987 Royal Rumble Match
The WWF debuted the Royal Rumble match in 1988 as part of a televised special on the USA Network.
Ahead of a meeting with Dick Ebersol, Pat Patterson pitched a variation on the standard battle royal to Vince McMahon. To circumvent the mass of static flesh, Patterson's creation would see two men start the match, with the remaining field entering the ring at timed intervals, thus substituting minutes of tedious non-action for calculable drama. That way, when the field fattened out, the sense of anticipation would sustain the interest of the crowd throughout the epic duration.
Vince McMahon didn't green-light the pitch with a booming "That's such good sh*t"; instead, he casually dismissed it as "stupid" before failing to improve on the idea and running with it, anyway. He trusted Patterson's genius at a time when he was more receptive to collaboration.
The WWF tested the concept the year prior in St. Louis. CBSSports later collated an excellent oral history of the first, underwhelming-at-best experiment. Featuring just 12 men undirected by the absent Patterson, the talent had no idea how to work the match, and the crowd had no idea how to react to it without the visual countdown cues and the unflappable Howard Finkel's famous breakdown of the convoluted rules.
One Man Gang won the first-ever Rumble, but doesn't have much recollection, suppressing the memory alongside that time he was made to perform as a deeply problematic white black man.
6. The Rumble In The Garden
[A previous version of this article was written before I discovered/watched the YouTube upload - Sidgwick]
Held just prior to the 1994 Royal Rumble pay-per-view, itself an unforgettable intersection of all that was awesome and naff at the precipice of the New Generation Era, the 'Rumble In The Garden' saw Owen Hart triumph ahead of his legendary heel turn.
Owen was a massive bumper of incredible stamina and cheeky ingenuity; a lengthy stint in a venue that demanded talents lace up their working boots, even without the presence of TV cameras, virtually guaranteed a superb performance from one of WWE's greatest in-ring wizards. At one point, he slid out of the ring, causing Johnny Polo to tumble over the ropes, before eliminating him with a crunching flying headbutt.
A less heralded but almost equally spectacular babyface worker in Marty Jannetty almost stole the final third; he and former Rocker rival Shawn Michaels pelted each other's brains in to molten MSG heat in a moment that powers through the cheap VHS grain to become vibrant in its heated star power.
Crush was handed an elimination spree ahead of his major match against Randy Savage at WrestleMania X in the same venue - this company once treated continuity more carefully on house shows than on television - but Bret Hart ended his watch before staying ringside to urge his brother to victory. The knowledge that it exists, albeit outside of canon and in dire quality, enhances Owen's heel turn in retrospect. What a little sh*t he was to betray Bret after that show of support.
What a magnificent little sh*t.
5. The Osaka Royal Rumble
On May 9, 1994, the WWF presented an 18-man house show Royal Rumble in Osaka, Japan. Bootleg camera footage of the match exists on the pirated fringes of the Internet.
Rick Martel and Bob Backlund kicked things off, working a more frantic pace bespoke to the Japanese audience, before Backlund attempted a roll-up, the batsh*t geezer, and the commentators pissed themselves laughing - whether at the botch, or the idea of bringing him back and deeming Randy Savage too old to wrestle full-time, isn't entirely clear.
The footage isn't, either; it is at times an unwatchable snowstorm of static (still preferable to Kevin Dunn's HD camera cuts). Jinsei Shinzaki (who became Hakushi) entered the fray in the #3 slot, and did absolutely nothing but wait for either Martel or Backlund to eliminate the other, unhelpfully digging a plot hole in the process. Shinzaki and the 1-2-3 Kid provided much of the entertainment as the resulting field idled by the ropes, and it is Shinzaki who provided the high spot of the match with his psycho bump to the outside. He missed the Kid by a fraction of a second in a mad elimination as perfectly timed as it was courageous and or stupid. The crowd reacted to that, but to little else, for this was a tedious Rumble match.
The Undertaker, killed off in January only to return at SummerSlam, descended from heaven for the night to emerge victorious. He proved, even all those years ago, that his battered body never stopped him from bagging a handsome payday.
4. Bret Hart Vs. Owen Hart - Iron Man Match
The first (canonical) WWE Iron Man match is perhaps the most divisive ever presented by the company.
The last 15 minutes were fire, but that fire was lit on piss-soaked tinder; Bret entered a logical but staunchly dull defensive performance that bored the arena senseless and, in the end, was rendered meaningless; the 0-0 match simply restarted, and Shawn won in overtime. Fascinatingly stiff is about the only positive superlative to apply. At various points - far too many - were Baron Corbin and Jinder Mahal to wrestle an Iron Man bout on RAW next week, it wouldn't look at all dissimilar to this dire chinlock festival.
Shawn was like a woodpecker to Bret Hart's psyche, and tensions simmered long before 1997; Shawn developed a habit of breaking Bret's heart by adapting his secret house show raves onscreen, the most intriguing of which saw the Hitman battle his brother in Iron Man matches over the summer of 1994 before the WWF settled on a steel cage stipulation at SummerSlam.
Reports of those matches promise an unseen technical wrestling utopia. In one Nassau Coliseum match, Owen took two falls over Bret in as many minutes via figure-four leg lock. The idea of Owen going back to the leg, relentlessly, and Bret's graduating comeback, is such stuff as selling dreams are made of.
That steel cage match was incredible for the way in which Bret and Owen worked around a stipulation unsuited to the PG arena. A series of matches in which their awesome chemistry was not inhibited, but enhanced, marks it as another Holy Grail.
Hart's genius was both timeless and endless.
3. Razor Ramon Vs. Shawn Michaels - Dark Ladder Matches
The WrestleMania X Intercontinental Title Ladder classic, between Razor Ramon and Shawn Michaels, is like the Kraftwerk of pro wrestling matches: simultaneously groundbreaking and timeless, it bears none of the dated, unrefined hallmarks that naturally come with genre experimentation.
Arriving perfectly-formed with a Germanic precision, the match didn't so much influence a genre but rewrite the language of professional wrestling; every WWE weapons match can in some way be traced back to Shawn and Razor's masterpiece. The ladder wasn't used as stunt pretext but a necessary strategical measure to out-best one another in the confines of a worked fight; Michaels only drove it into Razor's gut after the Bad Guy lunged at him with a bullet-speed lariat that sent him flying to the outside.
Scott Hall in the years since has revealed that he and Shawn practised this match on the house show circuit.
Speaking to Cult of Whatever in 2013, Hall set the pulses of collector geeks racing: "To be honest, we had some better matches before WrestleMania. Sometimes, the ladder does some cool stuff, or the ladder would just fall the right way and hit the guy right in the crotch, or it will bounce off the rope and do something cool."
A better match than a ***** classic, and one in which 1990s D*ckhead Vintage Michaels was potentially creamed square in the balls?
Shawn might have won another battle against Bret Hart by casually wrestling an even more intriguing Holy Grail...
2. 5-Man Dark Hell In A Cell Match
It reads as some over-thought daft sh*te that is normally the preserve of Saudi Arabia, but on September 26, 2011, in front of what presumably was an ice-cold market, WWE presented a bizarre Fatal 5-Way Hell In A Cell match as a desperate dark match attraction.
John Cena, Dolph Ziggler, Jack Swagger, Alberto Del Rio and CM Punk entered the doors of Satan's Playground, and none of them were quite the same afterwards. No, that's not true; they phoned in a nothing match and barely collided with the steel, as best as can be inferred from the shaky, nausea-inducing smartphone footage.
WWE has uploaded clipped professional footage of the match, but it's nothing you haven't seen before; in fact, it's something you used to see all of the f*cking time.
Five men, in a Hell In A Cell match, harkens back to the blood-soaked hoot of Armageddon 2000, but here, John Cena didn't take a psycho plunge onto a bed of hay. Here, John Cena...halfheartedly jogged through his Five Moves of Doom sequence, instigating a finisher spam-fest from which he stands tall. It's a pointless watch, but something quite wonderful reveals itself after a minute or so; the action isn't the gnarly, ugly drama one might expect from the stipulation, but there's a stark, beautiful silence to it, euphorically subverting the theme.
(It's a dark match so Michael Cole isn't commentating)
1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Bret Hart - Ladder Match
Not technically a secret, since the WWF released the match on home video, but Bret Hart is never credited in canon for importing the Stampede Wrestling experiment to the company - nor is he credited for starring in the first, experimental iteration.
Bret made sure not to walk under the ladder during his entrance, as if fate gave half a f*ck. Bret pummelled Michaels in the opening phase, and Michaels sold that old, concrete WWF ring with a pained conviction. They say, now, that the apron is the hardest part of the ring. Before the WWF made the sensible, belated decision to add more spring to it, every part of that ring was the hardest, and Michaels sold it as the ultimate battleground.
Gorilla Monsoon was a joy on commentary. "She has a tattoo - right on her breast!" he said of Sensational Sherri, in a quite endearing display of moral outrage, before going full Jerry Lawler and requesting a close-up, just to make sure.
The primitive match was a committed but gruelling exercise in delayed gratification, fought at a deliberate pace with a strategic bent. It at times lived down to those euphemisms. There were no birdbrained decisions employed, but the lack of urgent, escalatory drama flattened the pace. Sensational Sherri was the difference-maker; this wasn't a relentless, unyielding war that required a bold high spot to finally settle it, although Shawn did yeet himself right into the steel near the finish.
The crowd is almost too anxious to react to a punishing and unprecedented match, creating a weird and distracting dissonance between the suffering endured and the sympathy directed towards it.
It's better than the Iron Man match, but then...