7 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Dynamite (3 May - Review)
AEW Dynamite returns to form as Double Or Nothing comes together and title pictures clear up.
Momentum is everything in wrestling, and for the first time in a while All Elite Wrestling went into an episode of Dynamite with absolutely loads.
In an odd similarity to the last time wrestling ran the UK's biggest stadium, the United States markets have been a little soft for AEW of late, but that wasn't a concern when pre-sale opened for the company's All In spectacular later this year. 36,000 pre-sale tickets were sold on the first day, instantly making it AEW's biggest show ever. Further pre-sales and general sale dates may well bring the attendance close to Wembley Stadium's mammoth 80-90,000 capacity, and that's before a single match has been announced.
It all stands as a monument to the organisation's relationship with its base, even if that has felt a little tenuous domestically. There's time to address a disappointing Double Or Nothing build, but it's disappointing to even speak in those terms when AEW is leading from the front with a battle between pillars and a huge showdown between The Elite and The Blackpool Combat Club.
But momentum is everything in wrestling, and could AEW get a burst of that transatlantic energy?
Let’s light the fuse…
Downs…
1. Ricky Starks Vs Juice Robinson
Not for the want of trying, Juice Robinson and Ricky Starks struggled to recover from a mid-match spot that saw Starks' spiked and the two briefly work through a few miscommunications en route to the finish.
Falling afoul of the 2023 Good Wrestling Curse, this was "just" a nice bit of in-ring business from two men trapped in a story that feels like it's lost its way. If it ever even had it.
Jay White didn't get involved until after the bout and 'Switchblade' and 'Absolute' have looked a Double Or Nothing lock since Robinson's arrival several weeks ago, but there's never been a personal issue established between the pair. They're fighting because it's the natural pairing, but last week's Rampage tag satiated some of it, and neither man feels positioned to thrive afterwards regardless of the result.
Ups…
7. Adam Cole, Roderick Strong, Orange Cassidy & Bandido Vs The JAS
Given traditionally one of the hottest spots on the show, an eight-man tag that looked more wacky than good in the build turned out to be the perfect use of every babyface and an expert way to advance the bubbling dissension between Adam Cole and Chris Jericho.
With multiple showcase moments for Orange Cassidy, Bandido and the returning Roderick Strong, the battle itself existed for their benefit more than Cole’s, but his crucial involvement put over his drive and desire.
After scoring the decisive blow and pinfall win, Cole raced up the ramp to get at the JAS leader in an important reminder of the company All Elite Wrestling is supposed to be. All the walls of Jericho had fallen, between the members of his group blocking the path earlier, and the invisible one AEW have relied too much on lately. He wasn’t ready, he got a little bit of what was coming to him, and then ate more sh*t courtesy of a Dr Britt Baker DMD slap he sold huge for. Fans in the building popped massively for both faces getting their pounds of flesh too, which bodes well for whatever remains between now and the pay-per-view.
6. Big Fight Build
The Blackpool Combat Club and Kenny Omega shared words rather than actions this week, with May 10th’s Steel Cage Match built up - as it should be - as a point of no return for the warring factions.
In another BCC stairwell in Baltimore, Bryan Danielson was yet again sublime in his indignation about what it is to be really be the best, and a needless shot at Bret Hart seems perfect to fold in FTR, CM Punk(!) or Bryan’s own attempt to win the upcoming Owen Hart Invitational when the company heads to Canada in June. Meanwhile, Moxley made it crystal clear that the beating he was ready to give ‘The Best Bout Machine’ was - in keeping with the group’s psychotic modus operandi - for the entire industry’s gains as well as his own. Moxley spoke in such grandiose terms about his wars with Omega over the last four years that next week’s clash immediately felt like the most important chapter in the company’s true greatest legacy programme.
Maybe it will be.
Omega promised violence on par or beyond what we’ve already seen between the two, but Don Callis talking about the enormous scar left by the group as a daily reminder of the blood that has already been shed was clearly all the motivation the former AEW World Heavyweight Champion needed. Vengeance for everybody (apart from Hangman Page) was promised. The first time he won that belt, Callis was key.
Just how will ‘The Invisible Hand’ factor into next week’s showdown?
5. Saraya Vs Willow Nightingale
Hikaru Shida's first appearance on Dynamite since January paid off everything that was going on with her when she was last aligned with Saraya and Toni Storm, and actually progressed the story between the warring sides for the first time in a while.
Saraya had just defeated Willow Nightingale in a decent effort with ample help from Storm and Soho, and the trio of heels were continuing to beat the popular star down post-match when Shida's music hit and her apparent heel turn was confirmed. The former Women's Champion joined up with the villains, but Dr Britt Baker DMD and Jamie Hayter appeared from behind in a mirroring of the Outcasts set-up alongside Chris Jericho a fortnight ago and revealed the ruse. The AEW original was indeed part of the Homegrowns, and the Outcasts ate sh*t for a change.
An unexpected return made for a great moment, and the story moving forward was a welcome break from the usual rinse-and-repeat formula with this story. That it paid off a loose thread was a reminder of what can make the organisation so great at its core, and hopefully bodes well for whatever grand payoff is coming for the ongoing turf war.
4. Tres de Mayo Trios Battle Royale
Bolstered by an intriguing change to the rules of Trios matches (as long as the House Of Black have the belts, it's no rope breaks and 20-counts outside), the Tres de Mayo Trios Battle Royale was another AEW multi-man that offered some nice intra-match action while also informing a bigger picture just in time for Double Or Nothing.
Eventual victors The Acclaimed and Billy Gunn secured their spot on the pay-per-view (or became next in line for the champions at another to-be-determined date), El Hijo Del Vikingo and The Lucha Brothers's battles with Powerhouse Hobbs, QT Marshall and Aaron Solo immediately led to a Rampage trios bout between the two sides, and The Butcher & The Blade's always-the-bridesmaids-never-the-brides Battle Royale lore continued with the contest's thrilling conclusion.
Going under 10 minutes, the whole thing carried that same frenetic energy associated with typical title defences, and shone some much-needed spotlight on a division that had gone begging over the last few weeks.
3. Wardlow Vs Logan Laroux
Wardlow's brutal destruction of Logan Laroux existed to create another standoff with Christian Cage and Luchasaurus, but the squash was yet another step in the TNT Champion's long journey back to the position he was in about 12 months ago.
Working with confidence again, Wardlow adding Armed Anderson's gun taunt before finishing his feckless opponent was a nice nod to 'Double A', not least considering the difference the Horseman seems to have made while stood by his side.
Of note, Cage confirmed that he'd be the one wrestling for the title rather than his 'Right Hand Of Destruction', teeing up a match that might actually be better than the projected monster mash between the two behemoths. Wardlow conquering either of them down the road should continue his steady re-ascension.
2. Sandy Fork Becomes Planet Jarrett
A just-about-perfect slice of pro wrestling comedy found Jeff Jarrett, Jay Lethal, Satnam Singh and Sonjay Dutt visiting Mark Briscoe's farm in Sandy Fork to help out with chores, entertain the children and woo Papa Briscoe whilst barely covering their real (and sinister) motivations.
Pitched magnificently, the heels made clear their strategy at last - befriend Mark in order to get intel on how to beat FTR for the AEW Tag Team Championships, but Briscoe himself was sublime at playing just naive enough to make them think the plan was working. Papa Briscoe swallowing absolutely none of their bullsh*t was one of the many highlights, as was Jeff Jarrett almost dusting off "With My Baby Tonight" in a campfire moment.
Bringing together some superb characters that have an impeccable understanding of their characters and how to do wrestling comedy, this felt like peak TNA comedy mixed with AEW warmth and wit, and served its purpose from a business perspective too - the Double Or Nothing tag team title clash will be super-heated, particularly if Jarrett et al have cruelly grown tired of sucking up to Briscoe by then.
1. Sammy Guevara & MJF Vs Jungle Boy & Darby Allin
A quality (if predictable) main event saw Double Or Nothing's main event story finally get back on track after Jungle Boy Jack Perry and Darby Allin vanquished MJF and Sammy Guevara, putting paid to the uneasy and doomed alliance between the heels in the process.
Memphis stuff but all the better for it, working the heat over illegal use of MJF's scarf was the sort of agenting that inspires yet more hope that the power might well be creeping back. Sammy Guevara's inevitable turn following dissension in the ranks got him the most over he's been in this story so far, and the seeds of discontent MJF attempted to sow during the broadcast failed to sprout until the fall was registered.
There's been lots of justifiable criticisms about how long and winding the road to this inevitable match graphic has been, but upon arrival at the destination everything finally clicked. With three Dynamites left before the show, keeping it simple could and should be the way to preserve this renewed faith.