7 Ups & 1 Down From AEW Revolution 2023 (Review)

AEW overcome flat build to deliver one of the best pay-per-views EVER.

Hangman Page Jon Moxley
AEW

The general consensus was that AEW Revolution 2023 was a two match show - and since AEW had ran Jon Moxley Vs. Hangman Page three times on TV prior to it, the old feeling of rapt anticipation was missing.

It was still an excellent prospect on paper; while the approximate 39 hours of television between the quarterly pay-per-view cycle should mean far more, for fours at least, high-end action was all but guaranteed last night. The roster is simply too talented for that not to happen.

But how true was that?

Running two grudge matches that required blood represented a risk of diminishing returns, and to compound things, Jack Perry Vs. Christian Cage hasn't truly been hot since last summer. Chris Jericho Vs. Ricky Starks was more cold than any featured upper midcard match in the history of AEW on pay-per-view. Surely, it was never going to beat their first meeting on January 4, and there, the atmosphere was more hot than the action. Jericho Vs. Starks 2: Quieter and Longer hardly seemed like a blockbuster sequel, especially after that phoned-in cliché of a gauntlet-driven build.

Saraya's saviour complex incited a bizarre ripple effect in which the women's division did end up revolving around her - and became really quite bad. She hadn't performed to the expected level, either. Wardlow and Samoa Joe had already worked a fairly unremarkable limb work match that hardly felt like a spectacle of a hoss fight. The carny irreverent fun of the Acclaimed Vs. Jeff Jarrett and the lads peaked on TV and didn't feel worth the premium PPV fee.

Did Revolution over-deliver...?


Downs...

1. Not A Great Night For Wardlow

Wardlow Samoa Joe
AEW

Wardlow Vs. Samoa Joe was the one flaw on a show that was otherwise brilliantly sequenced.

In and of itself, the match was decent. Wardlow impressed with his bombastic aerial spots, and the byproduct of Samoa Joe's monster push was that, deep in the stretch, the crowd bought the fact that he could put Wardlow to sleep. The right man won, but the result while correct didn't register as some great comeback story.

The fans were exhausted by the intense, terrifying Texas Death match. Anything that followed was damned, irrespective of what that something was, but it was imperative that Wardlow emerged from Revolution as the superstar he was this time last year. That didn't happen; instead, the match just existed for the most part. The concept behind the finish was astute - in successfully using the Coquina clutch, Wardlow, ceremoniously, became the new monster in AEW - but it scanned as anticlimactic. The drama had not been built sufficiently.

Everything looked crisp and impactful, and this unfussy sequel wasn't as drawn-out and tame as their first encounter, but it felt inessential compared to most everything else on the card - that it did not even approach the greatness of Joe's programme with Darby Allin also worked against it.

Wardlow - who is still very over most weeks - felt somewhere between an afterthought and a consolation prize.


Ups...

7. Hot Opener

Ricky Starks Chris Jericho
AEW

Chris Jericho didn't become a legend by not knowing what he's doing.

The cynical take is that he lobbied to nab the hot opener and guaranteed himself a strong reaction. The sensible take is that Tony Khan, knowing this was the coldest big programme in the company, pushed it to the front so that it would benefit from a hot, excited crowd. That it did, and in either event, it was a smart decision.

At a tight 14 minutes, it achieved its two objectives: it set the tone for a phenomenal night of action, without being phenomenal in and of itself, and further cast Ricky Starks as a player. The action peaked at very good - the match was in the ***1/2 range - but the crowd was up for it, and if there's a benefit to Jericho's perception as a clout vampire, it's that the correct result wasn't expected as a formality. The fear lingered from the Eddie Kingston programme to add an edge to this.

Not as great as the best of Jericho's 2022 output, it was still dramatic and well-worked. The duality of Jericho however was in effect; after hitting his best Codebreaker counter in an age - he neutralised that Starks spear with impeccable timing - he took far too long to make the cover. This dampened the effect of the near-fall. The finish was tremendous; Starks defended the Judas Effect with a cool, unique block and struck the Roshambo for the win.

Jericho likes to be put in a position to put people over, but he does put them over. Acclaimed next alongside Sammy Guevara will do nicely; the former champions will need something important to do over the spring.


6. A Masterpiece Of Tone

Jack Perry Christian Cage
AEW

It's great to be proven wrong, and expectations were low for Jack Perry Vs. Christian Cage.

Actually, it was difficult to have any expectations at all; AEW's social media first advertised a No Holds Barred match after Perry's vague challenge of a "fight" on Dynamite before the 'Final Burial' stip was announced on Rampage. The framing of Perry's promos also hinted at - or threatened - a cinematic-style attraction.

As it happens, it was a casket match - and an unfathomably brilliant one.

This was outrageously good and creative, infinitely better than anything the Undertaker ever did. Cage - in full turtleneck! - was on delightful form in particular. Sh*t-scared of the casket, he wrestled the match like a rat. One of the best match layout architects and counter specialists in wrestling history, the stip was beyond inspired because it maximised his slimy character work. He wanted none of it, and was at his cunning best to avoid it. The gimmick also allowed Perry, a great working babyface, to outwit Cage and guide him towards his fate.

The climactic sequence was fantastic. Loaded with suspense and schlocky to a massively entertaining extent, the set design didn't detract from what was brilliantly worked mutual loathing.

In the end, after a brutal Con-chair-to, Perry slammed the lid shut - and in a superb practical effect, the casket plummeted below the floor immediately. He went to hell where he belonged.

A tiny bit silly, but mostly very intelligent, super-cathartic business.


5. The Elite Do What The Elite Do

Kenny Omega House Of Black
AEW

In a shocker of a result, the House of Black dethroned Trios champions the Elite.

In an altogether less surprising development, the match was out-of-this-world phenomenal.

It was phenomenal immediately and only escalated its breathtaking exhilaration. Kenny Omega and Malakai Black worked a martial arts-inspired standoff that was just stupidly great. The timing was unbelievable; the intent behind every attempted strike was so full-on that, were it all not so perfectly-timed, one of them may have suffered a head injury. But it was all timed perfectly. Everything was.

What the Elite do - and this was outrageous even by their standards - is magic. The ambition should be impossible. They simultaneously do so much in these absolute barnburners and generate the feeling that you never want it to end. In one of the most famous trios wars ever, Do Fixer and Blood Generation worked a match at ROH Supercard of Honor 2006 so fantastic that the fans, audibly, begged them not to go to the finish. Somehow, the Elite have bottled that magic, and sell the potion time and time again.

As ever, an incredible amount of thought went into it. Brody King was depicted as the Final Boss, and to put this thread over, he kicked out of an awesome Nick Jackson 450 at one. In another great detail, as the match reached a breathless, all-action crescendo, Kenny Omega had to join the superkick party just to make him wobble. The Young Bucks' signature tandem move was enough to send Black and Buddy Matthews to the outside, but King, who has never looked more like a total beast, was treated with that bit more reverence. Omega couldn't even hit him with the snap dragon, let alone the One-Winged Angel.

Omega and Black need to work a singles match at some point because holy f*cking s**t: their work deeper into the match was sublime. Omega destroyed him with a multiple snap dragon salvo, but couldn't position him for the One-Winged Angel. He was distracted by Julia Hart, who ate an unintentional V-Trigger. Omega's shrug of the shoulders was priceless.

The finish was amazing; Buddy Matthews with inch-perfect timing caught Nick Jackson mid-rotation with a knee flush to the face to counter the Meltzer Driver, who succumbed to Dante's Inferno.

If the Elite can combine this level of in-ring with the intricate storytelling prowess of 2020-2021, something very special beckons.


4. Women's Three-Way JUST Gets Over The Line

Saraya Jamie Hayter
AEW

If the standard in-house review format at WhatCulture Wrestling was 'Ups, Downs, & In-Betweens', this would fall under the latter category - but as it stands, Jamie Hayter Vs. Ruby Soho Vs. Saraya was just about good enough to warrant an 'Up'.

There was a far better women's match on free television 48 hours before this one happened, which isn't ideal, but the crowd was remarkably up for it. Too often, Tony Khan has asked the women to follow the Elite, which is hardly fair. Whatever you think of their work, they are guaranteed to make the AEW live crowds go banana.

The San Francisco crowd actually reacted to much of three-way match, which really wasn't half-bad for what it was. The genre trappings are what they are, but the fake selling on the outside wasn't as egregious as it all too often can be, and the action was physical and was constructed well enough to wrong-foot the audience. Any time one wrestler seemed to grab the advantage, a well-timed interception kept the momentum going. The oft-derided Saraya was up for this; she wasn't outclassed, and took a nasty-looking Saito suplex from Ruby Soho. This was encouraging; she's bound to work Hayter in a singles match this year, and proved herself capable of the inevitable sh*t-kicking that comes with it.

The post-match angle was mixed. The timing was poor.

Ruby Soho turned after beating up Saraya throughout the match. She should have dwelled on the result and the frustration and turned on Dynamite before doing the if-you-can't-beat-them-join-them deal here.

Still, it was a newsworthy development that, and this is probably generous, at least means that the bad acting of melodramatic inner conflict is over with. The stable warfare storyline is set now - and if there was a lesson to be learned at Revolution, it's that you should let things play out in this promotion.


3. This Is What Pro Wrestling Violence Should Look Like

Hangman Page Jon Moxley Revolution
AEW

Wrestling violence isn't being speared through a barricade. It should be horrifying. And so long as these people aren't staring at their hands, it should horrify its heroes.

Bruno Sammartino walked out of the cage when the bad guys had had enough. Here, Hangman Page nearly choked Jon Moxley to death at the awesome finish of an incredible, committed and polarising Texas Death match - but only because he happened upon a means of leaving it behind.

The intensity with which it was worked bordered on terrifying. Bricks, barbed wire, chairs wrapped in the stuff: all were used to tell a simple, harrowing, compelling tale: who makes it out of the desert?

The drama was never overshadowed by the plunder. The disturbing set-pieces, like Page taking a somersault header through a suspended barbed wire board, would have meant nothing had both men not stumbled, dazed, into standing positions - sometimes with defiance, sometimes through dumb luck. The violence while grotesque wasn't executed for the sake of it.

An uneasy, agonising suspense was threaded through everything, and it never once peaked. The creeping feeling that only something awful could put an end to it never subsided, and the finish paid that off. Moxley tapping out was the perfect ending. He wasn't obsessed with keeping himself strong. The man was going to die. He had to escape.

What's ironic, given the inevitable outrage that followed the match, is that the blood was shed with purpose.

On the go-home Dynamite, Hangman Page lamented violence. Near the finish, Jon Moxley wrapped chain around his neck, but was undone by his thirst for blood.

Page did what he had to do when the opportunity presented itself to him. It was no source of pride, or even enjoyment. He was challenged as a man and the violence was a byproduct of that. Of his environment. Mox, cosplaying Bruiser Brody, used violence as something to glorify; Page recognised it a necessity.

The "wrestling is cinema" craze on Twitter is excruciating, but thematically, this had as much in common with a western as a pro wrestling grudge match. Wrestling is a lawless world, but it isn't without honour.


2. Probably Not Worth Undermining A Title For, But...

The Gunns
AEW

The Gunns retained their titles in a fun match cleverly slotted.

The ends - a fun, comedic match that coaxed the fans into a party atmosphere and gave them a second wind ahead of the main event - did not justify the means. Tony Khan could have accomplished this by booking Sting and Darby Allin to go over virtually anybody, and maintaining the prestige of the World Tag Team titles in the process, but he didn't.

Ultimately, the Acclaimed remain over, Jeff Jarrett's lads are still stupidly entertaining, and FTR are set to rebuild the importance of the belts. The puzzling meta game that Khan has played with the division of late is coming to an end, and this last round was raucous and played a quietly important role on a card that had to be great. Revolution '23 was so amazing that it restored the magic feeling that AEW has lacked this year. The second wind semi-main was such a great Tony Khan idea, and here, Orange Cassidy doing the Double J strut with his hands in his pockets did the trick.

The action was uneven. The saves, high spots and interrupted posing were timed well enough to draw laughter.

If FTR are going to get something outstanding out of the Gunns, it will require a career-best performance. Their slapstick, stalling bumping was fun, but they didn't own the occasion and really get over as the ar*ehole heels who commit daylight robbery. The finish didn't sting. It was anticlimactic. Then again, when the main thrust of the match was building a Satnam Singh bump, perhaps what passes for heat in 2023 was impossible.

Elsewhere, Orange Cassidy and Jay Lethal worked well together, not that that was the point. The point was to thread together silly b*llocks in a halfway intelligent and engrossing manner, and they pulled it off.


1. All-Time Classic Headlines

MJF Bryan Danielson
AEW

Not to denigrate the legendary Bret Hart, but there's an interesting comparison to be made here.

Per his autobiography, Hart was proud, during his Iron Man match at WrestleMania XII, when he caught a small moment to reflect and realised that he had followed the clock to the very second. Everything he had plotted unfolded with perfect precision.

With 59 minutes elapsed in a 60 minute Iron Man match, Bryan Danielson and MJF generated "Fight forever" chants. "Fight forever!" chants!

MJF and Danielson caught something else last night: a feeling thought impossible.

Bryan Danielson has a long-held goal of working a three hour match. On the evidence of this - a classic match, the architecture of which was a wonder of the wrestling world - he'd sell tickets for it and probably exceed all expectations.

The last 20 minutes were among the most dramatic ever worked in the history of the business. Fans were delighted by the fact that it might have gone even longer. Again: comparing wrestling to a prestige medium is an invitation to mockery, but the plotting here was worthy of Breaking Bad. In the best episodes of that show, it felt like there was no way out for Walter White. The series was at its best when the walls closed in, and you knew he was going to get away with it - there were several episodes and even seasons left - but you didn't know how. Because it was impossible.

Here, MJF was done. It was a predictable match heading in - the man around whom the future of AEW is being built wasn't going to lose his first PPV match - but in those last 20 minutes, you had no idea how. He was done. Bryan Danielson was going to dethrone him. In the thick of the action, he smiled as MJF wept, telling the story of their dynamic with a brilliant visual, because he knew it too. Suspension of disbelief was cultivated to perfection.

The trap MJF had successfully set for Ricky Starks at Winter Is Coming, attempted again here, didn't work. Danielson, the best technical wrestler ever, was simply too accomplished, his repertoire too deep. MJF was also gushing with blood. Minutes 50:00 to 55:00 were unbelievable. The tension was off the charts, and they were simply trading holds on the mat. The struggle elevated this to an immortal, elusive standard. They got the "Fight forever!" chants when they weren't even fighting. They got them when they were selling.

But don't discount the careful plotting of the first 40 minutes.

Through awesome mat exchanges, and one scintillating display of cardio in particular, Danielson had drained MJF's tank. His babyface spirit allowed him to endure MJF's desperate, uncharacteristic high spots in a more spectacular final third. Bryan preserved his own stamina levels at key moments. All of this informed the magic of the twist because Danielson had made himself look unbeatable.

The twist, the how MJF escaped, was so exquisite because it only revealed itself after normal time was up. You literally couldn't see it coming.

As overtime unfolded - and Tony Schiavone's giddiness at announcing it was genius, maintaining a plot thread first weaved when he called MJF a "pr*ck" all the way back in October 2019 - the oxygen tank used to treat MJF found its way to the outside. MJF, in a smash-and-grab, timed his cheating wonderfully. The last act of a desperate man went unseen, and like a true ar*ehole, he finished the job with Danielson's hold.

Five glowing stars.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!