7 Ups & 1 Down From WWE SmackDown (14 Feb - Results & Review)

WWE set up WrestleMania 41 matches, more Elimination Chamber fun and 2025's future on SmackDown.

Charlotte Flair Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

It was Valentine's Day, but there wasn't much love in the air on this week's SmackDown.

Charlotte Flair picked out Tiffany Stratton as her WrestleMania 41 opponent, Kevin Owens challenged Sami Zayn for a match in Toronto at Elimination Chamber, Jacob Fatu got some answers from Solo Sikoa before things fell apart again, Trish Stratus became Tiffany Stratton's new bestie, and Damian Priest qualified for the men's Chamber bout in a searing main event.

Meanwhile, WWE Champ Cody Rhodes is still waiting to find out what he'll be doing on the next PLE. Solo is a strong possibility, but things that happened right at the end of Friday's show could throw a spanner in the works. There won't be too much interest in a rematch between those guys anyway. Fatu taking matters into his own hands and trying to bring gold "back to the family" is a way better plot point. On Jacob: He stacked up well next to top stars like Cody and Drew McIntyre on the mic here.

It's only a matter of time before the 'Samoan Werewolf' takes up permanent residence in the main event scene. He certainly isn't one of several WWE stars in real danger of missing 'Mania. You've got to love what Triple H has been cooking up with Fatu lately.

Overall, this was a really good episode of the blue brand. There's only one 'Down' to report, and even that's avoidable if WWE's creative team bang their heads together a little more in the future. LA Knight has the United States Title challenger spot cornered though, so there isn't much for Carmelo Hayes to do right now.

Here's all the great, the good, the disappointing and the outright bad.


Down...

1. Carmelo Hayes Lacks Direction

Carmelo Hayes R-Truth
WWE.com

On the plus side, at least Carmelo Hayes was wrestling someone on his own brand this week (R-Truth moved in the seemingly never-ending Transfer Window), but a win over Truth isn't what Melo needs right now. The dude needs some direction. Being honest, accepting The Miz’s backstage offer and becoming “Melo Don’t Miz” wouldn’t be the worst thing for him right now.

A run in the tag-team ranks could do Hayes some good, because things aren’t working on the main roster thus far. There's time for that to change, but yeah - it’s been a bit rough for somebody who was a lightning rod on NXT, and that was unexpected. This fan definitely thought Melo would be a smash hit on SmackDown, especially when he was working with everyone from Cody Rhodes to Randy Orton.

The sensational series of matches he had with Andrade proved to be a false dawn too. Since then, Carmelo has been spinning his wheels and trying to find something/anything to remain relevant on TV. It perhaps says everything that his match was the only one that could've been deleted from scripts without anyone noticing on Friday night.

Yikes. That is not a good sign.

As the intro stated, LA Knight is next in line to challenge Shinsuke Nakamura for the United States Title. Hayes going after Shin was always far fetched 'cause they're both heels, but Melo badly needs creative to toss him a bone. It sucks to see somebody so talented working such lowly spots every other week. Maybe patience is a virtue?


Ups...

7. Guns Up (Los Garza Shines Again)

Motor City Machine Guns Los Garza
WWE.com

To their credit, Motor City Machine Guns vs. Los Garza didn’t try to be something it wasn’t. These lads didn’t have bags of time to work with, so they went the spot, spot, spot route and it clicked for them. Personally, one would actually like to see Los Garza become a focal point in this division, because they’ve got something about them and have been knocking it out of the park lately. Giving Sabin and Shelley the win wasn't a bad idea though.

The match was fun, and it's just the latest example of how much juice the tag division has on SmackDown these days. Machine Guns are working excellent bouts aplenty, Los Garza are coming into their own, DIY are fine champions, The Street Profits are sniffing around looking for respect, and even Pretty Deadly have a story path to follow. That's all anyone can reasonably ask from a well-rounded division.

Long may it continue.

Those who enjoy The Young Bucks style will get a kick out of Guns vs. Garza on this week's show. It was reminiscent of the sugar rush of spots the AEW duo work on their best days. Maybe not as fast as they like to go, but it was up there. There sure wasn't much room for selling in the match, admittedly, but sometimes all you need is a zippy, quickfire tag match to get the blood pumping.

Sabin and Shelley won, Angel and Berto looked good, and it's clear there's way more to come from everyone in the tag scene. A big multi-team bout at 'Mania could be an option. DIY defending vs. MCMG, Garza, Profits and Deadly isn't out of the question.


6. Similarities Don’t Hold Them Back

LA Knight The Miz
WWE.com

Some combos don't blend well in WWE. Steve Austin and The Undertaker always felt clunky, for some reason, but not because they were similar. There was just a weird lack of chemistry between two top names. Any worries that LA Knight and The Miz (who are similar) would be the same were put to bed mere minutes into their United States Title number one contendership battle on Friday.

Vic Joseph and Wade Barrett pointed to the parallels between Knight and Miz immediately, then put Knight over as more likeable. They do have a similar style, but both worked hard and had a solid match. LA won, and now he’s going after Shinsuke Nakamura’s US Title. This fan has gone back and forth on Knight’s booking recently, but he has no issues with LA vs. Naka happening again in 2025.

The post-match standoff was a bit odd because they didn’t come to blows, but that’s no biggie either.

Now, they can either headline a three hour episode of SmackDown (which would be sweet) or get a midcard spot at Elimination Chamber. It does look likely that Knight will be reclaiming the gold soon enough though, because there's probably more branching paths to go with him as champ than Shin. Oh well, it was worth it for Nakamura's Mortal Kombat-esque reinvention; his title win hardly made the belt worthless.

The Miz knows his role since moving to SmackDown too. He's there to make others look good, and could potentially help Carmelo Hayes out by teaming with him in the future. WWE presumably won't let that 'Melo Don't Miz' name go to waste.


5. Women's Qualifier Was Really Good

Naomi Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Firstly, it could be argued that Naomi is a less interesting addition to the women’s Chamber match than Chelsea Green, but that’s a minor gripe. These women worked well together, and the match was made better by Chelsea's shocked facials whenever Naomi had the cheek to kick out of her moves. Green’s character work is a regular highlight of her matches, that's for sure.

Another bonus here? There wasn’t too much interference from Piper Niven or Bianca Belair around ringside to distract from the in-ring work. Piper picked her spots to try help Chelsea, and Belair was only there as backup incase Niven stuck her nose in and tried to pull a fast one on Naomi. Their restraint was appreciated, 'cause it meant full focus could go on the actual match itself.

Later, Nick Aldis showed Naomi and Bianca footage of Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez fleeing the scene after Jade Cargill got injured last year. That means the Women's Tag Champs are heading to Raw (they can go anywhere with the belts) for a bit, which is totally fine. They don't really have much going on with SmackDown at the moment anyway; at least not until Jade returns and things get spicy on a heel turn for either reigning champion.

Green missing out on Chamber sucks a wee bit, but she'll survive provided WWE moves on from the boring Michin feud pronto. Her entertaining character work goes a long, long way. However, Chelsea deserves praise for her wrestling on Friday. She and Naomi produced a tidy match you should go out of your way to see.


4. The Formatting Of That Opening Segment

Jacob Fatu Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

If you've seen one WWE revolving door promo segment, you've seen them all. The company rarely deviates from the usual tropes (babyface welcomes fans to the show > heel interrupts > heel looks annoyed when someone else interrupts them etc etc), but such skits are fine if the characters involved are strong and have a connection with the live crowd. That was the case with Cody Rhodes, Drew McIntyre and Jacob Fatu.

Cody addressed Elimination Chamber and Solo Sikoa before being interrupted by Drew. That, in turn, brought Fatu out with Tama Tonga, and there was a hot staredown tease between McIntyre and Jacob before the big Scot bailed. Drew rightly pointed out that he already had his spot in the Chamber match wrapped up, so he wasn't interested in fighting Fatu until he’d qualified later that night (which he didn't). Interrupting an interruption, Solo showed up on the tron and Jacob marched off to get an explanation from him as to why he walked out post-Raw on Netflix debut.

This was all formatted in such a slick way. Of note, it's also very interesting that Cody said last week’s Samoan Spike from Sikoa wasn’t for him. Maybe everybody, including this writer, jumped the gun on being disappointed that they’re running back Rhodes vs. Solo. The jury's out on the need for it to happen at Chamber though.

A lively crowd helped motor things along here, but Cody, Drew and even Jacob all had valid things to say on the mic. Last week, McIntyre's appearance was stricken by some seriously weak material. That wasn't the case this time, thankfully.


3. Second Half Of Women’s Title Bout Hits

Nia Jax Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

Think of Tiffany Stratton vs. Nia Jax as a tale of two parts. The first half was a little uncoordinated and threatened to go off the rails. Nia, in particular, was clumsy and things weren’t coming off for either woman. Right then, it seemed like Jax was reverting to type from her first run. That's something WWE hinted at last year in storyline. One could almost hear the sound of keyboards/phones rattling and pinging away as people took to socials for a dig.

Mercifully, the second half was a vast improvement.

Nia and Tiffy turned things around during that second act, which was great to see. They're still likely capable of better, and a lot of people won’t like the disqualification finish, but the second half was good. Trish Stratus getting involved leads to a tag at Chamber in Toronto too, which is nothing to sniff at and keeps Stratton warm for Charlotte Flair heading into WrestleMania 41.

Honestly, either Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez or Nia and Candice LeRae would be a decent shout to replace Naomi and Bianca Belair as Women's Tag Champs once Jade Cargill returns and one of them turns heel. There are worse ideas on the table. Jax needs something fresh to do, LeRae has shown herself to be an able lackey, and there must be a reason why WWE decided not to have Tiffany pin Nia here.

They could've got to the Trish stuff post-match regardless, so they're not protecting Jax for no reason.

Skip the awkward early portions of this, but join in progress once Tiffany starts her comeback. That babyface fire will stand the champion in good stead if she manages to survive Charlotte in Las Vegas.


2. Sami Zayn’s Intense Pre-Tape

Sami Zayn
WWE

Everything Kevin Owens touches has been turning to gold since he went rogue. Anyone worried that chapter 8,262 of him turning on Sami Zayn would be boring should rest easy - it's going to be anything but. Sami's update showed why. WWE aired footage of his social media promo on SmackDown. Throughout, Zayn came across as a confused, realistic human being who's seeking answers.

He said that something feels different about this latest example of either one stabbing his mate in the back. This time, it wasn't about "getting ahead", but instead seems to revolve around Kev thinking Sami should've helped him cheat to beat Cody Rhodes at Royal Rumble. That's something Zayn thinks is pretty pathetic, especially after everything they've been through as friends and enemies.

In a neat touch, this candid to camera piece dispensed with the usual shouty/ranty wrestling promo style and went for something more subdued. Sami put over that he's hurting both physically and mentally after the package piledriver Owens gave him on Raw. This is about to get good. It could even get great if WWE plays their cards right.

The company followed up with KO sending out the challenge for Elimination Chamber in Toronto from his car. That’d certainly make sense, and it leaves Kevin open for Randy Orton at ‘Mania. Logically, KO smashing Zayn in Canada like a callous, cold son of a bitch, then going to injure him before Orton's music hits for a massive pop is the right way to go.

Aah, storytelling and character consistency. It's unmatched.


1. Chaos Ensues And Priest Is In

Braun Strowman Jacob Fatu
WWE.com

Braun Strowman vs. Damian Priest vs. Jacob Fatu was always going to be chaotic as a SmackDown main event, and it didn’t disappoint. If you’re in the mood to nitpick, you’d say some of the stuff between Cody Rhodes, Solo Sikoa, Tama Tonga and Fatu was a little busy outside the ring, but that only added to the lawless feel of the match in progress.

Priest qualified for the Chamber match, Fatu saw Solo accidentally level Tama with a Samoan Spike, and Rhodes got some measure of revenge for last week. Everything worked out, and Triple H's writing managed to hit several heavy plot points without coming across as forced. They even found the time to have Cody and Priest share a handshake before both stared up at the big neon WrestleMania 41 sign.

That's highly unlikely for Vegas, but there's nothing wrong with setting the scene for a match between the pair later this year.

Braun, like The Miz, knows what he's there for on Friday nights. He's a tool to help others look amazing, and he's smashing that role opposite Fatu. Their collisions always come across as must see. Throw Damian Priest into the mix and you had one hell of a scenario to close out the show.

The biggest takeaways from this are Priest's Chamber qualification, Solo giving Jacob answers then distracting him by levelling Tonga, Cody going after the ex-New Bloodline leader, and the lure of matches to come like Cody vs. Priest or Rhodes vs. Fatu. Things are looking good when it comes to Trips stacking up title bouts for the rest of 2025.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 12 Exact Moments WWE Titles Became Worthless and 10 WWE Wrestlers In Danger Of Missing Out On WrestleMania 41!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.