7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Dec 7 - Review)

Ricky Starks shows why he is Absolute, and the Acclaimed become the top guys.

FTR Acclaimed
AEW

Tony Khan has recently played down criticisms that his booking of ROH titles has affected the AEW product.

Many fans are alienated by the small-time feeling of a brand that is significantly less meaningful than the brand they set time aside to watch. They believe AEW presents: ROH has inflated the value of the very concept of titles and, crucially, offers nothing that AEW does not. The self-contained storytelling in "ROH" is often very good, but it's at best unnecessary, at worst an imposition on the show. The mainline titles used to mean more than they do. Protesting fans want to feel that inimitable all-or-nothing drama of peak AEW.

Khan however maintains that he only really books Chris Jericho frequently on AEW programming, but isn't that in itself a telling admission?

"I've stopped inundating you with ROH stuff on Rampage, so calm down" isn't likely to get fans hyped at the prospect of Final Battle - but then, many would be unhappy were Khan to go hard on the sell. ROH is untenable either way: it's not worth dulling the special feeling AEW once cultivated, but it won't be worth anything if it just sort of exists.

If it's not already a real problem, it will certainly become one if it is felt that a ROH-related development actively detracts from something that might otherwise feel massive in a context exclusive to AEW.

That was the threat heading into this week's Dynamite: was FTR Vs. The Acclaimed, a potentially huge match at Revolution in an alternate universe very close to our own, booked only to set up an ROH World Tag Team title match at Final Battle via distraction finish? Was the biggest doubles match in AEW mere pretext to a Ring Of Honor match?

And if that's the case, isn't the presence of ROH now actively hurting the AEW product?

Happily...


Downs...

2. A Weird And Unnecessary Twist

William Regal
AEW

It was revealed that William Regal had conducted in an interview with Tony Schiavone ahead of MJF's betrayal last week that was only to be screened in the event of said betrayal actually taking place.

This was strange.

It turns out that Regal half-knew the turn was coming, and was equally uninterested in aligning with MJF as MJF was aligning with him. The finish to Full Gear was reframed as one last lesson imparted to the Blackpool Combat Club: keep your eyes in the back of your head. A carny wrestling villain is always plotting some scheme or other.

It was already debatable whether it was a good idea to position an outgoing talent in such a featured role when a lot of bother and discourse and confused fan reaction could have been saved if, for example, MJF bloodied and injured Regal offscreen in the build to the pay-per-view. Ultimately, the decision put MJF over as the most cunning and despicable heel in the company. He out-Regal'd Regal.

Except he didn't. Regal had him worked out. It's just as well MJF had such a great night; otherwise, this might have damaged his credibility badly. It's one thing to actually use a departing talent in a role of such high importance.

This was far too magnanimous for its own good.


1. Another Unnecessary Segment

Red Velvet
AEW

Jade Cargill, Red Velvet and Leila Grey Vs. Madison Rayne, Skye Blue and Kiera Hogan wasn't without merit.

The exchanges between Skye and Velvet were a stirring competitive flex, nicely wrestled on the mat, but this had very little reason to actually exist. There are no Women's Trios titles. Yes, Hogan is out for vengeance having been kicked out of the stable, so there was a modicum of purpose to it.

Also, Red Velvet did at points convey apathy with the stable she too is slowly being negged out of, but the TBS title division barely exists, the advancement of what is hardly a compelling story was very, very gentle, and there's no real anticipation ahead of the ending of the story because what, exactly, is the endgame here? If the Baddies turn on Jade, they'd be justified, because Jade is heeling on them, but there's a numbers advantage at play that would babyface Jade.

And if it's just Red Velvet, AEW are hardly doing a good job of slowly allowing fans to remember the babyface fire of old because she's being directed to sulk.

It's all a bit baffling.


Ups...

7. A Good, Tight Battle Royal Opener

Jack Perry
AEW

The Dynamite Diamond battle royal was raucous, creative and very well-received by a hot Texas crowd. It was uneven in quality, without being messy, but one wrestler in particular elevated a match genre that more often than not occupies its usual space between fun and flawed.

Jack Perry is a battle royal artist. His approach to elimination attempts proves that he is more prodigy than pet project, as difficult as it was to make that distinction following a singles run that hasn't exactly propelled him to mega stardom. His risky and creative strategy in this match didn't so much elicit drama as palpitations. He was brutalised by W. Morrissey, and heaven knows Perry is miserable now because that back bump on the apron looked horrific. He was almost half a person after getting snapped in two like that.

Distance needs to be created between Perry and Christian, and since Perry has only really excelled in singles this year opposite Luchasaurus, Morrissey as stylistic surrogate should work well. While that story was incited, the indentured servitude stuff between Ethan Page and Matt Hardy was advanced. Hardy carried out the orders reluctantly before threatening to disobey. And so what if he bloody did?

This sort of thing always ends with the heel accepting a match. It's a waste of time devoid of real stakes, but the fans seemed to be into it, and not just on the basis that they like to chant "Delete!"; they were with this subplot the whole way.

Shawn Dean played his role brilliantly too, and what an inspired choice. In English football, most big clubs have what is known as a "bogey team" - a lesser side that seems to have their number, inexplicably, even if the starting eleven changes every season. Dean is that to MJF, and Tony Khan deserves more credit for building this sports-oriented concept.

Starks won, after a finish stunning in its execution, which led to...


6. That's How You Heat Up A Big Match

MJF Face
AEW

After the battle royal, MJF - who continues to do the impossible, at which so many wrestling luminaries have failed, by telling the fans how they should feel - confronted Ricky Starks to build their match next week.

This was an incredible duelling promo that ranged from piss-funny entertainment to pure unbridled emotion. MJF accused Starks of cosplaying as the Rock and revelling in the secure idea that he is underutilised. If he was utilised, little would actually happen. Starks disproved that by cutting a rousing promo that summoned a standing ovation with its sass, wit, and graduating level of heart and intensity. It's just as well it was so good, because MJF's material was drawing laughs across the arena before he was cut off.

Otherwise, MJF was exceptional in an understated and selfless way here. Already, he knows his role as World champion, and he hasn't even defended the title yet. In this context, he has to show ass, let the TV-level babyface challenger win this battle, and then f*ck him to get his heat back ahead of the next narrative cycle. Starks meanwhile will be remembered as the man who gave it his all, but got cheated out of it, when he locks up with his next rival.

It's no hyperbole to state that WWE has chased the laughs, soundbites and crowd response this segment achieved by its hot conclusion for the entirety of this century.


5. Darby Allin Vs. Samoa Joe Is What AEW Was And Should Be

Samoa Joe Darby Allin
AEW

The optics here didn't look great: ex-WWE star, past his prime, beats homegrown project that fans have been asked to invest in for over three years. The execution of the story here was so fantastic, though, that it was impossible to think less of Darby Allin for losing clean.

If anything, as a result of this return to bold, decisive, meaningful booking, Darby looked like a badass for nearly surviving the challenge and going out the honourable way. It didn't matter that Joe, soaked in sweat and sucking air, looked past his best. Allin was such an effective victim here that Joe still has something of the old aura, even if he's more of a Hinox these days as far as monsters go.

This was a gruesome glorified handicap match in which Allin took on the combined forces of Samoa Joe and concrete, first after Joe noped Darby's shotgun blast of a lopé, and then when Joe slammed him into it himself. A smart (and very brave) match layout does infinitely more to protect a wrestler than a sh*tty cop-out finish, and this was a beautifully violent reminder of that.

Joe being gassed actually lent the hope spot and the size discrepancy a certain credibility; he took the Coffin drop to the outside credibly by falling, exhausted, onto his back.

An all-star clash with a clean yet flattering result: this is was the original high-stakes vision of AEW restored.


4. Gentle 'Up' For Very Good But Very Familiar Action

Wheeler YUTA Daniel Garcia
AEW

Strictly, Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler YUTA Vs. Jake Hager and Daniel Garcia was a good to very good match that generated a hot crowd response.

The spot in which Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler YUTA put their arms over one another's shoulders before launching a stereo big boot is neat babyface stable work, Jake Hager always looks so much more like the dynamic monster Jim Ross insists that he is in a tag team context, and the YUTA/Daniel Garcia exchanges did far more than the apathetic booking to get fans hyped on the prospect of their clash at Final Battle. That last bit of praise is especially glowing, since it feels like the opposite of a rubber match; yes, it is the deciding encounter, but it's far from the most highly anticipated.

The thing is, this was expected to be good. It had to fail dismally to be bad, given the sheer level of talent involved, and that does include Hager, terrifying botch aside.

The babyfaces prevailed, which ignited hope over the conclusion of the overdone Jericho Appreciation Society Vs. Blackpool Combat Club saga - of which this hardly the most captivating chapter.

And that's not all...


3. Yes, They're Listening

BCC AEW
AEW

Jon Moxley took the microphone in the post-match and, as the blessed man always does, articulated the emotions of the fandom.

With as much apathy as a lot of the AEW public, he deadpanned his absolute boredom over the ongoing pro wrestling versus sports entertainment programme without undermining his beloved philosophy. His tone was perfect here; while bored sh*tless of the feud, he will never get bored of pro wrestling because he lives and breathes for it. He also said something that those fans have been dying to hear for months now: at Final Battle, the war between the JAS and BCC will come to an end.

Of course, it would be far better if the programme had actually raced to an electrifying conclusion, but the reality is that it hasn't, and Mox, because he's still the best babyface in wrestling, had no interest in patronising his people.

Excitement is a far better emotion with which to sell a pay-per-view than relief, obviously, but this realistic hype-job was vastly preferable to pretending that the feud is still hot.


2. The Feeling Continues To Flood Back

Shawn Dean
AEW

Austin, Texas was hot as hell for most of the night. There is nothing like a passionate, interactive wrestling crowd, and Tony Khan and the roster deserve credit for cultivating the atmosphere and bringing back the inimitable AEW "feeling".

The company is unparalleled when operating at or near its peak, and the booking of the show overall serviced the audience.

AEW trusted the fans to remember that Shawn Dean, inexplicably, has MJF's number. Ricky Starks' Lights Out match win and Eliminator tournament triumph deftly led him to his home away from home ahead of the biggest match of his life. FTR Vs. The Acclaimed, more on which follows imminently, worked so well because it felt surreal that it was even happening.

The inspired tweak on a bogey team; a string of hard-fought wins mattering as a super-over babyface rises to his hardest challenge; a super-competitive main event with no hokey conflict and no bullsh*t finish with zero weight to it: this was AEW adhering to its original all-or-nothing sports-oriented vision, and the fans, clearly into this ideal of an alternative, went banana for most of the show.

The rating might disprove this take, but tonight was another tentative step towards AEW recovering its old soul.


1. FTR Vs. The Acclaimed Is Close To The Best Version Of Itself

FTR Acclaimed
AEW

FTR Vs. The Acclaimed seemed like strange business.

The proximity to Final Battle caused anxiety within some fans, particularly since this match, certainly worthy of the long build to Revolution, was also a week removed from Winter Is Coming. What was the rush? Why did it have to happen last night?

So that the Gunn Club could interfere and set up a match at the ROH show, was the cynical answer.

And the wrong one; instead, to establish this as a World Tag Team title reign as great in the ring as it is entertaining outside of it, the Acclaimed went over FTR clean. And it was amazing.

Cash Wheeler deserves to work as many singles matches as Dax Harwood in 2023 because, in less than a minute, he worked an early exchange with Anthony Bowens so pulsating and close and urgent that it was as if they were career rivals born to wrestle one another. That incredible exchange felt so thrillingly real; when Cash hopped over a leg sweep and instantly trapped Bowens in a gator roll, he presented himself as nothing less than a master and a monster at the same time. When he took the fall, it legitimised the Acclaimed as the undisputed kings of tag team wrestling. This excellent story was told across every second, and the twists that cast doubt over the notion that the Acclaimed could truly hang at this level were off the charts incredible.

Dax pretending to botch so that he could wrong-foot Max Caster and kick him on the arse and into Bowens was a sublime moment of heel deception. The finishing sequence was scorching, and in the most subtle - and best - Bret Hart tribute of the year, Cash sold the pin with resigned devastation. He had been out-wrestled. To him, that is the ultimate shame.

Are FTR doing business on the way out? Or is talk of their exit being filtered, carefully, to put over a redemptive triumph on pay-per-view next year? Or did Tony Khan simply decide to book a very bold finish in response to the campaign to give FTR an AEW World Tag Team title shot?

Transfer sagas played out in the media are tedious, one involving Dax Harwood a particularly brutal prospect, and on their seven star form here, the idea of FTR leaving AEW is soul-crushing.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!