7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Holiday Bash (21 Dec - Review)
Hikaru Shida vs. Jamie Hayter, Ricky Starks, and The Elite vs. Death Triangle highlight Dynamite.
AEW's run of end-of-year Dynamite specials continued with last night's Holiday Bash, building further momentum for a brand picking up important steam to close a 12-month period rife with challenges and controversies.
Dynamite's construction has felt tighter and less frenetic lately, without sacrificing too much of that all-important anything-can-happen energy. While there was one notable exception last night (more on that later...), whatever Tony Khan is doing to adapt his approach is working, with clever use of short video packages, quickfire recaps, and more purposeful backstage promos and angles breaking up the blood and thunder.
Not that Dynamite is lacking in blood and thunder. This week alone brought fantastic, hard-hitting matches between The Elite and Death Triangle, whose series continued, and Jamie Hayter and Hikaru Shida. Elsewhere, HOOK wood-chippered his latest opponent, FTR finally got a piece of The Gunns, and Jon Moxley tested high-flyer Darius Martin.
While Holiday Bash suffered from a cooler middle period, audibly bringing the wonderful San Antonio, Texas crowd down, this was another show brimming with enough electricity to evoke memories of Dynamite's Jan-Feb 2020 and Aug-Nov 2021 peaks. AEW, and its flagship show, are in good form as the year comes to an end.
Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
2. FTR vs. The Gunns
A noble failure, unfortunately, though not a complete failure.
FTR and The Gunns worked a bang-average television match after months of background build. Colten and Austin have been needling Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler for ages, coming off suitably annoying and obnoxious in their roles, as they should. FTR, meanwhile, have typically had bigger fish to fry while The Gunns have needled them, though recent events gave them a reason to step to the Daddy Ass spawn and smash them in a heated brawl last night.
The heat, or lack thereof, was the issue here. San Antonio had cooled off by this point and The Gunns' middling control work wasn't strong enough to turn them around, nor was FTR's structuring. Austin teasing a Sweet Chin Music before swerving into a Sharpshooter, mocking FTR's Bret Hart love, was the closest the bout came to coming alive. Even then, it was tepid.
The Feud Must Continue, too. Austin got the pin via roll-up, with Colten grabbing his hand from outside. A rematch that must improve on the first outing is now on the cards.
Dax and Cash have had a fabulous year and The Gunns have shown promise as a growing act. It's a shame that their first outing wasn't as combustible as they would have hoped, though perhaps they'll turn it around in chapter two.
1. Swerve Strickland Forms Mogul Affiliates
Mogul Affiliates' formation segment was a hot mess.
A fun, entertaining hot mess, but a hot mess nonetheless.
Rick Ross is as absurdly entertaining in wrestling as he is on record. The guy is great. While not everyone will have enjoyed his running commentary here, how could you not pop for his "You a big motherf*cker" at the sudden realisation that Keith Lee is, indeed, a big motherf*cker, or the casual "Wow, he may need attention!" after Lee had had a cinderblock stomped through his chest.
If his own hip-hop mogul-isms hadn't already made him rich beyond belief, Rick Ross should be in wrestling full-time.
The angle fell apart when it got physical. Parker Boudreaux attacked Keith from behind, drawing zero reaction, even with his green-as-Grinch-piss, over-the-top gesticulations. A mystery man, now revealed as Granden Goetzman, joined the party. He brought a tangible chaos factor to proceedings but it didn't sound like many in the building cared as he and Parker restrained Lee for the stomp.
A perversely entertaining segment, Strickland at least came off well in it. The entire wrestling world will belong to him someday. The Lee feud is going to be great, too, and stomping a cinderblock through a man's chest sends one hell of a message. Nonetheless, the Mogul Affiliate group's coming together felt all-over-the-place in good ways and bad.
Ups...
7. The Book Of Hobbs' Final Chapter
Short and sweet was the Book of Hobbs' final chapter, which saw Powerhouse drag through memories of being three years old and watching his uncle overdose, getting robbed and stabbed as a child, and worse. These experiences, he said, created the monster he is today.
While perhaps these vignettes could have used more meat on the bones, they have succeeded in establishing a new character direction for Hobbs following his Ricky Starks rivalry and failed TNT/ROH TV Title challenge. Rising stars too often disappear from AEW television just as they are starting to get hot. With Hobbs and Ricky, AEW isn't making those mistakes.
And Powerhouse will return to television as strong as ever.
6. HOOK vs. Exodus Prime (After Which Big Bill Put A Man In The Bin)
HOOK's squash of Exodus Prime was about what you'd expect.
Prime, who sadly isn't an Autobot, was restricted to wild swings and failed strikes. HOOK put him in the corner early, threw him around the ring, and blasted him with a full-blooded lariat. Redrum then came after the crossface shots, ending Exodus' night in quickfire fashion.
The bout was setting the table for a backstage angle. On the big screen, The Firm's Big Bill and Lee Moriarty, led by Stokely Hathaway, were putting the boots to Jungle Boy. This follows the fresh babyface alliance's coming together last week - and closed on Big Bill literally chokeslamming Jack Perry into a bin (followed by Moriarty, growing into his role as a television character, tossing a bag of trash atop him).
A supplemental Down for the sudden, jarring change of pace, with 'Wild Thing' hitting before it felt like the segment was done. Effective work nonetheless. HOOK and Jungle Boy works as a new dynamic, while The Firm is starting to feel relevant again.
5. Jon Moxley vs. Darius Martin
Jon Moxley vs. Darius Martin was effective, but closer to the middling television bouts Mox spent much of his fall working rather than recent firecrackers opposite Konosuke Takeshita and Sammy Guevara.
This nine-minuter was built around contrasting character and stylistic dynamics. Where Darius is a high-flyer, Mox is a dirty brawler. Where Darius wanted to start the bout with polite charges and position jostles, Mox wanted to slap him across the face. Being caught with an early dropkick momentarily threw Moxley off his game, while being launched, brutally, into the barricade put Martin all the way off his.
Similar themes played out throughout, with Darius' offense coming through superior athleticism and agility, while Mox attempted to clip the Top Flight man's wings and make it a fight. This proved a successful strategy when Darius was pinned with Bulldog Choke.
Preceding this was a gloriously cold-blooded promo from Moxley, whose recent work has foreshadowed a heel turn. Uncaring of 'Hangman' Adam Page and his sombre tones as well as Darius' car wreck and blown-out knee, Moxley was excellent in his short backstage bit, forecasting the great heel run to come.
4. Bryan Danielson, MJF, and Ethan Page Trade Shots
MJF's backstage promo was a good example of AEW's recent formatting changes working. Addressing Bryan Danielson chasing him down the ramp last week in the moment captured his rage in a way that doing it live this week wouldn't have. The World Champion wasn't there later on, however, when Danielson's fiery in-ring words were answered by Ethan Page, not MJF.
Danielson joined Renee Paquette to speak on William Regal, his now-departed trainer, who made him the man and wrestler he is today. Doing this in Shawn Michaels' San Antonio hometown (given HBK was one of Danielson's first coaches) was particularly effective.
A bitter Page commanded monster heat when he came out to whine about being overlooked for a title shot despite making it to the Eliminator tournament's finals and hitting the recent Dynamite Diamond Ring Battle Royal's last two. A good heel point. Danielson fired back by insulting Stokely Hathaway's bald head, later challenging Page to a fight. Predictably, Ethan backed down, promising to fight Danielson next week, not this week.
This stands as a sensible fill-in time-killer until AEW is ready to launch into MJF vs. Danielson full-speed. Page has an understandable gripe, given his escapades, and his ties to the World Champion through The Firm. 'Vegetable Man' is going to eat him alive, though.
3. Ricky Starks Gets The Chris Jericho Feud
AEW's familiar booking patterns meant Ricky Starks being de-pushed as a genuine concern coming out of his failed World Title challenge, though those fears were proven unfounded last night. Starks once again commanded an immense reaction in Texas, delivered a great promo, and is now in a feud with one of AEW's biggest stars, Chris Jericho.
Looking tremendous in his black and white ensemble, Starks acknowledged his loss to MJF, said it was on nobody but himself, and promised to climb back to the top. He was interrupted by the Jericho Appreciation Society, whose leader began the sales pitch by putting Ricky over as a million-dollar talent. As he has done plenty of times before, however, Jericho asserted that if Starks really wanted to make it, he needed the JAS' guidance.
'Absolute' chose not to fall for it. He ripped Jericho to pieces, twisting praise for his powers of reinvention into saying he looked like a single dad on his fifth divorce, slapping the JAS' metaphorical hand away rather than shaking it. Jake Hager then jumped him from behind. Jericho, Daniel Garcia, and Sammy Guevara joined the beatdown until Action Andretti's save, following last week's shock.
Later, Andretti's backstage promo was interrupted by 2point0, who distracted the newcomer long enough for Jericho to throw a fireball in Action's face. He's a wizard, remember.
Ricky was the star of the show here, but while the cynicism surrounding Jericho throwing himself into programs with hot AEW stars as they are gathering steam is earned, this should work provided it doesn't go on forever and ever. AEW would be wise to heed the lessons of Jericho vs. Eddie Kingston here.
2. The Elite Vs. Death Triangle
The Elite and Death Triangle have thus far succeeded in their endeavours to do something different in each of their trios matches so far. While each revolves around wild, chaotic action, they have taken on different themes, with Nick Jackson's ankle injury the latest. Transitioning now into gimmick match territory should help in that regard, too.
While not the best of the series, Holiday Bash's No DQ bout hit all the right notes. A stipulation designed to minimise Death Triangle's hammer-driven advantage started with a brawl encompassing Michael Nakazawa, and Brandon Cutler dressed like an elf. Spiced with similar moments of Elite-branded comedy, it escalated in violence, peaking when Rey Fenix took a Tiger Driver '98 onto Kenny Omega's barbed wire broom (a crime Omega paid for when said barbed wire got stuck to his backside).
Things started coming to an end when Kenny kicked out of Fenix's hammer shot, which ended the warring faction's first bout. Matt Jackson then broke Omega and Nick out of tandem submissions. A Snapdragon on Fenix preceded the Meltzer Driver, with Nick laboured to hit thanks to his bad ankle, wobbling before flipping.
A brutal, bloody beatdown by Death Triangle ensued, raising the temperate ahead of next week's Falls Count Anywhere.
1. Hikaru Shida Vs. Jamie Hayter
One of the best women's matches in AEW history played out in the slot it deserved: the main event.
Jamie Hayter vs. Hikaru Shida felt like both a step forward for the women's division and an acknowledgement of the bruising progress it has made in 2022. There's still work to be done (it would be nice, for example, to see more than one of these bouts on a Wednesday night), though the scene's stylistic shift towards a harder style of wrestling, driven by such fights as Hayter and Shida, has benefitted it immensely. It helps, too, that with these two, Serena Deeb, Toni Storm, and many more, the skill level is now higher than ever before.
But yes, Shida vs. Hayter ruled. Two wrestlers who have never had a problem with taking lumps and giving them back fought with fury. There was a palpable nastiness behind each shot, escalating as the match progressed, much like the drama.
The pace was heartstopping. Nearfalls for the Haytbreaker raised the roof while Shida's subversion of the heel interference spot by simply beating the snot out of Britt Baker popped. Moments later, a bona fide standing ovation was earned by Hayter's powerbomb, which came from multiple counters before the best near-fall of the night.
Until the new best near-fall of the night came following a killer lariat.
Hikaru was finished soon after by a Hayterade so vicious it may have sent the former champion's skull into orbit. An excellent, attritional battle between two fantastic pro wrestlers given an opportunity to shine in the perfect spotlight, followed by Toni Storm and Saraya hitting the ring to clear it of the heels.