7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (July 12 - Review)

Kota Ibushi finally lands in AEW, PAC is BACK, Nick Wayne soars, MJF & Adam Cole light up the dark.

Blood & Guts
AEW

Wednesday's episode of AEW Dynamite was as much a go-home show as much an edition on its own terms.

Next week's third annual Blood & Guts contest is likely to dominate all conversations and for good reason, and much of the hype going into Saskatoon for the latest Canadian pitstop was based around both sides picking their fifth men.

Elsewhere, the Owen Hart Tournament finals will take place on this Saturday's Collision, with the men's side pitting CM Punk against Ricky Starks in a tantalising encounter between the returning lightning rod and an in-house favourite looking to reverse his momentum. On that same episode, FTR will defend their Tag Team Championships against Jay White and Juice Robinson, and the winners of that will be waiting in the wings to find out who scores the big victory in the Blind Eliminator Tournament final next week.

It's all happening...but just didn't look to be doing so here ahead of showtime. Could the flagship maintain its no-skip reputation deliver under this unique set of circumstances?

Let’s light the fuse…


Downs…

2. Dark Matches

Kommander Chris Jericho
AEW

Has the Great White North ever looked darker on television?

More's the point, has a loaded Dynamite ever felt more like Dark?

The much-missed (by some) YouTube show didn't always have the best crowds depending on when people decided to turn up for the main show, but never in the flagship's rich history beyond pandemic times has it looked so empty.

This is perhaps because it was, of course. AEW's extended stay in Canada has brought with it a number of positives, but "significantly diminished crowds after the first show" hasn't been one of them. Fans did come up at specific points in the night (more on those later), but a blacked-out building made for a glum televisual experience during large portions of the show and that's not been the first time that's been a complaint this month, let alone this year.

Saskatoon's got some unique wrestling history, but this wasn't going to be a night to make some, and that was one of the only things that was all too clear.


1. Parked

Hook Jack Perry
AEW

The good news is that, as result of the latest cartoonish battle scene between the two, Hook and Jack Perry's programme has a central theme and its "escaping in cars".

The former 'Jungle Boy' was speaking to Alex Marvez from the car park again, incensed that his former Tag Team partner wouldn't just leave him alone. Then, the 'Cold-Hearted Handsome Devil' struck, but the fake feeling way the attack played out was reminder that this is sub-standard comedy at best and badly-blocked wrestling shtick at worst. Hook had the time and space to pulverise him in the back of that motor, but this is weekly episodic television so it can't be that simple, stupid. Perry was no great shakes at the big bad heel stuff following his Forbidden Door turn, but the pivot between serious and silly has been sharper than the objects Jon Moxley uses on his own dome.

And it's less-than-ideal away from that bargaining anyway. We are being asked to believe that the two are racing up and down the roads together, turning up at work on a Wednesday, clashing, and starting the loop all over again. Yes this makes Hook a little bit like the big bad from It Follows, but it yet again feels too lightweight for two men whose development relies on having something proper to sink their teeth into.


Ups…

7. Chris Jericho Vs Kommander

Chris Jericho Kommander
AEW

Chris Jericho Vs Kommander made for a bizarre match graphic but if it was going to be chaotic one way or the other, it had to veer on the side of great in order to validate the vile Don Callis' pitch for Jericho to join his Family.

In the end, it scanned as a good bit of business made better by the post-match.

Playing full heel after teasing a turn last week, Jericho bossed Kommander through the action, forcing the aerialist into taking risks to pull off his jaw-dropping feats of athleticism. This made them matter more too - a tremendous near fall was extracted from a ropewalk springboard shooting star press, but the only one that truly registered was the actual one; Jericho locking in the Liontamer got him a quick tap win so the show could get back to his big decision.

It wasn't made here, but Callis is certainly laying it on nice and thick. Showing footage of them as a team in 1995 alongside Bad News Allen was on-brand carny pandering but it might be working. Jake Hager as the Beefcake to Jericho's Hogan tried to get inside 'The Ocho's head later in the show but he wasn't giving the game away.

Perhaps, now he's not the fifth man for the Blackpool Combat Club, that will take place at Blood & Guts.


6. Darby Allin & Sammy Guevara Vs The Jericho Appreciation Society

Orange Cassidy Darby Allin Sammy Guevara
AEW

With Darby Allin and Sammy Guevara's parity so recently re-established in the Four Pillars feud ahead of Double Or Nothing, it fell to this match to make Orange Cassidy and Daniel Garcia equals too. The agenting was then so sublime that it felt like another International Championship defence has to be forthcoming.

Cassidy and Garcia exchanged a flurry of intricate cradles, with the switches between holds as slick as the minds that thought to do them. This came either side of the two constantly coming to blows, which also served as backdrop for Allin and Guevara to engage in their own typically bananas back-and-forths.

A great piece of tag team business was knowingly marred by Swerve Strickland and Prince Nana causing the faces to lose by decking Darby Allin while Orange Cassidy and the referee were otherwise distracted. Allin was left prone to be hit with the GTH, though 'The Spanish God's insistence on a handshake at the end suggests that JAS chemistry between the two going into the final may not be quite as tight as the bond between their frenemy foes.

Speaking of which...


5. MJF & Adam Cole Vs Big Bill & Brian Cage

Adam Cole MJF
AEW

Adam Cole and MJF's ongoing bond/blow-up may still not be for everybody and there will be questions raised through to the eventual payoff as if it's been too wacky for its own good considering the end goal, but the one-two punch of their latest bonding session and doubles victory made for irresistible television and brought light and loud energy to a darkened and silent crowd.

Ahead of their Blind Eliminator bout with Big Bill and Brian Cage, the two were out drinking together before settling in for a night on Fight Forever, where they of course became Tag Team Champions while inadvertently doing a little bit of bonding too. Cole's shock at MJF having never had a friend to try multiplayer with was as believable as MJF's when Cole wasn't interest in cheating on Britt Baker with women he'd met at the bar, but the fact that they were both making effort rather than simply backing out of their commitments added yet more tension to whatever eventually erupts.

Not that it did here. Matching their energy in the skits when they hit the ring, the two combined quite gracefully in the face of a basic but BIG challenge. MJF got the biggest pop of the night with a bodyslam he'd teased throughout, which was both an ingenious bit of heat-building for the contest, saved the double clothesline for another day, and perhaps a sly dig at a CM Punk more than happy to carry a red bag around to discredit the 'Salt Of The Earth's reign.

A Heatseeker/Boom combo finisher emphasised their effectiveness, which again was crucial - Britt Baker, Roddy Strong and Renee Paquette all cast doubt over Cole's ability to keep this particular train on the tracks. And as they should! But the more it does, the more it seems like MJF won't be the one to derail it! And that's when he strikes! And...that's why this is the good stuff.


4. Ruby Soho Vs Skye Blue

Skye Blue Ruby Soho
AEW

Ruby Soho and Skye Blue have got underrated chemistry, and their latest coming together brought the best out of both in a match that was given welcome time and space to breathe at just under ten minutes.

Ruby working the knee made for a classic heel/babyface dynamic, particularly with The Outcasts pleasingly not really involved in this one to their usual degree. Toni Storm's interference early on was ineffective but fundamentally unnecessary too - Soho was at her wily veteran best no matter what upstart stuff Blue brought to the table.

Both kept at their game plans - a game Blue fighting through the pain just to get back into the ring, a driven Soho inflicted more to stop her and beat her. Skye eating No Future as her time in the tournament came to an end was creatively cruel, but she increasingly looks like one of the division's best discoveries in years.


3. Harley Cameron's "Rap Lessons"

Harley Cameron
AEW

Not a lot to say about it other than to put it over for being awesome, even if that shouldn't really be the point. Or should it?

Will Harley Cameron be the next to walk away from QTV for realising that it's probably doing more to hold her back that project her forward? The video QT Marshall threatened Max Caster and Anthony Bowens was earnestly tremendous and Cameron has shown on-screen and off what a gifted performer she is as a singer, but don't The Acclaimed have to just nod in approval rather than presumably present their own work in return? A diss track would at least be a receipt, but the match being such a foregone conclusion would be added tax for wrestlers and fans alike.

A lot of doing stuff just for the sake of doing stuff going on here, but to not call it good on its own steam would be an unfair dismissal of the bit.


2. Swerve Strickland Vs Nick Wayne

Swerve Strickland Nick Wayne
AEW

Nick Wayne's All Elite Wrestling debut has been one of the best in recent memory and/or one of the best ever depending on exactly how impressed you are by the vignettes.

Dynamite's pace over the years has worked for many, but slowing it down to spend several minutes over two weeks with the Wayne family has worked wonders in fleshing his life and story out ahead of an historic debut. The 18-year-old was to be no pushover, and he'd fought back from some big challenges in life to prove it.

As one of the roster's best baddies, Swerve Strickland was perhaps the best possible choice of opponent. Ignoring the fact that they'd already built up terrific in-ring chemistry on the independent scene, this was all about Wayne's undeniably great high spot/counter game tackling veteran presence and a wrestling villain's will to win.

The influences were obvious here, and right now, that's charming. Wayne was channeling idol Will Ospreay a lot with the flashier stuff, and the more he requested love from the crowd, the more he actually seemed to get it. That might not work forever but it was impossible not to get taken along in the magic of it all before a JML Driver by Strickland ended the youngster's night on a low. Darby Allin had returned to ringside to play cheerleader earlier too, and while he didn't interfere, the tease of tension between Allin and Swerve threw up a captivating trios possibility should Wayne and Sting want to get involved.


1. The Blood & Guts Reveals

Blood & Guts
AEW

AEW were playing with fire in regards to exactly how Kota Ibushi was teased as The Elite's fifth and final member going into Blood & Guts.

Kenny Omega's words hit home with everybody, and the knowledge that he'd been off in Japan weeks earlier had planted the seed that the 'Golden Star' was at long last going to debut in the company he'd played no small part in helping come to life. But building a surprise meant that it could have been somebody else, which then would have drawn derision from those believing they were promised the IWGP World Heavyweight Champion.In the end, it was less about that reveal and more about the BCC's star man.

PAC's shocking return and attack on the 'Best Bout Machine' immediately made sense despite being speculated upon by absolutely nobody in the build-up. Omega used the Ibushi news to save himself from a potential Black Arrow neckbreaker, but the 'BASTARD' would have done it given the chance. A captivating figure for the 5-on-5 war, the stakes and sides were well set in a segment that shone even if it didn't quite sizzle. The feud itself might be done, but the last match at least has some very new life.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.