7 Ups & 2 Downs From WWE SmackDown (31 May - Results & Review)

AJ Styles becomes Mark Henry; LA Knight goes for gold; SmackDown storytelling smokes competition.

AJ Styles Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

SmackDown's side for Clash At The Castle started really coming together on this week's show. Piper Niven will challenge Bayley but still acts as muscle for Chelsea Green, and AJ Styles suckered Cody Rhodes into another WWE Title bout on the Scottish PLE. That was risky, especially when Cody looked foolish for believing AJ before, but Friday's segment was hot.

It must be summer, or something.

This wasn't the kind of show for fans who want blistering and/or lengthy pure wrestling matches. No, it was more of a story-heavy broadcast - the kind that busily sets about the task of lining up those in-ring scorchers for later on. Yours truly can get behind that, and it's hardly like most of the matches tanked. They were fine, but hardly the priority.

One of the emerging undercard stories is painfully uninteresting though, and a baffling decision from somebody who should really know better stood out as another 'Down'. Admittedly, negatives were few and far between. Triple H's WWE is cooking right now, and that's impressive considering the string of 'B' level international pay-per-views going on.

Here's all the good and bad from SmackDown's latest.


Downs...

2. Not Feeling Any Of This

Legado del Fantasma Andrade
WWE.com

Here's that uninspiring midcard story from the intro.

WWE plans to stall on either putting Andrade in Legado del Fantasma or having him feud with Santos Escobar. The glaring negative to all of this is that nothing about either outcome is particularly interesting, and nobody really has the mic skills to make it work. Andrade vs. Santos would be good in-ring, but...would it be memorable?

Angel trying to court his old mate for a gig with Legado only goes so far before things start to become boring too. There just isn't enough meat on the bone with those guys to make fans care about their frosty fractured friendship. The pair were hardly blood brothers first time around anyway.

The other problem with all of this is that Apollo Crews is involved, and it's real hard to get invested in anything Crews does in 2024. WWE can't expect people to get excited about characters with next-to-no direction as suddenly as this. You've gotta be worried for everyone concerned.


1. Stop Smiling!

Bayley Naomi
WWE.com

Well now, this was unnecessary.

Bayley was a little too cheery during the early knockings of her tag bout alongside Naomi. She'd been ambushed by Chelsea Green and Piper Niven earlier in the show, and even had to be checked over by docs behind the curtain. So, in short, Bayley should've been fired up and p*ssed off here.

Instead, she was rather happy-go-lucky and in the high-fiving, smiley mood. That conjured up images of when Bianca Belair smiled and danced to the ring minutes/hours after being hammered by Damage CTRL. These are tiny details, but they definitely matter within the context of a story. If you want people to invest, then focus on the small things.

Bayley grinning from ear to ear as she made her way to the ring for that match sucked, because it was almost like the champ had been totally unaffected by a heel beatdown. Why book it in the first place then? Also, she should've been looking over her shoulder incase Chelsea and Piper fancied a second round.


Ups...

7. Keeping Queen In The Chat

Nia Jax Chelsea Green Piper Niven
WWE.com

It's a smart move to keep Nia Jax in the conversation. She'll be Bayley's chief enemy come SummerSlam, after all, and Nia recently won Queen Of The Ring over in Saudi Arabia. Seeing Jax kick off SmackDown with another coronation that was then interrupted by Clash At The Castle business? That's clever booking.

Nia got to reiterate that she'll be waiting for whomever the Women's Champion is coming out of Clash. It doesn't matter to her if it's Bayley, Piper or Chelsea. This is exactly the kind of confidence Jax needed to carry coming out of King And Queen Of The Ring. She's on top of her game right now.

Long may it continue.

WWE didn't try anything elaborate here - they kept things simple (another plus), and had Nia lurk over the entire women's division like a dark cloud ready to rain down on them. That'll only accelerate the closer we get to SummerSlam and the big showdown vs. Bayley.


6. Austin Theory’s Slow Burn Turn

Tommaso Ciampa Austin Theory
WWE.com

Being honest, Austin Theory and Grayson Waller aren't long for this world as a tag-team. This fan had hoped to see Theory spin out of the duo as a babyface long term, so he can't credibly complain that there are some miscommunication issues bubbling away between the lads now. This has to happen so Austin can move into a new role.

DIY might benefit from that.

Let's be frank about something else: Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano badly need something to hang their hats on. They've been dull lately, and the team sorely need a spark to help make them relevant on the roster again. Bagging the tag straps from a heel tandem ready to split might work out well for them.

The actual match pitting Theory vs. Ciampa was decent, but it's the issues in-house between A-Town Down Under that scored this segment an 'Up' overall. Grayson looks at Austin like a disappointed jock brother, and Theory is getting over it in a hurry.

Stay tuned.


5. As Solid As They Come

Tama Tonga Bloodline Street Profits
WWE.com

Beating The Street Profits was a sweet introductory match for Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa. Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins showed a ton of aggression throughout, which helped, but Bobby Lashley's pals were only out there to put The Bloodline's mercenary recruits over and sell how threatening they are to everyone else.

It worked.

Ford and Dawkins might deserve a cheeky little pay bonus, 'cause they went above and beyond to make Tama and Loa look like devils. The Profits didn't just take a kicking and turn things into some elongated squash (they got their licks in), but the pair knew when to lay out and let Bloodline brutes get some heat on them.

This was a win both Tongas needed. Now, they can go back to Solo Sikoa with a wicked smile, and ask Paul Heyman if he still thinks they're too reckless to work out as fully-fledged faction members. TV matches that deliver in-ring and carry some storyline purpose are the best.


4. LA Knight Going For Gold

LA Knight Kayla Braxton
WWE.com

Logan Paul wasn't at this week's SmackDown. Truthfully, nobody expected him to be there following events at King And Queen Of The Ring; he'll be laying low until either Money In The Bank or SummerSlam build begins, and that's perfectly fine. WWE lined up LP's next chapter anyway.

LA Knight asked for a word with GM Nick Aldis, then made it clear that he wants to challenge Paul for the United States Title. That caused Carmelo Hayes to waltz in and say LA getting a title shot is ridiculous. It looks like Knight and Hayes will be working some sort of number one contender situation soon.

Most fans will be cool with that idea.

This will be a make or break moment in LA's career though. He has to beat Carmelo then beat Logan to grab his first piece of singles gold on WWE's main roster. That's been a long time coming for the one-time Max Dupri. Holding a title high above his head is going to feel unreal for the man.


3. Paul Heyman Snaps!

Paul Heyman
WWE.com

Paul Heyman has been wonderful since Solo Sikoa assumed control of Bloodline operations during Roman Reigns' absence. On Friday, Paul E again put over how dangerous Tonga Loa and Tama Tonga are, and tried to warn Kevin Owens off pursuing another fight with these bloodthirsty brutes.

KO wasn't playing ball, so Heyman eventually snapped and wondered aloud why nobody listens to him anymore. That revealed the truth behind his frustrations: Paul has lost control of The Bloodline and is utterly rudderless without Roman in front of him. That's another simple story, but a damn good one.

Bonus points go to Kev for never once buying Paul's pleading promo. Why should he after everything that's happened with The Bloodline? Heyman has been caught telling porkies countless times, and is a well-known master manipulator, so it'd be a bit silly if Owens was suddenly sympathetic.

It'd be unfair on everyone else to say Paul is carrying this Bloodline 2.0 thing, but he's a huge reason behind why it's working.


2. This Tiny Piece Of Business

AJ Styles Cody Rhodes
WWE

Triple H's WWE has become deft at lacing shows with tiny, seemingly-insignificant moments that become important later on. For proof, check out AJ Styles pausing to whisper something in the ear of Cody Rhodes before going through the curtain to "retire" from the ring. That laid the groundwork for his attack to come.

WWE didn't reveal what AJ said to Cody, but it was likely something about their banger of a match at Backlash. Maybe Styles was thanking Rhodes for that bout to soften him up for the following segment. In other words, AJ got the champ to lower his guard all over again.

That's delicious.

Previously, Cody had looked like a fool for trusting AJ's Bullet Club horns gesture pre-Backlash. Creative washed away any worries of more gullible babyface stupidity by having Styles lay his (put on) emotions bare. It was realistic that Rhodes would get swept up in the retirement stuff and walk right into a trap.


1. AJ Styles Goes Mark Henry

AJ Styles Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Speaking of delicious!

AJ Styles' retirement fake out was eerily reminiscent of Mark Henry's own ruse back in 2013. Styles spent all night teasing that he was ready to walk away and go home to his family, but it was an evil scheme painstakingly designed to lure Cody into another WWE Title match on Clash At The Castle.

Everyone involved laid it on thick with the crocodile tears. LA Knight was fooled, so was Rhodes, and AJ's old OC buddies added to the moment by feigning sadness over their friend's tough decision. Of course, they were in on it. Styles dropped Cody with a sudden clothesline, then hit his Styles Clash off the ringside steps to the floor.

This fabulous closing angle came at the end of an emotional journey that's actually been going on longer than some might think. AJ has been questioning his future for months now, but it was all a swerve. The next match between he and Rhodes over in Scotland may have to be 'No DQ' after this.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 10 Wrestlers Whose Careers TANKED After Winning Big and 10 Wrestlers Who NEED Out Of AEW!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.