10 Wrestlers Who NEED Out Of AEW

Don't go away mad, just go away. These AEW stars either need a break or a WWE jump!

Chris Jericho AEW Time To Go
AEW/Instagram/@chrisjerichofozzy

Tony Khan's All Elite Wrestling was once a haven for wrestlers sick of restrictive WWE life and seeking something new. In many ways, AEW still has plenty to offer. The schedule is less intense, the money is good, and creative freedom is there. That's why greats like Adam Copeland made the leap - he fancied doing his own thing and just having some fun without sacrificing cold, hard cash.

Fair enough, but the rules have changed. Triple H's WWE is very different to Vince McMahon's behind the scenes, and momentum has been swinging Hunter's way for a while. Now, rather than heading in the right direction with swagger and fan goodwill, Khan has started to find things real challenging.

His roster is bloated, some of them are unhappy, and programming is an up and down mess that's visibly booked last-minute. You'd have been right to suggest countless wrestlers looked at AEW as the place to be in 2019 and for a few years after that, but not in 2024.

There are loads of workers who could do with a break from AEW or a change of scenery. That either means a jump to WWE for the first time, or a return "home" like CM Punk and Cody Rhodes.

One thing's clear: They need to get out before anymore damage is done...

10. Thunder Rosa

AEW Collision Thunder Rosa Cassandra Golden
AEW

Thunder Rosa would be a fantastic addition to WWE's female roster. She'd work well on Raw, SmackDown or NXT, and brings experience with a neat sprinkle of hard-headedness. That's far from a bad thing. Rosa is passionate, and wants to contribute. Sadly, her AEW career is all over the bloody place.

Ignore backstage politics and disagreements for a second. On screen, Thunder flits between being presented as someone big time who's a threat to everyone/should be winning titles with ease and...a background figure who can't handle business on her own. It's jarring, erratic and is doing nothing for her career.

Make it stop.

The former Women's Champ has been with AEW since 2020, but hasn't come close to fulfilling her potential with Tony Khan's league. Does she take some of the blame for that? Sure, although finding space to grow as a performer and show off your skills on a roster this bloated is akin to squeezing onto a packed train and looking for a seat.


9. Athena

Athena AEW
AEW

Some will be reading this and saying: 'Erm...Athena is ROH Women's Champion". Yes, yes she is, but what is Ring Of Honor in 2024? It's a sub-division of AEW, and most pro wrestling fans barely give the once-proud workhorse promotion a second thought. When was the last time you paid full attention to Honor?

In other words, being a champ on ROH these days is like being a champ in any indy company outside the majors. It doesn't mean a whole hell of a lot in the grand scheme of things; Athena's main role in AEW is to occasionally (very occasionally) hope she gets onto Collision, Rampage or those Battle Of The Belts specials.

This is a far cry from the noise made when she leapt from WWE > AEW in 2022. People were excited back then, but there's nothing to be thrilled about these days. Athena would be well within her rights to ask Tony Khan, "...is this it, my dude?'.

She deserves a bigger platform.


8. Queen Aminata

Queen Aminata Hikaru Shida
AEW

You probs weren't expecting to see this name here.

Queen Aminata has been hyped up in various video packages explaining her Guinean heritage. Then, she's worked a few solid matches across the full range of AEW TV shows. All of them have been followed by gushing praise from the announcers and empty words about how she's "one to watch". Rinse and repeat.

This is a recurring theme with All Elite. Aminata's last mainline AEW match was a win over Anna Jay on the 16 February 2024 Rampage. After it, the commentators invited fans to invest in her and come along for the journey yet again. What journey?! She hasn't been on core programming since.

Anyone with a working pair of eyes can see that Aminata has potential. She has a great look, can go in-ring, and has an inspiring story to tell about emigrating to follow her dreams. WWE would do something with that; AEW really hasn't, and it doesn't look like they're going to either.


7. Dustin Rhodes

AEW Collision Dustin Rhodes
AEW

It's time.

Look, it's cool that Dustin Rhodes helps out as a mentor/coach behind the scenes in AEW. It really is, but he'll always be considered more of a WWE guy, and there are a few nice paydays waiting for Dustin should he return. His brother Cody is the top babyface in the biz right now too, and you'd think Rhodes would want to be part of that.

Obviously, he's a veteran who is free to do as he chooses, but going back to WWE this time would also let Dustin be himself on a grand stage. He wouldn't need to look out the old blonde wig to play Goldust one last time, and that perhaps wouldn't have been the case when Vince McMahon was booking.

This fan sees more value in Dustin playing the veteran and loving brother role over in WWE than he does with Rhodes wrestling sporadic matches on AEW TV. Dustin can still go, so it'd be a shame if he never graced Raw, SmackDown or WWE PLE again before retiring.


6. Anthony Bowens

Anthony Bowens
AEW.com

Please note: Anthony Bowens on his own, not with Max Caster and Billy Gunn. The Acclaimed package is sweet. It's been fumbled big time by Tony Khan over the years, but it still gets a reaction from live crowds and works as a midcard distraction. Bowens has more to offer than that though.

Anthony has looked really, really good anytime AEW has booked him in singles bouts against guys like Brian Cage, Jon Moxley and others. Those opportunities have been few and far between, granted, but Ant's performances always stand out when he gets the chance. It'd be fun to find out just how high he could go.

It's worth finding out.

AEW has typecast Bowens in that OTT tag-teamer role, so there's likely no chance he's breaking out into singles stardom at this stage in the game. A move over to NXT would let Anthony develop his skills and explore possibilities on his own. Personally, this fan would love to see what happened next.


5. Keith Lee

Keith Lee Rampage
AEW

It is important to talk about the various health issues and injuries Keith Lee has faced over the past few years, because it'd be unfair to put blame for his mediocre AEW run squarely on Tony Khan. If anything, Khan deserves praise for standing by Keith throughout it all. However, let's not pretend his All Elite career has been worth much.

Lee had serious steam behind him when he left WWE in 2021, and people figured AEW would make the most of him from 2022 onwards. Nope. Keith was mired in a tag-team run alongside Swerve Strickland, then the feud that stemmed from that was interminable and spotty to say the least.

Big Keith could use a change of scenery again.

Things just haven't worked out for him. Yes, health and injuries has been a major factor, but AEW blatantly don't have a clue how to book him effectively. Lee's best era came under Triple H and Shawn Michaels' watch on NXT. He sorely needs that sort of stability in 2024.


4. Miro

Miro AEW
AEW

"He sorely needs that sort of stability in 2024".

The same could be said for the former Rusev. Things got off to a wobbly start for Miro in AEW when he was introduced as Kip Sabian's "Best Man". It was sudden and lower-key than many fans hoped, but everyone prayed he'd have his (Rusev) day eventually. Meh, Miro has had some.

His TNT Title run should've been huge, but All Elite fluffed their lines (as they tended to do with TNT pre-Christian Cage) and a so-called unstoppable force became just another guy on the roster who didn't seem all that special. Since then, it's been very much stop/start for the Bulgarian.

He could use the same stability pitched for Keith Lee going forwards. In short, Miro would thrive if he landed back on WWE's scene as a powerful midcarder. Stick a manager with him, 'cause promos have never been his strength, and he'd be off to the races.


3. Ricky Starks

Ricky Starks
AEW

So, this is inevitable right? Ricky Starks didn't exactly burn the whole operation to the ground with a maniacal laugh during his recent interview with WhatCulture's own Andrew Pollard, but he'd have every right to be frustrated with how things have been going in AEW. After all, the talented star has worked just five matches on TV this year.

It's 31 May at time of writing.

Starks has been another victim of the start/stop push trend in All Elite, and that has to change. He's shown he's effective whether heel or babyface, and has even pivoted at the drop of a hat into tag action whenever asked too. That shows how versatile Ricky is, but he's been cycled off telly with pretty much zero explanation.

There's been a ton of chatter amongst fans about Starks joining his pals CM Punk and Cody Rhodes over on the WWE side. That'd be a blessing for Ricky right now, but everything hinges on his AEW contract and how long that deal runs. Once it expires, he's almost-certainly WWE bound.

Calling it now.


2. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Learning Tree
AEW

Chris Jericho prides himself on never looking back and always pushing forward with new, new, new. He's been rather outspoken over the years about knocking back a retread as 'Y2J' in WWE, but that was then and this is now. Jericho didn't need to look over his shoulder when AEW launched in 2019; maybe he does in 2024.

A lot of fans are sick of him. His latest 'Learning Tree' gimmick is also reminiscent of something Jericho did before in WWE. He's encouraging the boos by being obnoxiously friendly, which is a gimmick Chris used to great effect in early-2012. There are definite parallels despite his claims of always trying something different.

Few would be upset if Jericho took a nap under his own tree and vanished from TV for a while. He's had aspects of AEW programming in a chokehold for a while, and his continued heavy presence feels counterproductive rather than progressive. This FTW Title business has been the sh*ts.

Absence would make the heart grow fonder, and lead to one more WWE run. That might be Jericho's nightmare, but it'd work.


1. Wardlow

Wardlow Dynamite
AEW

Wardlow will go down in history as one of AEW's biggest flubs if his current career trajectory continues. The powerbomb-loving muscle man was over with fans when running roughshod over folks as TNT Champ, and the way he burst free from MJF's tyranny was wonderful before that. Then, everything stalled.

In fact, scratch that. Everything went in reverse!

Wardlow must be glancing over at how WWE books Bron Breakker with jealous eyes. They accentuate the ex-NXT man's strengths, hide his weaknesses and (thus far) book him consistently in a satisfying way. What is AEW doing with their version? Wardlow hasn't wrestled since March, and joining The Undisputed Kingdom hasn't worked out for him either.

The gig's up, people. Wardlow needs to get out of All Elite Wrestling and try his luck elsewhere. Perhaps replacing Breakker as a wrecking ball on NXT would serve him well. It's worth a shot, because he's living through creative purgatory where he is.

Which other wrestlers, if any, need to get out of AEW? For more like this, check out 10 Exact Moments WWE Stars BURIED Their Own Careers and 10 Wrestlers Whose Careers TANKED After Winning Big! 


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.