7 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (12 Oct)
Orange Wednesday in The Great White North as AEW crosses the border and Jon Moxley crosses the line.
All Elite Wrestling seemed to completely fall out of the conversational contraflow in the last week or so, and maybe that was no bad thing.
Between the return of Bray Wyatt to hotly debated Extreme Rules and Monday Night Raw shows in general, the events of Friday's Rampage/Battle Of The Belts double header almost completely disappeared from view. As - fortuitously - did yet more controversy that engulfed last Wednesday's Dynamite. Sammy Guevara and Andrade's backstage fight before the show put AEW back in the headlines for all the wrong reasons, and had The Fiend not had a weird old dance at ringside on Saturday night, we'd probably all still be pontificating on it now.
But dance The Fiend did, and AEW's first Canadian Dynamite represented the latest New Year/New Me refresh for a company that could desperately do with finding solid footing ahead of November's Full Gear pay-per-view.
"Chris Jericho Vs Bryan Danielson" is probably offered as a synonym for "solid footing" in pro wrestling thesauruses, but where would the third outing slot in between a TV ripper and one of the year's bigger in-ring disappointments? And what else did Tony Khan have in store for the organisation's north-of-the-border debut?
Let's light the fuse...
Downs…
3. Running (On Fumes) With Scissors
All the objective metrics - or quarter hour ratings and t-shirt sales at least - suggest that fans are still all in on The Acclaimed's scissoring shtick, but if last week's National Scissoring Day scanned as a risk that paid off, the latest development with 'Smart' Mark Sterling feels in desperate need of a director to yell "Cut".
Following a disappointingly non-committal victory for Swerve Strickland over Billy Gunn, itself a supplemental down for how little it did to maintain the heat between the former and current Tag Champions, Sterling and Tony Nese arrived on the scene to break up Daddy Ass getting a post-match scissoring from Max Caster and Anthony Bowens. He explained he had obtained legal use of the gesture, would make all the money from the t-shirt sales, and could and would sue if they dared test it.
And what, he's willing to put all that up for a shot at the Tag Team titles on Rampage in three weeks? There's obviously heat in robbing the fans of something they love in the short term, but the entire angle reeked of leaning into the result of The Acclaimed getting over rather what got them there. Caster and Bowens are characters and scissoring is a gimmick. Opponents should ideally target the former rather than the latter, no matter how many shirts all this sh*t flogs.
2. Jericho & Danielson Meet In The Middle
An unexpectedly uneven series between Chris Jericho and Bryan Danielson concluded with a match that, while heated towards the very end, only settled in somewhere between their All Out 2022 disappointment and Grand Slam Tournament Of Champions Semi Final scorcher.
Solid-to-good wrestling was hindered rather than helped by a partisan crowd. The Toronto fans were all the way into Jericho, and while Bryan's better than most when playing situational heel, that dynamic couldn't effectively mesh with the Sports Entertainment/Pro Wrestling angle that's dragged on with the Jericho Appreciation Society and the Blackpool Combat Club.
It flew in the face of reasoned suggestions that Jericho was the guy to elevate the Ring Of Honor Championship too - the match went on in the middle of the show and as it wore on didn't feel like it belonged any later. Daniel Garcia's decision to stick with 'The Ocho' went down well after weeks of foreshadowing that he'd probably end up staying put, and a pivot point might be forthcoming with him and Wheeler Yuta over the Pure Championship, but all of these developments further marginalised the match as something existing more as a vehicle to further stories than to definitively end a self-contained one.
1. My Guest(s) At This Time
It's to Renee Paquette's (more on her shortly) immense credit that she took the one line interviewers are permitted to say backstage in WWE and turned it into an eight year run in which she immediately became broadcasting royalty akin to other tenured legends in the role. She has brand new hurdle to try and hop over in All Elite Wrestling.
Paquette's presence magnified the continuing issue with interview interruptions being used as fake-feeling match set-ups. She elevated the scenes with her presence alone, but segments featuring Matt Hardy, Private Party, Ethan Page, Stokely Hathaway, Nyla Rose, Vickie Guerrero, Marina Shafir and Anna Jay were much of the infuriating norm.
Nyla was a so much of a popper in her promo that she almost earned an Up for her work alone, but 'The Native Beast' was a desert Rose and even AEW knows it. MJF called out the "trope" in his promo elsewhere on the show, highlighting that it's a known internal problem. Why, then was it not actually addressed? Doubled with Tony Khan's requests for referee improvements falling on deaf ears and the company looks like a place too prepared to put up with its nonsensical faults rather than challenge clichés and lazily embrace all the things that caused WWE to lose a monopoly in the first place.
Ups…
7. Renee Paquette Is #AllElite...
...and all feels right with the world. Not because AEW can present itself as a wrestling utopia anymore or even because wrestling's favourite real life couple have been reunited under the auspices of the same brand for the first time in four years. It all feels right because that's just one of the many things Renee Paquette offers.
Paquette is wrestling broadcasting royalty, it's a buzz having her back in the space, and All Elite Wrestling felt like the destination for professional wrestling when she walked out onto her hometown stage.
A hire is only as good as how well they're used, and while Paquette had to suffer the same interruptions Tony Schiavone, Alex Marvez and others have been made to put up with for years, she provided the perfect opening to a red hot show and will next be deployed as the anchor of an intriguing sit-down with Bryan Danielson and Wheeler Yuta.
Invaluable for her intangibles, she's a longterm gain for the company beyond measure.
6. A Man & His Former Dinosaur
With Christian Cage as the catalyst of a breakdown in relations between Jungle Boy and Luchasuarus, this was always going to be the match to set up the match, rather than the grand payoff. It was perhaps with these lowered expectations that the contest hugely, hugely over-delivered.
Centred around Jack Perry's knowledge of his former friend's weaknesses and if he could use that to cut a dinosaur down to size, a promising David & Goliath story entered the orbit of minor television miracle when Goliath nailed David with a sunset flip powerbomb from the ring through a table on the floor.
Existing for more than just the pop, the spot teased a still-injured Cage out of commentary and down to ringside, but Perry's rage was ultimately his undoing. The Canadian provided just enough distraction for Luchasaurus to score the win and further delay any gratification for the wronged party. A buzzing crowd were well serviced for now, and both men can count this as one of their best - if not the best - singles matches ever.
5. Mean And Thankfully Lean
Another routine win for WarJoe over The Factory was more about the post-match angle than the match, which was smart in preserving the understated cool of the TNT and ROH TV Champion's interesting pairing.
The unit has earnestly helped rebuild Wardlow's aura in recent weeks, and linking back up with FTR hasn't hurt him either. Most of it - outside of outliers such as the incredible singles battle with Brian Cage last week - is strictly undercard fare, but some care and attention has at least yielded a few small rewards. This week's was the subtle reunion with babyface returnee Shawn Spears.
Spears was last seen getting destroyed by Wardlow ahead of the Double Or Nothing showdown with MJF. The two men making amends in front of Spears' Canadian fans as the remnants of The Pinnacle were made whole again was a nice detail for the company that once treasured details as the norm. More of that is worth sitting through stuff that otherwise scans as filler.
4. The Bad Guy
Aside from the aforementioned acknowledgments that AEW promo interruptions are f*cking hack sh*t and whatever may or may not be going on with MJF and The Firm, this was electrifying stuff from the man every bit as generational as he says he is.
After doing yet more rationalising of why it's okay for him to be the worst person alive with a loaded callback to all he'd learned in his transcendent war with CM Punk, 'The Salt Of The Earth' offered an explanation of sorts about why he very nearly shook Wheeler Yuta's hand last week before backing off from William Regal. In doing so, he tiptoed around a bit of personal previous with Regal that was fleshed out on Twitter by Post Wrestling's Andrew Thompson, and never forgot the main message that an AEW Championship win is an inevitability.
The Elite were often praised for how their characters were never simply involved in the story they were in at that very moment. That what they did followed what they'd done before and foreshadowed what they'd do in the future. This is absolutely true of Maxwell Jacob Friedman. The more we learn of him, the more we learn about him, and the depth of thought confirms All Elite Wrestling still as the destination for the best version of pro wrestling is. If there's still a cloud hanging over this product post-All Out 2022, it's MJF who remains most likely to chart a course to clearer skies ahead.
3. Cowboy Shoot
Speaking of clearer skies ahead, a scintillating verbal showdown between Jon Moxley and Hangman Page may have been the standout moment from a show despite the awesome babyface triumph that sent fans home delirious.
Moxley was untouchable as usual, toasting the Toronto debut as a way to segue into bottling AEW's entire history into something he's had the tightest grip on since jump. Page was the perfect opponent to tee up with this specific rhetoric. His highs and lows have been baked into those of the organisation, as he explained without veering too much into exposition.
Moxley had dropped "anxious" into his opening salvo as a not-that-subtle knock at a man he'd otherwise shown respect to, but it was the last trait Page was willing to reveal as he steered into the hard sales pitch that cleverly doubled as a searing motivational speech for himself. Comparisons to one year ago were excuses to really soak in the gravity of all that's changed over the last 12 months, and MJF's lingering presence made him the ghost at this particular feast instead of The Elite and CM Punk.
This was the best, most believable and most relevant Page has felt in months, dating back to before he even lost the title. Beating Moxley was an impossible sell up until now, but with six days left before the battle, the two men located and nailed the crucial 1% doubt that will drive the emotional core of a major main event.
2. Walking The Walk Yet Again
The hunt for qualifier-free praise goes on as relates to the women's division in AEW. Between this match and the stolen TBS Title build between Nyla Rose and Jade Cargill, it still feels as though the company would rather partition a specific section of the show for females rather than just presenting a version of parity.
In spite of that - it's still a big "that", this contest was back in the traditional death spot - Toni Storm and Hikaru Shida's victory over Dr Britt Baker and Jamie Hayter was another hard-hitting affair with significant directions coming out for winners and losers alike.
Hayter's bubbling popularity was acutely preserved by virtue of the clean win the babyfaces achieved, she looked hard as nails running the show for the heels before the closing stretch, and Shida and Baker's old chemistry made a welcome return for a finish that put the former back in contention for a shot at Storm in the near future.
And just on Storm - she's rather selflessly stood back for much of this to happen, and more power to her confidence and maturity in the role as a result. The dreaded "interim" tag might be hanging around, but she's comfortably one of the best to ever hold any version of that top title and has become the cornerstone of what feels way more like a rebuild than the won we were told about in that regrettable Saraya segment a fortnight ago.
1. Big Thumbs Up
AEW hadn't explicitly labelled Orange Cassidy's All-Atlantic Championship scrap with PAC as a last chance title shot, but it felt universally agreed-upon that he was as good as done as a competitive concern if he lost here.
It's dangerous to lavish praise on doing bad things simply to further raise the highs of good ones, but Cassidy's defeats in multiple big matches in the last few years absolutely maximised the magic here. Champion and Challenger have tried and failed twice to summon the magic of their minor classic at Revolution 2020, but this was death or glory for the character and Toronto felt every potential beat of that all the way to Orange Cassidy's glorious triumph.
PAC's a super-athlete and Orange Cassidy is still funny, but this didn't reinvent the wheel and nor did it need to. After a killer war, actual justice was done - 'The BASTARD' went for his hammer, then a spare, and was rumbled and robbed of his weapons respectively. Cassidy has always been more of a traditional character than bad faith actors have ever given him credit for, and that should have been clear as the streamers popped for his celebrations. He may only hold the title half way up, but Steve Austin dragged it across the floor and nobody cried disrespect. Characters have characteristics, and thank goodness Orange Cassidy did have to add "loser" to his LinkedIn after all.