7 Ups & 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE Backstage (Oct 15)
WWE FS1 show proves to be low on actual "backstage" news, but high on just about everything else.
Wild as it may sound, this could have been one of the most anticipated episodes of a WWE television show in the company's history. Perhaps it still was.
Few gave too much thought to the news that WWE were to be adding shoulder programming to the deal with Fox that has seen them trouser a billion dollars for SmackDown. For the longest time, the figure itself was the story, followed then by the logistical reality of the move. There were more things to think about than a sister show full of fluff pieces.
Then everything went really weird.
Upon its formal announcement, the most pleasing element of the 'Backstage' show initially was the inclusion of the vibrant Renee Young as host. Taking Young off commentary (where results had been mixed) for the switch, it also harked back to the beloved Talking Smack series she anchored years earlier. Backstage felt like it could be fun, rather than filler. Not least with an insane story doing the round about one of her potential co-hosts.
Multiple outlets spoke of an audition gone well, but no further follow-up kept the audience guessing to see if it could possibly be real. Was this catch-up magazine affair really going to mark the return of CM Punk to WWE television?
Downs...
3. H-Bomb
CM who? Before we get onto that "skinny fat *ss" let's look at WWE's perpetual guest of honour Triple H, who spoke briefly about not a great deal from his spiritual home at the WWE Performance Center.
What to make of this, exactly? As a preview for the proper show starting on November 5th, the inclusion of Triple H here suggested that some of the Fox money was going to bring some big names to some big screens as part of the entertainment package. But company man Hunter had the sum total of sh*t all to add to his platitudes at the Crown Jewel press conference, outside of the odd bit of nicey-nicey about Bruce Prichard (more on that later), Fox and, somewhat cynically, Booker T.
He did have one announcement to make, but even he seemed keen to scale it back, wise as usual as to the eventual response...
2. "I'll Have An F-U, Please Bob"
In deciding that this inaugural casting of Backstage required a pro wrestling hook, WWE didn't actually fill viewers in on a number of potentially-excellent features that followed (more, pleasingly, on those later) nor the possibility of seeing Booker T give former TNA Tag Team Champion Adam 'Pacman' Jones a shoutout on FS1.
They promised, explicitly, repeatedly, a "blockbuster" trade.
With respect to Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross and blah blah blah everybody knows that bit because Bliss and Cross are class and SmackDown is better for them, but the pointed nature of the promotion permitted viewers to think big. Champions-swapping-brands big. The Fiend being forced back to f*cking Raw to feud with Seth Rollins forever big. Liv Morgan going back to the "Land Of Opportunity" big.
This was 'five feet of fury', but it wasn't big.
1. Can You Dig It?
No.
Here's the rub - Booker T did exactly what Booker T does every time Booker T is allowed in front of a live microphone on WWE television. He rambled, he raved, he put himself over relentlessly and he would have been even more insufferable had it not been for Renee Young's sturdy hand on the wheel.
Perhaps this is too subjective to be a fair Down. Maybe Booker T is your cuppa T, but by all means flame away in the comments with all the fury of his old pyro as to why. On Kickoff panels, he's exhausting. Over an hour, he was insufferable.
There is of course the hope that the two-time WWE Hall Of Famer was only doing one of these, with a very different co-host in line for the main show. And in the meantime, thank shucky ducky for Renee Young.
Ups...
7. Wild & Young
What a thrill it was to see Renee Young back in her element as an eloquent, effusive and enthusiastic host rather than in a prior miscast position at the Monday Night Raw announce booth. Announcers are no different to wrestlers in this regard - without making the best use of all the talents’ actual talents, the company risks ruining what they’re actually good at. Young is really, really good at this.
Her move to the red brand was made in good spirit (and good taste - Jonathan Coachman was abysmal in the role) but as the closing segment highlighted, she’s already only too keen to address and humour her failings in the position. It almost certainly came from increased confidence built up over a broadly enjoyable hour here.
A significant and valuable asset as long as WWE want to produce shows such as this (and around 35 years of precedent suggests they do), Young was the glue holding an at-times wobbly format together. As with Talking Smack, Unfiltered and other projects she’s been entrusted with over the years, it’s likely she’ll only improve further upon easing into the role. Or in this case, back in to it.
6. Paige HERE
The oddest thing about Paige making a terrifying meme of herself during the relentless WWE promotion of her film in 2018 was just how inauthentic and wooden the moment felt compared to how good she ordinarily is in these exact situations.
Put that down to nerves or possible dread over the end of her career, but 2019 Paige remains a vibrant and vital presence on a WWE product that is evidenced to be losing young people by the week.
Your crusty old writer might not get all the references, but nor should I. And the ones that were demographic-friendly were insightful and beyond the usual WWE bubble. Raving about the importance of Bayley's "heel turn" and forcibly ensuring that The Kabuki Warriors were actually taken seriously, the former Divas and NXT Women's Champion looked after her own far more than the main roster usually would.
5. Promo Class
Clearly looking to fill the hour and utilise the mammoth Fox rolodex, WWE turned to baseball star Adam Jones for the debut edition of a segment that was enjoyable in spite of itself.
An open and devout WWE fan, Jones' cosplaying turn as Virgil at Extreme Rules 2017 was one of the actual highlights of that shoddy show, with the footage spliced in here to remind/inform any fans of why he'd be an ideal choice for this particular bit.
Jones cut a serviceable promo on a mugging Booker T, to the tune of some upper-mid scores from the other three hosts serving as judges. There was a moment of unintentional hilarity as Christian extolled the virtues of a quieter promo before Booker T broke the knob off the b*llocks amplifier with his riposte.
These won't hit every week, but the good ones will serve WWE's brand well on their new home.
4. Captain Charisma
The aforementioned inadvertent negging wasn't the only thing Christian brought to the table (not literally, the lack of something for any of the hosts to lean on was slightly off-putting throughout) during an unlikely appearance on a show that could have succumbed to too much bullsh*t and bluster.
Composed, controlled and never short of his sharp sense of humour, Christian dictated his moments much as he used to his matches. Approaching all the current WWE storylines with a sincerity Corey Graves could do with adopting once in a while, the former World Heavyweight Champion leant huge credibility to the conversation in contrast to Booker's on-off buffoonery.
Plus, SmackDown's colour scheme is blue, so if Vince McMahon still hates his face, the dot across it on future episodes will as least be on brand.
3. Where's The Beef?
On the screen, where it always f*cking should be!
WWE Superstar Twitter is a mixed bag to say the least, with the performers able to help or hinder themselves with the exact same press of a button 280 characters deep into a flawed mission statement, emo song lyric or barbed dig at their boss or colleague.
It's a weird, unfiltered game that nobody has completely yet learned how to play, but the company's deal with Fox may yet be the change everybody desperately needs.
The WWEonFox Twitter account is...good! Funny, topical and self-effacing, it doesn't sell followers out for news and updates any more than it sells itself out. The crying Bayley boy was made famous by its retweet on the same day as the geniuses behind it lit an RIP candle for "The Wild Card" on Draft Day.
It must be these folk that inspired a closing skit featuring Renee Young and Paige roasting Twitter users for some particularly needless abuse on the app. Results were predictably mixed, but the idea was sound, outside-the-box and relatable. Imagine Vince McMahon grasping any of those terms in 2019.
2. Sunday Best
Armed with comments from sharply-dressed superworkers Sting and Shawn Michaels, a retrospective on Randy Savage and Ricky Steamboat's seminal Intercontinental Championship clash from WrestleMania 3 was a welcome interlude from the bright colours and swooshing graphics.
The Macho Man and 'The Dragon' provided all that sizzle along with the steak during their classic, but much like Savage's strategy on the night, this piece slowed the pace enjoyably, affording everybody the opportunity to talk about that the match meant to them at the time, or retrospectively as a training video.
This particular contest was a safe go-to for week one, but more live mini-breakdowns of WWE classics would be a welcome addition to the show when it kicks off for real next month.
1. Look In My Eyes, What Do You See?
A WWE Backstage personality?
Promoting-but-not-really promoting that CM Punk may well be a part of the finished version of this show several weeks ago was an absolutely inspired move from whichever triangulated forces carefully curated the message.
A spectre on the set throughout, the 'Voice Of The Voiceless' being airlifted in to the various piloted segments, skits and bits made for some fabulous fantasy television booking, not least to see how easily he'd find it slotting back into the ridiculous vernacular and vibe that permeates across all company output regardless of Network or direction.
This was an enjoyable hour of WWE fluff, but too much fluff results in a meandering mess. Who better than the 'Straight Edge Superstar' to add some jagged reality and keep the banter train on track?