7 Ups & 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE NXT (Oct 23)
In which NXT gives AEW hell at long last.
NOTE: Some ‘Ups’ are far more meaningful than certain ‘Downs’.
NXT has settled into itself—for the better.
It’s no longer the reactionary, desperate show that diminishes the prestige of an otherwise main event-worthy Championship match. Adam Cole Vs. Matt Riddle was a banquet of intensity, physicality and conditioning fought at 100mph—but it felt somewhat hollow because it was clearly promoted to spite AEW’s big premiere. This in no way helped the emerging vibrant babyface versus stale tweener narrative that has enveloped this Wednesday Night War.
This week’s show followed last week’s less showy but more foundational programme, the benefit of which is a better long-term serial. NXT has reverted to the formula that best serves it. There remains an emotional disconnect from too many of the characters, one informed by the way in which the angles are framed. The formula is thus:
Wrestler X wins match. Wrestler Y lays them out with a brief, one-sided beat-down and “stands tall”, main roster-style.
Or, alternatively: Wrestler X wins match, motions to retreat up the entrance ramp. Wrestler Y emerges with entrance music to stare them down in a very civil, staged confrontation—an IRL match graphic that just…sort of…ends.
NXT literally impaled that cynicism last night.
Downs...
1. Muddied Waters
The Io Shirai interference in the opener tainted Rhea Ripley’s win.
It was a clear attempt to weave a multi-pronged story together, which is good—theoretically—but it rendered the result somewhat indecisive. It moved that story forward, but not in a way that felt truly conclusive. Ripley is the clear choice to usurp Baszler. Her path should be clearer. Not to the detriment of drama, or her challengers in the field—but not in a way that muddies her aura as a killer.
This potentially leaves Belair with justification for a rematch.
Isn't this the "no BS" alternative to the main roster?
2. Pete Dunne Can't Talk; Shouldn't Say These Things
Obligatory, respectful ‘Pete Dunne is a superb, vicious technician’—but he can’t talk, and didn’t talk much, granted, and still, this was uninteresting. Cathy Kelly caught up with him, as he made his arrival, and asked him to collect his thoughts on Damien Priest’s win last week. He made no excuses, as no babyface should, but his delivery fell flat.
He was flanked by Tyler Bate, and his acting was grim British soap opera-level poor, too. “He hit you low,” he said, and it was unnatural and wooden and impossible to believe in as something he said on his own. Dunne also said he “didn’t care” about Killian Dain, which wasn’t ideal, since the Beast from Belfast is struggling to generate buzz.
The objective of any verbal segment is to build interest in a programme. Dunne literally said he didn’t care. This was counterproductive. At this rate, Dain looks closer to Forgotten Son than NXT Champion.
Is Bate’s apparent introduction to NXT proper an ‘Up’ in itself? It can’t not be. NXT doesn’t need another incredible in-ring performer who can’t build real, emotional interest in his matches—but AEW’s recent victories in the squared circle look in danger, if his seminal Cardiff war with WALTER is any indication.
3. Another Contrived Match: Made
Following Matt Riddle’s win, Cameron Grimes refused the fist bump.
Tyler Bate, standing at ringside like a magnet for contrivance that trope is, appealed to his sense of sportsmanship. Grimes, uninterested, shoved him away. Bate responded with a punch, setting up a match between the two of the sort that Mauro Ranallo will inevitably frame as Bate’s quest to “make a name for himself” at Grimes’ expense.
Very good match, dry build: that is very much the latter-day NXT story, one the lack of a competitive sporting framework apparently makes inevitable. NXT is trapped between two worlds: the scripted nature of itself and the competition-matters ethos it spouts without really qualifying.
So it’s all very much “Looking to make a name for himself” and it’s very much dry.
Ups...
1. The Right Woman Wins, Ultimately
A good match, not a great match, this is what should open NXT: forward-thinking storytelling with a progressive result. Ish.
Bianca Belair and Rhea Ripley toyed with and subverted the expected strength versus flash dynamic in a way that served the storyline: this was a meeting set to determine which star was best-equipped to challenge Shayna Baszler. To do that—as proven over the course of Baszler’s stranglehold over the Women’s Title—it’s not enough to even be the best version of oneself.
This felt much less like get-sh*t-in flex, accordingly, and the fans went bonkers for the unpredictable drama and twisting content.
Ripley performed and was received as a star here—so much so that, already, she feels like the most credible threat and welcome successor to Shayna’s crown.
2. Matt Riddle Is Da Man
An MMA fighter, NXT honoured the strategist by having him immediately scout Cameron Grimes’ over finish.
The match soon erupted into a beautiful exhibition of Riddle’s technique and personality alike; that Jackhammer spot—deployed so arbitrarily as to be a complete bantering off—was impeccable character work that popped the Full Sail crowd huge.
Cameron Grimes caught Riddle with a superbly-timed flip-into-a-German-suplex, Fénix-like in its smooth execution but adapted in a way that was congruous to this modern North American-styled fight. The exchanges at the finish were electric—the usual sort of modern counter-driven fare deployed believably and with real intensity—but was Grimes the best opponent for this latest (excellent) Riddle sprint squash? NXT has spent a decent amount of time building him as a player with the ability to chew through the completion with one bite.
It was a bit wasteful, but his finish wasn’t buried at least. The word “burial” belongs nowhere near this result.
3. Some Fun And Excitement
Breezango and Isaiah ‘Swerve’ Scott brought welcome reprieve from the grizzled, serious business that made up most of the first hour. Tyler Breeze and Fandango are quietly crucial to this televised NXT revamp: it would all be a bit po-faced without the fun and light comedy they bring to it.
Breeze was good value early; his repeated, boneheaded insistence on engaging in a test of strength with Jaxson Ryker was funny character work, and where it’s normally impossible to care about the Forgotten Sons—what an absolutely stupid, fatalistic act that is—here, they acted as a blank (bland) canvas on which the babyface trio showcased their stuff.
Scott was the obvious star here, and the match layout recognised that—but before his electric cameo, another welcome appearance from Fandango’s reinvented super-worker-adjacent character ignited the crowd. He is working his a*se off.
Scott bumped huge and selflessly for a pointless cause. He probably sold too much, without first mounting a shine, but the way he jumped around and off—and systematically took out the Sons—was tremendous.
4. A Welcome Return
Gentleman Jack Gallagher was one of early 205 Live’s few high spots—a very charming character that conspired to adapt slapstick silliness into a genuine, submission-savvy threat. It’s nice to see him back in any capacity of decent profile, much less the old, best version of himself.
He discovered that old fusion here, particularly in a neat spot in which he cowered at the prospect of an Angel Garza dive as an amusingly optimistic counter—only for the quasi-stripper to slap him on the back of the head.
This contrast in his character literally reared its head when he struck it against Garza’s in a wince-inducer of a counter of his own.
This wasn’t sold, at all, and it could not have been not sold at more glaring time: Garza shrugged it off right at the finish, which he sprinted into with a Cabrada.
Still, this was a decent enough showcase for the integrated Cruiserweight division, and it made sense to not completely geek-ify Garza in order to not undermine his sentimental favourite status.
5. A Better Result Than Match
Jessamyn Duke an Marina Shafir are still green, but that works in the context of their act—for now. They are more gnat than muscle for Shayna Baszler, little annoyances who act more as ego-massagers than true, Undisputed Era-like difference-makers.
Fortunately, the huge braces attached to the knees of Dakota Kai and Tegan Nox helped put over the dynamic, in place of the legitimacy that the MMA Horsewomen are meant to possess.
Obviously, this wasn’t anything special in itself, but it adequately served a bigger purpose: both Nox and Kai enjoy a heartfelt connection with the crowd, and NXT is in dire need of an emotional core. It was good for what it was, it didn’t overstay its welcome, and Nox looked on fire after a simple but well-built tease to her hot tag.
It was simply a nice little moment in a show that usually isn’t any of those things: a necessary shift in tone.
6. Main Event BANGER
Mauro Ranallo is a divisive commentator, truly love/hate, and much of the problem—beyond his distractingly awful wordplay—is how relentless he is. He screams about every morsel of action as if it’s the finish, and it all converges to become overwhelming. His boundless energy is too rarely measured, and it’s a shame: an all-time great play-by-play man lurks within him.
This outrageously good main event absolutely warranted full, unadulterated Mauro. In many ways, it was the match he was born to call: a blistering, richer and more ebbing tweak on the NXT version of the Keith Lee Vs. Dominick Dijakovic banger.
Roderick Strong’s inclusion added a more sophisticated strain of storytelling. His vulture character work neatly wove together the epic hoss spots, creating high drama and anticipation around them. And those hoss spots ruled: abandoning last week’s meh limb work, Lee and Dijakovic caught one another from ridiculous mid-air positions, as the advanced humans they are, in a string of well strung-together moments of awesomeness.
The means to which the match was made were main roster inelegant, but the end result was top-tier NXT brilliance.
7. Finn Bálor Turns Heel
Finally.
NXT has finally provided a true reason to tune back in next week beyond the promise of the sort of very good pro wrestling match that is too commonplace to truly savour. Finally, NXT learned or re-learned the true trick of great TV: the emotional hook.
After Johnny Gargano emerged to back up his old #DIY partner Tommaso Ciampa—a nice moment worthy of an Up in itself—Finn Bálor arrived on the scene to further even the odds.
The blocking of the turn was exceptional and so removed from NXT’s customs. Instead of cinematically drawing back for the purpose of “tension”, Bálor stepped forward and immediately smashed Gargano in the face with a Pelê kick. He spent just enough time registering the pop before the scene took on a note of melodrama, and then dropkicked Gargano through the barricade in a terrific-looking spot. He looked bigger, physically and in terms of his recovered presence, than he has in years. Johnny Gargano was the perfect target for this assault, too: he has assumed Bálor’s long-forgotten role as the heart of the brand.
The match will be exceptional, provided Bálor can recover his form, too—but it’s more than that, for once.
Bálor is a superb heel. If he can recover that character, NXT just improved by orders of magnitude.