7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE Extreme Rules 2021
Sasha Banks returns, Big E rules and Roman Reigns gets a gift from the heavens to topple a Demon!
If 2020 was a "Horror Show" in name and nature, what did that make 2021's edition of the show with barely a weapon in sight during the build?
Roman Reigns' Universal Championship defence against The Demon was slapped with the titular tag, but that felt inherently redundant due to the nature of the Challenger's character. What's scarier than the darkest recesses of Finn Bálor's soul? Said recesses tw*tting you with a novelty weapons, apparently.
Bálor is supposed to have to go to such a dark place to summon the creature from within that it causes him physical and emotional pain. It's why he doesn't do it all the time, other than because that intricate paint job looks like a total b*llache for a company that doesn't give a sh*t about any details let alone the literal devil in them.
But he'd have weapons at his disposal here. As for everybody else, it was just another Sunday in between the company's biggest stadium event of the year and a blood money event in Saudi Arabia that will likely prohibit a minimum of four performers on this card from even attending.
Based on those stipulations in the absence of any others, just how did it go?
Downs...
3. Demoted. Demoralised?
Liv Morgan and Carmella didn't exactly have a story worthy of a pay-per-view payoff ahead of their Extreme Rules clash, but something absolutely reeked about their battle being bumped to the Kickoff.
In keeping with Sasha Banks being taken out of her SummerSlam match with Bianca Belair just seconds before she she was supposed to enter it, WWE kept this uneasy information until they were live on the air. Not only does this sh*t alienate fans of both Morgan and 'Mella, but it can't do much for the mental states of the browbeaten wrestlers themselves.
Both have been dealt bad hands like this in the past, but when is enough going to be enough? Whatever was required of them on this night was made exponentially harder my yet another eleventh hour rejection
2. Doll House Blues
There's an arguably generous "Up" coming later in this article that will go into a bit of detail on the details that made Charlotte Flair and Alexa Bliss' Raw Women's Championship match better than it probably had any right to be.
But discussion of the contest can't go without time spent on whatever the f*ck it was that happened at the end. WWE certainly donated what felt like four eternities to it, so what's one entry in an article?!
Flair accepted the warped reality of all this by using then abusing the Lilly doll, but Bliss' act-ting as she sold devastation was excruciating. Going on, and on, and on and on, she'd stare then scream then cry then stare then scream then cry as Kevin Dunn presumably controlled the desk with his left hand and kept an ear out for somebody knocking on the door of the truck.
Rubbish stupid sh*t that undermined something good? In WWE?! It's still child's play for them.
1. Demon Daze
Wild ending at #ExtremeRules leads to Roman Reigns retaining against Demon Balor ?pic.twitter.com/qKdhjmdNfd
— Playerz Circle (@PlayerzCircle) September 27, 2021
Bang average from end-to-end, Finn Bálor's farewell to an undefeated Demon gimmick turned out to be not that big a heartbreaker after all.
There was one really cool bit when The Demon nailed Reigns in his c*ck off a kick out to give him a taste of his own b*ll shot, and the near fall it lead to was legitimately thrilling. Before and after that, the two mostly went through all the usual WWE pay-per-view main event tropes until they hit the biggest ones simultaneously. The announce table was broken just before the barrier, before Bálor's music brought him back to life for the sequence that brought his demise.
Before the ropes collapsed underneath The Demon's feet, he'd produced a bunch of taped up kendo sticks as a super weapon. His "dark place" is obviously a hardware story - why didn't he check those corners before the bell?
Ups...
7. Kicking Off & Kicking *ss
A worthy and physical offering, Liv Morgan and Carmella made so so much more of the reduced role WWE gave them.
The former SmackDown Women's Champion cut a promo before the match that reeked of the usual risible old-dudes-scripting-young-women energy hanging around WWE like a bad stench at the moment, but the in-match trash talk was infinitely better than the planned verbiage.
It genuinely built acrimony between them, and the crowd were totally on the hook by the end. Fans completely bought into the fistfight towards the end and lost their sh*t further for Thesz press/enziguri/stomp three-fer from the former Riott Squad member. The near falls flowed, the volume continued to increase, and Morgan's victory actually felt like it mattered!
6. Oh-High-Oh
A quick mention is in order for the Columbus, Ohio crowd before digging into the other positives on this card.
The whole roster had to know from early on that the potential was here for a particularly great night after the noise made for both the pre-show match and the opener.
It was one thing for Big E to get a hero's welcome, but quite another for Liv Morgan, AJ Styles and just about everybody else out there to blow the roof off. WWE haven't sustained these atmospheres over three hour Raws since crowds came back, but the reactions this evening were reminiscent of the era when Sunday supercards still carried some prestige.
5. Big Starting
A six-man tag set up on the pre-show brought Bobby Lashley together with former Raw Tag Team Champions AJ Styles and Omos in order to keep The New Day's euphoric reunion train on the tracks and set up the inevitable rematch between 'The All Mighty' and Big E.
To this end, it was massively successful. But that would undermine just how loaded it was with other stuff to love.
Xavier Woods was awesome as usual in epic exchanges with Lashley and AJ Styles having saved Kofi Kingston in the first of two awesome hot tags - and what a display from the WWE Champion that was when the second one hit. E swinging for Omos felt like money, the "New Day Rocks" chant he summoned for an attempted Big Ending was loud and unanimous, and the well-delayed brawl between the former and current Raw titleholder felt major before AJ Styles f*cked it all up with a heel miscommunication.
New Day were better on the night, E beat Big Bobby again, and fans loved the lot of it. 2021 had beaten 2020's show within one match.
4. Profit In Piece
Montez Ford was both the focus of both the narrative and The Usos themselves following the sh*t-kicking he took from Roman Reigns on Friday's SmackDown.
Ford dropped the theatrics on the pre-show to put forth a more serious side, having suffered the worst of Roman Reigns' temper while Angelo Dawkins wasn't there to make the save. But his ribs were a target for the Champions, who persistently used the weakness until it became the undoing for the Challengers.
When Jey Uso got the knees up during Ford's From The Heavens attempt, things looked bleak, but Dawkins didn't want to fail his friend. Everything was measured impeccably from there - neither Profit was at fault for the eventual defeat. Ford killed himself for the cause, Dawkins showed loyalty and guts, but neither had quite enough of either when it mattered most.
3. Good, But Not The One
A weird build - the Alexa Bliss character doesn't get a chance to have a normal one - threatened to undermine this Raw Women's Championship match until a go-home promo that finally got to the point of something a little purer.
Flair wanted Bliss to find the wrestler underneath the stupid gimmick, and she mostly got what she asked for. This was a hard fought battle with the expressed purpose of forcing Alexa's character into making a choice. Countering and outwrestling the Champion before refusing to lay down, Bliss was suddenly looking completely without a weakness. Then her opponent picked up her toy doll for like five seconds and totally threw her off.
A real sh*tter, that, and there's more on it elsewhere in the article. The women deserve an awful amount of credit for assembling something so strong before the weak finish they knew full well would tank it all.
2. Bringing The Immersion Back
Sheamus Hardy.#ExtremeRules @WWESheamus pic.twitter.com/Jd4Er480MH
— WWE (@WWE) September 27, 2021
The United States Championship triple threat match between Damian Priest, Jeff Hardy and Sheamus was careering wildly off the f*cking rails thanks to a couple of humiliating botches by 'The Archer Of Infamy' and 'The Charismatic Enigma', but the three's willingness to absolutely batter each other and Sheamus' incredible patter somehow made this nothing match feel like everything.
Did you see him doing his little crotch chops and Jeff Hardy poses as he gingerly kept his balance? Did you really see it, though?!
It can go such a long way, and it did here. Laughing at the whole thing suddenly made the prior errors feel insignificant, and eventual winner Priest felt like he'd accomplished something as part of that too. His teflon year continues.
1. Bossing It
A most subjective of an "Up" perhaps, but when WWE welched on offering a finish in an otherwise-excellent Becky Lynch/Bianca Belair match, the excitement of seeing Sasha Banks turn this singles feud into a three-way dance overwhelmed any disillusionment with the p*ssweak finish.
Banks' return was as out-of-nowhere as her SummerSlam no-show. She picked the exact moment Belair looked set to win her title back, but destroyed both Champion and Challenger to make it clear that she still believes herself to be superior to both.
Judging by the response of the Columbus natives, it'll be exciting to watch her try and prove it. A singles match as a curtain raiser was a treat - Lynch was terrific working heel and every single hard/fast/strong/quick comeback from 'The EST' ruled more than the last - but the triple threat could well outstrip on it on this scintillating slice of evidence.
WWE Quiz: How Well Do You Really Know Extreme Rules?