7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE WrestleMania XIX
The Showcase Of The Mortals.
Though WrestleMania 18’s failings informed much of what made 2003’s ‘Show If Shows’ so appealing, Vince McMahon could only look on with muted concern as the buyrate came in for his star-loaded response to the prior year’s sputtering spectacle.
Mindful that one iconic match had the power to derail the rest of the show, he booked three. A cavernous and disappointingly-decorated dome was cast aside for the beautiful Safeco Field. 2002’s midcard ran badly short on content and context, whilst WrestleMania 19 preferred the return of a ‘Showstopper’ in an angle and match that allowed him to live up to his name.
But numbers haven’t ever lied to The Chairman. In the pocket of the post-Attitude Era slump, WrestleMania XIX’s hugely disappointing 560,000 buys fell 320,000 short of its predecessor - EVERY fair-weather fan from time’s gone by had jumped off the bandwagon. As outstanding as this event was at times, McMahon had had to forcibly begin things again in 2004. More than any time WWE had branded a match or show as such, this event had no choice but to be the end of an era...
(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, XIV, XV, 2000, X-Seven, X8)
Downs...
3. Miller Sh*te
There's a place on every WrestleMania for a palette cleanser or two, and WWE often lean in to the celebrities involved in the show in order to break up the monotony of so many matches. But the needless titillation that was supposedly garnered from the segment failed to resonate with anybody beyond Jonathan Coachman and (obviously) Jerry Lawler.
For all the context needed, the Miller Lite Catfight Girls gained a shred of notoriety after a Superbowl commercial they featured in was banned - the sort of sh*t Vince Russo used to go wild for when the late-1990s audiences lapped this up.
Like much of what didn't work on this otherwise-entertaining show, it was a relic of a bygone era - and resulted in Rob Van Dam, Kane, Lance Storm, Chief Morley and The Dudley Boyz all having their 'Show Of Shows' moments relegated to a pre-show slot to make up the time.
2. "Now I Know You'll Be Loving This Sh*t Right Here..."
WWE gambled on their audience's adoration of The Undertaker to turn a possible catastrophe into a clandestine clunker after 'The Deadman's partner Nathan Jones was deemed unfit to join him against The Big Show and A-Train.
Long before his undefeated streak ever felt under threat, 2003's 'Show Of Shows' was a bit of a night off for 'Booger Red' despite his partner's absence.
A Limp Bizkit entrance a full year after he'd binned the theme was yet more echoing of a long-distant past, whist Jones' run-in at the very end justified his absence throughout the body of the match - the Aussie whiffed a spin-kick in the aisle before posing with his partner for the closing beauty shots. And that's all they were. Jones had an awesome look, and Seattle was the only city to see it spotlighted on the 'Grandest Stage' before he disappeared from view.
1. Reign Of Error
Triple H's removal of Booker T from his orbit in 2003 still triggers annoyance not just for the racially-charged content of their storyline but the sheer machiavellian magnificence of 'The Game'.
Everything about the match required the challenger to go over. Booker was subject to bigotry from the oppressive heel champion and his d*ckhead sidekick Ric Flair but lost clean as a sheet when he got his WrestleMania shot. As if to confirm everything spat at him by Hunter and 'The Nature Boy' beforehand, he was kept away from both the strap and the chap as he slid towards the Intercontinental Title in the immediate aftermath.
It was vintage gamesmanship from somebody identifying as 'That Damn Good' at it. Hunter was a ring general at his year 2000 peak but this was yet another reminder of what WWE used to have, rather than what they were now stuck with.
Ups...
7. Cruiser Wait
Timings were all over the shop on the show (back when the company had to actually concern themselves with such trivialities), with several matches severed in order to make ample space for the mammoth main events later on the show.
Though Matt Hardy and Rey Mysterio later stole a summer SmackDown with a powerful main event, the first chapter of their rivalry here was grossly underserved as a result.
Though it barely stands up against a Seth Rollins Raw match in the modern age, watched in context it at least played to the sneaky 'V1' gimmick Hardy had brilliantly honed, and gave Mysterio a grand entrance on the 'Grandest Stage'.
6. Girls Gone Wild
Jazz, Trish Stratus and Victoria provided a spiritual sequel to the WrestleMania 18 three-way clash, with Lita's replacement Victoria and safer placement on the card providing an even more satisfying outcome. The last 12 months had proved astonishing for Trish in particular - she'd exponentially improved as a wrestler, becoming doyen of a reinvented division in the wake of the first brand extension.
Victoria and Jazz were intense heels, sharing the load of smashing the sh*t out of Stratus before her eventual re-emergence. A double shoulder-breaker on Stratus was particularly innovative and ferocious and spoke to the innovative efforts that often went ignored.
The finishing sequence spoke to how well thought-out the contest had been. Victoria's valet Stevie Richards ran interference with a steel chair with Jazz disposed on the arena floor, but after nailing him with a hard Stratusfaction bulldog, Trish reversed Victoria's Widow Peak to leather the champion with a killer Chick Kick for the climactic title victory.
5. Tagging Out
2002's "SmackDown Six" period was considered the apex of Paul Heyman's WWE booking tenure as the former ECW head honcho pushed all his favourite wrestlers whilst using Al Wilson's sex drive as a distraction piece for Vince McMahon.
With Kurt Angle and Rey Mysterio otherwise engaged on the show and Edge out injured though, the spots in one final supercard showdown featuring the crew fell to Team Angle and Rhyno. In just 8:48, the replacement sextuplet brought the goods.
Charlie Haas and Shelton Benjamin were gifts to the midcard in early 2003 and slid effortlessly into the high impact action audiences had been permitted to expect from Los Guerreros and Chris Benoit at the time. 'The Crippler' himself was a stand-by main eventer ahead of the show - he'd get his moment next year but was one of the multiple moving pieces in a rapid-fire clash won by the newbies to help spins the Champions off into the feud that would eventually make Eddie Guerrero the next great babyface hope.
4. Showstoppers
Despite an epic SummerSlam return and some enjoyable Raw segments that followed, the jury was remarkably still out on Shawn Michaels' surprising return. Older heads were cynical towards his transformation, his part-time schedule and the potential political permutations, whilst those simply glad to have him back were willing to overlook dull duds such as his Three Stages Of Hell stinker with Triple H the prior December.
Then, 'Mr WrestleMania' made good on that self-proclaimed moniker.
'HBK' and Chris Jericho had a glorious pro wrestling classic, littered with countless callbacks to the mirror-man story that fuelled the build and just enough fire from Shawn himself to suggest that he'd opened himself back up fully to the one thing he did better than almost anybody else. 'Y2J' was more than a supporting player too - his nuanced heel work in the match foreshadowed the boot to the b*llocks at the very end.
He cut the catharsis off at the end as he had during the contest himself, and perhaps took with him the arrogance his opponent used to have. During his 1990s pomp Michaels' used to wail "TOP THAT!" backstage after one of his belters. Reborn Shawn simply let his work do the talking.
3. The Architects
On arguably the most loaded WrestleMania card in company history, Vince McMahon made this match the marquee, quite possibly because he completely bought into the story he'd scripted between himself and 'The Hulkster'.
Rooted in loose truths, it was fairly straightforward for hardcore fans to bite on even if it alienated a section of the mainstream that never really gave a sh*t - just who was responsible for the success of WrestleMania, and by proxy, WWE? McMahon had used the 1980s expansion and 1990s rebirth to present himself as a mogul and marvel, but Hulk Hogan's 2002 return served as a reminder to many of why they fell for the charms of his offering in the first place. Their bitter dealings throughout 1994's steroid trial and Hulk's 1996 heel turn were dredged for content - the two biggest carnies of the lot were asking us to buy into reality.
And then the bell rang.
Hogan and McMahon went full batsh*t banter with a blinding brawl. Taking every single shortcut but exploiting them as few others could, the duo cycled through their greatest hits in front of a rabid, rapturous crowd. Blood, wood and Roddy Piper were all deployed as the two milked every moment and delivered so much sizzle than a steak wasn't required.
At WrestleManias X-Seven and X8, they'd respectively (and unexpectedly) captured the imagination of the masses against wildly different opponents. Here, rather fittingly, they found a sweet spot with each other.
2. One More Round
There's a subtle beauty to Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock's final WrestleMania encounter, even if it understandably fell slightly short of their prior two clashes - this was not a battle between two creative and commercial juggernauts consumed by Attitude Era chaos but an encore performance of the period's epic season finale two years earlier.
'The Great One' hadn't yet fully stepped away for Hollywood (and that halfway house informed his outstanding heel schtick) just as Austin (as far as the fans were concerned) hadn't been forced out of action altogether, but in contrast to banter brawl they followed, both men still felt like they were in a version of their prime.
On the outstanding "Mania Of WrestleMania" proto-24 documentary made on this show, the extent of 'The Rattlesnake's plight was fully fleshed out. For the want of more words, he was f*cked, but got up one last time to lay down for the man that had helped enhance his incredible legacy. Rock knew all of that, and took a poignant moment centre-ring after the fall to tell him as much. Two larger-than-life icons had never looked so human.
1. Breakneck Pace
Away from the obvious kayfabe rivalry between the two most celebrated amateurs in WWE history, the real tension heading in to Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar's main event match was how the Olympic Gold Medalist would fare with another "broken freakin' neck". Astonishingly, it was the state of 'The Beast's head and neck that had everybody panicking when the match concluded.
John Laurinaitis catches some flack for allegedly needling Lesnar into concluding the contest with the shooting star press, but both men had every reason to believe it would be the biggest moment of the main event. Brock had hit the move countless times before - his botch was a simply worst case scenario sadly realised.
Otherwise, this clash was fiercely fought and full of gravitas. A low key changing of the guard, Angle and Lesnar's places in the headline spot (over the four men they followed) was at the very last moment a reminder that WWE weren't entirely trapped in their illustrious past.