7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE NXT: New Year's Evil (Results & Review - 2 Jan)

Trick/Melo takes center stage, Valkyria flies high, Roxanne comes unglued, Femi breaks out.

Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

After years of suffering from an identity crisis that saw it migrate from a pseudo-indy promotion to a third brand, to a dark and boring 3.5-star match factory, to a neon-infused, sex-crazed botch-fest, WWE’s developmental brand has finally hit on a blend of all of the above to arrive at something that truly offers a bit for everyone.

NXT’s New Year’s Evil special provided that mix for fans Tuesday night, with some quality in-ring action, recognizable names, green wrestlers plying their trade, comically bad backstage segments, and a fair amount of melodrama.

Overall, New Year’s Evil was a brisk, entertaining program with matches that didn’t overstay their welcome and segments that didn’t linger too long, so if they were bad, they just breezed by before viewers could become annoyed.

At the same time, there wasn’t a ton from Tuesday’s show that will likely make a year-end highlight reel, safe for Joaquin Wilde being launched off a unique slingshot and Oba Femi winning the NXT Breakout Tournament.

Fans who went into Tuesday knowing what to expect weren’t disappointed by New Year’s Evil. Even the bait-and-switch main event provided a good plot development for the Trick Williams-Carmelo Hayes saga, and it gave fans a nice surprise appearance.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

4. What’s The Play Here?

Ridge Holland
WWE

Devoting a sit-down interview to Ridge Holland to better explain himself after inadvertently putting Ilja Dragunov on the shelf wasn’t a bad idea, but the conversation only served to confuse the story more.

Heading into Tuesday, the story seemed to be that Ridge has had a black cloud over him when it comes to his opponents getting injured: Big E, Elton Prince and now the NXT Champion. The tactic of leaning into two real-life in-ring accidents was interesting, but it was worth giving them some latitude.

Holland’s New Year’s Evil interview instead focused on his personal journey and the injuries he’s sustained in the ring, including a gruesome one in 2020. However, they completely ignored the Big E and Prince accidents, making it weird when they suddenly zigged into the Dragunov injury. Ridge insisted there was no malicious intent and said he was back in NXT to prove who he is.

So, who is Ridge Holland? They wanted to play off his in-ring mishaps, but then sidestepped them completely at the most appropriate time. It’s one thing to want to show both sides of the coin, but that doesn’t mean you forget the obvious suddenly. It felt very disjointed and fake, when it should have been a great balancing act to leave things a bit nebulous.


3. What’s Roxanne’s Deal?

Roxanne Perez Arianna Grace
WWE.com

What in the world is going on with Roxanne Perez?

The Prodigy has been on a weird trajectory for a while now, with the NXT plants, er, fans booing her at times while she’s been showing a more heelish, aggressive side. The problem is that during her match with Arianna Grace, Perez still was fighting from underneath like a babyface, and only afterwards did she unleash a heel beatdown – which was triggered by Grace getting in her face after losing to Roxy.

The entire scene seems like NXT is trying to add an edge to Roxanne or have her play a tweener rather than the pure babyface she portrayed upon her debut. But it doesn’t feel like it’s clicking. Are fans supposed to rally behind her for standing up to a heel? Or is the play that she’s unhinged and overly aggressive (as the match result was overturned because Perez kicked too much a**?

When a character’s direction isn’t clear and it’s not terribly interesting, that’s when you get apathy from the fans, and that’s what’s going to happen here.


2. Who Writes This Stuff?

Even on a two-hour, match-heavy NXT program, there still must be a series of interviews and backstage segments, because that’s how WWE television goes.

And one of those segments gifted fans with some abysmal “acting” between Blair Davenport and Nikita Lyons. Davenport was fresh off her loss to Lyra Valkyria, and Lyons snuck up on her to point out that she could have attacked her former assailant and put her on the shelf for a year. Blair countered that she didn’t have the killer instinct to pull the trigger… and the dialogue went downhill from there.

Suffice it to say that it ended with referees and officials stepping between the two women before a brawl could break out, leaving viewers with the obvious grudge match between the two on the horizon.

This was just a groan-inducing segment with unconvincing acting between a woman who maliciously kneecapped nearly a half-dozen women and one of her victims. Instead, this more closely resembled two understudies for a junior high play rehearsing the dramatic confrontation that they were never destined to give in public.


1. Perez Wrestles Herself

Roxanne Perez Arianna Grace
WWE.com

Woof.

Yes, NXT is technically the developmental brand for WWE. Superstars on that show are presumably learning and plying their trade on live television, so it’s fair to give them a bit of leeway.

But Roxanne Perez might as well have been wrestling a mannequin during New Year’s Evil, rather than Arianna Grace. The match was about as basic as it could get, with Roxy racing about the ring and flying around, bouncing off the ropes, the mat and Grace herself, while Arianna was stiff and almost stationary at times. The match more resembled a professional dancer trying to lead someone in their third lesson through a tango.

Grace hasn’t been at this all that long, and she lost an entire year to injury, so there’s obviously time to make strides. But when you’ve got a TV special and a lot of attention focused on it, maybe throwing this match out there wasn’t the best idea.


UPS…

7. Backstage Segment Mayhem

Anywhere else than NXT and what preceded the main event would be ridiculed and sent to the trash heap.

But in the land of developmental, the rapid-fire backstage segments that peppered the latter half-hour of New Year’s Evil were just par for the course. If you’re accepting of that reality, they were just hilariously bad.

Chase U’s principles argued about who should enter the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, with Jacy Jayne of all people taking charge. As they walked off, Lyra Valkyria was just sitting on a road case 10 feet away, in the perfect position to be stalked by the crazed creeper that is Tatum Paxley.

Then the show switched to Axiom and Nathan Frazer discussing the Dusty Cup before some hilarious hijinks of inadvertently talking trash with Edris Enofe and Malik Blade right there. That gave way to the current NXT Tag Team Champions Tony D’Angelo and Stacks talking as they left the arena, introducing Adriana Rizzo as their new accomplice.

Oh, but they weren’t done. Stacks opened the trunk to reveal Joe Gacy, who had climbed inside hours ago to find somewhere quiet to think.

Just pure mayhem. Pure NXT. Either love it or hate it. But it can only exist there.


6. Something Different

Out the Mud
WWE

It would be easy to dismiss Out the Mud as a goofy act of wrestlers pretending to be street toughs, especially with former sommelier Reggie now going by Scrypts and fronting the group.

But even with some silly vignettes revolving around Chase U, OTM has looked more and more like they might be worth a look. Their pre-taped promo Tuesday night felt different – in a good way. They didn’t feel like three guys playing characters as much as three guys just spitting at the camera.

Bronco Nima in particular sounded raw, like someone scratching and clawing, and both he and Lucien Price made the scripted words sound authentic. Obviously, things could be very different when the bell rings, or they could be booked to participate in some ridiculous backstage skit next week.

But considered in a vacuum, Tuesday’s promo caught your attention and made you take quick notice of OTM, and that’s enough to merit an “up” here.


5. Breaking Out

Oba Femi
WWE.com

Oba Femi has just 20 matches to his name, but he’s definitely got something.

And Tuesday night at New Year’s Evil, Femi got something else: he won the NXT Breakout Tournament and earned a contract to challenge for any title. Femi knocked off a game Riley Osborne in a decent match that stayed within its means, with Oba working a bearhug and mixing in a backbreaker while Osborne relied on stick-and-move tactics and high-flying attacks to stay in the fight.

While Femi did muff a sell of a headscissors, he still did a nice job and showed some explosiveness at the end with a Snake Eyes, backdrop toss and powerbomb to put Riley down and win the contract.

It’s early, but it’s safe to say NXT could have something here. And kudos to booking a smart David versus Goliath finals with the more experienced Osborne keeping things on track.


4. Air Wilde

Joaquin Wilde flying
WWE.com

Whose idea was it to launch Joaquin Wilde about halfway up the ramp from the middle rope? Because that person deserves a raise.

The high-flying LWO – with surprise backup from Carlito after visa issues thwarted Dragon Lee’s involvement – toppled the boring ground game of No Quarter Catch Crew, a stable so bland that they think vanilla is too spicy. Or so some have said…

Cruz Del Toro and Wilde made sure to work the match at their pace rather than letting Drew Gulak’s crew control the tempo. As a result, a match that had “clash of styles” written all over it was pretty entertaining and kept fans pumped, right up to Carlito’s hot tag at the end.

Colon helped Cruz pick up the win with a Backstabber/Phoenix splash combo, giving the LWO a much-needed win. The only downside of this match was being reminded of just how good Wilde and Del Toro are as a tandem, because on SmackDown, they more often than not have been the “already in the ring” team rather than the exciting duo they showed Tuesday night.


3. No Messing About

Lyra Valkyria Blair Davenport
WWE.com

Maybe it was the jam-packed card, but the NXT Women’s Championship match didn’t waste much time in getting going and hitting high gear.

After a brief opening of mat work, Blair Davenport and Lyra Valkyria were sent right into the heavy artillery, with Blair nailing a diving stomp to Lyra’s head, then continuing the attack. Valkyria would come back with palm strikes and a running crossbody before Davenport wiped her out with an avalanche Falcon Arrow.

Blair drove her knee through the announce desk, leaving both women wounded and stumbling around for the remainder of the match. The war of attrition ended shortly thereafter when Valkyria hit a Landslide for the win.

What worked nicely with this match was seeing NXT not do a 15-20 minute back-and-forth struggle with 10 chinlocks and extended selling for drama. Instead, they worked a crisp 8-minute match where both women got rocked, playing into each going for knockout shots before the other could land a KO blow on them.


2. Stratton The Ranch Hand

Fallon Henley Tiffany Stratton
WWE.com

Come on, the minute the stipulation was announced, was there any doubt that Tiffany Stratton would be looking up at the lights against Fallon Henley at New Year’s Evil?

The very thought of the vignettes of Stratton struggling to clean horse stalls, milk cows, feed slop to pigs and other typical farm work was enough to make this outcome obvious. The match itself was fine, as Tiffany clearly has all the pieces to be a main roster success – the hope is that she’s got everything put together before WWE calls her up.

One moment provided a glimpse into Stratton’s poise: As she went for her Prettiest Moonsault Ever, she stumbled slightly on the top rope but followed through with the miss, landing on her feet and rolling through to take Henley’s attack. That slip could have derailed the entire sequence, but the former gymnast covered it so well that it was almost imperceptible if you weren’t looking closely.

Stratton being undone because she was so frustrated she couldn’t put Henley away that she attempted to use a chair was a nice beat, one that wasn’t a distraction finish but still gave Tiffany a bit of an “out” when accepting the loss.

Now, bring on the Ranch Hand Barbie vignettes!


1. The Saga Of Trick Melo Gang Continues

Kevin Owens Grayson Waller Trick Williams
WWE.com

By now, it’s pretty obvious to everyone except (possibly) Trick Williams that Carmelo Hayes is not completely on board with the Iron Survivor ascending to the NXT Championship.

Besides the backstage intrigue, there’s also been the constant side-eye from Melo, including a heavy dose of it Tuesday night after Williams defeated Grayson Waller – with some help from Kevin Owens.

Williams found himself in the match defending his title shot after Carmelo put it on the line for him, the match itself a substitute for the original main event since Ilja Dragunov wasn’t cleared to compete. Still, Trick was on the cusp of winning when Hayes ran out and “accidentally” distracted his buddy, which allowed Waller to set up for his finisher.

Enter KO, who continued his SmackDown rivalry with Grayson and laid him out, allowing Williams to get the win despite the Melo distraction. Afterwards, Hayes looked far less than pleased with the outcome.

Things will boil over soon, but they’ve managed to keep it bubbling just beneath the surface, or at least just enough out of view that it isn’t making Trick look foolish to not call it out.


In this post: 
Ups & Downs
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.