7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (15 May - Review)
Owens and Zayn face attacks on all sides, Cody excels on the mic, Nakamura survives Miz.
Let’s get right down to brass tacks: WWE Raw is an average TV show at best. Spread out over three hours is enough material for a really good 90-minute program, and maybe even a pretty good two-hour show.
But when you watch Raw, you have to accept certain universal WWE truths: The action will mostly hover in the three-star range; the promos will be mostly overwritten, though great superstars can elevate bad material; the comedy most likely won’t be funny; certain parts of the show will test your patience.
We tend to grade Raw on a curve, where you excuse some of the drag and mediocrity, likely due to stretching two hours of programming out to three hours and failed television writers trying to make athletes memorise ridiculous dialogue.
That’s not to say Raw was a slog. Monday’s program included a magnificent promo from Cody Rhodes that should serve as a template for how to build a story and set realistic stakes for a grudge match. Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn are just too damn good to be held down, and their interactions with Imperium and Judgment Day were good fun.
But you also had to endure Shinsuke Nakamura in a pitched battle with… the Miz. We were reminded that Natalya is not on Rhea Ripley’s level. WWE’s strange booking of new superstars continued as well.
What we’re left with is a Raw that raised the stakes for its major matches without committing any major sins – enough for passing marks this week.
Let’s get to it…
DOWNS…
4. Where Were These Videos Last Week?
Great idea by WWE to have short video packages (re)introducing fans to new Raw roster members JD McDonagh and Apollo Crews on Monday night.
Bad idea to run them on the same show as both men were unceremoniously eliminated in an Intercontinental Championship battle royal Monday night. Worse idea to run both videos after the match.
Shouldn’t the videos have run last week to welcome them to the roster, and then we’d know who they are and why they’re here? Instead, it was “hi and bye” in the battle royal for McDonagh, who then attacked Dolph Ziggler outside the ring. Later, we got JD’s video package, followed by a backstage interview where he said he wanted to make a statement.
The sequencing of all of this and execution was off. It felt like they were at a buffet and went for the main course first, then dessert, then the appetizer, and finally a salad. You have to get this stuff right if you want fans to connect and care about wrestlers. Otherwise, you get silence during their matches.
3. Nope, Take It Back
Last week, this column included an “up” for Natalya being Rhea Ripley’s presumed next challenger for the SmackDown Women’s Championship (you know, the blue belt being defended on Raw between two Raw wrestlers). The thought was that Nattie could provide a good challenger to further cement Ripley’s standing.
But watching Natalya “act” on Raw pretty much killed any goodwill from last week. Nattie interrupted Rhea backstage to defend her not “staying in her lane” last week because she was defending Dana Brooke from a beatdown. Ripley countered that Natalya wasn’t trying to help Dana but rather was trying to make people care about her by glomming onto the SmackDown Women’s Champion. (And I mean folks, where’s the lie?)
The problem here is that Nattie just isn’t believable as the babyface “conscience of the women’s locker room” defending Dana Brooke, another face who fans barely react to when she’s in action. Natalya walking – not running – out last week to “save” Dana also undercut her entire message Monday night and gave more credence to Ripley’s view.
And if the heel champion is making a better case than the face challenger, you’re in trouble. So yeah, sorry, but it’s going to take a lot of effort to put this one back in the positive category.
2. Don’t Live Down To The Gimmick
There’s no hotter heel on Raw right now than Dominik Mysterio. (Yes, that’s an actual sentence we never thought would be written, but it’s also one that can be verified.)
Dominik’s entire gimmick as a heat magnet is that he’s the ungrateful, undeserving, underachieving son of Rey Mysterio who manages to succeed in spite of himself. He relies on the rest of the Judgment Day to bail him out, as he is ill-equipped to defend himself or win his own fights.
This is backed up in reality because Dom is… well, not that great in the ring. He’s not bad, but he’s not exactly going to carry on the Mysterio legacy in the same way as Rey. But that doesn’t mean that he should be lackluster in the ring.
Monday, Mysterio battled Xavier Woods in a rematch from last week, where Rhea Ripley pulled Dom out of the ring to save and help him win. This time, Woods anticipated the save, but he still fell victim to a Ripley blindside.
She tossed Xavier back into the ring, where Dominik proceeded to do the worst rollup in history to get the win. It wasn’t even a rollup – there was no leverage, no weight across the shoulders, nothing. Woods had to lay there and flail and pretend that Mysterio’s bootlaces were magically holding him down for the 3 count.
That rollup shouldn’t negate the huge heel heat Dom earned on Raw, but when you botch the finish that badly, it’s going to get negative marks..
1. Going 50/50 With… The Miz
Let’s not waste time reading the Miz’s Wikipedia page of accomplishments as he does every week. Suffice it to say, Miz has a long list of credentials just by virtue of his longevity in WWE.
But Miz in 2023 is a jobber with a name. That’s not a knock on him, but no one is buying him as anything other than a human punching bag. So why did he go back-and-forth with Shinsuke Nakamura for 10+ minutes on Raw? Why did they trade kicks? (Yes, Miz exchanged kicks with Nakamura.)
If you’re trying to establish Shinsuke as a potential second-tier top babyface, having him sell for Miz’s offense is just a horrific idea. To put a finer point on it, Miz hasn’t won a televised match in 2023. Along the way, he’s lost to Rick Boogs, Pat McAfee, and Snoop Dogg.
So, explain again why Nakamura was selling Miz’s It Kicks and getting a foot on the ropes to save himself from a Skull Crushing Finale. It’s not like this was some entertaining battle. Give Miz his brief 30-second “oh crap, Miz could steal one!” moment, then have Nak vanquish him with a barrage. Done and done.
UPS…
7. Mustafa Is Positively Heading To Night Of Champions
Sorry for those of you who have given up on WWE doing right by Mustafa Ali, but this writer just wants to believe in things going right for him.
That doesn’t mean there’s a scintilla of a chance that Ali defeats Gunther for the Intercontinental Championship at Night of Champions, but seeing Mustafa win the battle royal Monday night (and not by hiding on the outside and sneaking back into the ring at the end) and then standing up to the Ring General was a nice couple moments.
Ali has toiled away and fought against the WWE machine for years, being dealt bad creative, bad gimmicks, and dropped storylines for what seems like forever. Even if he’s just Gunther’s first sacrificial lamb on Raw, if he at least gets time to shine at NOC, that in and of itself could be a victory for him.
After all, we’ve got to start somewhere and set the bar low enough to crawl over it. But you’ve got to also reserve the right to sour on this quickly.
6. Indus Sher Obliterates Jobbers
More like this please.
It’s a really simple formula that works when done correctly: Stick two big wrestlers in a tag team and have them demolish smaller, pasty jobbers week in and week out, tossing them around like lumpy pillows and beating them into jelly.
For Indus Sher, this is the best path for them to get over with fans as a threat. Have them repeat Monday’s massacre several more times against no-names before moving up to an entry-level tag team (most likely Cedric Alexander & Shelton Benjamin if Vince McMahon has a say) and see where it goes.
No one is predicting that Sanga & Veer are future tag champions, but they could be menacing heel challengers who float below that level, beating up weaker teams and always serving as a threat. Monday’s outing was short, simple and modestly effective.
5. True To Themselves
Few things are more entertaining than when great superstars know and fully embody their characters, turning the dial up as they go.
Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens know who they are, and they know how to play off each other and other wrestlers, so watching them open Raw Monday night was an actual treat rather than suffering the usual, unbearable promo train we have to endure.
Zayn railed against Roman Reigns and the Bloodline, screaming about how Roman has gone unchecked for too long, that he doesn’t know when enough is enough – the two world titles and 1,000 days as champs aren’t enough, so he’s coming for the tag titles.
The Judgment Day’s interruption could have felt tacked on, but KO lost it immediately, begging them for a fight. Sami tried to play peacemaker – again, both right in character. But the high point of the segment came with Owens asking Dominik Mysterio what he thought, just so fans could boo him mercilessly, and then getting pissed because he couldn’t hear him and asking Zayn if he could punch Dom in the face.
Tremendous fun to open the show, setting the stakes for the tag title match at Night of Champions, and of course, doing the WWE thing and setting up an impromptu main event once again. SIGH…
4. Reed Gets Dominant Heel Treatment
Battle royals can be great vehicles to give multiple wrestlers direction or character development all in the context of that one match.
Monday’s Intercontinental Championship battle royal saw Alpha Academy tangle with Maximum Male Models and the Viking Raiders, JD McDonagh and Dolph Ziggler start a rivalry, and Baron Corbin continue to struggle.
But one of the most notable performances had to be Bronson Reed, who was the biggest man in the match – and WWE leaned into that. Reed managed to eliminate fellow big men Otis and Ivar at the same time, which garnered a pretty nice reaction. He survived a gang-up and fended off various attacks, clearly playing the role of the biggest threat in the match.
Although he didn’t win, Bronson finally is starting to look like a “big man” rather than a guy who happens to be large. (Yes, there’s a distinction there.) Reed does have some potential, and Monday’s showing indicates that WWE is willing to explore that a bit and see if he can pull off the role.
3. Rousey, Baszler Return With A Bang
The women’s tag division hasn’t been a huge conversation-starter, but Monday night might have given fans something to talk about.
Ronda Rousey and Shayna Baszler returned for the first time since winning a women’s tag team showcase at WrestleMania 39, attacking Raquel Rodriguez after her victory over Chelsea Green. The duo seemed on pace to win the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship earlier this year, but an injury to Rousey derailed those plans.
The MMA veterans’ return could signal that those plans are back on track, as they laid out the only healthy tag champ (Liv Morgan wasn’t medically cleared to wrestle Monday night). Morgan and Rodriguez defeated Damage CTRL last week and were poised to take on Green and Sonya Deville Monday before Liv’s injury shelved that match.
Baszler and Rousey would add some star power to the tag division, and having them as champions could bolster the titles a bit if done correctly. Regardless, having the two of them back is a net positive based on potential. How they’re used in the coming weeks will determine if it stays a positive.
2. Sami And Kevin Versus The World
Babyface champions like Kevin Owens & Sami Zayn thrive on adversity – it’s what keeps fans in their corner as they continue to struggle as underdogs against overwhelming odds.
How do you continue to ratchet up the adversity though after Sami and KO have vanquished half the Bloodline and are already facing the other half next week? Simple: You have everyone else gang up on them and cost the tag champs a main event match on Raw.
The Judgment Day picked a fight with Zayn and Owens to open the show, setting up the main event. Just when it looked like the champs were in control, Rhea Ripley and Dominik Mysterio came out to tip the scales. Once they were ejected, it looked like order was restored… until Paul Heyman came out, followed by Imperium showing up at ringside (notable as this came moments after Gunther shook hands with Heyman backstage).
Sure enough, Imperium cost Zayn the match, allowing Finn Balor to get the win for his team. As Corey Graves noted, everything was closing in on Zayn & Owens from all sides, with the Bloodline, Judgment Day and now Imperium all triangulating on the tag champs at once. That’s a hell of a mountain to climb.
1. Cody’s Masterful Promo Mesmerises
Really, what else can you say about Cody Rhodes’ promo Monday night other than wow?
Rhodes managed to tell the parable of the scorpion and the frog and not lose the fans, weave it beautifully into a description of Brock Lesnar the hunter, and then proceeded to scorch the Beast. Cody talked about how Brock looks in the mirror and sees a black eye and staples in his head, while Rhodes sees the guy who bloodied Lesnar up. He put over the legitimacy of his win – “a wrestling counter to a wrestling move in a wrestling ring” – before circling back to the bigger point.
Brock’s early nickname of the Next Big Thing might have applied years ago, but Rhodes asked what happens when people just say “next” to him? This rivalry, Cody explained is about who is the “big thing” on Raw now, but he made clear that Lesnar needs to take his “busted face and step aside” because the Beast is simply standing in Rhodes’ way.
This was class, a top-level promo that brought the fans to their feet (a rarity in WWE these days) and fired everyone up (including this writer). Rhodes turned a simple rematch into a quest: Brock recognizes that Cody is a threat, and it’s his mission to finally push Lesnar off his part-time perch as the alpha male in WWE. Fan-freaking-tastic promo.
The only negative here is that this would have worked perfectly as the go-home promo before Night of Champions, so you worry that they might have missed the peak by a week. But we shall see and try to have faith.