7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2023

Cody Rhodes and Rhea Ripley win; Bray Wyatt's "new" gimmick; Sami Zayn exits The Bloodline.

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

WWE was in a tough position heading into Royal Rumble.

Cody Rhodes' comeback announcement made it pretty obvious that he was winning the men's match, and Rhea Ripley was arguably the only choice to win the women's bout. Regardless, social media lit up with anticipation for The Rock's comeback, or maybe even Naomi returning with a bang.

Now for something strange: WWE is in an even tougher position coming out of Saturday night. Yes, Cody did win the 30-man favourite and will challenge Roman Reigns for the title at WrestleMania. However, Rhodes isn't the name on everyone's lips coming out of San Antonio - Sami Zayn's is.

Triple H might have something crafty up his sleeve though. 'Mania 39 occurs over two nights in April, and that means Reigns could pull double duty over the weekender by working Cody (WWE Title, which is his dream) and Sami (Universal belt). That'd satisfy everyone.

The Rumble was lower-than-expected on retro surprises, and the undercard was a real struggle at times, but WWE did successfully set the tone for WrestleMania fun to come. Plus, and this is a big plus, the main event's post-match angle was one of the best ever.

Here's all the good and bad.


Downs...

4. New Look, Old Problems?

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Bray Wyatt LA Knight
WWE.com

This guy isn't quite sure what to make of the whole "Pitch Black" match. It was all spectacle, but did feel a bit hollow due to the heavy Mountain Dew branding. That brand dominance was slightly regrettable due to the fact this was Bray Wyatt's first match back since rejoining WWE late-last year.

Wyatt's new look was a neon-drenched twist on The 'Fiend' more than anything, and it does seem like this is something fans have seen before (albeit with some quirky new neon wrinkles). Being brutally honest? Your writer wanted to like this, but found it hard to justify giving the match an 'Up'.

It was just sort of there.

Look, it'll be interesting see where Wyatt goes next. The same could be said for LA Knight, because he's more than held up his end of the bargain throughout this feud, but the whole 'Uncle Howdy' thing better have some kind of resolution soon, and it's unclear how much tolerance fans will have for more bouts like this one.


3. A Complete Waste Of Time

WWE Royal Rumble Alexa Bliss Bianca Belair
WWE.com

Eek!

Saturday's Raw Women's Title match is why WWE needs to realise they can peak a feud at the Rumble rather than booking useless short-term challengers for champions on the show. Two-three months is long enough to build something else for 'Mania afterwards, so there's really no excuse for not kicking something off in October/November and blowing it off in January.

Alexa Bliss vs. Bianca Belair was a standard TV-style scrap that did nothing for either woman. Bliss was never a true threat to the champ, and Belair has been standing still for a while now. She badly needs a coming feud vs. Rhea Ripley to work otherwise she'll be staring at a nondescript midcard spot on the biggest card(s) of the year.

Also, the post-match stuff with Alexa is ground WWE has covered before. That's on thin ice with the audience too, because it's a little old hat and Bliss teaming up with Bray Wyatt didn't work a few years back first time.


2. What Was The Point?

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Five seconds.

That's how long Chelsea Green lasted in the women's Royal Rumble. She returned to a modest pop at #20 (fans generally didn't seem too excited by most of the entrants in the match), then got eliminated in jig time by the all-conquering Rhea Ripley. This...doesn't bode well for Green.

Michael Cole harped on about how she just made Rumble history, but it's obviously unwanted history. Basically, Chelsea means nothing straight away after returning, and that's just poor creative. Remember this when the commentators try to big her up on Raw or SmackDown soon.

That's assuming she's sticking around and this wasn't a one-off deal. It could be, and that'd explain the comedic nature of it. Triple H bringing someone he supposedly believes in back and then handing them this spot on the show doesn't make much sense.


1. Yikes! What A Production Botch!

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Nia Jax
WWE.com

One of the biggest moments in any Rumble is finding out who's the final entrant. In fact, that countdown into entrance music loop is something most fans look forward to across the board for all 30 participants, but San Antonio got robbed of the right to be surprised or disappointed during the women's bout.

The countdown clock hadn't even appeared on-screen when Nia Jax' music suddenly hit and she made her entrance. The clock then showed up for a few seconds (counting down from 10) before disappearing again - that was quite the screw up, especially for the #30 spot in the match.

It was a baffling mistake from the production truck that kinda spoiled the potential for a proper surprised reaction from the live crowd. Even Cole, Corey Graves and Pat McAfee didn't really know how to sell the moment, so they went quiet for a sec.

WWE only had 59 chances to perfect the countdown before Nia's comeback.


Ups...

7. Starting Off Physical

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 GUNTHER Sheamus
WWE.com

GUNTHER and Sheamus were the right pairing to kick off the men's Rumble.

No-one out there would criticise WWE if they kept these guys close permanently. They always deliver the goods, and there's a ton of goodwill from the core audience because of their prior scraps. The pair reopening old wounds was an intense way to start the 30-man special.

Sometimes, the first two names out of the hat in the Rumble can feel a bit low-key. For example, Brock Lesnar and Elias going toe-to-toe in 2020 didn't work, and neither did Jeff Hardy and Bull Buchanan locking horns (ahem) in 2001. This was a little more akin to Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker in 2008.

Clearly, Sheamus vs. GUNTHER isn't on par with that battle between icons, but it is a combo currently revered by fans. They gave the Rumble a bit of star power to help jumpstart it, which came in handy to get fans onside early. This was the right decision.


6. Bobby Lashley’s Revenge

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Bobby Lashley Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Brock Lesnar being eliminated from the Rumble should always be a big moment, but it's probably deceptively tricky to include the 'Beast' without having him dominate. So, with that in mind, it was nice to see creative give Lesnar his usual suplex tour then have Bobby Lashley chuck him out.

That was revenge for recent attacks.

Bobby eliminating Brock sets the scene nicely for their coming rematch. WWE have two choices here; they can either power through that at Elimination Chamber, or keep it back for WrestleMania 39 if they don't have anything better for either man to do.

Put it this way: If Brock isn't working Steve Austin, then have him brawl with Lashley for a solid 10-15 minutes on the undercard. Their combined star power should help beef out one of the nights in April, and it'd be a suitable excuse to get both on the marquee.


5. GUNTHER = Record Breaker

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 GUNTHER Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

GUNTHER just made WWE history.

The big Austrian broke Rey Mysterio's record in "traditional Royal Rumble matches" by lasting a whopping 1:11:25 in the match. That 71-minute performance beats Rey's 62-minute one back in 2006, but it still doesn't topple Daniel Bryan's colossal 1:16:05 in 2018's Greatest Royal Rumble.

"Greatest" Royal Rumble, my arse, but records are records. Michael Cole noted that GUNTHER made history anyway, and it must be said that this was a huge show of faith in the reigning Intercontinental Champion from WWE higher-ups. The Imperium leader made the most of his night too - he was involved in some big moments throughout the match.

It's impossible to imagine this would've happened under Vince McMahon's watch. Triple H knows the kind of heel he has on his hands with GUNTHER, and he wanted to show the world just what the 'Ring General' is capable of on Saturday night.

Great things. That's what he's capable of!


4. Cody Rhodes’ Moment

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Cody Rhodes
WWE

Sure, this was all-but-set in stone the moment WWE announced his comeback ahead of time, but WWE did a neat job of adding some doubt to Cody Rhodes' win by booking GUNTHER so strongly. His 'Iron Man' performance threatened to upset Cody's destiny.

That destiny is one step closer to being fulfilled.

This year's male Rumble was peppered with plenty of mini-stories and drama which kept the pace up. There are always a few natural lulls, and some may hate the lack of more part-timer/retro surprises, but the full-time roster is good enough to carry things and they did.

Winning this kind of match justifies Rhodes' decision to leave AEW and return to WWE last year. He's had injury struggles, but now he's poised to wrestle the best all-rounder in the industry (Roman Reigns) on the biggest wrestling show of the entire calendar year.


3. Rhea Ripley Wins

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Rhea Ripley
WWE.com

Like with Cody, booking the obvious winner wasn't the wrong call in the women's match.

Going all the way from #1 to the finish made Rhea Ripley look great. Cole didn't mention the others who had achieved that feat, of course - there was no chance of a Chris Benoit mention on pay-per-view. This wasn't about the past though. No, it was about the future. More specifically, the future of the women's division.

Ripley had a stellar 2022 as part of Judgment Day. Pinpointing individual matches is tougher than you might think, but her character work and all-around star appeal improved by association with the group. That really made her the only choice heading into this match for many.

It's fair to say WWE suffered from booking two Rumbles on the same show again. Nothing new there when it comes to fan excitement, but Rhea was the right winner and can (hopefully) look forward to becoming the new face of Raw by beating Bianca Belair come 'Mania.


2. The Final Few Minutes

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Roman Reigns Kevin Owens Sami Zayn Paul Heyman
WWE.com

There was a period during the main event when this fan picked up his phone to browse Twitter. The fact that Kevin Owens was never taking those belts away from Roman Reigns didn't help the match going in, and it all felt a bit too routine/boring for a spell. Now for some good news...

...the final few minutes rocked.

Sami Zayn was the real drama around ringside, but the final stretch of the match was excellently-worked. KO even got a few nice near falls in, and there was always the thought that Sami might turn on Roman to help Kev win lurking in the back of fan minds. Seemed impossible until around halfway through, but better late than never.

WWE did well to sidestep Owens' temp-challenger status on the whole. He and Reigns didn't try to have some carnage-filled spot-fest - they kept things simple and told a story. That's appreciated, and everything peaked during the last five minutes.


1. Post-Match Brilliance

WWE Royal Rumble 2023 Sami Zayn Roman Reigns Kevin Owens The Bloodline
WWE.com

The entire post-main event angle was f*cking superb.

Roman demanding that Sami do his bidding, then Zayn cracking him in the back with a steel chair sent the live crowd wild. The way Jimmy Uso then instantly turned on Sami, but Jey didn't? Genius. They've been building this story for quite some time now, and it was role reversal from last year.

One thing you would say is that WWE better have some proper good build in mind for Cody Rhodes, because everyone's crying out to see Sami vs. Roman. That's the biggest match on the active roster right now, and no amount of tear-jerking promos about doing his dad proud from Cody will change that.

It'd be a travesty if the company didn't book Zayn to go one-on-one with Roman soon-ish. It has WrestleMania written all over it, to be honest. The Rumble's post-match storytelling ended this show on a real high, if only 'cause everyone was dying to cheer Sami anyway.

Now, they have every reason to.

What did you think of this year's WWE Royal Rumble? For more wrestling, check out 4 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (Jan 27) and 5 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE SmackDown (Jan 27)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.