7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE WrestleMania I

'The Showcase Of The Immortals' comes to life...

Wrestlemania 1
WWE.com

WWE have always loved the (slightly) false narrative about Vince McMahon gambling everything on the success of inaugural WrestleMania, and as the self-appointed gatekeepers of the entire industry at this point, why wouldn't they?

As if genuine wrestling history wasn't already being made, the company have retroactively added even more to the landmark event by implying that Vince and Linda would have gone bust without the incredible boom that followed.

Much about All Elite Wrestling's 2019 launch mirrored the maiden 'Mania's madness. As with ALL IN and Double Or Nothing, the 'Brawl To End It All' and 'War To Settle The Score' events in 1984 and 1985 respectively helped solidify the company's burgeoning relationship with MTV whilst promoting Madison Square Garden as a home base for what was for many fans a renewed artform. The Elite glibly promised to 'Change The Universe', but these and other comparisons only serve as a reminder that WrestleMania - more than StarrCade or any other NWA event Cody Rhodes could weaponise - was the business' real Big Bang.

Understanding the heft of the history is important in getting through the show too. The magic is as real as it gets, but your personal mileage may vary...


Downs...

4. Bundy Bullsh*t

King Kong Bundy SD Jones
WWE.com

There'll be a few occasions here where your writer applies a little too much generosity to the content thanks to the rose-tint of bonafide wrestling history being made, but that nostalgia-driven exaggeration won't compare to the flaming hot bullsh*t WWE served in an effort to set a record on a record-setting night.

King King Bundy's 23-second destruction of the Special Delivery Jones served the stated aim of getting Jimmy Hart's newest monster over as a clear and present danger to Hulk Hogan and others, but the company's blatant lie over the run-time reflected one of the few facts that could actually be checked and verified back in 1985.

Howard Finkel's "nine seconds" announcement popped the crowd, but the fabrication is a touch too absurd on rewatch.


3. Sins Of The Father

David Sammartino Beefcake
WWE.com

Not until David Flair dared follow in his father's footsteps did a second generation performer disappoint so spectacularly, but was the 'Nature Boy's oldest boy cursed by his first name as much as anything else?

The coincidence lets both off lightly in truth, but David Sammartino's failed attempt to forge a career from under his 'Living Legend' Dad's Madison Square Garden spotlight was flawed before it became apparent how bang average he was between the ropes.

Bruno's appearance on the show at least ensured that the territory's legendary past briefly featured amongst it's razzle dazzle future, but - unlike his pre-'Barber' opponent - his progeny never really looked like he'd be a part of it.


2. Dog Rough

Greg Valentine Junkyard Dog
WWE.com

Junkyard Dog was half the performer he'd been for Bill Watts during a prolific spell atop NWA Mid South Wrestling in the early-1980s - unfortunately the 50% retained was all charisma at the expense of doing anything memorable between the ropes.

This only took him so far against a Greg Valentine also some way short of his early-decade best, with Jimmy Hart's heel only really a cause of concern to the MSG faithful when engaged in the post-match punch-up with existing Intercontinental Title rival Tito Santana.

Santana would eventually wrestle the strap away from 'The Hammer' so the teaser here served a wider purpose (imagine that), but the 6:55 match felt treble that as they ambled along to a cheap countout finish.


1. New Champions? PHOOEY!

Iron Shiek Nikolai Volkoff
WWE

The risk of watching shows even a decade old - not least three - is that, robbed of context, the matches may not mean much. Wrestling as an artform is both something that needs to capture the frenzy of the moment but ideally survive the ravages of time, and it's for this contest's failure to achieve the latter that it lands in the negative column.

The heat is sensational for typical evil foreigners The Iron Sheik and Nikolai Volkoff when they dethrone babyface pretty boy tag champions The U.S Express, but the limited duo aren't particularly able to sustain it during the contest itself.

This results in a frenetic finishing sequence that somehow feels unearned. It is at least one of the show's notable shock results, but even that doesn't help it survive the most context-friendly rewatch.


Ups...

7. Never Forget Your First

Wwe Mean Gene Okerlund
WWE

The late, great (and won't those qualifiers tragically appear a lot over the course of reviewing past WrestleManias) Mean Gene Okerlund was - according to the man himself - a late replacement for a no-showing singer that night.

It was far from the most memorable rendition of the Star Spangled Banner, but was by its very nature a collectors item - Vince McMahon preferred 'America The Beautiful' anyway and made sure to include in place of the National Anthem as often as he could in the years that followed.

Affording the absentee some dignity, Okerlund never named the AWOL star - though considering how heavily the other celebrities were promoted in advance, it's very possible that the airlift story was used to cover up a charmingly cheesy start to McMahon's biggest ever undertaking.


6. The Original Mr WrestleMania

Tito Santana The Executioner
WWE.com

Tito Santana would go on to appear at the first eight WrestleManias (and do dark duties at the ninth), so it feels fitting that the popular white meat babyface could kick off the 'Showcase Of The Immortals' with a showcase for himself.

Working as an old faithful gimmick for the territory, the future 'Playboy' Buddy Rose donned the Executioner hood to make his own lone WrestleMania appearance, but was really little more than a warm body for Tito to despatch before he moved on to bigger and better things later in the night.

Inofensive and reliably enjoyable without outstaying its welcome, the match was Santana's entire appeal in a microcosm. Crucially, it's still eminently watchable for younger audiences - a grizzled twenty minute grapplefest kicking off the first ever WrestleMania may chase fans off before they've even settled in.


5. Tricky Steamboat

Ricky Steamboat Matt Bourne
WWE

Ricky Steamboat had gained acclaim for legendary wars waged with Ric Flair before the first WrestleMania, but found himself in the midst of a stop-start WWE push during the inaugural 'Show Of Shows', and one that would take two more years to bear fruits.

Across from him was celebrated technician Matt Bourne, working at a rather rudimentary level to ensure 'The Dragon' was cast as one of the company's brightest stars. It'd be eight years before he appeared on 'The Grandest Stage' again, but this lacked the clowning around of that infamous appearance.

Steamboat looks years ahead of his time here. His high spot finish raises the roof, whilst his chiseled frame outstrips virtually anybody else's on the card. Miscast in the Sports Entertainment madness, he nonetheless shone enough to convince higher ups to keep him around before finally making the most of his incomparable babyface fire.


4. Big Money Match

Andre The Giant Big John Studd Wrestlemania
WWE.com

Bolstering the old cliche about McMahon's fascination with big guys they might have been, but Andre The Giant and Big John Studd were in another postcode to the usual airport attractions McMahon typically meddled with. It wasn't about the biceps or beef here, more the sheer mass - and just how impressive it would be to see one of them hit the deck.

Relatively recent WWE arrival Bobby Heenan doesn't feature hugely on this show, but is at his typical 'Brain' best when he nicks off with Andre's bag of cash after he scores $15,000 for dropping his mammoth foe.

The two would make far more than that when they came together years later, but this cute bit of post-match comedy between the pair made the best of the vast discrepancy between them in both size and sensibility.


3. Girls Just Wanna Have Fun

Wendi Richter Cyndi Lauper WrestleMania
WWE

A clash undeniably carried by the star power of recording giant Cyndi Lauper, new Women's Champion Wendi Richter nonetheless has the necessary 1980s glamour to suggest she too belonged amongst other crossover stars Hulk Hogan and Roddy Piper at the front of Vince McMahon's canny Rock N Wrestling movement.

Far from just because it went on second from the top, Richter's victory over Leilani Kai was next in line as god was handing out main events. For all the match was makeshift, the extra-curricular activities between Lauper, her manager Dave Wolff and Kai's cornerwoman The Fabulous Moolah was inch-perfect tabloid fodder exactly as intended.

It was, tragically, the most significant Women's Title match at the 'Show Of Shows' for a full decade. WWE were wise enough to celebrate the importance of equality in 1985, but rapidly walked back from it when the mainstream attention dried up.


2. THE. MAIN. EVENT.

Wrestlemania 1
WWE

Not in Vince McMahon Jr's life had a match mattered more, but he got everything he could have dreamed possible out of the notoriously ill-prepared megastar Mr T as he joined forces with Hulk Hogan to take on Roddy Piper and Paul Orndorff.

The loaded clash protected it's 'A-Team' investment too. It wasn't enough to have three of the industry's finest in the match itself - the bout also boasted Jimmy Snuka and Bob Orton Jr as cornermen, as well as Pat Patterson as the man in the middle ensuring the contest clung together.

'The Hulkster' was the cornerstone of the early WrestleManias, and performances like this prove why even today Vince McMahon would risk public scorn just to get a few dollars more out of his walking, talking, flexing ATM. The most famous arena in the world went ballistic for his every move, even as he shared screen time with Ali, Liberace and the other celebrities that had entered his orbit.


1. History In The Making

Wrestlemania 1
WWE

It's almost comical to consider how WWE once transformed the landscape of professional wrestling within the confines of a 2:16 runtime when the product it later became barely books cogent title switches over 7 hours, but in less time than it takes to sit through two thirds of a Monday Night Raw, Vince McMahon changed everything.

For those already clinging on to his 'Rock N Wrestling' juggernaut, this was validation that professional wrestling was the place to be. For those that hadn't yet seen the faddy phenomenon, it was perhaps the best possible exhibition.

Celebrities were worth more than the sum of their parts in creating the spectacle McMahon craved, but the likes of Muhammad Ali, Liberace and Cyndi Lauper were legitimate megastars lending their names and credibility to the project.

WrestleMania I informed not just a wary wrestling audience but a brand new mainstream one that it was cooler to be on the inside of the operation than locked outside.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.