7 Ups & 5 Downs For AEW Collision (26 August)
This week's AEW Collision kept the wheels in motion as All In looms large.
Another week, another AEW Collision in the books.
For this week's Saturday show, it had the unenviable position of taking place the night before a major PPV, with its taped nature meaning spoilers were out online, and overall just being viewed by many as a Collision that you didn't particularly need to be going out of your way to see.
Still, the guys and gals of All Elite Wrestling delivered another solid, if not at times flawed, episode of Collision.
This time out, with All In looming on the horizon, in-ring-wise we had an opening six-man match with one eye on today's Stadium Stampede bout, we had a nice showcase outing for the Dark Order's Alex Reynolds and John Silver, we had Big Bill demolishing another enhancement talent, we had the ever-fun Willow Nightingale against Robyn Renegade, free agent 'Outlandish' Zicky Dice got a shot against Keith Lee, and there was an eight-man All Stars main event.
Elsewhere, Jack Perry looked to lay rest to the FTW Title, Le Faccion Ingobernable's Mexican adventure continued on, and another match was added to next weekend's All Out.
As a nice change, we also had ROH's Caprice Coleman filling in for Nigel McGuinness alongside Kevin Kelly to call the action. While McGuinness is phenomenal, it's always a welcome surprise to have Caprice on AEW programming in any capacity.
It may have been far from the best episode of AEW Collision, but we still got an overall good outing for this Saturday staple.
With all of that in mind, then, Saturday night's alright for fighting...
Downs...
5. Six-Man Nonsense
Some may have been impressed by the trios bout pitting Eddie Kingston, Penta El Zero Miedo and Orange Cassidy against Kip Sabian, the Butcher and the Blade, but this bout is on the Downs list for the sheer lack of rules adhered to in this match.
Since its inception, AEW has been a company that's bafflingly loose with its standard match rules, and this was fully on display in the opening match of this Collision.
When the ball rang, it was Penta and Sabian starting the match for their respective teams. Immediately, the four other competitors piled into the ring, before the action then spilled to the outside for nearly two minutes. And when the first pinfall attempt came, it was Cassidy getting a two-count on Sabian... despite not one tag having been made by that point, meaning Penta was the legal man for his team.
Stuff like this forever remains so frustrating and takes away from what was some solid in-ring work. Making it all the worse, poor Bryce Remsburg could be heard at several points shouting "no tag" as he did his best to inform the wrestlers that tags hadn't been made and that the legal men weren't in the ring.
Of course, this will very much come off as "old man shouts at clouds" to some out there, but what's the point in having fundamental wrestling rules in place when they're just so badly, blatantly ignored?
4. The Same Problems
Yes, I'm going to have to be that guy.
The exact same issues of the opening six-man match were prevalent in the Dark Order vs. Action Andretti & Darius Martin match later in the show.
In terms of in-ring, the action was great, with Andretti and Martin as ever bringing the high-energy, high-risk offense, and it's nice to see Alex Reynolds and John Silver being presented as a more serious tag team act. Unfortunately, this was another match where rules were totally ignored.
Because some of us are nerds for numbers, the finishing sequence of this bout saw at least three competitors in the ring at the same time for nearly one whole minute. All while referee Aubrey Edwards looked on, didn't try to get the illegal men out of the ring, and also didn't bother to start any sort of count; as in, an illegal man only being allowed in the ring for five seconds once a tag has been made.
This wasn't something reserved solely for the finish, though, for there were large stretches of the match where all four guys were in the ring at the same time, with the referee just standing there looking utterly useless. After all, what's the point of a referee if they're not going to enforce the rules of a contest?
Some people can brush this off and not let such ignoring of the rules dampen their viewing experience, but to others - such as this miserable bastard - stuff like this hugely tarnishes what, in this case, was really solid in-ring work.
3. Back To The Old Formula
One of the biggest gripes about AEW Collision - and the wider AEW product - has been its formulaic, tired approach to its female talent.
Week after week, the women's roster would get around eight minutes of Collision ring time, with three minutes of that taking place during a picture-in-picture commercial break. Then, last week saw mild improvement in how Willow Nightingale and Diamante got 12 minutes between the ropes, and so there was a smidge of optimism that maybe the ladies of AEW were to get more time to wrestle on Collision from here on out, or that, even crazier, maybe one day we'll actually get two women's matches.
Sadly, it was very much back to the 'norm' on this week's Collision.
For poor Willow and Robyn Renegade, it was back to the eight minutes of action, three of which were in picture-in-picture.
As ever, the talent involved did well with what they had - even if there was a smidge too much obvious interference from Charlette Renegade - and it was no surprise to see Nightingale pick up the W. What makes this week's Collision even more frustrating, though, is that it was a show brimming with so much filler ahead of All In later today.
That's not to say necessarily it would've been the right call to have Willow and Robyn get a competitive 15-minute match, per se - after all, Nightingale is way higher on the food chain right now - but surely on an episode clearly filled with matches and segments designed to merely take up time and not rock the boat too much before All In, could we have not got a second women's match?
Do better, Tony.
2. LFI BS
Last week, there was an Up for the Le Faccion Ingobernable segment simply because it was nice to see AEW doing something with RUSH and his crew.
That Up was met with the caveat that this whole LFI stuff could end up being great or it could end up being trash, and if this week's Collision is anything to go by, it appears to sadly be the latter.
Here, we had Dralistico and Preston Vance tied up in Mexico, with their heads covered by sacks. Beaten and bloodied, the two managed to untie their roped chains, crack some skulls, and lead all of their attackers in a heap. All as a mystery figure - seemingly RUSH - appeared to end out this segment.
This was awful, this was way too phoney, way too cheesy, and just was all a bit naff. The lighting, the camera cuts, how fake the blood looked, and the illogicality of this being 'filmed' was just too much.
1. So. Much. Filler.
While this was a solid if not spectacular AEW Collision, it was the weakest Collision so far, and it was a Collision that felt like such a filler episode.
Obviously with All In taking place later today, a show which airs the night before that isn't going to be able to do anything too major where it pertains to impacting that PPV. Still, this also throws up problems for All Out, which is a PPV taking place next week.
Yes, a couple of extremely brief backstage promos set TBS Champion Kris Statlander vs. Ruby Soho for All Out, but that was the only advancement for that Chicago-held PPV. To be one week out from a PPV and only have three matches announced - Stat vs. Soho, Miro vs. Powerhouse Hobbs, Darby Allin vs. Luchasaurus - is absolutely ridiculous.
Running PPVs on two consecutive weekends was always going to throw up so many problems, and while it's all well and good to champion "the biggest event in pro wrestling history" for All In, this bizarre scheduling makes All Out feel like a total afterthought.
This episode of Collision largely had its hands tied when it comes to All Out, and thus we got a bunch of nothing matches and some - not all - totally needless video packages. For instance, could the time allotted to recapping AR Fox apologising to Nick Wayne had not been spent on something else?
As for the main event, to call this an All-Stars match is quite the stretch. Sure, Sting is an icon of the business. Yes, CM Punk is one of the biggest - if not the biggest - stars in the company and also the Real Worlds Champion. Darby Allin is clearly destined for huge things in AEW over the next several years.
For the rest of the talent involved in the match, labelling them as All-Stars felt a little disingenuous. Large chunks of the audience are still getting introduced to Jay White, Swerve Strickland has huge potential but isn't positioned as a main event player yet, Brian Cage has been treated awfully for the bulk of his AEW tenure, Luchasaurus has largely become a background player to the brilliant Christian Cage, and HOOK is a rookie who's not even had 40 matches.
Not to be harsh on those names, but when you say AEW All-Stars, you think CM Punk, you think MJF, you think Kenny Omega, you think Sting, you think Jon Moxley, you think Chris Jericho, you think Samoa Joe, etc.
Ups...
7. Jack Perry Continues To Shine
It may have taken a couple of weeks for him to find his feet, but Jack Perry as a heel continues to shine on a weekly basis.
Here, the former Jungle Boy opened Collision by hosting a funeral service for the FTW Title. As the greatest FTW Champion of all time, Perry viewed himself as the only person worthy of calling time on this famed trinket of ECW.
Jack himself has previously talked about how he isn't particularly enthusiastic about having to cut promos, but this new heel persona is something that's fitting him like a second skin right now. To make all of this even better, Perry brilliantly cut to a pre-prepared video that was a collage of him and the FTW Championship having a blast together by the pool, in the pool, on a bike ride, in bed... all while a faux sad Jack watched this footage from inside the ring.
Of course, just as Jack Perry was about to bring a sledgehammer down on the FTW Title, the arena lights went out, a HOOK video played, and the Cold Hearted Handsome Devil himself turned up behind Perry to drop him with a few suplexes, including one through a table.
Perry vs. HOOK was confirmed for All In simply by the son of Taz grabbing a mic and stating "Wembley. Sunday", and that match is now set for the All In Zero-Hour pre-show.
The HOOK video here was a little corny, but the overall segment was good, with HOOK showing some nice physicality and Perry being great in his heel role.
6. "'Cos You're My Sweetheart"
We don't deserve Eddie Kingston. He's too good for all of us. We don't deserve him. #AEWCollisionpic.twitter.com/oYlDDMY9Tg
— Jack Cassidy (@RealJackCassidy) August 27, 2023
Eddie Kingston is the most believable man in professional wrestling. What the Mad King does and says, you believe every single second of.
While Collision's six-man tag may have been way too haphazard for your writer's particular tastes, Eddie's post-match actions were magnificent.
The initial post-match fallout had Chuck Taylor and Trent Beretta say a few words ahead of All In's Stadium Stampede, and Orange Cassidy was about to follow suit before the Blackpool Combat Club and Pride N Powerful appeared on the video screen.
With that, Kingston immediately exited the ring, pulled down his straps, and headed to the back to confront his All In opponents. It was brilliant, it was pitch-perfect, and it was obviously so, so Eddie Kingston.
Of course, by the time Eddie got backstage, the BCC and PNP had disappeared, and it's here where Kingston cut another fantastic promo. According to Eddie, at Wembley Stadium, Santana and Ortiz are going to get gutted up and die in the middle of the ring, Wheeler Yuta is going to get buried, and Claudio Castagnoli is being left for last "'cos you're my sweetheart" and is going to be burned and scarred. As for Jon Moxley, Eddie implored his on-off friend to stay out of his way.
Once again, Eddie Kingston delivers pro wrestling gold.
5. Lack Of Rules, But...
The rules may have been made a mockery of, but there's no denying the in-ring work of Alex Reynolds, John Silver, Action Andretti and Darius Martin impressed on AEW Collision.
Here, the action was extremely fluid, was worked at a fast paced, and did not overstay its welcome by the time Reynolds got the jacknife pin on Martin for the 1-2-3. The biggest takeaway here, though, was how much bigger a deal this Dark Order duo feel when presented in a serious light.
There was no hamming it up here, no laugh and joking; this was Reynolds and Silver working as a no-nonsense serious tag team, and they were much the better for it.
Now, if only this sort of action took place in a setting where the referee isn't made to look like a total idiot.
4. Just About Fine
Heralding the return of 'Daddy Ass' Billy Gunn, the Acclaimed's rap video on Collision was just fine.
Hyping the Acclaimed and Gunn taking on House of Black for the AEW Trios Titles at All In, this video did maybe drag on a tad, but it served its purpose in utilising Max Caster's rapping skills and reminding audiences that this six-man bout is on the horizon at All In later today.
Not great, not awful, but decent enough to fall on the Ups side rather than the Downs.
3. Ricky Stark's "Bigger Strap"
Last week, pairing Ricky Starks with Big Bill got a Down for being somewhat of a downgrade for Absolute, but there was just about enough this week to warrant a mild Up.
The reason for that prior Down was due to the fact that Starks had gone from a hot feud with CM Punk - complete with a rare pinfall win over Punk, a Real Worlds Title match, and an assault on the legendary Ricky Steamboat - to merely being the manager of Big Bill.
Unless Ricky is injured or there's other issues at play, creatively it's a total back step to have Starks in his current role, and even more insulting to not have him on the All In card. Alas, it does thankfully feel that the Stroke Daddy has something more substantial on the horizon after this week's Collision.
Big Bill decimated Vary Morales in less than two minutes, but it was the post-match promo from Ricky Starks which proved most interesting. Being the scumbag that he is, Starks whipped Morales with Steamboat's belt, before proclaiming how he'll back next week with "a bigger strap".
Your writer did speculate last week that maybe we could get Starks and CM Punk in a strap match at All Out, though if that is the case, as with so many other All Out bouts, there's only one week to get that set in motion. But the prospect of these two locking horns once again, with the added meat of Big Bill backing up Ricky? That's certainly an intriguing proposition.
2. An Outlandish Squash
Having two squash matches on the same show can often feel a little much, but Zicky Dice certainly made the most of his minutes in his loss to Keith Lee on this week's Collision.
For those not familiar with Outlandish, he was once a mainstay of Billy Corgan's NWA - before that place went to sh*t, of course - and then had a solid spell in IMPACT Wrestling. A product of Seth Rollins' Black and Brave Wrestling Academy, Dice is an extremely entertaining athlete, and so it was nice to see him matched up with Limitless here.
Did Keith Lee need to decimate Zicky in barely 90 seconds? You could certainly have maybe given this match another couple of minutes, but the larger picture here was to give Big Keith a dominant win to help re-establish him as a potential major player, and it's not like Zicky Dice is employed by AEW at this point.
Of course, that may change in the future, for Dice pulled off the rare feat of managing to impress and show a glimpse of charisma despite being on the losing end of a 90-second squash match.
1. "All-Stars" Deliver A Solid Main Event
As mentioned elsewhere, billing HOOK, Swerve Strickland, Brian Cage, Luchasaurus, and Jay White as All-Stars right now feel a little disingenuous. That's not a shot at the talents themselves, but more just the way that they've been positioned by AEW so far.
If you think All-Stars, you think the biggest AEW names, the talents who have headlined PPVs, the stars who have held World Titles. Still, the match itself delivered for what it was required to do; as in, put on some solid in-ring action to pad out a Collision that was killing time waiting for All In.
CM Punk secured the win for his earn, submitting Brian Cage with the Koquina Clutch after having already nailed the Machine with the GTS. Of course, Punk did all of this while staring directly at Samoa Joe - who's patented submission is the Koquina Clutch and who was on commentary.
On that front, away from the stellar in-ring work, it was great to have Samoa Joe joining the commentary team for this match. The King of Television is forever a welcome presence in such a role, as proved during his stint calling the action for WWE.
Likewise, it continues to be a positive to have Jim Ross join Collision for its main event, even if four voices - Ross, Joe, Kevin Kelly, and Caprice Coleman - could be deemed a little overkill for this eight-man tag.
Post-match, Samoa Joe hit the ring to attack CM Punk, Jack Perry came out to brawl with HOOK, Darby Allin made an immediate beeline for Swerve Strickland, as did Sting, and the scene descended into general chaos as Collision went off the air.
This week's AEW Collision wasn't up the standard of previous episodes, but it still did enough to be a solid outing as All In looms large on the horizon.