7 Ups & 5 Downs From WWE Raw (May 16)

Rebooked main event delivers, repetitive heel hijinks, Bliss botched, midcard gets love.

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

What a weird, strange and confusing night.

Some things actually happened on Raw on Monday night, but all anyone is probably going to be talking about are the strange circumstances that led to the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions walking out and forcing WWE to rewrite its main event on the fly. The idea that Sasha Banks and Naomi would leave the company high and dry sounds absurd on its face, and obviously more details will surface in the coming days.

Raw itself was a bit of a mess as a result, but you have to give WWE a bit of a pass on a lot of that. The show still had its usual issues, most notably its first three matches all featuring a babyface outnumbered by the heels in a singles match with outside interference. That kind of lazy booking really can’t be excused. Then there’s the issue of Alexa Bliss’ return being mishandled.

But on the flip side, Raw’s midcard actually is looking decent suddenly, and different acts are interacting with each other, which is refreshing. Cody Rhodes’ promo was solid, and the new #1 contender for the Raw Women’s Championship should provide a quality PLE matchup.

So yeah, this was a weird show. Good enough for passing marks, but not without its problems.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

5. Walkout

Naomi Sasha Banks
WWE.com

We’re clearly going to learn much more in the coming days about Sasha Banks and Naomi’s decision to walk out of Monday Night Raw, but as of now, there are no winners here.

Banks apparently wasn’t happy with the creative, and the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions decided to just leave rather than work through their differences with the booking. Considering it forced a very late rewrite of the show, that’s got to be a pretty serious offense to higher-ups.

It calls back to mind “Stone Cold” Steve Austin walking out on WWE when he was scheduled to wrestle – and lose to – a rookie Brock Lesnar way back in 2002. Austin was able to mend fences, but he did a lot of damage to his reputation in the short- and medium-term.

It will be interesting to see what happens with the two superstars, the tag titles, and any plans for the women’s division going forward.


4. 24/7 Shenanigans, Catty Women

If Sasha Banks and Naomi actually walked out of WWE Monday night for good, then they’ve got two fewer women in the division. So maybe it’s a good idea to get Dana Brooke and Tamina… and now Carmella??? out of the 24/7 “division.”

We got to endure a backstage segment with R-Truth serving Akira Tozawa his divorce papers from Tamina, then getting thwarted when he tried to get his 24/7 title back from Dana. Brooke then almost literally ran into Carmella, who jawed with her and called Dana a “sorry excuse for a competitor and wife.” We then got some cattiness, with a veiled James Ellsworth reference and a shot at Corey Graves’ prowess in the bedroom.

Carmella later told Truth she’d help him get his title back when she could get revenge on Dana. So now you’ve got three women on a roster of 14 (on Raw) competing over a joke title. That’s just ridiculous. Put a bullet in the title and be done with it.


3. Dumpster Fire Booking

Asuka Becky Lynch
WWE.com

It took WWE less than an hour to completely overhaul its main event #1 contender’s match for the Raw Women’s Championship, and while it wasn’t necessarily the company’s fault, there was a level of weirdness to it.

Raw opened by announcing a six-pack challenge for a title shot against Bianca Belair. The match would pit Asuka, Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks, Naomi, Doudrop and Nikki ASH against each other. But about 45 minutes later, Lynch ran up to Adam Pearce to breathlessly tell him that the WWE Women’s Tag Team Champions had packed their bags and left Raw. Yes, they just left Raw, and no explanation was given. (We later learned that this wasn’t originally part of a storyline, but a real walkout from the tag champs.)

Without 1/3 of the main event, Pearce did what any good official would do: he axed another 1/3 of the participants, making the #1 contender’s match a straight-up one-on-one bout between Asuka and Lynch, completely nixing Doudrop and Nikki from the match.

Just… what? Why? You could argue that the two Scots haven’t done anything to deserve being in a title contender’s match, but why were they in it in the first place then? Yes, it’s obvious that WWE had its hand forced by Sasha and Naomi walking out, but why not keep it a fatal four-way? Or even add Queen Zelina and Carmella to the mix to keep it a six-pack challenge?


2. Agents Aren’t Agenting

Riddle Uso
WWE.com

One of the important roles agents play in putting together a wrestling show is to make sure the matches and angles aren’t too repetitive. You shouldn’t book three count-out wins in a row, or two monster heels destroying jobbers in back-to-back matches.

And yet, Raw opened with three matches that saw the heels gang up on the babyface to really stack the deck against them. Bobby Lashley had to contend with MVP and Cedric Alexander while wrestling Omos inside a steel cage. He only prevailed by luck, going through the cage and being able to put his feet on the floor.

Right after, Theory played bait-and-switch to have Veer Mahaan face Mustafa Ali, with the Miz as special guest referee. Miz and Theory interfered and made things difficult for Ali, allowing Veer to pick up the win. And then after that, Jey Uso cheated liberally to help his brother Jimmy against Riddle, though the Original Bro prevailed.

It was pretty noticeable for the first two matches to include very similar dynamics, which makes you wonder why they didn’t just space things out a bit better. But throw that third match out there and it’s just overkill.


1. Botching Bliss’ Return

Alexa Bliss Sonya Deville
WWE.com

If you needed evidence that WWE can actively screw up the easiest stuff, witness Alexa Bliss’ return.

Let’s set aside the January vignettes that were rushed through to get Bliss back on TV for Elimination Chamber – and then she was promptly forgotten about because WWE didn’t have anything else for her, despite filming a nine-part series announcing her return.

Bliss finally returned last week as a straight babyface (albeit carrying Lilly, but sans mystical powers) and squashed Sonya Deville. It seemed straightforward, though she got zero promo time to explain where she had been and what her character is going forward.

Then Monday, WWE just decided to run back that same match. Only this time, Deville got a bunch more offense, and Alexa lucked out that the referee was out of position, or she would have lost. She put Sonya away, and that was it. No promo, no character development. A five-time champ returns for only her third match since September and she gets… that.

And somehow, WWE officials will be confused next week and the week after when Bliss’ pop diminishes as fans have less reason to react to her.


Ups…

7. Getting Right Down To Business

Omos WWE
WWE.com

This column has criticized WWE for its penchant for opening Raw each week with a 15-20-minute soliloquy or promo train, so we have to issue some praise when they mix it up too.

Raw opened with the steel cage already encircling the ring, and MVP and Omos came down so the manager could cut a relatively brief promo before Bobby Lashley came out to start the match. But Cedric Alexander jumped him in the aisle, allowing both heels to gang up on Lashley briefly, until officials could separate the men to send us into break.

So, we spent the first 12 minutes with a promo previewing the upcoming match and then a brawl that set the table for the cage match itself. Plus, we got a rundown of the card for the night, which is always appreciated.

We’ll take it.


6. Barbecue Sauce

Only Kevin Owens, Chad Gable and Otis could make barbecue sauce work as a punchline so perfectly.

The ongoing saga of KO and Alpha Academy trying to expose Ezekiel not as Elias’ younger brother, but as Elias himself continued Monday night when Gable’s DNA lab work was returned. However, the sample was “contaminated” with barbecue sauce. Owens read the report and stared at Otis, who remarked that Elias must’ve eaten ribs and pulled pork. KO yelled that he wanted a lie detector test for the human tree trunk because he saw him chowing down in catering last week.

All of this was really very silly, but all three men delivered it perfectly, making it a really comical scene that continues to take the absurd and make it work.


5. Just Enough Smoke And Mirrors

Omos Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

It’s pretty clear that Omos still has a ways to go in his development as a wrestler, but WWE did a nice job hiding his weaknesses inside a steel cage Monday night.

Omos’ slow movements were offset by having a cage to occasionally bounce Bobby Lashley into. MVP and Cedric Alexander were able to provide enough interference to keep fans invested in the All Mighty and keep the match active and alive. If anything, they could have bounced Lashley around a bit more in the cage to sell Omos’ dominance, but this actually worked decently.

The finish – which saw Omos toss Lashley into the cage wall, the wall gave way, and Bobby roll to the floor for the win – was a cop-out and a redo of Roman Reigns/Brock Lesnar from a few years ago. But at the same time, Lashley was getting battered by three men despite being inside a cage, so escaping with the win isn’t all that bad.

And this most likely will set up one more match between the two at Hell in a Cell. Hmmm… a cell, you say…


4. Liv Is Too Sweet

AJ Styles Angel
WWE.com

The booking was pretty linear and logical, but that doesn’t make it anything less to see what unfolded between AJ Styles, Finn Balor and Liv Morgan Monday night.

Morgan was cutting a promo backstage when Los Lotharios interrupted her. They were shooed off by Styles and Balor, who pitched to her that she should join them to battle THE Judgement Day. Last week, AJ and Finn were overcome due to Rhea Ripley being the X-factor in a post-match melee.

Liv, to her credit, didn’t just jump at it. She told them she needed to think about it. Then we got a rambling promo from THE Judgement Day. Afterward, Morgan had made her decision and joined Balor and Styles for their match.

After the duo beat back Los Lotharios in a competitive match, AJ and Finn asked Liv to join them in a Too Sweet gesture, to which she looked surprised and then a little geeked. It all worked pretty well, and now we’ve got two trios to square off in the near future.


3. Combining Midcard Angles Smartly

Veer Mustafa Ali
WWE.com

One of the biggest criticisms fans have been able to level at WWE in recent years is their total lack of focus on a viable midcard. You’re either Roman Reigns or a select few pet projects, or you’re just churn.

But lately, they’ve been giving some midcard guys stuff to do, which has made the show more tolerable – at least, the three hours aren’t as unbearable. Monday, they took a couple of the midcard stories and intersected them.

Theory and Mustafa Ali were set to square off, but he brought Miz in to be his special guest referee. He then threw another curveball by bringing in Veer Mahaan as his replacement. With Veer, Theory and Miz all against him, Ali eventually fell to the Cervical Clutch, despite putting up a good fight.

Afterward, Mahaan was going to attack Ali again, but Rey & Dominik Mysterio saved him by taking out Veer. It was a simple way to reignite the feud, but what was really impressive (for WWE) is how they made these two stories intertwine pretty well.


2. Cody Lets It All Hang Out

Cody Rhodes is definitely getting the star treatment, but he isn’t afraid to remind fans where he came from in his previous WWE run.

Rhodes continued to add an element of realism to his promos Monday night, talking about costing Seth Rollins the winner’s bonus at WrestleMania, an old trope used to partly explain why wins and losses matter – if you win, you’re paid more.

But Rhodes also compared his previous run with Rollins’ rise in WWE, noting how Seth came in as part of The Shield, captured gold and then broke the glass ceiling to become world champion. Meanwhile, Cody kept losing a lot, even painting his face and smiling while he was “dead inside” as Stardust. However, he endured, reinvented himself and rebuilt himself.

Cody talked about vindication and second chances, then said that Rollins would have to kill him to keep him from succeeding with his second chance, setting up his challenge for Hell in a Cell, which Rollins would quickly accept.

This could be another barn-burner of a match. Let’s hope they continue to build off the previous two and elevate the game, because this feud has been solid so far, and it would really be a kick in the teeth to trail off now.


1. Becky’s Descent Continues

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

It’s safe to say that regardless of changes that Sasha Banks and Naomi’s walkout caused with the booking Monday night, Becky Lynch’s overall trajectory wasn’t going to change.

Lynch has been spiralling since WrestleMania 38, when she lost the Raw Women’s Championship, becoming more delusional and paranoid, so naturally, she lost her shot at becoming #1 contender for the title when an attempt to cheat backfired and she lost to rival Asuka.

The Empress of Tomorrow countered Becky’s attempted umbrella attack with green mist, blinding Lynch and allowing Asuka to knock her out and pick up the win. The match itself was all action and a solid TV main event, though it unfortunately felt rushed and wasn’t able to be advertised in advance.

Still, given the circumstances, we’ve got to give this passing marks. And Bianca Belair versus Asuka in a real PLE matchup should be gold.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.