7 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE Raw (13 Feb - Results & Review)
Cody and Sami steal the show... together! Street Profits stumble, Judgment Day rises.
Stop us if you’ve heard this one before: Monday Night Raw continued on its road to WrestleMania with an overall good but uneven program that saw the show hit several massive highs while also producing several easily skippable segments.
Such is the life of a three-hour program where they add more and more stuff that clearly isn’t fully baked, leaving Raw feeling like it’s overstuffed with half-cooked ideas.
Consider the Cody Rhodes/Sami Zayn segment, a daring move that succeeded beyond anyone’s wildest expectations. It was bookended by a Piper Niven/Mia Yim match that played out to silence and an abbreviated Baron Corbin interview before it, and a bizarre and ultimately useless women’s backstage segment immediately afterward.
It feels like peak-valley-peak-valley with Raw some weeks, like an inability to maintain momentum throughout the show for more than two consecutive segments. The result is your faithful reviewer saying it was “uneven” but overall enjoyable because the positives are so good, while the negatives are rarely on the level they were a couple years ago.
Raw is rolling toward the Elimination Chamber event this weekend, with Mania looming. Several matches are in the works, and we could see some nice peaks in the coming weeks. But don’t expect that pitch-perfect program in the next seven weeks. This is more or less what we’re getting.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
6. Chelsea Green (So Far...)
The jury is still out on Chelsea Green’s latest WWE run, but it certainly isn’t a runaway smash.
Green has spent her time on Raw and SmackDown complaining about management, threatening to contact Adam Pearce’s manager, all while demanding she be treated as a major star… who’s 0-2 since returning. Monday, she demanded to be put in the triple threat to get a spot in the Elimination Chamber and was soundly rebuffed.
No one expected Chelsea to be slotted in a WrestleMania title match out of the chute, but this is a bit silly. Having her act in such a way is such as WWE thing. It’s not exactly part of the zeitgeist right now.
Maybe it’ll catch on and click, but this gimmick isn’t really doing it right now. Fingers crossed for Green that she finds success.
5. The Sounds Of Silence
Every time someone crows about how Triple H has rebuilt the women’s division, people should take a second and listen to the sound of when some of these superstars come out to wrestle.
Monday night, Mia Yim and Piper Niven locked up as a follow-up to last week’s fatal four-way match… and the bout played out to a mostly silent crowd.
This isn’t a comment on the wrestlers, but an indictment on the booking. It’s not enough to bring these women (or any superstar) back to the company (or in Niven’s case, restore her original WWE name). There’s been no real character development for either woman, no real promo time, no story for either woman in the ring, backstage or anywhere on WWE programming. It’s impossible to relate or empathize with either woman, so the match plays out to mostly silence.
Until WWE starts treating these superstars like three-dimensional characters, nothing is going to change.
4. Theory/Rollins Continues
Seth Rollins and Austin Theory will never be finished, apparently.
Despite WWE clearly setting the table for Rollins to face Logan Paul at WrestleMania 39, Seth still has a shot at the United States Championship this weekend, and they made sure to drive that point home with Theory jumping Rollins on Miz TV.
After Rollins dispatched with Miz, Theory hit A-Town Down on Seth, continuing a feud where neither man really can win convincingly but also shouldn’t lose. Theory is rumored to be headed for a collision with John Cena at Mania.
It also didn’t help that the budding rivalry between Rollins and Paul is very forced and one-sided. Logan isn’t on Raw at the moment, which makes it difficult to begin building a Mania feud. You have to have Miz as a stand-in while Rollins says “Logan Paul” a half-dozen times to drive it home.
And then you have Theory still buzzing around, waving the US title.
3. Heel Turn? Does It Matter?
Can someone explain how we should feel about Bobby Lashley right now?
During this ongoing, stretched-out feud, both Lashley and Brock Lesnar have continued to be de facto babyfaces, playing to the fans, slapping hands and smiling as they go. But then you saw Lashley’s antics Monday night, where he employed 10 security guards and set up a table on the ramp to avoid getting in the ring with Brock, triggering a “Bobby’s scared” chant.
All of this was a plot to unnerve Lesnar, who charged right into Bobby’s trap, and he backdropped and speared Brock before signing the contract for their Elimination Chamber match. So it was an elaborate setup to irritate Lesnar until he made a tactical mistake? That’s quite the move.
Does this make Lashley the bad guy? Or a situational one? Or was this just “mind games” and we should continue to cheer both men as we see fit? Regardless, none of this made this match “must see.” At this point, it’s more of a relief to see it going on now and not at WrestleMania.
2. Choo Choo!
If your wrestling program is opening up with a promo that gets interrupted multiple times, all to set up the main event for that evening, then you’re clearly watching Monday Night Raw.
The show opened with Becky Lynch in the ring acknowledging that she lost focus on WrestleMania in the name of toppling Damage CTRL and asking Adam Pearce to let her fight her way into the Elimination Chamber – a good babyface virtue.
But this brought out Bayley so the two could verbally spar and read off their Wikipedia pages to each other, only for Bianca Belair to trot out and suggest that if either woman wanted to get to Mania to face her, they should have to go through her, setting up a triple threat for later.
Yes, we have to fill three hours of programming, which is why we get 10 minutes of patter rather than just an announcement for the match. But it’s all meaningless stuff, just to get to what ideally would be an outstanding triple threat match.
But hey, explain again how there isn’t enough time to get other superstars onto Raw each week?
1. ‘Can They Co-Exist?’ No, They Can’t
Oh look, it’s a match lumping all six superstars involved in a big “every person for themselves” match at the upcoming PLE into two teams based on the brand so the announcers can wonder how they’ll function together.
Answer: Not at all.
Thankfully, this match broke down quickly when Asuka decided to assault everyone, including her Raw teammates Carmella and Nikki Cross, laying out the entire field en route to winning. Of course, while this kept things mercifully short, it also made everyone look like a geek just five days before the Elimination Chamber match, where we’re supposed to believe that any of the six have a chance of winning a WrestleMania title match for the Raw Women’s Championship.
This was not how to accomplish that goal. It telegraphed that Asuka is the overwhelming favorite, with Raquel Rodriguez as the dark horse. And that’s all there is to that.
Ups…
7. Maxxine’s Pitch To Otis
If teen movies have taught us anything, it’s that nothing is better than a makeover montage.
We’re about to get our own wrestling version of this with Alpha Academy’s Otis, or “O-Teece,” as Maxxine Dupri said his name (can’t wait to see how it’s styled in print). The bearded mountain of a man is clearly Maxxine’s project, as she sees him as someone to transform, which could provide some hilarious segments during the next several months.
Perhaps we’ll get the final reveal at WrestleMania, with O-Tis walking the catwalk down the Mania ramp. Regardless, this has the potential to be great fun, so we’ll allow ourselves to laugh a bit and hopefully enjoy it.
6. Bronson Reed Rolls
It’s disheartening to see Mustafa Ali treated as a whiny babyface who gets shunted down the card and jobbed out, but it’s clear that’s how WWE views him right now.
Instead, let’s give praise to Bronson Reed, who got to look a bit like a beast Monday night in his match against Ali. Reed tossed the smaller Mustafa around, at one point catching a dive off the apron and slamming Ali into the timekeeper’s area in a brutal spot. He also countered Ali’s attempted rolling neckbreaker with a wicked clothesline, followed by a Tsunami splash for the win.
If they keep booking Reed like this, to run through guys in impressive fashion, he just might catch on. It’s still early, but at least they’re giving him wins like this, which is a good sign. Next, work on his personality a bit on the main show, not the digital exclusives so more fans see that development.
5. Cody Destroys Corbin
Now that is a perfect way to use a down-and-out Baron Corbin.
After getting dumped by JBL last week, Corbin was bound to get a chance to weigh in on the latest development. In a clever little nod, he was brushed off and his interview postponed for “something important,” which was Sami Zayn in the ring. Once that segment was over, they returned to the interview, where Baron ranted and raved, then trashed Cody Rhodes (and his family)… who just happened to be coming back through gorilla and overheard the comments.
Cue a brawl, with Rhodes demanding that a ref follow them out to the ring so he could beat him in a match, which he did in short order. It was a perfect burial of the spiraling Corbin, and it continued Cody’s momentum with a convincing win once again.
Simple and effective. Sometimes that’s all you need. Had this gone on a minute longer or Baron landed a Deep 6, we might have had a different opinion. It didn’t, so we’re good here.
4. A Surprise Outcome
When the main event was made during the opening segment, you could have mentally prepped the “[SUPERSTAR X] Added to Women’s Elimination Chamber” news item.
So it was a bit surprising to see Bianca Belair standing tall at the end of Raw, defeating Bayley and Becky Lynch to keep both women out of the chamber match this weekend. The quality of the match itself is another story – and it dragged this item down – but it was an interesting move to keep both former champions out of the chamber after making the stipulation match.
It also was probably the smart move, as beating either woman (Neither Becky nor Bayley was going to win) would do nothing to help them in the build to WrestleMania. But then again, why book the match in the first place?
Oh right, because not everything needs to be super-obvious. If anything, it lets your Raw Women’s Champion stand tall winning a marquee match before her Mania opponent is known.
3. Ripley Outsmarts Phoenix
Last week gave us an endearing moment when Beth Phoenix captured Dominik Mysterio and spiked him with a Glam Slam, but not before Dom cried out for his “Mami!”, who wasn’t there.
Monday night, Rhea Ripley was apparently still traveling internationally and not with the rest of her Judgment Day cohorts during their match against the Street Profits. After the match, the group assaulted the Profits, only for Edge & Beth Phoenix to run down to save them. Fate would have it that Beth was once against alone with Mysterio, and she prepared to hoist him up again… only for Ripley to appear in the ring to take out Phoenix.
It was a very simple move, having Dom claim Rhea wasn’t there when she was being held back in case the “Grit Couple” attempted to interfere in JD’s business. But it was effective and followed up on last week’s memorable moment. Plus it reinserted Ripley into the fray just before the upcoming PLE.
2. Street Profits Faltering
You wouldn’t think that a babyface tag team losing is a good thing, but if it serves a purpose, it can be a net positive.
The Profits have been a solid duo for several years now, but they haven’t sniffed tag gold in quite some time, and it doesn’t look like they’re destined to hold a championship anytime soon. At the same time, both Montez Ford and Angelo Dawkins are immensely popular and talented.
So what to do? Having them lose a couple matches – against the Bloodline to open 2023, in tag team turmoil, and then again Monday against the Judgment Day – puts a thought in their heads that maybe it isn’t clicking like it used to for them. Then you have Ford advancing to the Elimination Chamber to compete for the United States Championship, while Dawkins lost his qualifier.
Now you’re looking at questions of a “weak link,” or at least a reason for Montez to want to go it alone for a bit. You don’t need to book a Rockers-like breakup, just have them amicably separate to pursue singles glory because the tag deal isn’t working right now. There has to be a reason for the Profits to lose these high-profile matches all in the past six weeks.
1. Cody Pumps Up Sami
So… WWE went there, huh?
Conventional wisdom would have said to keep Cody Rhodes and Sami Zayn far apart for fear that fans would turn on Cody and back Sami, thus ruining Rhodes’ WrestleMania journey.
Instead, WWE went all-in by having Zayn call out Rhodes, only to ask the American Nightmare if he meant what he said last week that he believed Sami could beat Roman Reigns for the Undisputed WWE Universal Championship at Elimination Chamber this weekend. Cody pumped Sami up, saying he did believe it, but then turned the tables and asked if Zayn believed it himself.
This prompted Zayn to show immense vulnerability, that while he knew he was capable, he didn’t know if he believed he could walk out of Montreal with the titles. Rhodes went into overdrive putting over Sami for cracking the Bloodline’s foundation, a masterful way of one title contender selling out for another. He went a step further, noting that his ticket is punched for WrestleMania, and that Sami needed to finish his own story to see him at Mania.
Good Lord. What a way to put these two together and have them interact in a way that doesn’t betray either character, doesn’t diminish one or the other, and most importantly, doesn’t force fans to choose one over the other. You can have both! You can cheer both! Here’s Cody being the only shoulder Sami has to lean on just five days before the biggest match of his career. That’s just insanely courageous and daring booking.